from the beginning to the end He presents himself to the Soul as its Idea its Original Image its beginning its way and itsend in whose bosome the Soul hath alwayes lien there meeting with every change every scene of things springing up within it in that bosome while the same Jesus hath lien in its bosome as the seed of its Being and of every Change This is the Souls Father Brother Bridegroom and Perfection As Jesus Christ thus appears and unvails himself within the Soul he at once gathers up the Soul into the most intimate the most entire Union with it self He transforms it into the likeness of the same Image with himself in the full Glory of the Divine the Universal the eternal Harmony in the Unity of the same Spirit the Spirit of this Harmony and Glory The Lord Jesus as he is the universal the eternal Image and Harmony of the Divine Nature of all Variety in the Divine Nature as he is the Idea of Ideas thus is he the Original Image the Idea of the Intellectual Soul or of Man As then he forms himself in this Soul he also formeth all things in it that man comes forth from the bosome of his Idea replenished with the Ideas of all things He is now the whole Creation the universal Nature within himself This Jesus then being risen springs up into Man in the virtue of his Resurrection and together becomes the Resurrection of all things in man to man In like manner through man as the head of all he riseth again in all the particular Forms of things as they stand without man in themselves in their own proper Existencies In the Lord Jesus God through Christ the universal Image inhabiteth in the proper Ideas of each Creature with the fulness of his Divine Glories in the Unity of the blessed Spirit According to this Original Jesus Christ the Universal Harmony through the humane Nature his immediate his full Image his compleat Birth and Bride rests entirely and distinctly upon each form of things as the Divine Race of this heavenly Marriage-Bed in the Resurrection As all together make up the Universal Harmony in the Soul in Christ the end of them all So each one enjoyeth the whole Harmony in it self being upon its own proper Form cloathed with the Universal Form the Form of the heavenly Man and of Christ in Glory So all dwell together in the Unity of the same Divine Spirit the Spirit of a Saint and of Christ. In the Unity of this Spirit all mutually are Divine Palaces each to other clearly compleatly comprehending and comprehended by each other eternally feasting upon the heavenly Beauties and Virtues drinking in the Sweetnesses the Lives the Spirits of each other And of Jesus Christ of God the Unity and the Variety in all This is the Kingdom of God which is Righteousness Peace and Joy in the Holy Ghost Jesus Christ the essential Image of God the Divine and eternal Harmony is the Righteousness the mutual Peace and Joy of this Kingdom In this Kingdom Jesus Christ cometh with his own Glory the Glory of his Father and of all his holy Angels united in one in each form of things The lowest form of things here is an Angel an Angel made new in the Resurrection of Christ where each Angel being only a distinct part of the Harmony yet hath the Universal Harmony resting upon that part This is that new Jerusalem where the street the lowest form of things is as Gold and Glass The pure Glory of the eternal Spirit as the finest Gold shineth in each Creature like the Cherubim or the Angels standing up out of the Mercy-Seat made of the same piece of massy Gold together with it The lowest Creature here is an Angel of Glory the street that sustains us is composed of Angels Angelical Glories In every Angel as a particular Glory all the Angels with their several Varieties of Glory the Glory of Christ and all the Saints which is the full the Universal Glories of the Divine and Humane Nature the Original and its best beloved Image in Union The Glory of God as the Father in its simplicity in its paternity and transcendency over all meet all in one This Unity of the Spirit in each Creature renders it divinely transparent like the finest glass In the beauty of every Face we have the prospect of Eternity We see in each single Face fresh Beauties all Beauties with an endless Variety opening themselves one within another one beyond another all equally clear present and pleasant in every one Thus Jesus Christ becomes according to St. Paul the first-born from the dead and the first-born among his Brethren the Saints The Saints in the Language of St. James are the first-fruits of the Creation which is brought forth in its proper time and order into the liberty of the Glory of the Sons of God Thus is our Jesus the great Jubilee where all Debts are remitted all Servants go free all persons return to their Inheritances to the free Possession the full fruition of themselves and them In the Resurrection of the Lord Jesus from him as the Root springing up into the Body of the Saints through them into the rest of the Creatures as Branches of the same Tree All Sins are pardoned the whole Creation is set free from its bondage to Vanity and Corruption All things return to a free fruition of themselves of all Beauties and Joys in their native Inheritance their Original Images their proper Ideas in Christ first Christ then the Saints through them Heaven and Earth and the Seas with all things in them are made new by being married anew by being newly reinvested with the Glories of their Original The Reader is again desired to take Notice That neither the remainder of this Fourth Argument nor any thing upon his Fifth could be found amongst the Authors Papers A DISCOURSE OF THE Freedome of the Will The SECOND PART Wherein the Arguments for it are considered and answered HAving finished those Arguments ranked under their several Heads in opposition to that Liberty of the Will which is placed in the determining of its power received from the first cause unto a Contrariety or Contradiction in its actings with an independency upon the first cause the order and connexion of Causes and the Understanding We pass now to a consideration of the Reasons upon which that Opinion of this Freedome is established These Reasons are taken 1. From the Will it self 2. From the nature of Sin and the Divine Justice 3. The Language of the Scripture 4. From the end of Laws 5. From the order and nature of things 1. Reason The Prerogative and Excellency of the Will consisteth in this Liberty 1. How otherwise doth man excel bruit Creatures and natural Agents 2. How otherwise is man free and not necessitated in all his Actions To that I shall give two several Answers 1. Answ. This Freedome of the Will of which we speak and which is opposed to necessity
and Hell But this Heathenism and Manicheism are exploded as by the universal consent of all sober Christians so by the voice of reason it self For if there be two first Beings these agree in Being they differ in being two Being it self as it is One making both these one in its self as it is pure is before and above that state in which it is allayed and abased by being mixt and compounded with those differences which make it two This then alone is the first and supream Being the eternal One the only true God 2. If God then be not properly and directly the Author of Sin Sin is no positive Being but a privation only So the Scriptures express it which call it 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 an irregularity a falling short of the Glory of God a missing of the mark 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Divines generally teach us That the Sin consisteth not in any Act but in the Deordination in the privation a want of the due order appertaining to the Act. Sin then being nothing positive but a meer privation can have no efficient but a deficient Cause only This deficient Cause is that defectibility which is inseparable from every created Nature Darkness is the privation or absence of Light which naturally and necessarily accompanieth obscure and opact Bodies as the Air the Water and the Earth While the Sun shines upon them this deficiency or want of Light discovereth not it self All things are illuminated and the natural obscurity of these Bodies illustrated by the Sun-beams when these beams are withdrawn or intercepted then the defect of Light natural to these substances appeareth and so the darkness is predominant Thus every Creature hath in it self a tendency to annihilation being of it self like the Earth before the beautiful work of the first day which was light void and without form Thus the Soul of Man in its Understanding and in its Will hath naturally of it self a tendency to unreasonableness which is a degree of Annihilation the privation of that two-sold Beauty Truth in the Understanding and goodness in the Will While the Face of God shines upon the face of the Soul by a continued irradiation as in the first moment of the Creation these Intellectual Forms of Divine Beauty Truth and Goodness flourish in the Soul binding up the natural defectibility both of the Understanding and the Will in the golden Chains of an heavenly Light and heavenly Love but in that moment in which God turns away his Face with-draws his beams in the same moment the Soul of Man is left naked its natural defectibility prevails the privation or absence of Truth is now the darkness the deformity of folly and falshood The privation or absence of Goodness is now the evil and the disorder into which as a bottomless pit the Understanding and the Will and the whole Soul with these miserably endlesly sinks This is that horrible pit out of which sin ariseth the defectibility or nothingness of the Creature in it self This is the way by which it ariseth upon the Soul over-spreading it and carrying it back into that pit of horrour the deflectibility or nothingness of the Creature prevailing in the absence of the Divine beams The Royal Prophet divinely sings the penury of the Creature and the Praises of the great Creator in this Mystery Psal. 104. 29. Thou hidest thy Face they are troubled thou takest away their Breath or Spirit they die and return to their dust Thou sendest forth thy spirit they are created and thou renewest the face of the Earth It is a truth asserted by all Philosophers and Divines That the Understanding acteth necessarily being infallibly and irresistably reduced into act by its Object duly presented The Scripture manifestly teacheth us that sin entreth into the Soul by the Understanding Those two places which I have cited above are clear The woman being deceived was first in the Transgression Sin deceived me and so slew me St. Paul speaketh in both these places of the first entrance of sin into the World in the person of the first Woman and in his own person set as a figure of all Mankind as it was collectively and representatively in the first Adam Musaeus joyns these together 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The Light going out and Leander perishing Man is deceived and so slain by sin As the Light of Truth goes out in the Understanding the Life of Goodness dies in the Will As the sight and light of the eye from the natural composition of the eye faileth as the irradiations from the Sun which it enjoyeth either mediately or immediately from the body of the Sun it self or from other luminous bodies depending upon the Sun are obscured So is the Souls eye the Understanding obscured according to the proportion in which the Divine illuminations in the way of Grace or Nature cease In these two first steps I have endeavoured to make clear the nature of Sin and the way of its entrance into the World in which we see a most genuine conformity to the dependance of the Will and of the whole Soul in all its changes and motions upon the first Cause as a link in the mystical Chain of the order of Causes The beauty and goodness of the Soul in its Understanding and its Will flow in the golden Pipe of the order of Causes as golden Oyl from the first cause as the Olive-Tree flourishing upon the Mount of Eternity As this golden stream from its Well-head fails beauty and goodness are no more in the Soul The deficiency or privation of these is the evil of Darkness Deformity Sin and Death to this intellectual and immortal Spirit But the knot seems to be tyed stronger by this discourse man sins inevitably by the necessity of his nature The first and free withdrawings of the Divine influence give way for the deflectibility of the Creature to spring up into those defects which are properly and formally the evils of Sin the first and greatest evils the fountains of all evils How then doth shame or guilt lie upon the Creature Why is God yet angry How is he just in punishing Is not the evil of sin from these grounds clearly cast upon God as the Author of it I shall endeavour to answer these Objections and to remove these Difficulties in the three following steps 3. I shall endeavour here to bring in some clear light into the obscure shades of this doubt how shame and guilt lie upon the Soul when it falls inevitably from the necessity of its nature Shame is a fear of Infamy from a sense of Deformity Deformity is the absence of the Divine Form originally present and so proper to the subject The subject of the form or beauty while it is present is also in its absence the subject of the privation and deformity To the deformity is annexed the reproach or disesteem Esteem or disesteem is a right judgment and so a value of each thing according to its proper state
present moment to the embraces of the Will which was condemned in the general Rules as a most dangerous evil a most certain ruine Two circumstances upon the place and in the moment of action are cast into the ballance upon the place or in the moment of an action or temptation which weigheth it down with a great force 1. One is the difficulty and pain in resisting the alluring evil 2. The other is a flattering hope of enjoying the false sweetness of the present Action and being delivered from the unhappy consequences threatned while they are looked up either as uncertain or contingent or capable of being diverted by the Divine Goodness or by a succeeding repentance and change especially for this one adventure We may seal up this Answer with the impression of this golden Truth mentioned formerly Good under the form of good is the Object of the Will This alone attracteth the Will this alone moveth it The connexion then is inviolable and immediate between the Ultimate proposals of the Understanding presenting any Object to the Will under the formality or appearance of good and the motions of the Will towards that Object to receive it with mutual embraces 6. Reason What do most persons upon this Subject say Can I not walk sit or stand when I will at my pleasure Can I not choose or refuse Can I not Will as I will Is not my Will then free Answ. This Argument indeed is formed Crassâ Minervâ from a very gross conceit from the want of distinguishing between a spontaneity in the Acts themselves and an vndeterminedness in the essential Principles from which the Acts flow The question is not concerning the power or pleasure of the Will in Actibus imperatis in governing the Loco-motive faculty and the Instruments of motion the members of our Body Neither is it about the Elicit Acts of the Will it s own immediate motions of loving or hating whether these be in the power and pleasure of the Will That which is the subject of the Controversie is the root of this power and pleasure in the Will which it putteth forth in its immediate or more remoâ—…e Acts the Essence the essential form and principles of the Will it self However the Will in its essential form and principle be determined by superior and universal Causes which as essential Principles and as nature it self are complicated in the essence and nature of the Will yet doth the Will move in all its Acts with no less power and agreeableness Yea rather the sweet and harmonious concurrence of the superior and universal Cause in the Essence and Operations of the Will by the combinations of all Coelestial Angelical Divine Virtues make the motions of the Will more potent and more pleasant In truth the Will of man in a temptation may be like a Ship in a storm The Ultimate dictates of the Understanding the appearances of good and evil in the moment of Action cloathed with all its circumstances may suddenly and violently vary They may be like contrary Winds and Waves carrying the Ship in several moments unto contrary motions As the last gust of Wind and the last motion of the Waves so the last dictates the last appearances of good carry the Will away whether it be upon a Rock or in a safe course to its Haven Yet still this is true which Aristotle saith 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Election or choice is a desirous Understanding or an Intellectual Desire or 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 A desire from deliberation 7. Reason I have met with this Argument for the freedom of the Will from a learned pen. The chief ground on which the predetermination of the Will is built hath been this Principle That sin is a privation and no positive Being Thus God is believed to be cleared from the evil of Sin in the Acts and Motions of the Will while evil being a deficiency is capable of no efficient Cause An instance is brought to overthrow this Principle from a Spirit hating God Here this Act of the Will the hatred as it is formally drawn forth by and terminated in this Object the Person and Nature of God is formally in its positive Being a sin Answ. 1. If sin in any Subject or Act be a positive thing I know not how by any skill or understanding Humane or Angelical God can be acquitted from being the Author of sin For this is without controversie the sense of all Divines of all sorts except the Manichees and those who with them establish two co-ordinate Godheads of Good and Evil that he who is the only true God is the first the universal Being the Fountain of all Being the Being of every Being 2. Here seemeth to be a plain mistake for want of distinguishing this individual Act of hating God as it is considered in genere moris and ingenereentis In its moral and in its natural capacity 1. While we look upon this Act of hatred in a complex proposition as it is determined upon this Object the Divine Essence we consider it not naturally but morally we rightly pronounce it to be morally evil But this moral evil ariseth from a moral circumstance which is the undue determination of the Act upon an undue Object The evil here lies in the irregularity and obliquity of this Act morally considered in the determination to its Object This irregularity and obliquity is a privation of the due rectitude in which principally consisteth a right determination of the Act upon a right Object Thus is the evil of sin no more any thing positive here but altogether privative 2. If you consider this Act ingenereentis in its natural capacity you abstract it from all its moral circumstances you take a naked view of it as it is a natural motion in the will of aversion or opposition Thus it is clearly good It hath a natural or physical goodness as it answereth the proper and immediate Principles of the Form or Essence from which it flows and those formal essential Principles by which it is constituted It hath also a metaphysical goodness as every thing that is is good in its conformity to the Divine Will which as the Seal setteth the impression of being upon every thing that hath Being 3. There is also in this case before us a deception of our Intellectual sense by a mist cast before our eyes in which appearances are taken for realities I humbly conceive that there is no greater contradiction to all Principles of Truth and Knowledge than this assertion That any Spirit hateth God as God as he appeareth in his own proper Form God is that which all things desire God alone is Good saith Jesus Christ. If God alone be good he is the first the supream the universal Good The general Good of the whole the proper good of each particular All Good in one the only Good in all the only Suitableness the only Agreeableness to every Spirit Person and Nature the Truth
it self in these Images presented to the Soul by their essential truths in their understanding is that power which we call the Will The sutableness and agreeableness of these forms of things to the Will The 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and so more principally the Divine Unity in them the root and life of this agreeableness is the good which is the Object of this inclination the Will of the intellectual Spirit Love is defined the union of the Lover and the Beloved The will as it is an essential inclination to its Object the good shining forth in its proper Image and beautiful forms of truth in the understanding is love it self the essential love of the Soul The Soul in this essential power which we call the Will is the Lover This is that which Plotinus seemeth to mean when discoursing of the Soul he saith That every Soul comes forth with a Cupid or love proper to it and inseparable from it It is commonly known that the Soul is represented by Venus the Queen of Beauty and the Mother of Love the Daughter of Jupiter of Jehovah As the intellectual Soul is the â—…enus so is this essential inclination of the Soul to good which is its will the Cupid or Love born of it and born with it inseparable from it As is the intellectual Spirit so is its Will or Love the highest and loveliest Image of the first Spirit and the first Love so hath it in it next to the Divine Love the highest the most potent the most universal force of inclination and love to the highest and most universal good The Beloved or the Object of this Love and this Lover the intellectual Soul and the Intellectual Will is the highest and most universal good as it presenteth it self in its highest lustre in its richest amplest most unlimited variety of beauties in the Understanding This good being an agreeableness to the Will and so meeting with a mutual and answerable agreeableness in the Will to it self presenteth it self thus by the Understanding in these forms of truth which is the Divinest beauty as a lover and a beloved both to the Will that they may be equally and mutually happy by equal by mutual embraces and fruition This is the liberty of the Will consisting in two parts mutually answering each other The first is the vigour and amplitude of the principle the inclination or love carrying the Soul to rendring it capable of good in its absolute and universal form The second is the vigor and amplitude of its Object which is the highest good the Divinity of good it self presenting it self in its absolute universal or intire truth beauty and essential form presenting it self in all varieties of distinct truths beauties and forms as they are represented in their highest completest Image next to the Original it self in the Understanding Here is the Will like a Bee in a Garden or flourishing Field or rather in an heavenly Paradise flying at liberty over all forms of truth and beauty as the Flowers and Plants in this Paradise resting at pleasure upon every one of them sucking 〈◊〉 sweetness the virtue the good the unexpressibleness of the Divinity and the Divine Unity from them as the Honey which is its Divine Feast Nourishment Life and Treasure This is the liberty of the Soul of the Understanding of the Will in its proper Nature and primitive State This is the liberty which it still enjoys inseparable from its essence under the fall it self so far as by the promised Seed putting forth it self in the moment of the Fall the essence of the intellectual Spirit is renewed and maintained universally by common Grace in the midst of the ruines of the Fall I have this one thing only to add under this fourth Head the Liberty of intellectual Spirits that as God is the Original Spirit as Angels and intellectual Souls are Image-Spirits so is the liberty of the Divine Essence the Original liberty and the liberty of all other intellectual Spirits Humane or Angelical is the Birth and so the Image of that liberty Having thus passed through the several degrees of liberty in the several Orders of Being we come now more particularly and distinctly to state the question concerning the Liberty of the Will which is the subject of our present Discourse There is a two-fold liberty of the Will 1. One by all acknowledged inseparable from the Will in all States and acts 2. The other hath been through all Ages Religions and Philosophyes the ground of many learned eloquent deep Discourses and Disputes between persons eminent in all kind 1. The first uncontroverted liberty of the Will is that which is built upon the grounds already laid It consisteth in two glorious preheminencies 1. The liberty of acting from an internal essential universal Principle of inclination or love which is confined or restrained in its nature and power by no particular differences which is by nothing determined in its actings except only as it determines it self by the Laws of its own universal nature in which it bears the immediate and most express figure of the Divine Nature and so of the Divine freedome or liberty 2. This Principle hath for the sphere and compass of its activity the absolute and universal good in the entire freedome of his unconfined form or Essence in all the varieties of its descents and ascents its divisions and compositions The Will of the Intellectual Spirit is free here in the chase and pursuit of all good unconfined to any particular form of good determined by it self alone and its own internal essential motions to the choice and embraces of every good 2. The second liberty of the Will which hath so different aspects to the differing understanding of excellent persons for the most part in all places and times is generally known by these terms of Libertas contradictionis libertas contrarietatis Liberty of contradiction and of contraricty Suppose an intellectual Spirit in the moment immediately preceding its Action positis omnibus requisitis ad agendum now ready for action in the constitution and concurrence of all circumstances essential accidental from above from below from the first universal cause from all second and particular causes from within from without in respect to any Essence Power and Operation in respect to any thing in any potentiality or act The Will of this intellectual Spirit without any change in any circumstance in any degree may act or not act which is the liberty of contradiction may act either in this way or in the way directly contrary to it which is the liberty of contrariety This is also expressed by a liberty or power in the Will to determine it self in the moment of acting by its act without any predetermination in the Will it self in the power of acting in its proper Essence and the laws of its own Nature in the connexion of causes or in the first and universal Cause The method of my treating upon this Question
divinely beautiful the only beloved Person and form of his only eternal Birth his own Son there hath the view of the Will of Man in every distinct motion act and determination as in its first exemplar cause in eternity 3. The will of man then in every motion act and determination of it is from eternity predetermined in the Divine Understanding as in its first cause and Original form Upon these grounds the Knowledge of God is at once a fore-knowledge of future things and a knowledge of things present 1. It is a fore-knowledge as it sees things in their first cause in a state far above and transcendent to the state of their proper existency as they stand forth out of their causes 2. It is a knowledge of things present as eternity and the Divine duration containeth in it self the measures the exemplars and so the most exact forms of time and every successive duration in its several aspects of past present and to come Besides that as the Sun looking forth makes the Day and the Light with all the visible Images with which it beholds the Heavens and the Earth so the Divine Eye is at once a Glass to it self and a Fountain to all things by beholding things every moment in it self it doth formally every moment send them forth from it self so at once it seeth them in their formal cause and present existence 6. Argument The sixth Argument drawn from this Head is the infiniteness of God This is a Negative expression representing to us a Positive Perfection which surmounts all Assimilations all Similitudes or Images which the highest understanding of men or Angels is capable of taking in or the whole Creation united in its most abstracted and heightned Excellencies of bringing forth We figure it to our selves only by a Negation or removal of all figures of all terms or bounds We seem to touch it with the Top point and simplest Unity of Spirits by a silence and cessation of all created powers or faculties in us We seem to apprehend it only by being comprehended of it and lost in it If we knew and tasted the unexpressible Sweetnesses the high Raptures with the Divinest Pleasures in the contemplation of the Divine Infiniteness how far should we be from streightning or darkening its Glories by limiting and in limiting dividing them If God be God that is before all things and above them he is absolutely unchangeable As He is unchangeable He is every where every way the same equal and entirely perfect equally and endlesly removed from all bound and limit If God be God that is the first of all things He hath the Fountain of Life in himself Thus he is ever fresh and new ever springing into fresh and new Glories ever equally endlesly removed from any conclusion or confinement in his Births and Beauties The Divinity and Poetry of the Heathen from their most ancient most sacred mysteries teach us that Love is the Eldest and Youngest of all the gods Our God the God and Father of our Lord Jesus is the God of Love in the truest the sweetest and the best sense He alone is Love it self in an abstracted eternal Divine Essence and Substance pure Love altogether unmixt having nothing in it self different or divers from it self thus is an infinite Love a sweet and clear Sea which swalloweth up all bounds all shores and bottoms into it self This Love as it is every way the same is the ancient of Dayes the eldest of all the Gods This Love as it ever flourisheth with a perpetual Spring and Youth of all Beauties of all beautiful Delights is the youngest of all the Gods Thus is this most high and holy Love the God of Gods the First and the Last containing all things within its own blissful bosome as the bound of all but being it self every way beyond all bounds without all bounds infinite How infinite are the joys and blessedness of this Infiniteness How is this infinite God our God the only true God a Paradise of Love infinitely heightned in all the beauties and sweetnesses of Love infinitely diffused through all things beyond all things How is He at once the Paradise of Love with its infinite heightnings with its infinite amplitudes in every part in every point of things entirely perfect How is it every where the same every where new to the satisfaction to the swallowing up of all the most fixt most various most vast desires into an Aybss or Ocean of Delights equally unconfined and undivided Shall we then limit the holy One of Israel If we do not we must ascribe this greatness to Him that He contains all things in Himself In Him all things live move and have their Being We must attribute this immenseness or immensurableness to Him to fill all in all as the only distinct exact measure of all things himself still transcending all and being measured by nothing It is said of Christ That the Church is the fulness of him who filleth all in all The Humane Soul or Intellectual Spirit is a rude imperfect shadow of the Divine Infiniteness Our thoughts are living Images in various postures and motions They are in a manner the Creation the Creatures of our Souls They live move and have their being in our Souls Our Souls alone fill all in them all How far greater is the distance between God and his Creatures than between the Soul and its Creation How much more less even less than nothing are all the Creatures to God How much more truly more entirely are they all that they are in Him how much more absolutely is he their fulness silling them all in all All things then all Essences all Lives all Vital Powers and Faculties in each Essence all Motions of life all Acts or Operations of every power and faculty are in God He alone filleth all in every Essence Life Power Faculty Motion Act. All are in Him have all their distinct forms degrees modes of being in Him to the least degree or shadow of Being Thus Angels and Men the Understanding and Will of each Man of each Angel every act motion determination of each Understanding of each Will are comprehended in God God entirely filleth all every Person or Spirit every Understanding and Will every Determination and Motion Where we exclude him out of any Spirit Essence Power or Operation there we set a bound to the eternal Spirit there we limit the holy One that pure Essence and Act there we say to Him Thus far shalt thou go no farther If God be acknowledged for Being it self in its purest simplicity it is Being alone which can bound him All without him where he ceaseth and terminateth is not Being But who understands not this that that which hath no Being can be no bounds 7. Argument The seventh Argument is the causality of God The celebrated Argument of the Philosopher by which he asserts the Divine Being is the necessity of one first mover For if the causes of motion did
not terminate in some one first mover but did proceed to an infiniteness of successions all things will be at a stand motion will universally cease For an infinite succession of causes could never be past through nor arrive at any effect This determinates the truth of a God and the Nature of a true God that He is the first Mover the first Cause The force and dignity of this first Cause declareth it self to us in these following Maxims which stand fixed in the eternal Reason of things as in their proper root and shine clearly in the evidence of their own Light and have their Truth sealed by an universal Testimony 1. The first Cause is the universal Cause All things all causes and effects all causalities and efficacies all order and connexion of things are virtually and eminently comprehended in the first Cause from which according to their proper places and eternal patterns they flow 2. The first Cause is most of all most truly and most fully most properly and most powerfully the cause of every effect 3. The first Cause is more intimate to every effect than any second Cause It is most intimate to every effect with an intimateness of presence and power it is immediately omnipotent with an immediateness of Person and of Virtue of Operation and of Efficacy 4. Every second Cause hath its causality acteth and produceth its effect in the virtue of the first Cause Therefore Philosophers and Divines have taught us that all Causes and Effects in their orders and connexions are onely explications or modifications of the first Cause 5. That which is the Cause of the Cause is also the Cause of its Effects The Operation of each thing followeth its Essence All Operations which are second Acts are folded up in the first Act which is the Essence and flow forth from it as that unfolds it self in them within the compass of its own proper Orb and Sphere All these Maxims reign with an universal Soveraignty of Truth and Power through all orders of things over all minds They seem to be unmoveably established upon the Basis or Foundation of that Principle That which is the first in any kind of things is the universal Root Rule Truth and Life to all things of the same kind That alone is such by it self All other things of the same kind are such in the force and virtue of that by its presence and power in them Let us now bring this down to the particular Subject of our Discourse If God be the first Cause if the Will be a second Cause if the Acts of the Will and the determination of the Will in these Acts be the effects of the Will then is God the universal cause of all these then is he more truly and effectually the cause of each act and determination of the Will than the Will it self then is he in the immediateness of his Person Power and Operation more intimate to each act and determination of the Will than the Will it self then doth the Will with all its acts and determinations in their several Orders Connexions and Circumstances lie virtually and eminently in the Divine Will as in their first Cause from which in their proper seasons and places they flow distinctly forth as that first Will which is one pure eternal Act unfoldeth it self into them A great Philosopher and Divine representeth all Births and Productions those of Flowers and Trees in Gardens of Beasts in the Fields of Fishes in the Sea of Birds in the Air of Celestial Light of Men and Angels as so many Songs of Praise celebrating the first Birth and Production the eternal Generation of the Son from the Father in the Trinity For saith he all other Productions or Births spring up and stand in the virtue of this All causes and effects in like manner are so many Divine Songs sounding forth through the whole Heavens and Earth the Praises the Power the Efficacy of the first Cause For in the womb of that as they all immediately fall in the bosome of that they lie together in its virtue and presence they spring and flourish its sacred Image and Impression they all bear divinely engraven upon them I have now finished my Arguments drawn from the first Head the Nature of God Gentle Reader Perhaps I may seem to thee to have drawn out to a great length and to have made frequent large Digressions upon this Head of the Deity I have indeed willingly taken every fair occasioâ—… as I have past along through this Land of Life and Bliss amidst the Gardens of true Adonis the eternal Son to stay thy self and me some moments upon the contemplation of the charming Prospect as also to gather and present thee with some of the Paradisical Flowers and Fruits which grow so plentifully here I have endeavoured in my way according to the narrow measure of my weak capacity far below the Glories of this Object if not to open yet to point out to thee the Excellencies of the Godhead as they lie in their first and fairest ground of eternal life Two Reasons have moved me to this 1. God is the first and fairest Ground the clearest and sweetest Light of Truth The Philosopher hath taught us That demonstration is only by first and immediate Principles The first and immediate Principle is that which hath the Light of Truth immediately seated and shining in it self which receiveth not its evidence from any Superior Medium or Argument which immediately displayeth its beams from its own face on the eye of the Understanding without the interposal of any inferior Medium or Argument This is the only Principle of Demonstration and this is God alone He is the Father of Lights the Intellectual Sun God unvailing Himself in our Spirits setting Himself as the golden Seal of purest Light upon our Spirits Thus by his immediate embraces he impregnateth them with the Divine forms of truth In this sense St. Paul saith That our Faith is in the demonstration of God Accordingly he describeth the truly Evangelical or Spiritual Knowledge to be the shining of God in our hearts unto the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ. He that in a clear Evening fixeth his eye on the Firmament above him beholdeth by degrees innumerable Stars with springing lights sparkling forth upon him If God lift up a little of his Vail and by the least glimpses of his naked Face enlighten and attract the eye of our Soul to a fixed view of Himself with what Divine Raptures do we see the eternal Truths of things in their sweetest Lights springing and sparkling upon us besetting us round in that Firmament of the Divine Essence as a Crown of incorruptible Glory The heavenly Bridegroom in the Canticles singeth thus I am come into my Garden my Sister my Spouse I have drunk my Milk with my Wine I have eaten my Honey with my Honey-comb If this lovely Bridegroom lead our Souls his Bride into
which is the universal and supream good there cleaving to and becoming one with that blessed and triumphant Will it hath no more any sense of opposition or force all things now round about it make a pleasant Musick to it in the Harmony of the Divine Will and shine upon it with a most ravishing and heavenly lustre as they lie together in the Divinely-beautiful Form of the first and universal good This is that true Liberty of the Will of Man in which he transcends all other Creatures here below by which he triumphs over all Chances and Changes over all Confinements and Comâ—…lsions over all the extremities of Force and Fury while it keeps these wings unlimed uncloged unclipt by the filth or guilt of fleshly lusts while it preserves it self from the Chains of Vice 3. I come now to the third Circumstance of the Liberty of the Will Man is to be considered in three states 1. Of pure Nature 2. Of the Fall 3. Of the restitution by Christ. 1. Man in the state of pure Nature is an Image of God an earthly Image Gen. 1. God said let us make man in our own likeness after our own Image let us make him Some interpret this of God in the three Persons others of God Cum indumentis suis as the Jews speak of God in his holy Angels Both together make a proper and full sense God in the holy Trinity God in all the various Virtues of the Divine Nature spread first through the innumerable company of Angels and by them through the whole Creation sets himself as a seal upon man in whom as the Consummation and Crown of his whole Work by this impression he unites all into one Nature and Essence which is a compleat Image of himself and a comprehension of the whole Creation Thus now the Essence the Faculties the Operations of Man are a shadowy similitude and figure of the Divine Essence the Divine Virtues and the Operations of the Divine Nature Thus the Will of Man is a shadowy figure of the Divine Will and its freedom a shadowy resemblance of the Divine Liberty like the colours of a Rainbow in the Cloud which are so many reflections of the light of the Sun That which we say in natural Philosophy Exiisdem nutrimur ex quibus gignimur We are bred and nourished composed and continued by the same things is most true in its application to the first or universal cause with its effects As the Sun is the formal efficient cause of its beams which are its shadowy Image in the air and as the living face is the formal efficient cause of the face in the Glass so is God to man his Image and shadow The continued out-shinings and Operations of the Sun make maintain and act anew its beams every moment The continued stream of Species or beams from the living Face every moment form anew the Face in the Glass with all its meen and motions So doth the Divine Essence the Diviue Understanding and Will every moment by the continual influences of each moment compose and conduct their Image the Essence the Understanding the Will of Man as the Face in the Glass in their whole make manner and motions This is not a diminution but the perfection of Liberty in the Will of Man For God in his holy Angels as superior and universal Causes works upon the Will of Man or rather in it after the manner of an internal Principle So that well known Maxim of the first Philosophy assures us That the first and universal Cause is of all Causes most intimate with every effect As in logical Definitions the summum genus or the highest nature enters into the Definition and so into the Essence of the lowest Species or kind of things inasmuch as it enters into and constitutes the next genus or nature together with all the intermediate natures For examples sake Substance and so Being it self in its highest and most absolute form is comprehended in and constitutes the nature of man descending into it by the intermediate steps of Corporiety and Animality that is becoming first a Corporeal Substance then a living Corporeal Substance lastly a rational and so a man In like manner so is the first and universal Cause the most internal and essential Principle of every effect of all humane Operations of all the acts of the Will For it is the Essence of every Essence the Being of every Being the Act of every Act the first the formal Cause the most immediate the most intimate Cause of every Effect Let me add to this for a Conclusion as the Crown upon the liberty of man in pure nature that his conformity to God as an Image to his Original is his Perfection in this doth his Will become a most beautiful figure of the ever-glorious life the Divine Will that its Liberty is the free-springing flourishing and fruitfulness of it in all good through the whole Latitude and Amplitude of the most spacious and blissful sphere of good and so that a most pleasing and agreeable necessity of being good is inseparable from this sweet and ample freedom while it continues in the state of a Divine Image and Figure 2. In the Fall of Man we read according to the Language of the Scripture of his being deceived being brought into servitude being a Captive in bondage to Vanity and Corruption and of being dead While they boast of Liberty saith St. Peter they themselves are servants to sin For to that of which a man is overcome he is a servant It is the Observation of Plato That the names importing any thing of good natively signifie a freedom of motion as 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 good from 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to run swiftly On the otherside the names of evil express a restraint from motion as 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 malice from 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to lie down upon the ground In like manner the Hebrew word for Darkness signifieth restraint and confinement by force All Liberty being an enlargement of Being is comprehended in the nature of good alone Neither is there any thing so inconsistent with Liberty as evil which is a privation of Being Plato therefore rightly expresseth the Soul in her faln state by the loss of both her wings which are an Intellectual Light and an Intellectual Love or the Light of Reason in the Mind spreading it self with a clear brightness as one of the golden wings and the force or freedom of the rational Appetite to good in the Will extending it self in a pure flame as the other of the golden wings To this I might add the testimony which the Scripture gives of another seed that of the Serpents springing up in the Soul unto its fall in its fall and through its fall of the Soul being now the Child of the Devil being implanted into the Powers of Darkness of being acted by the Prince of the Power of the Air the Spirit which is now become its Root its
in both from the meeting and blissful embraces of these two this Love and Loveliness in the Divine Nature his Joy and Complacency is alike in both equally full equally at the heighth A Divine Philosopher with a pleasant and beautiful Allegory teacheth us That the expansion of Light in the heavenly Bodies which is the Act of the Angelical World in this their most beautiful Figure is Risus Coelorum the laughter of the Heavens God maketh every thing beautiful in its proper place and time to kill as to make alive unformed deformed privations as the fairest and most flourishing forms In every Act of Providence in every accident from the beginning to the end of things he equally preserveth and perfecteth the Divine Order and Harmony This golden Harmony extended like the sweet Light of Heaven over all things is as a Divine laughter the complacency of the Divine Nature in its Work in its Image in it self I have yet one thing more to say before I take my other step We learn from Philosophers That heat and cold which continually fight in the Elements below are in the heavenly Bodies but after so eminent a manner that there they meet and enfold each other with a most harmonious agreeableness By the Laws of Divinity we are answerably taught That Anger and Love as all forms of things most discordant in the Creatures are first in the Divine Nature But they are there with an eminency with a transcendency in which they are refined and heightned far above all imperfections Here they all meet as most grateful and most agreeable Varieties in the entire and undivided Unity of the same eternal Light of the same eternal Love of the same eternal God As from this heighth of a most perfect Unity these Divine Varieties bring forth their various effects in shadowy resemblances here below they make the figure of the whole divinely one and divinely beautiful As Divine Seals they likewise impress the figure of their own Divine Unity upon each single effect Thus the whole work in general each single effect in particular is a divinely beautiful figure of the Divine Beauty shining with delightful beams upon those Eyes and Spirits which anointed with a Divine Knowledge see the golden and secret Seal this glorious and sacred impression of the Divine Unity upon it Thus we have spoken of the shame and guilt of Sin as also of Anger and in part of the Justice of God concerning which there remaineth more to be said 5. Step. We have yet before us that great Deep which swalloweth up all Understandings the face of which seemeth covered with a thick and impenitrable darkness Let us pray to the Father of Lights for irradiations from his eye that so this unfathomable Deep may discover it self to us as a blissful Deep of purest clearest and sweetest Glory If God first from the counsel of his own Will alone withdraw those beams which are all our Light and Beauty and we then by the inevitable necessity of our Natures wander as deformed shades in a wild darkness through the Regions of Sin Death and Hell Is not God now in a moral sense clearly and fully the sole Author of Sin and Evil This is the knot which indeed standeth in need of the Rosy Fingers of the heavenly Morning the beams of the eternal Day to unty it How shall we in this place vindicate the Justice and Goodness of God I have here three things to propound 1. Let us impartially and ingeniously consider whether the freedome of the VVill to determine it self absolutely in all its Acts reflect a greater Glory upon the Justice and Goodness of God than the VVill predetermined in its Essence in its superior Causes in the first and universal Cause That we may make a clearer judgment in this case let us compare these two different states of the VVill together with several Antecedents and Consequencies by placing them both in our view one by another as plainly within as narrow a compass as we can Let us set that Free-will in our eye after this manner God brings forth an Intellectual Spirit with a Divine Light of Truth in its heavenly Beauties shining upon its Understanding with a Divine Love of the true Good with all its heavenly Sweetnesses springing in its VVill. He now sets down the will of this Spirit upon such a ground of indifferency and absoluteness in it self that being undetermined into any forms of good or evil the most heavenly or the most hellish it is equally free for it in the face of all this blessed Light shining in the Understanding in the midst of all the heavenly sweetnesses flowing from the bosome of the true Good through the VVill it self to cast it self forth from the bosome of the eternal Good Appearing thus in its own naked and Divine Form and to cast it self into the embraces of the foulest evil the fountain of all evil presenting it self as evil in its own most direful and haggish shapes A great part of Intellectual Spirits far the greatest part of humane Spirits placed by the Divine Providence in this state refuse the good choose the evil so render themselves obnoxious to the Divine Justice and become by the pursuits and inflictions of that Avenger the lost Subjects of all horror and woes without end Let us now in the like manner cast our eye upon the Will predetermined in its Causes God brings forth an Intellectual Spirit compounded Ex aliquo Dei ex aliquo sui With something of God something of its own That of God in it is all the good of it the clear Face of the eternal Truth shining in its Understanding as in a Christal Mirror the sweet flame of pure Goodness and as pure a love to this Goodness burning in its VVill as upon the golden Altar in the Temple of God the beams of this Beauty and the flames of this Love unitedly spreading varying and forming themselves through the whole Person and Life of this Spirit into all Divine Virtues and Joys by which it becomes as God himself descended into a God-like Image of God himself This is that of God in the Creature That which is ofits own in this Intellectual Spirit is beneath all this heavenly beauty and goodness a deflectibility inseparable from the nature of the Creature bound up only by the heavenly charms of this Divinity resting upon the Person of this Spirit God in the depth of a design perhaps too blessed and too glorious to be penetrated and fathomed by us as the eternal Sun ascends up on high going away from this Spirit and carrying away with him his whole train of immortal beams with a Divine Light Heat and Virtue Now like a mournful and hated darkness from below the natural defectibility of this Spirit covers the whole face of it making it like Hell it self the seat of all evils both of Sin and Suffering which lie eternally upon innumerable multitudes Let us now consider the two-fold Law or
flow from his unvailed Person his naked presence and appearance As the Sun carrieth along with him in his Circuit a sweet flourishing Spring and Summer When God withdraws himself behind clouds of darkness and of night when he withholds the sweet beams and pleasant influences of his own face and person behind thick coverings strange forms and disguises Now man withers and dyes away in all the beauties and sweetnesses of the Divine Image in the place of these Deformity and Death spring up from that deficiency which is inseparable to the natural principles of the Creature which then discovers it self and overspreads the whole man with the shadow of Death and Hell when those principles are no more fed and supplyed from their eternal springs in the bosom of Christ. In this sense these words are most properly true Thy destruction is of thy self but thy Salvation is of me O Israel saith the Lord. 3. God in himself and in the person of the Lord Jesus as he is the essential Image of God is a most simple Unity comprehending all Varieties within himself In this Unity he is Love it self the first the supream the most pure the most potent unconfined love All pleasantnesses are in his Face and Presence he is the Bridegroom entirely fair and pleasant altogether delightful the Object of all Loves Desires the Seat of all Delights and Glories the Spring of Immortality and Eternity As himself is such in the highest affinity and resemblance is his work as it springs immediately from him his principal design and contrivance with which he begins in which he ends and rests eternally which he carrieth along as his first and Ultimate design throughout all things This then is one entire universal piece comprehending all Variety in it self this is one entire piece of sweetest Loves of riches Lights of purest Glories All scenes all forms of darkness and death are subordinate and subservient to this are parts of this are comprehended in this drawn forth from it terminated in it by a Divine and delightful skill set with a shining amiableness in their proper places overspread with a sweetness and lustre in the Unity of the grand design and finally in a manner most pure most harmonious most ravishing swallowed up into the eternal Lights in which the whole piece terminateth Of him and through him and to him are all things who is blessed for ever How true is it how exceeding large now is this truth in all senses in all languages Humane or Divine That God willeth not the death of a Sinner That Destruction is not of him As the Understanding of God is Truth it self the highest and most universal Truth the measure of all Truth so is the Will of God which is himself the first the highest the most comprehensive the unconsined Good the only reason and measure of all good We have passed through those Reasons which seem of greatest moment and to have greatest difficulty in them We hope that we draw near to our Haven and that with easie and gentle stroaks we shall now soon arrive at it The Reasons on this part which now remain seem to be rather mistakes arising from vulgar or general conceptions unexamined undistinguished than from the exercised judgments of wise and learned Spirits They are derived from the nature of things Moral Physical or Metaphysical I shall continue them in the same order with the precedent Reasons 4. Reason If the Will of Man be not free all Laws seem useless Answ. The force of this Reason seemeth to be entire and powerful on the contrary part If the Will of Man be free undeterminated by the dictates of the Understanding Laws have no more any signification or efficacy For the intent of these is clearly to work upon the Understanding Precepts and Prohibitions are Rules propounded Lights set up to the Understanding to inform what road or course is to be followed what to be carefully avoided in our Navigation through the Sea of this World that we may pass safely free from the danger of Rocks and Shelves to our desired Port. Rewards and Penalties are to be weighed and judged by the Understanding according to whose standard and estimate they have all their value Vexatio dat intellectum The proper end of Punishments and Rewards is to excite the Understanding The proper end of Precepts and Prohibitions is to enlighten the Understanding The excellency and efficacy of every Law is to impress upon us the sense of Good and Evil. So Moses the Law-Giver among the Jews saith to them I have set before you this day Good and Evil Life and Death What effect hath the sense of Good and Evil seated in the Understanding if the Will be guided by an absolute ungoverned arbitrariness within it self without Order without Harmony without Connexion without respect to the dictates of the Understanding How useless how fruitless are all impressions of Good or Evil if the Will be not by the Law of its own Essence by its own essential Principles determined to good sub ratione boni under the formal appearance of good 5. Reason Who meeteth not with this frequent experiment in himself which the Poet expresseth in the person of Medea as I remember Video meliora proboque deterior a sequor Better things I see approve The evil yet I choose and love Answ. This thin mist is easily scattered and cleared into a pure Air by the beam of one distinction between good propounded in the Thesis in its abstracted and general nature or in the Hypothesis cloathed with all its practical and individuating circumstances In the first it is the subject of the Dictamen practicum intellectus of the Understanding in its proposal of general Rules of practice to the Will In the other the good is the subject of the Dictamen practice practicum of the Understanding in its dictates and directions to the Will in arenâ upon the place in the singular and individual action now this moment lying before it with all its circumstances The Schools well distinguish between Act us signatus and Act us exercitus An Act marked out and described by the Understanding or an Act now immediately presenting it self unto a real existency out of all its Causes Whoever vieweth and distinguisheth exactly the sentiments of his Understanding the commerce between those and the motions of his Will maketh this clear discovery if I be not very much deceived That in the general conception and rule in the practical dictate and direction in the exactest contemplation and description of a moral Act one thing seemeth good to us when after this when we come upon the place to exercise the Act it self our sense is altogether changed The practically practical dictate of the Understanding its sentiments now in the moment of action in the presence and immediate impressions of all Circumstances differeth from the precedent Rules and passeth quite to a contrary Point to present that as the present good the good of the
the Perfection of each Being That which all things desire that which equalleth and transcendeth all desires As St. Paul saith to the Athenians That God whom ye ignorantly worship I preach unto you So by these unquestioned Principles it seemeth unquestionable That God as he is in his own proper Form is alone that Object which all things in Heaven on Earth and under the Earth love seek and adore If he shall please to lift up his Vail and discover his Face to be seen by all eyes of mortal or immortal Creatures all casting away their several Idols would run swiftly and unanimously into his Bosom alone crying out with an universal shoot This is he whom our Souls love This is our Beloved This alone is the Good which we have pursued in all things through all things Here is our Rest for ever If any Spirit then hate God it directeth its hatred not against God but a false Image which it hath set up to it self of God as an hater of him as a cruel one as extending himself to a larger compass in severities and wrath than sweetnesses and loves as an hard Task-Master requiring Brick when he affordeth no Straw as an enemy or a neglecter of the joy and felicity of his Creatures as raising a pleasure and glory to himself in the shame and ruine of his own Work or at least from a want of natural goodness and kindly affection leaving his own Work his own Birth to shame and ruine when it is every way in his Power to make it good and great in Blessedness and Glory So now it is no more God which this Spirit hateth but an Idol set up within it self in the place of God So sin deceiveth it first and then killeth it by a misplaced hatred upon a mistaken Object So this Spirit sinneth by falling short of the Glory of God and manifesteth its sin by this to be nothing positive but a privation only 8. Reason This predetermination of the Will placeth Man in the same rank with Automata the self-moving Works of Art as Clocks and Watches These are determined by the Workman to a certain motion which they cannot vary and being put into motion by the hand of the Workman they continue it without any power over it unto its designed period Such a piece of work Man seemeth to be if the motions of his Will upon which all other Humane motions depend be not in his own power Answ. What if Man be not allowed that Prerogative in respect to the superior and universal Movers which these works of Art have in respect to the Artificer He frameth his pieces for their motion he putteth them into motion they now continue their motions without any assistance from the Workman the Author of their frame and motion Man lives and moves and hath his Being in God Every distinct moment of his Being Life and Motions are new and distinct emanations from God as in their first Beginning as at their first Creation yet are the preheminencies of this self-mover the Soul of Man many great and glorious above the self-moving works of Art 1. The motions of the Will are Intellectual The Soul in the actings of the VVill understandeth reflecteth upon its own motions It comprehendeth the beginning the end of them their causes out of which they arise their nature and differences their course and stream in which they run along their effects and consequents in which they determine 2. The motions of the VVill are with a relish and agreeableness They all flow from Love the love of Good the love of Beauty which is good in its proper Image or appearance This is the first and great wheel in the VVill which puts all the wheels of the other affections or passion sinto motion The motions of the VVill tend all to delight and joy as their mark to the delightful and joyous fruition of the beloved Beauty the beloved Good in the which the VVill together with the whole Soul and the whole Man hath its rest and its end 3. The Soul of Man in the motions of the Will is acted by superior and universal Causes not as an external hand or power but as internal Principles as the springs of Being and Beauty of Life and Light of Activity and Motion of all power sense and relish which are essentially comprehended in the Essence of the Soul and Will which continually feed it Give me leave here again to cite those uncontroverted Maxims in the Metaphysicks the universal cause is most truly is most of all the Cause in every kind of casuality So is it most truly most of all the essential the formal cause of the Soul and of its Will The universal Cause is most intimate to every effect It is then most intimate to the Will and to the operations of the Will VVe read in Proclus That the Soul containeth all things in it self 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that is after the manner of a Soul The subordinate and supream kinds of things are comprehended in the inferior kind entring into the definition and essence of each specifical nature together with it Thus man comprehendeth in his Essence the superior forms of a living Creature of a corporeal substance of substance it self in its abstracted eminency of Being the Fountain and Head of all these After the same manner the Divine Ideas their eminencies and virtues the Angelical forms in their powers and properties descending and forming themselves into an inferior Image in which they are all united constitute the Essence of the Soul and are complicated in it But to conclude my Answer to this Reason Doth this darken the glory of the VVill of Man Doth this confine it destroying its freedom and its Joy that it acteth and moveth in conformity to in communion and fellow ship with the Divine VVill from the same Principle in the same amplitude to the same end by the same necessity of good alone of the supream the universal Good comprehending all things in it self unchangeable in all This is the proper nature of Man and of his VVill that Divine Similitude and Image in which he was first created 9. Reason But the Variety of things that it may be entire requires it that there should be in nature a free agent undetermined to motion or a cessation from motion to this or a contrary motion having the disposal of it self of its own acts independantly entirely in it self Answ. 1. I do not remember that I have hitherto read or heard this pleaded That the VVill is equally undetermined and free to Good or to Evil presenting themselves in the formalities or appearances of Good or of Evil. This were to affirm that evil equally with good is the Object of the VVill That all things desire evil in its own proper form as much as good Yet this Variety here asserted clearly asserteth this 2. A full Variety is directed to the most perfect Harmony as its end It is the Unity preserved entire in the Variety
is linkt by heavenly embraces to Jesus Christ Jesus Christ to God the Father of Lights and the spring of Loves Homer tells us of a Chain fastned to the Throne of Jupiter which reacheth down to the Earth He speaketh to Neptune Minerva and the rest of the Powers about him which reign in the Skies in the Seas in the Earth in Hell below If ye should all hang with your whole weight upon the end of this Chain I would at my pleasure draw you all up to my self The Throne of the most High God is a Throne of Grace of Love Like a Chain doth the whole Nature of things descend from this Throne having its top fastned to it What-ever the weights may be of the lowermost links of this Chain yet that Love which sits upon the Throne with a Divine delight as it lets down the Chain from it self so draws it up again by the Order of the successive Links unto a Divine Ornament an eternal Joy and Glory to it self All things of Nature in its Beauties all things of Nature in its Ruine Life and Death in all forms are a Saints a Saint is Christs Christ is Gods But gentle Reader this is enough to set forth the suitableness between the two Subjects of my Epistle and my Book the Divine Love and the VVill of Man the Daughter and the Bride of this Love by its immortal Birth and Espousals essentially inevitably determined to its heavenly Father and Bridegroom To this Love the only Good in all appearances of it the Will turns it self as the Needle toucht with the Loadstone to the North-pole Beautiful and blessed is this Will when it s own Bridegroom shines upon it and attracts it by beams by sweet glimpses of it self spread through all things more clear or more obscure but true Then do her beauty and blessedness both change into deformity and misery when by hellish enchantments she is deluded and drawn into the embraces of a wrinkled VVitch or a Spirit from the darkness below transformed into the likeness of her heavenly Love There are now a few things only remaining of which I would briefly give thee some accompt 1. Persons engaged on both sides in this question which is the ground of my Treatise are highly honoured by me and truly dear to me in an high degree A natural Understanding Ingenuity Integrity Learning VVisdom Knowledge an heavenly mind set a great price and lustre upon them The ends at which these persons on both parts profess to aim are truly Spiritual and Divine It is the design of one part to beighten the Grace of God by its freedom and peculiarity Of the other to enlarge the Glory of this Grace by its extent and amplitude One admires and adores the absoluteness the soveraignty of God the other his goodness On one side is an holy jealously for the Unity and the Beauty of the Divine Nature lest God should be imagined like the natural day in the Creation made up of two Contraries co-ordinate and equally predominate as Day and Night Love and VVrath a ground of Holiness and a ground of Sin The others are equally jealous of the same Unity and Beauty of the Divine Nature lest the eternal Power and so the Godhead should be divided between the Creator and the Creature least in effect two Gods should be set up like those of the Manichees a Fountain of Good and a Fountain of Evil lest the Divine Glory should be darkned in its work and the Harmony broken in which the Divine Unity and Beauty most sweetly shine by taking away in any part of the work the fix'd subordination of Causes and Effects O what Joy and Glory would crown the Earth and the Church of God on Earth if those Divine Persons who have fix'd to themselves ends so Divine instead of opposing each other in their way perhaps sometimes mistaken to those ends would unite their Divine Will and Forces mutually to advance the ends each of other St. Paul saith If the falling away of the Jews be the bringing in of the Gentiles what shall the return be but life from the dead If the dividings the disputes of these Parties have brought much light to the Church what will the reconciling and uniting of their glorious ends and their Spirits in the glory of those ends be but as a Marriage-day shining from on high which shall fill the Angels themselves with a new joy The day will come when men shall say Blessed is he who comes in the Name of the Lord Who reconciletâ—… the freedom and peculiarity of the Grace of God unto a full amplitude and extent so raising its sweetness to a perfect heighth who shall bring into mutual embraces the soveraignty or absoluteness of God and his goodness that the soveraignty the absoluteness may be soveraignly and absolutely good that the goodness alone may be absolute and soveraign who through the whole compass of the Divine Nature and the works of God shall discover to the eyes of men in the evidence of a Divine Light the Unity the Beauty of the Godhead in their clearest Purity their highest Perfection springing and shining through all making all in the whole one entire piece pure and pleasant perfect in the Beauties of Holiness The Rules which I have desired to govern my self by in this Discourse are these Right Reason the universally acknowledged Principles of all sober Philosophy and sound Divinity the Analogy of Faith the Letter of the Scriptures the Spirit of Christ in the Head of the Church Christ himself in the Scriptures in the Church in the Spirits and experiences of each Saint As all these answer each other in a mutual Harmony like the several strings upon a well-tuned Lute So shall I ever as I humbly believe take it for granted That what-ever jars upon any of these strings is also out of tune to all the rest That what-ever is not conformable to any one of these Rules crosseth them all If any thing of this kind shall have faln from me I do here humbly repent of it and recant it I humbly desire all those who shall stoop to read what I have written to believe that no Gift can be so acceptable to me as the displacing of any Errour or Falshood in my Mind with the gentle hand of Love by bringing in the Truth which it hath counterfeited and vailed If any Errour have seemed sweet beautiful or desirable to me in any kind I humbly undertake to have a confident assurance of this That the Truth it self shining forth will bring along with it far more transcendent Sweetnesses Beauties Agreeablenesses and Satisfactions to all my Desires excelling it in all the impressions of a Divine Pleasantness Power and Profit as the true Sun doth a Parelius or a counterfeit Image of the Sun in a Cloud If any shall undertake to answer this Discourse with reviling and reproachful Language I shall endeavour to imitate the example of the Marquess de Rente fixed with
shall be 1. An humble proposal of those Arguments which seem to fight against this liberty 2. To state and examine the Arguments brought to establish this liberty with all the clearness and candour that I am capable of To these also I shall annex those answers which may appear proper to give any satisfaction to those Arguments These two sorts of Arguments I shall digest into so many Books 1. The first Book shall contain the first sort of Arguments opposed to this liberty in question divided according to these five Heads from which they are drawn 1. The Divine Nature 2. The Nature of the Creature 3. The Mediation of Christ. 4. The Soul intellectual with its Will 5. The proper form and essence of liberty 1. Head of Arguments The first Head of Arguments is the Divine Nature From this Head we shall draw seven Arguments 1. Argument The first Argument from the Divine Nature is the Being of God God is Being it self in its simplicity and absoluteness the first the supreme the universal Being This is his Name by which he makes Himself known to Moses I A M Being it self in its absoluteness undivided unrestrained unconfined unallayed by any differences of mixtures Being it self at the utmost heighth of all Eminencies and Transcendencies Being it self in its fulness in its greatest Amplitude and Majesty Being it self in its Truth in its substance the only true Being the universal Being comprehending the excellencies of all Beings heighthned to a transcendency above all Being and all Excellency all Being in one all Being complete in one complete Person which is a perfect number of Persons Three Persons in One that it may entertain and enjoy it self in a perfect immortal Circle of all Being and blessedness This is God this is his Name I A M. His Name Jah imports the same sense Being it self His Name Jehovah expresseth the same thing the universal Being All Beings past present and to come with all their distinctions and differences in one Every thing that I S beareth written upon it this Name of God I A M. All things that be declare a Being While all things agree in this That they be they demonstrate an universal Being Being as it is divided and restrained by particular Differences in all things particular and different one from another by being lessened contracted and obscured is imperfect Nothing that is imperfect can subsist exist of it self or by it self for so far as it is imperfect it is not Imperfection is so far a privation or negation of Being Before then that which is imperfect is that which is perfect from which and by which that which is imperfect existeth Thus Socrates in Plato from the beauties of sense scattered and divided among divers beautiful Subjects or Persons leads us to all the beauties of sense united in one Person compleatly beautiful From this perfection of beauty where it is an accident seated in a subject of dark matter ever changing he raiseth us to the innumerable forms of beauty the unchangeable essences and immortal substances of beauty where beauty is the whole substance pure and immaterial These manifold forms of immaterial and essential beauties awakened into the intellectual Spirit he maketh as golden wings by which we fly upward into the bosome of that first Beauty where all beauties meet in an entire and transcendent Unity Thus all particular and imperfect Beings carry us up to the perfect and universal Being abstracted from them all set on his Throne high and listed up above them all from which as their proper Head they flow by and in which as in their proper Root they subsist being the beams of this glorious Sun and Rivers from this full Sea This is God in his high and holy place of Eternity This universal Being where all Beings meet in one is Eternity This is the holy place of Eternity Being it self in its most exalted Purity abstracted and separated from all differences mixtures allayes from every thing forreign This is the high place of Eternity Being it self in its first and supreme Unity comprehending all Beings all perfections of Being heighthned to a perfection so far above themselves that no Being the most perfect is able to look up to it Can now any thing any where any Essence Power Act any Will or motion of the Will be and not be originally contained in this first Being and not be subject subordinate to this supreme Being and not lie within the compass be full of be universally filled with this universal Being In Metaphysicks we are taught That God as He is Being it self in its simplicity is the proper immediate and formal Cause of all Being every where and that the modifications only of each Being proceed from it by the mediation of second Causes Is it not clear then that these modifications themselves so far as they be or have any Being in them are the immediate and formal effects of the first and universal Being If now the motion the modification the determination of the Will in its Acts be not it is no more the subject of any dispute discourse or thought it hath no more any place or effect in the nature of things to bring forth any Consequences or to make any Differences If it be if it have any Being at all Can it have any place without the comprehension and embraces of the universal Being Shall it not yield the Power the Preheminence the Soveraignty to Him whose Name alone is I AM and I AM that which I AM Shall it not confess to him and say Thou only art the only true Being the universal Being I am a shadow and empty figure Thou art the truth the substance of my Being Thou fillest all in all of me Thou art that which thou art I am a shadow of my self only I am only That which I am in Thee That which Thou art in me I am my true self only so far as I am in Thee the Original truth of all Being only so far as thou art in me the Substantial truth of all Being Object Do we make the Creature nothing Do we make God All Do we confound God and the Creature Answ. Far be it VVe speak the Language of the general stream of Divines Philosophers Poets Heathen and Sacred through all Ages VVe speak their Language with their sense and upon their grounds But we chiefly build upon the foundation of the holy Scriptures in which we read such characters of men of the world of all things in it that they are a scheam or figure that they are not lighter than vanity less than nothing a vapour a vain shew a tale that is told a dream in sleep All that we converse with is stiled by Plato 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that which is not and distinguished from 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that which truly is Aristotle stiles God 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Being of Beings We learn of him that that is True which terminates and gives rest to the
chiefly turneth about in respect to its Beauty and Deformity its Misery and Felicity its Eternity have no Connexion with or Dependance upon the other parts of the work the Image or Original Model in the Divine mind Can there be an Order here in the whole Can all the parts in the whole have an harmonious proportion to each other Can the Work outward agree with the inward Model the whole agreeing with the whole and each part answering each part Can this work be perfect Can it be wrought in Judgment Is the whole way of this work the way of Judgment Is there in each step of it the foot-step of a Divine Understanding the impression of a Divine Wisdom which is an entire uninterrupted Order Do all the parts in this Work according to the Model or Image in the mind of the Work-man lie together in one whole piece in one beautiful body knit together by fit joynts and bands ministring to each other by these joynts and bands mutual strength beauties and perfections from the same Head whose Unity runneth through shineth in the whole and all its several parts thus uniting them as one body to each other and to its self Doth not this supposition of such an independent Liberty in the Will to Contrarieties and Contradictions naturally lead us to an imagination of two Gods one Good the other Evil striving together in the composure of the same work bringing in consusion upon it by crossing and interrupting each other according to the sense of the Manichees Or doth it not favour that Opinion of some Platonists of a matter the subject of the Divine Work co-eternal with the Divine Spirit the Work-man which being in some parts of it altogether intractable resisting the skill and power of the Archytect or working Spirit receiveth not the Divine form which that would introduce could not be made beautiful and so brought Confusion War all Evil into the Work Or if that seem more probable would it not incline us to the belief of fortuitous motions of numberless Particles confusedly concurring which have neither beginning rule nor end of themselves their shapes or motions What skilful Poet makes his Poem so that the great Chain and final Catastrophe in the conduct and government of which the chief beauty of the whole Work is plac'd from which arise the greatest Consequences together with the perfection and praise of the whole piece should be derived from a meer Contingency which hath no coherence with any antecedent part which receiveth no force from any thing of any reason proportion or order in the whole which hath no place nor form in the design of the Poet Would any wise Work-man who had an absolute power over his work who brought forth from himself entirely both the matter and form of it according to his will frame a work in which the great end of the principal parts and of the whole should be undetermined by being dependant upon the great and chief motion of the work which can have no complete Idea in the mind of the Worker from which it may receive its form which is uncapable of having any certain conformity to the will of the Workman to derive from thence an agreeable sweetness and goodness through the veins of the whole and of all the parts that the spirit which hath wrought it may have rest and complacency in the work it self in the harmony of the work within it self and in the harmony of it with the Model in its own Understanding Would he frame a work which in this its principal motion should be altogether out of its own power should have no natural no moral necessity or certainty from any antecedent causality and reason which should be altogether fortuitous which should be thus rendred altogether uncapable of being one entire piece where all the parts first contained in the Potentiality and Unity of the whole flowing forth from it by virtue of that Unity are united among themselves by their mutual Relations and Proportions making up a beautiful harmony in the whole This in all learning and observation hath been esteemed the first and chief part of wisdom to fix determinately with full strength of inclination thought and contrivance the end of every work This the second part next to it particularly stiled Prudence to dispose and direct all the means efficaciously and infallibly to those ends Object 1. Perhaps some one will say That the parts of the Divine Work have their coherence connexion and proportion while this grand motion of which wespeak the determination of the Will flows from the power of the Will which flows from God the Fountain of causality in the centinued stream of second causes Answ. This indeed is often spoken of Let us see if it be well understood if there be no fallacy or ambiguity latent or manifest in this Assertion If the power of the Will be the cause of its determination if God in the order of second causes be the Author of this Power then also is the determination of the Will from Him after the same manner by the force of that Rule Quicquid est causa causae est causa causati The cause of any cause is also the cause of the effect produced by that cause Now is the Will no more free with an undetermined freedome or liberty being thus predetermined in its superior causes from which it receives both the power of determining and the determination of its power Now is the power of its Will in its state of acting not undetermined or indifferent to contradictory and contrary terms or bounds of its motion If it be replyed that the power of the Will in determining it self is from God in the natural course of things but the act of that power in the determination of it self from the power of the Will alone with an absolute and universal independancy upon all things antecedent to it either natural or moral Although this be very difficult to be understood yet I shall not at present make any other opposition to it than this that it leaves my present Argument untoucht in its full strength and vigour Object 2. There is something of greater moment which perhaps may seem to shake the structure and strength of this Reason The great and Ultimate ends of God in his Work are the glories of his Goodness and his Justice In this the Divine Wisdom shines out with a lustre dazling the eyes of our Reason of every created Understanding in finding out this the most proper and effectual way to these ends viz. The setting up of intellectual Spirits free in the determination of themselves to good or evil and compensating this good and this evil with suitable torments suitable triumphs Answ. Three Answers offer themselves to this Objection 1. Answ. This also yieldeth that on which the whole weight of the Argument against Free-will lieth the righteousness and wickedness of intellectual Spirits that is the highest Beauty the foulest Deformity upon the
relations from the Creature to it self Thus doth the Divine goodness in the Divine VVill terminate the relation of every created VVill to it self in the agreeableness or disagreeableness of every Act. This supream goodness then hath in it self the measure of this agreeableness and disagreeableness which it receiveth not from without but hath originally in it self So all the acts of the VVill according to their conformity with or deformity from the first goodness derive themselves from their proper Original in that goodness Accordingly the Goodness and the Will of God hath a complacency in every Act of the VVill if it be agreeable to it or an aversion from it if it be disagreeable Thus is the created VVill in all its motions with their several most exact distinctions the Object of the eternal VVill in its love or hatred Every faculty or power hath an essential relation to its proper object and dependance upon it It is drawn forth by it into the most proper Acts of its essence and receiveth from it the perfection of its essence which consisteth in its Activity The supream VVill the supream Goodness being perfectly eternally in Act hath all its Acts all its Objects by which it is actuated perfectly eternally from and in it self Object You will say How can this be Can the Divine VVill which is infinitely pure in the beauties of Holiness in the joys of all blessedness comprehend in it self Good and Evil agreeableness and disagreeableness to it self which are the proper measures and essential forms of all good and evil Can it comprehend in it self Objects of Love and Hatred Can this Fountain send forth from it self sweet and bitter waters How is it holy if there be these mixtures How is it happy if it be thus divided within it self Answ. The Flats and Sharpes the Bases and Trebles the Concords and Discords of Musick are all comprehended by the spirit of the Musician in one Act of Harmony in one simple and undivided Act of Harmony This single Act of Harmony by its proper force first invented and formed all Musical Instruments prepared them for it self through all the diversity of touches and motions actuated them that it might compleatly figure and display upon them and upon all things round about them it self in its own full sweetness according to all those rich varieties virtually and eminently comprehended within it self in one simple Act. So in one indivisible Act or Idea of beauty in the Spirit of the Painter lie together all the differing lines lights shades and colours by which that Idea reflecteth it self in Picture upon the eyes and spirits of the Beholder In like manner the far greater perfection the Will of God being a simple 〈◊〉 of Goodness supreamly indivisible and eternal containeth originally eminently within it self complacency and aversion love and hatred with their several objects in their several forms and degrees in their several risings and fallings most properly and harmoniously suited to each other From it self doth this supream Goodness bring forth its own Objects like tuned Instruments wound up or let down every way prepared for the diffusion and discovery of it self upon them in those Varieties of love and hatred complacency and aversion with their several steps or modifications which as so many distinct forms or virtues of the Divine Goodness dwell together there in the highest and most absolute Variety as in the fullest and most unconfined Unity The Will of God is commonly and rightly distinguished into positive and permissive Evil is by the permissive Good from the positive Will of God All the determinations and motions of the Will in every Spirit are at least from the permission of the Divine Will I will not now enquire how the most perfect Goodness can be permissive in that in which it is positive This only I take which is universally granted That there is no permissive Will in God without a positive Act. He permitteth nothing without a positive Act of his Will for that permission If the permission of any Act in the will of man antecede that Act then is that act or motion of the humane will the Object of a positive Act of the Divine Will for the permission of it before it be brought forth here below This objective existence in the Divine Will is either the Copy or the Original to that motion in the will of the Creature If it be universally received by all Understandings from the universal Harmony and principles of Truth that the Divine Nature can take no Copy receive no Impression of any thing from any thing without it self it necessarily followeth that all motions in the will of man flow from that antecedent existence which they have in the Divine Will as the Objects of that Thus that I may not be too long upon this Head of Arguments drawn from the Divine Nature I have contracted three sorts of Arguments into one Those from the Will the Goodness the Power of God being drawn together under that of the Divine Power I have in it built upon this sure ground The VVill of God is the first the supream the essential Goodness The Goodness of God is his Power As every thing depends upon the VVill of God in its permission or positive Act As all things in their measures of Good or Evil lie together in the Divine Goodness the Original the eternal measure of all Good and Evil so have all Powers all Acts and Motions of Power their first spring their exact form and rule in the Power of God 5. Argument The fifth Argument is the Knowledge of God This is in our present cause a most celebrated Argument I shall therefore endeavour to represent the state of it with all exactness clearness and integrity that I can bring to it I shall divide this Argument into two parts 1. The first is the perfection of the Divine Knowledge 2. The second is the Original 1. Part. The first part is the perfection of the Divine Knowledge This consisteth in two things 1. The Comprehensiveness 2. The distinctness of the Knowledge VVe then know perfectly when we know all things capable of being known when we know each thing in its proper distinction in all its distinct forms properties and relations Shall not He who made the eye see Shall not the Fountain of Knowledge contain all Knowledges after the most exact and eminent manner Shall not He know all things most accurately by whom all things know and are known St. Peter saith to Jesus Christ as to God Lord Lord thou knowest all things thou knowest that I love thee See two things remarkable here 1. The universality of Christ's Knowledge extending its self to all things 2. A confirmation of this by a particular instance Thou knowest that I love thee The instance is most pertinent to our present purpose It is that peculiar Object of Knowledge which is the ground and subject of this Discourse the Will of Man the motions of the will the freest
and Divine Harmony through the Death and Resurrection of the Lord Jesus But we will leave these things to their proper places In the mean time this Truth seemeth tâ—… be firmly established upon unmoveable grounds that nothing as it lies in the whole in all its causes concurrences relations and circumstances is mean vile or little unworthy of the Divine Mind which if it were a stranger to any the least circumstance of things even the first most unperceptible motions of the Will were uncapable of judging of the Harmony of the whole of Good and Evil which consist in order and disorder especially of moral Good and Evil the chief Good and Evil of the chief pieces of the whole Work Intellectual Spirits whose Good and Evil in order to an eternity of Happiness or Misery are defined and determined by every motion of the Will If I have been at the expence of much time and pains upon this Subject the Omniscience of God or the universality of his Knowledge and the exactness of it in this Universality I humbly conceive that I have not done it impertinently being moved to it by these two Reasons 1. Learned men know that this Flower in the Crown of the Great King this Attribute of God hath been denied to him in the face of the whole World with great confidence with bold pretences of Reason and Learning opposed to it I have heard this perfection of the Divine Nature in the Process of a Discourse upon this freedome of the Will questioned Whether it were proper to God or a Perfection and this Question made soberly there where modesty goodness and learning have met together 2. This Argument of the Divine Omniscience appeareth to mewith so great weight in this cause that if this be freely granted and clearly understood I cannot at all comprehend by what way or means the liberty of the Will now examined can suppart it self without the overturning the whole fabrick of our Philosophy and Divinity with the absolute ruines of all their beauties and strengths I hope in a few words to manifest this in the Second Part of this Argument which now follows 2. Part. The Second Part is the Original of the Divine Knowledge This knowledge of God ariseth not from without but from within himself This Truth seemeth to carry the full and sweet light of its own evidence brightly shining in the face of it If God receive any thing from without he is no more immutable impassible independent a pure Act a perfect eternal Act a simple Unity but a composition of divers and different ingredients If any Species or Image if any Knowledge flow in upon the Divine Understanding from any external Object not only all the Properties Perfections and Attributes ascribed to God but his Godhead it self with all its most essential Glories are shaken overthrown and utterly demolished If God be receptive of any thing from any other he is no more the first the universal Being the Fountain of all Being and so no more God It is generally and rightly affirmed That the Essence of God and the Operations are the same that his Knowledge is Himself If then He receive the knowledge of any thing He receiveth also Himself and his Godhead from a Forreign Spring Wâ—…o saith St. Paul hath been his Counsellor or who hath given to Him first that He should repay Object Some eminent Divines seeming to understand the force of the Reason in this Point to lie in the fore-knowledge of God have believed themselves to have gained a full Victory over it by an imagined co-existence of God with the Creature For say they God is infinite as in his Essence so in his duration By virtue of this infiniteness he after an immutable manner co-exists with the Creature in all its changes Eternity which is the duration of the Divine Essence in its undivided and unchangeable but unconfined Unity co-exists with time the duration of the Creature in all its numerous and successive motions in all its undivided moments Thus say they God properly foreknows nothing but knoweth every Creature as it is present with Him in its own proper existence and time Answ. If all this in the full Latitude be freely granted I humbly conceive that the present Argument remains still in its full force unshaken untoucht But first I shall crave leave to offer some incongruities and mistakes which make me uncapable of satisfying my self with this co-existence thus formed and founded 1. This seems to take away out of the mouth of God Himself speaking by the Prophet Isaiah one Principal proof of his Godhead which he pleaseth to make use of several times over and in which he glories challenging all the gods of the Heathen to come and try their Divinities by this Test This is the Power of Prophecying the declaring of things to come 2. Doth not the Co-existence mentioned commensurate God with the Creature make God the Subject of a Relation to the Creature establish a proportion between Him and the Creature which are all contrary to the infiniteness of God as to the most uncontroverted Principle of Divinity shining in upon us by the light of Nature or of Revelation 3. If God by Co-existing with the Creature in the moment of the Fall at the beginning of time declares that full Victory of Christ over the Serpent at the end of time which he knows only by coexisting with that action in its proper scene and duration at the winding up of all Ages Doth it not follow that the beginning and the end of time in their proper seasons and durations co-exist and fall in with each other For this is a Maxim of universal force That those two things which meet in a third meet in themselves 4. The best Understandings pure and clear as the Sun it self clouded with flesh while they see through so thick a medium are capable of various and disproportionate views of their Object A weaker sight fixed on and confined to some narrower and more particular Image may in that sometimes discover to better eyes which extend themselves to a more spacious Object an error in that smaller Point Accordingly those great Spirits with whom I now treat perhaps may find themselves mistaken in their sense of the Divine Co-existence with the Creature if they please to consider this which I shall now propound God indeed is infinite By this infiniteness he is above all proportion to all commerce with every thing that is finite By this infiniteness he comprehends in himself all Creatures with all theirExistencies Formalities and Modifications after an infinite manner eminently and with the highest transcendency Thus he beholdeth thus he converseth with all things within Himself Divines generally place the Joys of glorified Spirits in that Beatifical Vision which is the sight of all things in the most amiable face of the most highly adored Trinity as in the only clear Glass of all Images of things in their eternal Truths Is not God Himself blessed in the
most beautiful Ideas of his Skill and Wisdome Shall he not here lay on the greatest Riches of his Divine Goodness Shall he not stamp on these the most glorious Seal of his Truth his Faithfulness to the work of his hands Shall he not give the most heightned life and sweetning to this Seal of his Goodness Truth and Skill Doth not he understand that the perfection of the whole work lies that the praise and glory of the Workman depends principally if not entirely upon these Joynts on which the motion of the whole in so high a degree depends I will briefly conclude this part of my Discourse Reader think of God as Sweetness it self all pure unmixt unconfined Think of God as the Spirit of Love Beauty Joy all in one in their most abstracted Essences in their highest Exaltation in their greatest amplitude in their most potent vigour incorruptible eternal Think of God as the purest and richest Spring without beginning or end as the clearest Sea without bottom or bounds of all Perfections in the highest degree of Pleasantness of all Pleasantness in the highest Perfection Think of all things together with thy self in this God the Unchangeable Original of all according to their first and truest forms according to their eternal Truths one Goodness and Sweetness together with this goodness and sweetness it self one Spirit with this Spirit of all Loves Beauties and Joys in Divine figures divinely distinct as the first and fullest Variety in the first and entirest Unity When thou hast thought thus of God now think whether all things within thee do not with the fullest concurrence meet in this one only most passionate desire that this God may alone conduct his whole Work the whole course of all things that he may be present may act may appear alone in every part in every motion of it as filling so many figures and shadows of Himself After all consider whether that ground in which is founded the desire of this as the most perfect good the Object of all desires be not as firm a foundation for the belief of this no less agreeable Truth to the Understanding than it is of good to the Will Can Goodness and Truth be separated when Truth is Goodness in its essential Image in its fullest fairest reflection Shall not the most perfect Workman bring forth the most perfect Work the best from the best Shall not the highest God the most true of Himself thus do who is the supream Good whose Will is Goodness it self where as Ficinus upon Plato speaks the highest Voluntariness and the highest Necessity most beautifully and most pleasantly meet in the most inviolable band of the most true the most perfect Good 2. Head of Arguments I pass now to the second Head of Arguments taken from the Mediation of Christ and opposed to that Liberty of the Will which is placed in a freedome from the predetermination of its Acts in its essential Principles and superior Causes My method of treating of the Mediation of Christ and directing my Discourse upon it to the service of my present design shall be this I will endeavour with all humility and holy reverence by the conduct of that sweet Light which falls from the Face of Christ by the guidance of his Eyes the only Fountain of Grace and Truth to set before us the Lord Jesus in those three principal Parts of his Mediation as he is 1. The ground 2. The way 3. The end of the whole Work of God 1. Jesus Christ is the ground of the whole Work of God This is the first and principal part of Christ's Mediation in which he is the Golden Head of the whole Image of things in Grace and Nature This well understood according to the weak capacity of our Understanding here below seemeth to make all the other parts of the Mediatorship with the whole tract of things plain and pleasant That which in Divinity and Philosophy is understood by the name of a Person is an Intellectual Being compleatly existing Therefore God Angels which are called Gods and Men made in the Image of God which are also dignified with the Name of God in the holy Scripture are only stiled and esteemed Persons The reason of the Name I humbly conceive to be this Every Intellectual Spirit according to the propriety of its Nature and Essence comprehendeth entirely within it self the principle of its own Essence its essential form and operation by comprehending in it self the whole nature of things The Understanding in its perfect Act and Being in its largest compass are said by Philosophers to meet in a mutual proportion and union the one being the proper and adequate Object of the other Therefore the Greeks call every Intellectual Spirit 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the whole The prime operation of every Intellectual Spirit is contemplation The first and immediate Object of its contemplation is its own Essence In this Glass of living and immortal Light all other things according to their proper essences in their several and essential forms appear to it most clearly and delightfully as its own Births and Beauties God the first and most perfect the Father and King of all Intellectual Spirits is the truest Person He alone in truth subsisteth in himself existeth without and above all things He truly containeth the whole compass of things in their unchangeable Truths and Substances within himself although he Himself be the most absolute and most abstracted Unity Angels and Men in the perfection of their Natures are no more than shadowy persons They have only shadowy Essences a shadowy comprehension of shadows God then alone most perfectly and substantially enjoyeth Himself in the contemplation of Himself which is the Beatifical Vision of the most beautiful the most blessed Essence of Essences This Act of Contemplation is an Intellectual and Divine Generation in which the Divine Essence with an eternity of most heightned Pleasures eternally bringeth forth it self within it self into an Image of it self According to the Perfection in which God knoweth Himself and enjoyeth Himself so is the Perfection of this Image As those are so is this clear distinct and full The more distinct the beam is from the first Light in its emanation the more strong and full is the reflectiou This Divine Image then is at once most perfectly distinct from its Divine Original most exactly equal to it and most perfectly one with it As then God is so is this essential eternal Image of God a compleat and distinct Person in it self in every point with the highest and most ravishing agreeableness answering the Divine Esseunce in its spring out of which it ariseth If this Image were not a compleat Person Gods knowledge and fruition of Himself would be incompleat without the pleasing and proportionate returns of an equal Loveliness Life and Love If this Image were not most perfectly distinct from the bosome out of which it flourisheth the knowledge and enjoyment of God would be confused more
one breath one beam one stream from the eternal Spirit succeeds new in the place of the other sprung forth from it in the point of time immediately preceding The whole Creation each particular Creature is no more the same hath no continuance hath no Unity with it self save only as it is in Jesus Christ in its first and eternal Form its truest Form its truest Self in Him who alone is the true the substantial the universal Image of God the express Image of his Substance Unity and Eternity All created forms are so far only the same and one in a figure or similitude as they are sealed with the impression of their Ideal and Original form in Christ as they subsist in this Root as they are Garments with which this their eternal Truth and Substance cloathes it self In the my stical Fables of the Heathens the Goddess of Wisdome contending with the God of the Seas for the tutelage of Athens made suddainly at once to spring up out of the Earth an Olive-tree in its perfection with its branches and leaves all green laden with ripe Olives When an Olive-tree or an Apple-tree riseth up by degrees from its Kernel to a perfect Plant when it successively putteth forth it self thorow the Spring and Summer in buds in leaves in blosomes in fruit unto a fulness in Autumn then in that state of maturity with its leaves and fruit in full growth and beauty upon it it standeth up immediately and entirely out of its Ideal or first Cause out of the Divine Omnipotency or Almightiness as if it had never before existed as if no Summer no Spring had ever gone before Yea the whole Creation round about that Olive-tree in its present posture with all Plants on Earth with the present face of Heaven with the present configuration of all Bodies of all Humane or Angelical Spirits comes forth from God as immediately entirely absolutely as when on the third day all Herbs Flowers and Trees first appeared and rose up in a moment at once perfect out of the Earth or as if this present Autumn had been the first and the beginning of the World as some suppose that season to have been All things in the Creature upon this ground have their order and connexion not by virtue of any dependance upon each other but by the force of the eternal Order the inviolable Harmony in the first Cause the Ideal or exemplary World in the Divine Mind If the Being of the Creature be an emanation or beaming forth from the first Being then as the emanation or flowing forth is distinct new and fresh every moment so is there every moment a new fresh distinct World or Creation If man thus with his Soul his Powers his Operations with all the modifications of his whole Person Body and Spirit in each moment spring forth fresh and full that moment from his first and universal Cause as Philosophers say the Sun and his beams were concreated at the beginning of the World What then is the liberty of the Will in determining it self Is it any other than this the truest the happiest the only desirable freedome of coming forth as it is sent forth from God the first and the best of all things in a conformity to its eternal Truth its Original Form in the highest Beauty the highest Bliss the Divine Wisdome and Will Reader if any difficulties arise in thy mind about the reconciling of the appearances of things in the World so mixt with Good and Evil the evil of Deformity the evil of Sin the deformity of Intellectual Spirits the most hateful Fountain of all Deformity the evil of Sufferings consequent to this Deformity with this proceding of the Creature distinct and new every moment from God the pure Fountain of Good I entreat thee to carry this along in thy thoughts that the second part of this Discourse is designed for a clear stating and full examination of all Objections I am unwilling therefore to disturb my method to prevent my self or make Repetitions by bringing in these things here which are there to be treated of I entreat thee here only to mark with a skilful and curious eye whether the foundation of Truth be firmly laid and whether the building arise regularly out of it In the second Book it will be thy part to see whether this building stand fast against the assaults of all contrary appearances which like the Rivers the Wind the Rain from above from below on every side beat upon it This is enough upon this Head the universal Nature of the Creature 4. My fourth Head from which I draw my Reasonings upon this Subject of Free-will is The Nature of the Soul From the Nature of the Soul we thus reason the Essence of the Soul and its Faculties the Understanding and the Will differ not really but formally alone All three are one and the same Every one is all three in one They are distinguished according to the distinct forms in which they appear ever appearing with all their forms in each form 1. The Essence of the Soul is immaterial a substantial Act an undivided Unity and essential Form which comprehends the forms of all Essences essentially in it self We speak all this while of the Intellectual Soul This Soul then essentially comprehends it self reflects upon it self and all forms of things in it self Thus it springs up into an essential Image of it self and of all Essences to it self within it self Thus is the Essence of the Soul it s own Understanding by virtue of its immaterial Substance and its substantial Unity 2. The Understanding of the Soul differs from the senses in two things 1. The Senses touch and take in their Objects only by material accidents as shadowy figures The Understanding toucheth taketh hold of and embraceth the Substances themselves incorruptible immutable in their eternal Truths 2. The senses take in the Images of their Objects from without but the Understanding brings forth its Object in an essential Image from within which is therefore called Verbum mentis The Senses being material are thus passive but the Understanding as an immaterial power altogether active If the Understanding bring forth from it self and comprehend within it self the essential and substantial forms of things it can be no less than a substance it self and one substance with the Soul in the essence of it For nothing unsubstantial can receive into it self that which is substantial We have also said before that the Soul in its essence or substance essentially comprehends all things in their essential and substantial forms Let me add this upon the same ground that if the Soul understand it self the understanding is every way adequate and equal to the Soul in as much as it adequately comprehends it The Will is described by Thomas Aquinas to be the Inclination of the Soul It is also a Rule That every Power or Faculty is distinguished and defined by its Object The Object of the Will is Good Good is
externae pepulerunt singere Causae Materiae fluitantis opus verum insita summi Forma boni livore carens Tu cunct a superno Ducis ab exemplo pulchrum pulcherrimus ipse Mundum mente gerens similique in imagine formans Perfect asque jubens perfectum absolvere partes Tu numeris Elementa ligas ut frigora flammis Arida conveniant liquidis ne purior ignis Evolet aut mersas deducant pondera terras Tu triplicis mediam naturae cuncta moventem Connectens animam per Consona membra resoluis Quae cum sect a duos motum glomeravit in orbeis In semet reditura meat mentemque profundam Circuit simili convertit imagine Caelum Tu causis animas paribus vitasque minores Provehis levibus sublimeis curribus aptans In Caelum terramque seris quas lege benigna Ad te conversas reduci facis igne reverti Da pater Augustam menti conscendere sedem Da fontem lustrare boni Da luce reperta In te conspicuos animi Desigere visus Deiice terrenae nebulas pondera molis Atque tuo splendore mica tu namque serenum Tu requies tranquilla piis te cernere finis Principium Vector Dux semita terminus idem The English O thou who by the golden linked Chain Of reason's Musick with an even strain Conductest all from thy bright Throne on high Father of shady Earth and shining Skie By undiscovered Tracts Time's stream and spring Thou from Eternity's vast Sea doest bring Motion and change ever unknown to thee From thee deriv'd and by thee guided be This work of floating matter which we see By inbred form of good from envy free By sweetest force of Native Loves rich seeds Without external cause from thee proceeds In Loves eternal Garden as its flowers Flourish in their first forms and fullest powers All Beauties These are the life the living Law From which thou dost all forms of Being draw As light to dazled eyes all things below From these pure Suns in fading circles flow A World all fair from thee supreamly fair Shines in thy mind above controul or care In an harmonious Image thou the same By perfect parts dost to perfection frame By potent Charms of sacred numbers bound The waving Elements keep their set round Fire Aire Earth Water in mysterious Dances Move to thy Musick through all times and chances Mixt into various figures with sweet grace In each form undivided they embrace Earth sinks not nor doth fire to Heav'n fly Frosts Flames Droughts Floods meet in an Unity The three-fold Natures golden Knot mid-band The Soul thou tyest in one by Love's bright hand Then it by thee unloosned spread doth lie In Limbs well suited to a sympathy Of motion and distinct melody Diffus'd through things below or those on high This is the Spring and Circle ampler far And purer than the Christal Heavens are The universal Beauties charming face Where sweetly spring and dance each lovely grace Within it self divided this great Soul Into a double Globe it self doth roul One hidden from us by excess of light One with shades sweetly temper'd to our sight As thorough these it moves it still returns Into it self still with Love's fire it burns By force of this it still doth circle round Th' eternal minds great deep Heav'n thus doth found And in like figure of those unseen Lights Doth turn about these Glories in our sights Brought forth from causes like Souls and less lives Thy will aloft in airy Chariots drives And sows in Heaven in Earth which by Love's Law Turn'd back to thee thou to thy self dost draw By the innate returning flame Grant Father to our minds thy glorious Mount To climb to view of good the sacred Fount In thine own Light which doth within us shine To fix the clear eyes of our Souls on thine Cast down the mists and weight of earthly mold The joyous splendors of thy face unfold Thou art to holy minds the golden Calm The sweet repose the grief appeasing Balm To see Thee our Beginning is our End Guide Chariot Way our Home to which we tend I mean to take no notice of any thing in this Poem besides that alone which immediately concerns the Soul In that part I shall after the manner of a brief Commentary present the Reader with some few Notes upon the several Passages for the illustration and confirmation of my fore-going Discourse upon the Nature of the Humane or Intellectual Soul 1. Passage The three-fold Natures golden knot Mid-band The Soul Thou tiest in one Triplicis Naturae mediam Connectens Animam  1. Note The three Natures here are manifestly The Invisible Incorporeal Nature Immortal Spirits The Visible Corporeal Nature Bodies Mortal or Immortal The Soul the middle between both these 2. Note The Soul is a middle-nature between both these not by Abnegation or Separation but by Participation and Connection So that word imports Connectens the Golden Knot lying all in one The Soul is a middle-nature three wayes 1. The Soul extendeth her self through both Natures to their utmost Heighths above and Depths beneath by her Idea which is her Golden Head by her Angel which is her Arms and Breast of her Silver her immediate Image and Birth as she springs forth from her Idea her incorruptible Essence above all motion the first seat of her Life Understanding Virtue Power as they flow from her Ideal Spring Thus Plotinus believed the Soul her self in her Essence in her Intellectual Form at its first abstracted heighth and purity to be her own good Angel But the Soul dissuseth her self also by her Coelestial Garment or Body through the wide-spread Heavens These are her Belly and Thighs of Brass the Springs of Generation the first seat of Motion Division and successive Forms By her Elemental Body she swims in this uncertain Sea of Generation and Corruption The Elements in their Orbs compose her Legs and Feet of Iron Here is the lowest Region of Division Motion and Change Here is the scene of Corruption here is the Soul most obscured In the lowest parts of this Earth is she resolved into a shade 2. The Soul is a Nature distinct from the other two Angelical Spirits are Omniforme or Universal Bodies are extended into divisible parts The Intellectual is composed of both universal and particular Forms all which it contains in an indivisible Unity The Soul circles through all forms of things universal and particular as they subsist apart or united appearing mutually infolding each other within the undivided Unity of its own Essence whilst in the Unity and Majesty of its undivided Essence it rouls through all forms and parts of it self as the Sun through the whole compass of the Heavens In this is a more glorious Sun and Heaven that it is in each point of it self at once as a distinct Sun in its full glory and every Sun a spacious transparent Glass in which the whole Heaven of its Essence with all its
the Glory The darkness now in the place of these formed it self into false deformed monstrous Images in man in every Creature which had indeed some resemblance of the true and primitive Images which were in Paradise As a Monkey hath the similitude of man but in proportion height beauty life greatness power majesty differed from them as a lye from the truth The expressions of the Holy Ghost seem skilfully chosen to declare this change to us verse 23. He saith They turned the Glory of God not into the Image but the similitude of the Image of Man verse 25. They turned the truth not into the Image or shadow but into a lye These false Images of the Night and the blackness of Darkness were inhabited and acted by so many Devils so many dark Spirits the first Springs and Seats of this Darkness As an Angel filled each Form in Paradise figuring it self upon it so were all forms in the Fall filled ahd figured by Devils Thus they became Idols of which St. Paul saith They that worship Idols worship Devils Angels in Paradise were pure and sweet Lights springing freshly forth from the Divine Glory rendring every Creature pure and transparent with a Light of Glory shining in it as clear Christal all over replenished enriched and heightned with the Sun-beams This Light every where transmitted the eye and the glory through each Creature to each other married them one to another in each Creature This was a Paradise indeed of Divine Plants full of Divine Beauties Fragrances Virtues and Fruits The Devils as Clouds of Night and Darkness resting on each Creature suffer not the Light from above nor the sight from below to pass through them They at once exclude the brightness of the Divine Glory and draw the eye to themselves in each Form to rest in themselves This is the Head the Well-spring the Mystery of all Idolatry whether it be of the grosser or finer sort But I pass now from the first to the second Proposition 2. Proposition The immediate cause of the first change made in the Understanding at the Fall was the Divine Glory with-drawing or with-holding it self The immediate the proper cause of the deformity and disorder in the change was the defectibility the nothingness of the Creature of it self sinking down to nothing as the Glory removes it self from it or the Variety of the Divine fulness the Order in the Divine Wisdome the Harmony of the Divine Beauties by the power of which the Unity descending to its lowest state to a shadow of it self in Paradise and having there acted all the parts proper to that shadowy scene or state having carried it to the utmost now passeth from that shadowy Unity into a new Scene or state properly arising out of the darkness of the shadow and the lowest degree of Unity which is that of Contrariety As the Unity is the scene of Light Life Love Harmony Beauty Joy all Good So is this of Darkness Enmit Death Deformity Disorder all Evil. But I touch this transiently here and return The Perfection of the Understanding is Light or Truth The Corruption of the Understanding is darkness or falshood That which makes manifest is Light saith St. Paul Every Image then so far as it is an Image is Light Each Image is a composure of Beams sent forth from every part of the Object represented by the Image The first Light is the first Image the Image of God the brightness of the Glory of God As colours which are shaded Lights are constituted by this Light and actuated in their appearance to the eye so is every other Light Light only by and in this Light as a shadow of it Darknese is the absence or privation of Light Privations have no proper but accidental causes only Thus the Divine Glory retiring from the Understanding or ceasing to shine in it is by accident the cause of the Darkness there As the setting or departing of the Sun is the cause of Night which is not a blemish to the Sun but its Glory that in its presence are all the Beauties and Joys of Light in its abscence all the Disagreeablenesses and Melancholies of night and darkness But if at the ebbing of the Tyde when the Sea sucks into it self again the streams of water which at the Floud it powred forth from it self in the River Tagus or Pactolus a beautiful Form of golden sand present it self to our eyes in other Rivers a black ill-sented Mud offend our senses The emptiness of the Chanel the absence from the Waters is indeed from the Sea But the pleasing or displeasing Forms appearing in the absence of the waters are from the Rivers themselves In like manner all Defects have deficient Causes The change in the Fall is from the Divine Glory drawing into it self that stream and tyde of Beauties which it powred forth upon the understanding of man The Darkness Deformity Disorder in this change proceeds from the nature of the Creature from its natural tendency to that nothingness which alone is its own and its native Element as it is in it self This nothingness hath the same relation to the beautiful Essences the essential Beauties of all Forms of things of all Creatures while they stand in the Divine Image as the Contrariety hath to the Divine Unity A Cloud looseth all its lustre in a blackness and darkness a cold of Earth hath no more any sweet light to entertain the eye when the Sun takes his golden beams off from them But the Stars and Diamonds sparkle and shine in the absence of the Sun in the depth of night The reason of the difference is the opacity or shadiness in the nature of the Cloud and clod of Earth the native light in the Diamond and the Stars Thus the Creature being nothing in it self tends to nothing as the eternal Sun goeth down upon it This tendency to nothing is the proper the formal cause of all Deformities and Disorders as the springing of the Light in the Morning is of all those lovely colours which then adorn the Sky But thus much for this second Proposition 3. Proposition The change in the Will and Affections followeth the change in the Understanding as its immediate and proper Cause This lies plain in the Text verse 22. They turned the Glory of God to the similitude of a man c. verse 24. Wherefore also God gave them up to their hearts lusts to all uncleanness c. verse 25. Which turned the truth of God unto a lye verse 26. For this cause God gave them up to vile affections But you have this most fully asserted and amplified verse 28 29 30 31. As they liked not to retain God in their knowledge God also gave them up to a Reprobate mind to do things not convenient being filled with all Unrighteousness Fornication Wickedness So he goes on enumerating in the three following verses all the Evils of Sin in the Will of Man from thence breaking forth in his life
As Nature is distinguished in Natura Naturans and Naturata that is Nature in the Fountain God the Divine Nature Nature in the stream the Copy to that Original So the Scripture attributeth that to God which he in the natural order of things hath connected and linked as in a Chain for its proper cause Thus God is said to give up men to all disorders in their Will for the darkness in their Minds The phrase hath also this depth of sense in it That God as the first cause is every where in the whole Chain of Causes most intimately present and immediately operative in every effect He is the Spirit the Beauty of the Order in the whole He is the band in every step or joynt of the whole Order tying each Link to the other each Effect to its Cause each Cause to its effect He is the sole force in every Cause the sole Cause of every Effect in particular Thus God gave them up to vile affections who had changed the truth unto a lye All Imagery is the furniture of the Mind All Images are formed there The motions of the Will are raised and governed by the Images in the Understanding as their formal Cause from whose impressions they flow as their final Cause to which they tend in which they end The Understanding is a Power in the Soul of generating Images of good within it self which Images are the only Truth the only Beauty of it The Will is the Spring and Seat of a mutual Love-Union and Love-Communion which the Soul hath with it self in these Images infusing and taking in a mutual Sweetness Complacency and Joy They the Images in the mind are the Objective Cause of all the motions of the Will raising and laying them as the Winds do the Waters So God gave them over to vile Affections This manner of speaking hath a clear signification of that principal mystery in Divinity so sweet so sure so deep All good is from the presence of God the shine the smiles of his unvailed Face the Reflections of him as he appears in his own Likeness in his proper Form This makes all Light Beauty Joy All Evil is from the absence of God from his Back-parts from the Clouds and Disguise upon his Person without the Vail I cannot well proceed any further until I have cleared my way by removing an Objection or two which may be made against the Interpretations which I have made of these Scriptures and the Propositions drawn from them Object 1. The Apostle seemeth to make this the ground of the inexcusableness of men in their sins that they knew God yet sinned in the Face of that Light Upon this ground sin seemeth to arise first in the Will rather then in the Understanding This Objection is confirmed by the Apostles attributing this knowledge of God to man in his faln Estate To the Heathen as he seemeth clearly to do Answ. 1. If man hath this knowledge of God in his faln state yet was that Perfection in which we have described it only in Paradise Answ. 2. The Holy Spirit seemeth expresly to place the Knowledge of God antecedent to the first Sin the not glorifying him as God for this was either the same or Concomitant with or resulting from the vanity of the reasonings in man the want of Understanding the darkning of his Heart Answ. 3. There is indeed a constant Glory from the Face of God shining in man through all changes and states A Light which can never be extinguished by any storms But this Light of Divine Glory shineth in the midst of the Darkness which arose upon it within which it withdrew it self in the first moment of the Fall and hath ever since dwelt This Darkness comprehendeth not the Light receiveth it not rejecteth it as a Reprobate a false Light so casts it down from the Throne in the dominion of the Soul and reigneth it self in the place of it This truth is with Divine Authority affirmed with a Divine clearness and elegancy illustrated in those words As they liked not to retain God in their knowledge God gave them over to a Reprobate mind to do things not convenient What a manifest Connexion of these four things have you in this Scripture 1. A Knowledge of God in the Mind 2. A Rejection or Reprobation of that Knowledge 3. A Reprobation or Corruption of the Mind in the Rejection of this Light of Glory 4. All Evil generally mentioned under the Character of Inconveniency or Uncomeliness in the end of this verse particularly and distinctly recited in three following verses flowing all from this Reprobate or Corrupt Mind But we shall more evidently more delightfully behold this mystery of the Fall this Mixture this War of Darkness with the Divine Light its triumph over it the presence of the Divine Light in the midst of this Darkness maintaining its Glory unshaken unstained in a constant opposition to the darkness in the mind of faln man if we observe and unfold the elegancy of the Holy Ghost in these words Those words They liked not to retain A Reprobate Mind are in Greek the same in their Root and Essence They manifestly allude to each other with a great power and pleasantness of sense The Original word primarily and properly signifieth the trying the truth of any thing as the Gold is tryed by the Touch-stone or by the Fire God in the presence of his Glory resides in every Creature beneath the form of that Creature as a Vail wrought with a Figure of himself Thus he constantly resides in each Creature as the Root and Being of its Being In the pure nature of man he shines through the Vail of the Angelical or Intellectual Image as a transparent Vail of finest Lawn or sweetest Light sprung from his own Face In the Fall God drawing in the Beams of his Glory by the mysterious Operations of the Divine Wisdome in the place of this pure and pleasant Light thick Darkness fills the Angelical Image of God in man The Divine Presence and Glory stands in this Image presenting the Light of its unchangeable Beauties to the eye of the Soul in the midst of this darkness The Understanding now taking in the Divine Glory through this dark medium through the darkness takes in a dark and falfe Image of it It tryeth and toucheth the Glory in this false Image upon it self now darkned and depraved It receives the Image as a true Image but rejects the Glory rejects God as reprobate Gold as a false counterfeit Divinity and Glory God in like manner by the presence of his Glory toucheth and tryeth the Understanding rejecteth that as a Reprobate Mind This Reprobate Mind he leaveth to it self and man to this Reprobate Mind from this source issues forth all the Evils of Sin and of Sufferings Object 2. How in this order of things is man rendred inexcusable which seems to be a principal Care and Work of the Holy Spirit in this Scripture Answ. An excuse is
all her changes were but circlings through the various parts of the Divine Harmony within her self within the heavenly compass of her own Divine Essence While all that while she with her beautiful Essence and Form lies in the embraces of the Divine Essence it self There compleating in her self the circle of the Universal and Eternal Harmony returning thither as into the Bosome of her Beloved Bridegroom from whence she first came forth as from her everlasting Father and first Cause Thus I have endeavoured to bring to the Eye the Ear of our Understanding the Beauty the Musick of the Divine Harmony in the discords of Humane Nature in the Fall of Man which excludes all undetermined Liberty in the Will as altogether inconsistent with this Harmony and the Divine Unity the band of this Harmony I pass now to the Essence of the Soul in the third Scene into which it opens it self or that third state into which it rouls it self within it self My design is the same here to shew how the sacred and irresistible force of the Divine Harmony restores the Soul without any thing of Free-Will in the sense in which we have stated it intermingling it self in this Work 3. State This third state of the Soul is its return or restitution This is clearly and compleatly described by St. Paul after the lively Picture which he hath given us of the storm in the Fall But now the Righteousness of God is made manifest without the Law being witnessed to by the Law and the Prophets Rom. 3. 21. Even the Righteousness of God which is by faith of Jesus Christ on all that believe verse 22. Being justified freely by his Grace through the Redemption which is in Jesus Christ verse 24. Whom God hath set forth to be a Propitiation through faith in his blood to declare his own Righteousness for the remission of Sins verse 25. To declare I say at this time his own Righteousness that he by his his own Righteousness or Justice might be just and by the same his his own Righteousness the justifier of him which believeth in Jesus vers 26. Take here four brief Notes upon the words 1. The Righteousness of God is with great care and skill distinguished here and specificated in its distinction from the Righteousness of Man under the Law in the state of Innocency You have this distinction emphatically set out and sealed with a deep impression four times over The Right eousness of God without the Law vers 21. Even the Righteousness of God vers 22. God to declare his own Righteousness vers 25. To declare I say his own Righteousness or Justice That he may be just or righteous and the Justifier or the Maker righteous by his own Righteousness This is the Righteousness of the Gospel by which we have the pardon of Sins and are justified This the Law the Prophets Nature in its Purity in all its natural Improvements point out to us in shadows and pictures But cannot set before us nor give to us no more than the Picture can give a sight or fruition of the Life the living Beauty 2. Grace free Love alone without the Conjunction of Free-will discovers and brings in this Righteousness This Righteousness is the Beauty of the Divine Harmony Grace or Love is the sweetness the sweet force of this Harmony or the Unity in this Harmony which alone carries it on through all things and makes all things perfect in it 3. Jesus Christ with his Blood and Faith in him are means to this end the declaration of the Righteousness of God This Divine Harmony which is the Beauty and the Righteousness of the Divine Nature as the last end is the first Mover carries on it self by its own sweet most agreeable and irresistable force which is the Grace and Love in the Godhead This forms and fashions all its own means brings forth Jesus Christ to die for us to live in us by Faith and it self in this Jesus through the death and the life of this Jesus 4. The essential Righteousness of God as it brings forth it self through Jesus Christ is that in which we have the pardon of Sin and Justification It is his own Righteousness or Justice by which God is just himself and maketh us just In Greek the words are all the same his Righteousness that he may be just and the Justisier You will understand this and the elegant force of this Scripture which is very much lost in English by the change of the word in the Translation from Righteousness to Just and Justifier When you know that in Greek Righteousness and Justice are both one word as in the sense and in nature they are both one thing This essential Righteousness of God alone hath an infiniteness of value and virtue in it to be a satisfaction for the infinite Demerit and Guilt in Sin to make a Saint infinitely amiable and lovely that it may be proportioned to the Eye and infinite Love of an infinite Spirit We say our Jesus was Man that he might Suffer God that he might Merit by suffering We are rightly taught That it is the Person in Christ which gives the value to his Active and Passive Obedience That gives the value and virtue to the whole work of his Mediation The Person in Christ is God the second Person in the Trinity the essential Image of the Godhead eternal unchangeable infinite It is then the essential eternal infinite Beauty Value Virtue Righteousness of this Person which declares it self through the Humane Nature of Christ in the Humiliations the Exaltations of that unto the Remission of Sins unto Justification to make us infinitely amiable in the eye of an infinite God the worthy Objects of an infinite Love the worthy Subjects of an infinite Glory and Blessedness in the eternal unlimited free and full fruition of an infinite Object infinite in Loveliness and Delights But let us endeavour according to the meanness of our capacity in taking in so great Glory to give some Light to this so sweet and so high a mystery Righteousness and Justice in Greek are the same Justice is defined that which giveth every one it s own That is to every thing it s own due and proper to it which makes up the Harmony and Unity of the whole in that part The Harmony and Unity of the whole is the perfection of the whole and of each part Every part is in order to the whole as its end As it is perfection which is due to each thing So the end of each thing is its perfection Thus Justice consists in the Harmony and Unity of things Righteousness is that by which we are right and do right Right is a conformity to its rule The first in every kind is the measure and rule of all the rest God is absolutely universally the first of all things so is He the absolute measure and rule of all The Righteousness of God then is the conformity of the Divine Nature to
is no perfection I shall make way for the explanation and confirmation of this by distinguishing necessity into a 1. Necessity of Coaction 2. Necessity of Nature 1. A necessity of Coaction is from an outward power restraining the subject from acting according to the principles of its nature or constraining it to Actions besides or against its nature This necessity is indeed contrary to true freedom A freedom from this necessity or from a capacity of being thus necessitated is the perfection or excellency of man 2. The necessity of nature is that which is founded in and flows from the Essence it self the essential and internal principles of each nature This necessity is so far from being inconsistent with Liberty that it is the establishment and firmness of the subject in its proper freedom The demonstration of this is clear in the Divine Nature for as God alone is Ens perfectè liberum A Being most perfectly free so is he according to the Doctrine of all the Schools alone Ens absolutè necessarium A Being absolutely necessary And as is his Being such is his Understanding such is his Will such are all his Acts necessary and necessarily good as they are most perfectly free For his Being in the absoluteness and simplicity of it is his Understanding his Will one pure simple and eternal Act goodness it self The learned Prideaux in the Chair at Oxford rightly teacheth us this That God in those his first Acts of Election although he be not moved by any Causa 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that is any cause from without giving occasion for these distinguishing Acts is yet determined to them by a Causa 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 A reason from within from the glorious secret of his own Essence which hath so much the more of a Divine force in it by how much the more it is incomprehensible to us 2. Answ. The freedom of the Will if it be rightly understood and stated will as I humbly conceive appear far more beautiful glorious and divine in these three Circumstances 1. The Liberty of the Will is truly Divine in the amplitude of its Object which is goodness in its utmost latitude and fulness in its utmost heighth and glory The Will of Man is not determined or confined to a particular good or an inferior good to that of meer nature or of sense It hath its freedom to range through the flowry and spacious Field of all good in its richest Variety yea to soar up to that blissful Paradise of the supream good it self in the third and highest Heavens there to spread it self and roul it self in the midst of all the Treasures of all the distinct Beauties and Joys of every good as all meet here with the highest lustre with the purest and most perfect sweetness in the bosome of this first and chief good 2. The Will of man is in this divinely free that it always acts after an irresistable manner according to its own proper Nature so that nothing can move it but per modum interni principii and secundum morem objecti propositi after the manner of the inward Principles of its own Essence and the proposal of its Object As the Divine Will is goodness it self in its greatest amplitude and perfection so is the Will of Man which is the Birth and Image of the Divine Will goodness in the seed which as the Divine Goodness is presented in various appearances so it can by no means by no power beneath a power of creating and annihilating be restrained from springing up and flourishing and flying into the bosom of that appearance to become perfectly one with it as a most chast and affectionate Bride with her most beautiful and beloved Bridegroom If this Bride the Will of Man embrace a Stranger or an Enemy in the place of her own Beloved it is by being first deceived by his coming and presenting himself to her in the appearance of her Bridegroom The woman being deceived was first in the Transgression Sin deceived me and so slew me saith St. Paul Thus is the Will of Man not like to that figure in the Poet Monstrum informe cui lumen ademptum A rude unformed power acted without Light without Order without Principle or End by a rash uncertainty in an unformed darkness This were no liberty but the greatest servitude of a Spirit bound in Chains of Darkness and hurried by the Power of Darkness it knows not how nor why nor whither No the Will of Man is in its own uncorrupt state a beautiful Virgin with fair eyes like Doves washt in Milk by a Divine Love carried in a Divine Light to the Arms of her Beloved the Divine Beauty and Goodness In its faln Estate while in the midst of false Lights and false appearances raised by that great Inchanter the Prince of Darkness it is held in the Serpentine embrances of false Lovers as in nets and bands yet is it its own Beloved and Bridegroom which she loves and seeks in all these It is also its essential inclination and love to the Divinity of the true loveliness the true good which is abused and by which advantage is taken for it self to be abused by all these Impostures and false loves Good is that which all things desire saith the Philosopher That God whom ye ignorantly worship that God preach I saith St. Paul to the Athenians The highest piece of Worship is the inclination and motion of the Will our Love Object But you will say What preheminence hath man by his freedome the inclination and sensitive Appetite of bruit Creatures may be allured but cannot be forced no more than the Will of Man Answ. I give two Answers to this 1. The Civil Law saith That he is free who is sui juris in his own power the freedom of each thing is a power of acting according to the Principles of Nature and the Law of its own Essence As then the excellency and preheminence of each Essence or Nature is such is the dignity of the freedome or liberty of working according to that nature As Reason the essential form of man which is the Universal Harmony of all good transcends the life of sense confined to the inferior and shadowy Image of good in its immortal substance So doth the rational Appetite in its freedom which is as ample as reason it self and diffuseth it self at liberty upon the blissful Bosom of the Universal Good excel the sensitive Appetite tyed up to the narrow and fading Objects of sense 2. The Will of Man is a rational inclination to the rational intellectual eternal and supream good This is the Coelestial Love which is born up upon its two wings of Rational that is Coelestial delight and desire While it continues in its naked state of Innocency and true Freedom it hath a liberty and power in it self in despight of all impressions of outward force to fly above them all upon these golden wings into the Bosom of the Divine Will
rule of Justice and Goodness by which this is to be tryed The general Rule or Law of Justice is this To give to every thing its due or its own Solomon expresseth this Rule of Justice from the Mouth of God in his Proverbs after this manner With-hold not good from them to whom it is due or from the Owners thereof when it is in thine hand to do it Divines interpret those Owners to be all persons in want all Subjects in any capacity of receiving any good from us Beneficence or a disposition to do good to all is with the Heathen Philosphers a branch of this Vertue of Justice The Law of God which is the Rule of Justice commands to love our Neighbour as our self St. Paul interprets this Neighbour to be every other Rom. 13. 8. He that loveth another hath fulfilled the Law The Jews teach us that the Law is founded in the Name that is in the Nature of God Man was made in the Image of God The Perfection then of the humane Creature is the Image of that Perfection which is in the Divine Nature the Law of the humane Nature is the transcript of the Divine Nature Our Lord Jesus interprets this Universal Law of humane Commerce and Justice among men Thou shalt love thy Neighbour after this manner Love your Enemies do good to them that hate you He layeth the ground of this Universal Justice in the Divine Nature That you may be the Children of your Father which is in Heaven He adds for a clearer Conviction If you love them that love you do not even the Publicans the same He concludes by referring the perfection of men to the Divine Perfection as its Original and Law Be ye therefore perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect Thus we see the Rule of Justice with God and with men to give our Love and all good according to our utmost power to every other as to the Owner of that love and good to whom they are due 2. The second Rule or Law is that of Goodness The Law of Goodness and its Essence is to diffuse and communicate it self The law of each thing is to act according to its nature of Light to shine of sweet Waters to send forth sweet waters of good to do good This Law is most deeply rooted and highly radiant in the Divine Nature inasmuch as God is the Chief the Universal the only good Accordingly he makes his Rain his Sun both Coelestial and Supercoelestial in their season to fall and to shine upon the Just and the Unjust Having stated the Case between Free-will and the Will predeterminated in its Causes and having set the Rule by which the Case is to be tryed Let us come to the Point in which we must joyn Issue 1. Both Cases agree in four grand Circumstances First In both Cases God makes man and the Will of Man from nothing according to the absoluteness of his Will and Power Secondly The event which is eternal ruine and torment to the greatest part of Mankind is alike certain to both by a certainty of infallibility 3. God before and in the making of his work clearly seeth and perfectly understandeth that this will be infallibly the event of his Workmanship Can it then with any reason be thought that the event of the work of an infinite Wisdom fore-seen should not be agreeable to the design of that Wisdom and the Will of that infinitely Wise Spirit whose Power is as infinite as his Wisdom 4. God could have made man otherwise in a Divine necessity of being good and blessed like himself in a confirmed state of Grace and Glory like the Elect Angels and Saints These are the Circumstances in which both Cases agree 2. The grand dâ—…fference between the two Cases where they joyn Issue is this In that Case of Free-will Man perisheth because God with-holds the good which he hath in himself and might have given to him that is a confirmation in good In the other case of the Will predetermined Man perisheth because God withdraws the good which he had once given him There are two Fathers with their two little Children one Father setteth his Child down so that he may run into a pleasant Field or a devouring Flood He fore-seeth that he will certainly run not into the Field but into the Flood he suffers him to run and perish in the Flood when he may as easily prevent him by laying his hand upon him or taking him into his arms The other Father holdeth his Child fast and safe in his arms for a while over the cruel Flood then he casteth him not in but he taketh away his arms and leaves him by his own weight necessarily to drop into the Flood and perish there I appeal now to every equal and impartial Judge whether both these Fathers seem not both guilty or innocent Whether they be not both likely to be cleared or convicted if they be tryed by those fore-mentioned Rules of Justice and Goodness Is not the two-fold Plea of both these Wills of equal force against the Justice and Goodness of God 1. Why hath he made me thus certainly to perish What is it to me whether this certainty be a certainty of infallibility only from the mutability of my nature or a certainty of inevitableness from the necessity of nature while I certainly perish 2. Why is he yet angry who hath resisted his Will Is not the certain event of his Work clearly fore-seen by him from the beginning interpretatively his Will Which Opinion shall we prefer That of the Will predetermined gives to God the full Glory of his Soveraignty Absoluteness Wisdom Power making his work in the whole and in every part from the beginning to the end one entire piece altogether dependent upon himself wrought throughout by himself and conducted from one supream principle by one universal Form of the Divine Understanding and the Divine Image to one Universal and Ultimate end the Divine Glory But it seemeth to cast an imputation upon the Divine Justice and Goodness The other Opinion of Free-will seemeth to violate the Soveraignty and Absoluteness of God making his actings dependent upon the actings of Creature The Power of God in giving to the Creature the determination of it self with an independence upon him in these Cardinal Acts of the Will upon which the whole Circle and Globe of things in the Divine Love Justice and Wrath in the happiness or misery of Man from eternity is turned about His Wisdom while his work hath breaches and gaps in it like a Chain whose links are not fastned one in another while the Harmony is thus broken while all the great effects and end of his work are casual uncertain in their Causes and in their Nature inasmuch as all depend upon the free and fortuitous motions of the Will independent upon and undetermined by all preceding or superior Causes even the first and universal Cause it self Together with all this Cloud which the Opinion