present we haue an example in Saint Paul who had his Conscience witnessing with him for his present estate 1. Cor. 4. 4. for his words and also for the inward affection of the heart Ro. 9. 1. 2. The like wee haue in Peter after his fall whose Conscience after repentance vnfained made him to appeale to Christ touching his loue his conscience encouraged him to say to Christ Thou knowest that I loue thee Ioh. 21. 15. 16. 17. Thus we see how Conscience witnesseth for vs for time past and present Some mens consciences may beare witnesse for the time past as Hymeneus and Alexanders and Demas might but not for the present because they fell away But a Pauls conscience will witnesse for the time past and time present too 2. Tim. 1. 3. Heb. 13. 18. Touching the time to come conscience is not altogether silent not that it can witnesse for vs what wee yet neuer thought spake or did but in respect of our resolution for the time to come it can witnesse with vs that wee doe resolue to doe well and endeauour it as Paul speakes Act. 24. 16. and as Iob said that his heart should not reproach him so long as he liued Iob 27. 6. 2. For the thing it beares vs witnes of which is both for matter manner For matter Nehemiah his conscience stood for him Nehem. 13. 14. 22. for manner Saint Pauls in his teaching 2. Cor. 1. 12. that it was in godly simplicitie and sincerity so Abimelechs conscience witnessed for his integrity and innocency in taking Sarah Gen. 20. 6. For both matter and manner in Hezekiah Isai 38 3. he walked with God and this he did vprightly Labour to haue Conscience witnesse both for many mens consciences will witnesse for them that they haue been at Church heard the Word prayed sung Psalmes receiued the Sacraments but it will not witnesse for them for the name of doing but rather condemne them for their vnpreparednes their hypocrisie meere formality c. Section 2. Of Conscience witnessing against vs. THis act of Conscience is called accusing Ro. 2. 15. and as in excusing it hath regard to time and thing so here in this likewise Concerning the time First past it accused Iosephs brethren of that which was committed long before Gen. 42. 21. so it did Shimei 1. Kin. 2. 44. Dauid 2. Sam. 24. 10. Adonibezek Iudg. 1. 5. and the Iewes Act. 2. 37. Secondly for the time present it wrought vpon the Scribes and Pharisies Ioh. 8. 7 9. So vpon Belshazzar Dan. 5. 6. the Lepers of Samaria 2. King 7. 9. and vpon Felix Act. 24. 25. accusing them for their sinfull courses wherein they liued as also of their irresolution to mend for the time to come As touching matter and manner Conscience will not halt It will tell Dauid of his blood-guiltinesse 2. Sam. 12. Psal 51. and it will accuse Iudas for his treason As also other for the ill manner and by-end in their otherwise good actions as Hamor and Sichemites for receiuing circumcision for worldly and carnall respects Iehu for his counterfeit zeale Scribes and Pharisies for their fasting praying giuing of almes Simeon and Leui for pretending Religion to bee reuenged some for following Christ for loaues Ioh. 6. 22. 24. and the Iewes for their hypocriticall fasting for a day Isai 38. And thus much for the fifth act and office of Conscience Section 3. Of some questions propounded and answered concerning the accusation of Conscience Quest 1. WHether this power to accuse was in Adam before his fall Answ It was but not in act because there was in him no matter or cause wherby conscience should accuse him yet that it had power it is cleare for presently vpon his transgression it accused him And the Text saith that their eyes were opened that is the eye of the Vnderstanding and the eye of the Conscience by which they knew what they had committed against God Their eyes were opened but no new qualitie wrought in the soule other then they had before Quest 2. If aptnesse to accuse was in the Creation it may bee asked Whether it bee now an euill Conscience that accuseth Answ It is not simply euill First because this power was and is from God Secondly because God doth approue of it when it accuseth rightly 1. Ioh. 3. 23. Thirdly because herein it is as Gods Register booke by which he will proceed against the wicked at last day Reuel 20. Fourthly because it is a meanes of much good through Gods blessing as of sorrow for sin of feare to offend and becomes as a preparatiue to repentance sometime Act. 2. 37. Fiftly because it is in the best of Gods children and a blessed meanes to worke in them renewed repentance vpon a fall Quest 3. If it be not to be called an euill Conscience whether may it be termed a good Conscience Answ From the accusation simply it cannot bee called a good conscience First because it is a defectiuenesse in respect of that peace which man had in the Creation and shall enioy in heauen Secondly because it followeth vpon Adams fall as a punishment for sinne here and the worme in hell hereafter Thirdly for that all the wicked haue an accusing conscience but not a good conscience Therefore the conscience from the very act of accusing cannot haue the name of either a good or an euill conscience but as the person is in whom it is For if hee bee euill his conscience is euill though in some thing it excuse him and if he bee a good man his conscience is good though it sometime accuse him CHAP. 16. Of the sixth act and office of Conscience WHen Conscience hath eyed well Man made him acquainted with himselfe written downe his thoughts his doings and sayings accused or excused him then it sits downe as a iust Iudge of Oyer and Terminer to heare and determine to giue sentence against which there is no appeale to be made This sentence is twofold either to acquite and absolue or to bind and condemne Rom. 14. 22. 1. Co. 11. 31. 1. Ioh. 3. 20. 21. In condemning it makes him see his sinne and so causeth him to thinke and speake basely of himselfe and of his ill deeds as Dauid did I haue done very foolishly 2. Sam. 24. 10. and was as a beast Psal 73. 22. and to confesse with the prodigall sonne that he is vnworthy to bee called Gods childe Luk. 15. Lastly it will make him apply as iustly deserued the hand of God against him as Ionah did Chap. 1. 12. and Dauid 2. Sam. 24 17. and withall to acknowledge the Lord to be righteous as did Rehoboam 2. Chron. 12. 6. In absoluing it doth not reproach a man Iob 27. 6. but doth make him stand vpon his innocency wherin he is guiltlesse as it did Dauid against Sauls malice enuy and false accusations This Iudge let vs take notice of and labour for absolution from it and beware of its sentence of condemnation for God will
iudgment to finde out the true Religion and to be able to difference it from all false religions or rather superstitious See a little Booke intituled Good Christian looke to thy Creed and Satanicall inuentions Fourthly to striue to feele the power of this true Religion that so Conscience may be bound to hold vs to the vnfeigned performance of the same CHAP. 29. Of the large Conscience THere is an euill large Conscience a spatious and wide Conscience like the way to Hell This is the Conscience of such as can swallow downe sinnes great and many that can admit of cart-loades thereof without any rub or let to this Conscience This is the conscience of some worldlings some of all sorts of professions vsurers extortioners and such like The cause of this spacious and so large a Conscience is the vnderstanding highly esteeming of profit and preferment and in respect hereof vnder-valueing and vnder-prizing of Religion of iustice and of vpright dealing Whence followes sinfull practises to gaine and to come to aduancement giuing way to any sinne that may hale in profit make a man rich and exalt his estate in the World No sinne stickes in the way as sinne but onely for the infamy thereof if openly knowne or the danger of the Law by which may ensue punishment otherwise through largenesse of Conscience all is fish that comes to net all is lawfull prey and booty that may finely and cunningly bee come by The remedie to bounde this wide conscience is by tying it strictly to the Rule of righteousnesse and by vnderstanding iustice iudgment equity and euery Prou. 2. 9. good path for our right dealing CHAP. 30. Of the Cheuerill Conscience THere is a Cheueril ill Conscience which is like Kids leather which may bee made wide or strait This is the Conscience of him that can as occasion serues his turne make large or straiten his conscience playing fast or loose for his owne aduantage for hee chuseth and picks out particular duties to obserue as best pleaseth his humour neglecting the rest This was the Conscience of Saul in his warfare 1. Sam. 15. 14. 34. 22. 17. 18. against Amalek who could spare the best and destroy what was vile and naught hee made conscience of the peoples eating of blood but it was nothing to hate Dauid to persecute him and to murther 1. Chro. 13. 3. the Lords Priests and to neglect the Arke of God This was Ioabs conscience he could abhorre Dauids command to number the people yet to kill treacherously Abner and Amasa it was no scruple Iehu could destroy the idol-seruice to Baal but hold vp the golden Calues in Dan and Bethel The Scribes and Pharises had their consciences straite to put Iudas Mat. 27. 6. wages into the Treasurie and to goe into the Iudgement Hall but it was Ioh. 18. 28. wide enough to giue money to betray Christ and to cause Pilate to put him to death causelesly Iewes would not haue Christs Ioh. 19. 31. body and the two with him to hang all night on the Crosse because of the Sabbath following but it troubled them not to consent to his death Such a conscience they had in 2. Cor. 11. 24. whipping the Apostle giuing one stripe lesse then forty but not what cause they had to whip him at all Scribes and Pharisies could tithe Mint Commin and Annise but yet let passe the weighty matters of the Law This is a Papists conscience that will eate no flesh on Friday but can seeke by Gunpowder to blow vp the Parliament The Cause of such a Cheuerill Conscience is First that a man makes the Rule of Conscience subiect to his owne will by false interpretations by subtill distinctions thereby weakning the power of the Rule that it hath not force vpon Conscience Secondly the secret and hypocriticall reseruations in his minde and heart in obeying the Rule to which hee neuer wholly can nor will submit himselfe Thirdly a deceitfull and very false imagination of minde that the Rule is alterable and may bee enlarged as may best serue their turne as Cardinall Cusanus once deliuered in a letter to the Bohemians The Remedy is to hold the Rule euer to bee one and the same impartiall constant vnalterable without varying as God himselfe also to be perswaded that we are to be wholly led by it and not it to be framed to our owne lusts CHAP. 31. Of the benumbed Conscience THe benumbed conscience is that which hath lost it mouing as dead for a time as a member benumbed This is the conscience of such as haue lost the feeling thereof by some foule offence lying therein without repentance This may happen sometime to the godly to Iosephs Brethren to a Dauid for a while The causes hereof may bee expressed by a similitude taken from a member benumbed First A member becomes so yea the whole body after violent heate and exercise by suddenly attracted cold So a man very forward in Religion and religious exercises growing cold by suddenly leauing them liuing where the word is not and companying with others of no Religion or with contemners of it Secondly By a dead Palsey So Conscience by some deadly sinne Thirdly by tying it hard so as the bloud wherein the life is can haue no passage till it be loosed So Conscience is benumbed when the mind is tyed to the world so as it cannot bee free to meditate vpon Gods word for the freedome of the minde for holy meditation is as the life and bloud to the Conscience Fourthly by some violent blow So Conscience by some violent suggestion of Satan which for the present may make a man senslesse of his sinning Fifthly by being put out of ioynt So Conscience which is put as I may say out of ioynt when memorie hath lost and forgotten what it should keep to carry it from the mind to the Conscience touching things past either of sin committed or of duty omitted In this case if memory faile the vnderstanding and Conscience are put out of ioynt Sixthly a member becomes deadish by lying still but crookedly vpon some hard thing and weight vpon it as the Arme will be in bearing vp the head and the elbow vpon some hard bord or other thing So Conscience is benumbed when the vnderstanding is crookedly bent to crooked paths the heart hardened and some heauie corruption pressing it downe The effect is that during this time that the Conscience lyeth as dead the partie is without remorse for sinne he cannot out of generall reproofes see his fall without a liuely and cleare application as appeares in Dauid when Nathan spake to him parabolically The Remedie is to haue the word applyed as a Nathan did it to Dauid and to bee content to bee rubbed vpon by wholsome reprofes priuat admonitions and mutuall exhortations that the heart be not hardened by the deceitfulnesse Heb. 3. 13. of sinne CHAP. 32. Of the cauterized Conscience THe last and worst
at the last day And therefore by this so large an Epistle Right worshipfull you may see how it is not onely fit but very necessarie also to be acquainted with Conscience which in most is without all authority to bind them to the good behauior so loosely so licentiously do most men liue But blessed be God that you haue better learned Christ and haue felt the commanding power of the word and the comfort of a good Conscience by shewing your selues Patternes to that your wel reformed Family In which true pietie is attended vpon with loue vnfaigned one towards another and your profession adorned with workes of charitie abroad Your frequent reading of holy Scriptures I well know affords you examples not a few of holie duties but you want not a rare president at home that most honorable Ladie Marchionesse your noble Mother Whose singular humility great bountie desire to please God loue to his word in the powerfull plainnesse thereof and performance of good duties are much to be admired especially in so great a Personage in one so verie aged full of daies in one so long brought vp in her former yeares in the most eminent place of royall seruice vnder that famous Queene Elizabeth I hope I need not to stirre your readie minds to a thankfull acknowledging to God of this and other his mercies nor to excite you to striue for the euerlasting hope of blessednesse seeing that your iustifying Conscience accompanying your iustifying faith as I am perswaded giueth you good assurance in your waies of well doing For your happie continuance wherein I am bold in this ample manner to present vnto your courteous acceptance the excellencie of Conscience and to commend the same to your Christian meditations And so I humblie take leaue in my heartie prayers commending that right Honourable Lady with your worthy Selues beloued Children and all your religious houshold to the fauour and guidance of the Almighty euer resting Your worships in any Christian seruice at command Ric. Bernard Batcomb Calend. Ian. 1630. THE CONTENTS of the insuing Treatise THere is such a thing as is called Conscience Chap. 1. Conscience is distinct from all other faculties of the soule Chap. 2. Of the rule and power of it ouer them and how knowne Chap. 3. Of the name of Conscience and of the distinct knowledge thereof from the vnderstanding Chap. 4. What this knowledge of Conscience is and how described Chap. 5. Of Con-science as it is knowledge with another Chap. 6. Of the rule binding Conscience Chap. 7. With whom Conscience hath to doe Chap. 8. What it meddles with inwardly in man Chap. 9. What outwardly it hath to doe concerning him whose Conscience it is Chap. 10. Of the first act and office of Conscience Chap. 11. Of the second Chap. 12. Of the third touching things commanded forbidden indifferent Chap. 13. Of the fourth act Ch. 14. Of the fifth act witnessing with or against vs and here are three questions touching the qualitie of Conscience accusing Chap. 15. Of the sixth and last act of Conscience Chap. 16. Of the reasons why God hath placed such a thing within Man Chap. 17. Of the excellency of the Conscience aboue all other faculties of the soule Chap. 18. Of the causes why men are not subiect to the power of Conscience as they ought Ch. 19. What is to be done to make vs become obedient to Conscience Chap. 20. Of the kinds of Conscience and first of the euill Conscience Chap. 21. where is shewed in whom it is how it comes and continues and the remedy to amend it Of the twofold distinction of the euill Conscience the still and stirring Chap. 22. Of the still euill Conscience in generall of the causes how to know it of the effects with the remedies Chap. 23. Of the dead Conscience Chap. 24. Of the blind Conscience in Heathen in Christians the misery of such so led and the remedy Chap. 25. Of the sleepy Conscience with the causes and the remedie Chap. 26. Of the secure Conscience in whom it is the causes thereof and the remedies Chap. 27. Of the lukewarme Conscience Chap. 28. Of the large Conscience Chap. 29. The Cheuerill Conscience Chap. 30. The benummed Conscience Chap. 31. And cauterized Conscience with all their causes and remedies Ch. 32. Of the stirring ill Conscience in generall with the causes effects remedies C. 33. Of the erroneous Conscience with the difference betweene it and the blind Conscience in whom it is the causes thereof effects and remedy Chap. 34. with certaine questions about the same Of the superstitious Conscience and whereabout it is exercised with the causes and remedy Chap. 35. Of the scrupulous Conscience the causes effects and remedies Chap. 36. Of the terrifying Conscience with the causes effects and remedies Chap. 37. Of the desperate Conscience the causes thereof effects and remedies Chap. 38. Of the good Conscience in generall Chap. 39. Of the naturall good Conscience Chap. 40. Of the morall good Conscience with the helpes thereto the goodnesse of it and yet insufficient to assure a man of hope in heauen who they bee which only haue this Conscience Chap. 41. Of the regenerate Conscience what it is in whom it is the causes the excellency and effects of it Chap. 42. Of the Gospell binding this Conscience to what it bindeth and yet from what it freeth the regenerate Conscience of the difference betweene the Conscience regenerate and vnregenerate Chap. 43. Of the tender Conscience in whom it is the effects of it meanes to get it that it may be troublesome the difference betweene it and scrupulositie and how to keep it from it Chap. 44. Of the wounded Conscience the causes the continuance longer or shorter time the effects and preparatiues to cure it of the soueraigne Salue and Cordialls after how to keepe from a wounded Conscience of the difference betweene it and the desperate and betweene it and melancholike passion Chap. 45. 46. 47. Of the quiet good Conscience how obtained the effects with the difference betweene the quiet ill Conscience and it Chap. 48. Of the vpright Conscience how gotten and the effect thereof Chap. 49. Of the pure Conscience in whom it is how gotten the effects of it the signes thereof how to keepe it pure Ch. 50. Of the iustifying Conscience how it iustifieth wherein it consists how it differs from a iustifying faith of the comfortable effects thereof and how to keeke it Chap. 51. Of the singular benefit of the regenerate quiet pure vpright and iustifying Conscience Chap. 52. Of the difference betweene Confidence of a good Conscience and presumption from a deceitful heart Ch. 53. where is set downe in whom the one and the other is with their differing causes and effects Lastly of Conscience continuance here in this life at death at last Day in Heauen and in Hell Chap. 54. CHRISTIAN SEE TO THY CONSCIENCE CHAP. 1. That there is such a thing in Man as is called Conscience COnscience
the Scribes and Pharisies Mat. 15. 2. 6. the following whereof is called by Saint Peter a vaine conuersation which Christ by his bloud came to deliuer vs from 1. Pet. 1. 18. Thirdly By the precepts and commandements of men Mat. 15. 9. Col. 2. 20. 22. Fourthly By custome which becomes as a law to the ruder sort to bind their Consciences Fifthly By the shew of wisdome and shadow of great humilitie in such a voluntary worship Col. 2. 18. 23. Sixthly By examples of Forefathers and Elders which strike a great stroak in many as formerly it hath done with such superstitious hipocrits as Christ calls them Mar. 7. 3. 4. 5. 6. Section 4. Of the remedie TO remoue this superstition from Conscience and to acquit it from such slauish feare and bondage is to settle iudgement in fiue things First wee must know that the doctrines and commandements of men binde not conscience of themselues but as they be grounded on Gods Word Secondly else the Scripture condemneth them Matth. 15. Mark 7. Col. 2. 20. 21. 22. 1. Pet. 1. 18. as vaine worship and vaine conuersation Thirdly That we must know our Christian libertie purchased by Christs blood from these yoakes of bondage 1. Pet. 1. 18. and that wee must stand fast in this libertie Gal. 5. 1. Fourthly we are to be resolued in this point that all will worship though neuer so wisely contriued by man and though it carry neuer so faire a shew is condemned of God as the forenamed scriptures doe shew Lastly we must be well assured that where God giueth no law himselfe there is no transgression Rom. 4. 15. and 5. 13. and so no bond to tye Conscience Section 5. Of the second thing about which the superstitions Conscience is exercised THe other thing about which the Conscience of the superstitious is troubled is about some works of Gods prouidence which men though falsly take to be Gods forwarnings and forbiddings and as signes and tokens frō him of some good or of some ill to befall them as a hare to crosse in a morning to stumble in going out salt falling burning of the right or left cheek or eare finding of siluer gold or old iron sudden bleeding at the nose and many such obseruations of superstitious people Section 6. Of the causes hereof THe causes of this feare in this superstitious conscience and the awing of it in respect of this prouidence are these First a strong conceit that there is here in a will of God forewarning people wherupon the conscience becomes bound and the heart made fearefull Secondly the obseruing of the euent which hapneth according to the conceited opinion to the more confirming therof and the further binding of the superstitious to credit the same Section 7. Of the remedy TO heale this and to free the Conscience from such a superstitious bond and the heart from this idle feare note these things 1. That God neither by his word foretels nor by his prouidence doth prognosticate either good or ill in the falling out of such things 2. That albeit such things happen according to mens vaine imaginations yet no credit is to bee giuen thereto nor any conscience to be made thereof First because the opinion in these things is Heathenish and from pagans which Christians are therefore to Ier. 10. 1. 2. detest and not feare their feare Secondly because Satan workes herein and seekes to weaken our faith in God Thirdly because these sometime haue been found false by religious mens true obseruations who contemne these fooleries Fourthly because if they proue true sometime that 's but to try vs whether we wil be wise or become vaine and superstitious Lastly because it is well obserued that the more naturall men be and ignorant of the Gospell the more foolishly superstitious are they the more fearefull and vaine in such obseruations and the more inthraled in their minds to such vanities On the contrary the more people increase in knowledge of the Gospell faith in Christ and be renewed in the inward man the lesse they regard yea the more they contemne these things and are lesse troubled with them as held altogether idle and vaine And thus much for the superstitious Conscience CHAP. 36. Of the scrupulous Conscience THis scrupulous Conscience is the stirring ill Conscience about vncertainties of which the iudgment is vnresolued and passeth neither this way nor that way Section 1. In whom THis is the Conscience of the Ignorant especially in particulars Of such as be Questionists in and about commonly things indifferent or disputable not necessary to life and saluation of such as be like Scribes and Pharisies straining at Gnats and swallowing Mat. 23. 24 Eccl. 7. 16. Camels Of such as will be ouer righteous iust ouermuch straining duties beyond the rule or making somethings which be indifferent necessary to be either done or left vndone These are troublers both of themselues and of others too very often Section 2. The causes hereof THe Conscience of a godly man may haue sometime a scruple in it through ignorance or errour in some particular but his Conscience for a scruple is not to be called a scrupulous Conscience for that which is scrupulous is commonly and for the most part so This happeneth first through the iudgment very vnsetled vnresolued ambiguous wauering this way and that way suspicious hauing no certaine ground to settle upon but onely running vpon coniectures disputing too and fro with and against so as Conscience is much troubled 2. This happeneth by misapplying generall rules about things indifferent according as they conceit to particular actions as to suppose that they edifie not that they be offensiue not decent not to Gods glory deciding within themselues sometimes positiuely that which an other makes disputable by conference with whom their former conclusion is shaken and so stand vnresolued in their iudgement 3. This scruple happeneth when a thing indifferent is needlesly questioned vpon which the Apostle laboured to preuent among the Corinthians saying aske no question for Conscience sake 1. Cor. 10. 27. For in truth there is nothing that more breedeth scruple than idle questioning of matters which might bee well passed ouer 4. By stretching a thing for want of knowledge beyond the nature of a thing indifferent so taking it to be worse than it is through some shew of euill in his apprehension as some did among the Corinthians 1. Cor. 8. 7. 5. By vncharitably expounding such things as be established and onely proposed as indifferent by authoritie beyond the intent of the Church Lastly by giuing way to doubts and to trouble themselues needlesly with vnprofitable disputations of things vndetermined Such peruerse disputes the Apostle liked not 1. Tim. 6. 5. Section 3. Of the effects FRom this scrupulositie ariseth inward trouble feare heart burning vncharitable censuring and iudging one an other and outward diuision sects vnwarrantable courses oppositions forcible impositions and much euil euery way for want of peaceablenesse both on