seconded by the peaceable and happie accesse of a greater Kingdome So that in this case vnlesse to a minde that hath no Religion at all it shall bee much harder to perswade a moderation than too little For with righteous Kings and of vnderstanding as nothing is dearer than Religion so in nothing they imploy their labour and authoritie more willingly than for the preseruation and honouring of the Church it selfe all kingdomes hauing no other safetie but this Their prosperitie to flourish for no longer time than the prosperitie of the Church is maintayned among est them This being by all obseruation the truest signe of a decaying Kingdome To haue a Cleargie vnhallowed and the Church vnhonoured But whilest all men are carefull that the Church may bee well gouerned euerie man obtrudeth his owne fancy and liketh best of those Rules which haue neerest affinitie with his owne brayne Hence commeth it to passe that some men are not fully resolued to whom especially belongeth the Authoritie to prescribe with warrâ—nt the direct forme of the Church gonernment Other offices for the attainment of this end as to instruct and to aduise may in all reâ—son to make the burthen of gouernment both more vertuous and more easie belong vnto other men But to prouide for the safetie of the Church for the publicke enioying of the Word of God for the maner of gouernment for the maintenance of the Clergie all these in a strict vnderstanding are the religious duties and the honourable effects of the King so that what authoritie is deriued vnto any â—yther in a blinde and false obedience to the Sea of Rome or through a partiall affection to a new Consistorie are both if not equall yet equally vsurpers of the Kings right Nay whilest some of late haue beene earnest though ignonorant refusers of Subscription they hane showed in their actions how vncharitably they haue thought of their late Souereigns sincere ReligioÌ„ For to mislike the book of Orders is indirectly to affirme that we haue no ministery which some impudently shameles haue dared to affirme plainly not to subscribe to the Booke of Common Prayer is to teach that we haue no forme of Church Liturgye And lastly to refuse to subscribe to the Articles of Faith is to make men beleeue that our Church maintaineth vnsound doctrine This as it was alleaged once by a Reuerend bishop in a SermoÌ„ so it is an accusatioÌ„ not yet cleered by any that I know by one it is slubbered ouer vnhandsomely making the Obiection stronger than himselfe was able to answere truly but this wee shall haue better occasion to confute hereafter And it is too plaine what opinion they had of Her Religion liuing whom so boldly they dare depraue being once dead But flattery looketh no further than eyther to escape punishment or receiue a benefit so that when the one is past feare and the other past hope wee dare then speake what wee thinke and more vnreuerently oftentimes of the same partie being a Saint in Heauen than we durst being a Prince in earth It were fit all men considered but especially Kings whose authoritie it doth secretly vndermine how farre the admission of a Consistoriall Gouernment in a kingdome may suddenly vsurpe vpon that right which Scripture and Lawes haue ascribed to the King That Kings ought to haue rule in all causes ouerall persons as it is warranted by the word so it is confirmed to the Princes of this Land by Act of Parliament This giueth vnto them Supremacy in Ecclesiasticall Gouernment Exempteth from Inforcement of any Domesticall or forreigne power and freeth them from the penaltie of those lawes both Ecclesiasticall and Ciuill whereunto all inferiour persons in a Kingdome are tyed And howsoeuer sinnes in Princes ought to be reprooued and rights of Clayme may be recouered against Kings yet in nothing are they liable to penall lawes much lesse subiect to the Iurisdiction of Elders or Excommunication of this Tyrannous Consistorie Vnhallowed blouldnesses attempted in other Kingdomes and Imperionsly affected and vrged by some amongst vs nay the power to call Synods an Authoritie by Parliament graunted vnto the Prince some violent spirits haue attempted with that bouldnesse as if those only were Lawes which were warranted by this Consistorie Princes being but to Execute what they appoint them out of Gods word whereof notwithstanding themselues must be only Iudges Thus whilst the Prince warranted by his owne Law which is the publike Act of his whole people gaue Authority to some graue Commissioners for Reformation of Ecclesiasticall disorders They denie that any such ought to be appointed Iudges and often both in priuate and publike depraued that honorable and high Commission a thing as it is vnseemely for them to controule so if our late Souereigne in great Wisedome and care of the Church had not giuen it authoritie and strength the bolddnesse of a great number pretending a Zeale had growen to bee so strong that in all appearance There had beene little likelihood of safety to the Queene her selfe And seeing all attempts are most violent that haue their beginning and strength from a Zeale to Religion bee it neuer so false there can be nothing doubtles of greater vse either for the safetie of the Prince the peace of the Church or the quiet of the Commonwealth than the seuere and Reuerend authoritie of this high CoÌ„mission without which assuredly long since we had miserably tasted of all those euilles which vncontrouled ignorance Hypocrisie and crueltie cculd haue brought amongst vs. It is small reason Princes should giue eare vnto these plots which leaue them naked without meanes to defend themselues or their Subiects in the time of danger nay those of the honorable and highe Court of Parliament are to thinke themselues and I doubt not but will iniured by such who haue taken from them on of the three States a State not of the least wisedome and grauitie and from them all that Authoritie which they ascribe to a number of ignorant and sillie Artificers for such some Consistories must needes bee and guided by a youth sometimes neither of wisedome nor vnderstanding It is miserable where men are ruled by no lawes seeing nothing is in man of greater daunger vnlimited than his owne will which imperiously commaundeth ouer his fancie that is able to corrupt and peruert all Rules of order Thus they interprete Tell the Church tell the Consistorie Which because Iohn Morrell did expound otherwise himselfe was excommunicated and his Booke burnt there is nothing more vsull than their pleasures to become Lawes A thing peraduenture men may affect which either desire Change or do hate gouernment but doubtles in it selfe Tyrannous and vnsufferable and so much the more odious and daungerous by how much the Rulers are base there gouernment lesse equall and once admitted not easie to be shaked of In on word There is nothing in the Lawes of this whole Land nay not in the possession of any priuate persoÌ„ safe if
of those times and the Art to speake euill had extended it selfe no further but to the infinite iniurie of the worthiest in this Church their error peraduenture might haue had pardon and that which was indeed the malitious consultation of a number would haue beene thought to haue beene but the madnesse of some fewe but after all this as either desiring themselues a sedition or being misledde by some politicke Atheist to be the actors of the Churches ruine they assemble in diuers places they make lawes despise Authoritie and leaue nothing that is violent vnatēpted In the midst of all which the happinesse of the Church was this that malice had not so much force as shee had Endeuour I am sorry that men endued with vnderstanding and making Religion to be the ground of what they did could so farre deceiue themselues and delude others as to thinke a practise so disordered so inconsiderat so vnciuill could possibly be allowed in an vnderstanding and well gouernd Kingdome only because it seemed to be masked with an Idle shadowe of a pure Zeale Now these proceedings that seeme to bee warranted by Religion are most easily spread abroade because all men presume themselues to haue an interrest in Religion and they are for the most part more hotly pursued than other strifes for as much as coldnesse which in other contentions may bee thought to proceede frō moderatiō is not in this so fauorably cōstrued This made them that if all other meanes fayled them they hoped to effect their desire by force of Armes To this end they write that in this quarrell for reformation a hundred thousand hands would be gotten and then say they you may easily think what stroke so many would strike togither Doubtlesse there is nothing that could sauour of greater sedition especially vnder so gratious a gouernment than being so violently addicted to their owne fancies what they could not obtaine by any quieter meanes rather than faile to seeke to establish it with th◠hazard of so much bloud Nay all seditions almost and the open Rebellions of all times haue proceeded at first from this ground that what in the beginning was but weakly thought vpon grew afterwardes to bee affected with more violence and in the end rather than to fayle to bee attempted by open warre I confesse the part against whom wee striue was a long while nothing feared the wisest contented not to call to minde how errors haue their effects many times not proportioned to that little appearance of reason wherupon they would seeme built but rather to vehement affection of Fancie which is cast towardes them and proceedeth from other causes And surely if a sparke of errour lightening in those dispositions which in all mens thinking were farthest from any inclination vnto furious attemptes was in all reason like to bee verie daungerous must not the perill thereof bee farre greater in men whose mindes are of themselues as drye fewell apt before hand vnto the tumults For surely in a cause of Religion men will strayne themselues vnto desperate aduentures for the reliese of their owne part though Lawe and authoritie bee both against them This then will bee a consideration of importance at this time both for the King and the high Court of Parliament when as it is like those humours will growe strong through confidence in their cause and a hope of friendes how vnsafe in reason it must needes bee to suffer the sparks to bee blowen that are almost quenched or to hazard an Established forme of Church Gouernment by experience found profitable with much peace in exchaunge with any newe imaginarie forme lesse warrantable in trueth and in all reason lesse possible to stand with the safety of the Commonwealth Now that wee haue laid open some part of their proceeding for this Discipline a poynt handled by vs sparingly and with great vnwillingnesse for hee that desireth to see more of their practises may read some Bookes written alreadie to that ende wee will briefely examine whether any man and vpon what reason doth endeauour to iustifie the proceeding of the Reformers in this kinde The Booke which wee Censured in the former Chapter called the Plea of the Innocent vndertaketh verie straungely in my opinion the defence of the proceeding in this whole cause For although the Author himselfe might haue assurance of his owne sinceritie whereof I can not accuse him though some doo yet surely hee could not bee so ignoraunt of what had past since the beginning of her late Maiesties Reigne nor so charitable to excuse the maner of it but that a defence of the whole Storie might haue beene better spared than written at that time and doubtlesse if all other meanes of opposition had fayled their owne dealing was an ouerthrow sufficient to that cause The first thing that hee misliketh is that they are called Puritanes and in the clearing them from all effectation of this name hee spendeth the whole Chapter making other of his brethren that seemed to bee lesse Religious and the Vniuersities places which in duetie hee ought to haue more honoured to bee the principall Authours of this name for to tearme them Puritanes But seeing the end of names is but to distinguish and those who first vsed it amongst vs did rather showe what their owne followers did esteeme of them and what themselues affected than what they were It cannot in reason bee an imputation to any that they were tearmed by that name Neither doo I thinke although diuers of them did glorie to bee so tearmed that this name first proceeded from vs but rather that the Church of Rome seeing vs to reforme our selues to a purer Religion than they professed and that diuers amongest vs not content with that desired yet to be more pure accounting all of vs to bee Heretikes these by a speciall name as affecting to seeme more holy than others a common practise of the Heretikes in olde time they tearmed by the name of Puritanes so that the fault which hee layeth vpon vs doubtlesse had his originall from those of the Church of Rome and therefore one Rishton in a Table dedicated to Cardinall Allen then Gouernour of Doway maketh Puritanisme an Heresie which began in the yeare 1563. neither do I thinke it can easily bee found that any Protestant in England before that time in any publike writing vsed the name of Puritan for no man can bee ignorant but that hee who was the strongest first opposite to this new discipline and handled this argument with greatest learning was himselfe in all precisenes farre purer than those that most gloried in that name and was neuer an aduersary to any of this cause that was not eyther malitious arrogant or an hypocrite neyther is it fit to lay that distinction vpon the Vniuersitie of youthes and Prescisians as this pleader doth as though all that were not for this new Reformation were like one Athacius who bending himselfe by all
if we finde both the words and the deedes of the best amongst them to haue been such as no man hath reason to allow it cannot choose but seeme strange that any one carefull of what he vttereth should become a patron to that proceeding which is no sooner barely rehearsed but must vnto all men of necessitie appeare to be without warrant For iffailing in Cmilitie of tearmes their actions had beene more milde or if ouer seene in their Actions their words had beene of a better temper some colorable snow might haue been their excuse which now is wanting seeing they doe faile in both and therefore euen to discouer their proceedings is to ouerthrow theÌ„ As few Societies are or can be hoped to be without some euill so the principall remedies in the iudgement of wise men haue been thought to be three First that all things corrupted by time should with discretion be brought to their first Institution SecoÌ„dly if this were not to be hoped for they might vtterly be abolished Thirdly that no InnocatioÌ„s were permitted to begin and being begun immediatly by the hand of Authoritie to be cut of The first of these was called Reformation which is a repetion or Restitution of the auncient deede So that to Reform is not to make new but to restore to his former well being what time and corruption by continuance had made euill Now as authoritie and wisedome are both requisite to performe this so must it needs be a disorder in those that would reforme and doe want both And it cannot bee but a great ouersight in them Who hauing thus erred ought to bee silent and craue pardon dare aduenture notwithstanding to plead this cause and to publish Apologies in there owne defence Wee will not touch the first Authors and Originalles of this euill being deriued from those who then both for scituation and gouernment were straungers to our state But only make it appeare that since the beginning of our last Soueriegnes reigne what holinesses so euer was pretended the whole proceeding in matters of Reformation both in worde and deede was altogether vnlawfull and without warrant A thing howsoeuer obserued by diuers heeretofore yet not vnfit to be handled in this place and at this time The ground of that euill which followed was layd in Queene Maries time in whose Zealous gouernment a Zeale in others of our Countrie from other forreigne places in both peraduenture a like euill sowed the vncleane seede of those immoderat growing tares which since haue daungered our whole Church Neither can the goodnesse of Religion bee any warrant for euill doeing seeing what is lawfull where true Religion doth seeme to giue leaue must of necessitie bee as Lawfull being permitted by a Religion or don for a Religion though it be false So that it was no more fit for priuat and Inferiour persons at that time by violence to remoue Idolatrie the contrarie whereof was their Doctrine than in times much purer which haue since followed it was or could be lawfull for any of the Church of Rome by inuasion or treason to establish the Doctrine of that Sea This euer remaining a true rule That good then deserueth the name of euill when being good it ceaseth to bee well done and no Religion can warrant to pull downe Kings when true Religion doth commaund that whatsoeuer their Religion is wee must obay them either in suffering with patience what they impose or in dooing with obedience what they doe commaund So that the iust hatred of Idolatrie seruing to giue warrant to what they did then in times when the Church was much polluted hath been not the least occasioÌ„ since to attempt the like and farre worse when by many degrees the times the Religion was more pure And I am sorie so good a man by name should publish to the world a Doctrine so false and daungerous that it should be lawfull to kill wicked Kings and Tyrants Neither had this being but the priuat error of one been in all respectes so daungerous if an other for his place a Deane and not meanely esteemed had in not his preface to that Booke affirmed it to be the doctrine of the best and most learned in those partes meaning as I thinke Caluin and the rest So that all thinges being duely weighed the practise of those in that time for religion was neither more honest nor lawfull than the late practises of those of the Church of Rome neither let any man thinke that Religion can be a warrant for that deed which must remaine an euerlasting blemish to that Religion that caused it to bee doone Others our countrie had at that time men of famous and worthie memorie which liued in Zuriech Basâ—ll and Franckefort these discretly obserued without Innouation the reformation established in King Edwardes dayes Nowe when those that had liued in Geneua and obserued with what policie Caluin and others swayed the whole gouernment a thing peraduenture neither much contradict seeing the worthinesse of the man nor Difficult to effect considering the forme of that state they began sayling in both repects being equal only in a violeÌ„t Zeale to attempt the like discipline in their owne Countrey A thing so much the lesse sufferable by how much the parties were meaner the gouernment of their Countrie farre better and the alteration not safe in so great a Kingdome And yet at that time the Zeale of these contented it selfe little to meddle in shew with the matters of disciplie but rather was busied about the apparell of Ministers Cerimonies prescribed and amendment as they thought of the Communion booke But after so hardly are those things limited which are but the workes of a strong fancie those that succeeded made their discipline an essentiall Note of the true Church were as ready as they said to become Martyrs in that quarell as for the defence of any Article of the Christian faith of whom I may say as Saint Austine doth of some such they were Martyrs if they had died of a foolish Philosophy Out of this strong and vehement perswasion of well doing and from a desire of goodnes peraduenture in some although it is like that those who were most earnest had not the best conscience were published sundrie Dialogues able to haue iniured a good cause complaints petitions to her Maiestie and the Parliament in the name of the Comunaltie their appellations their exhortations fiue or six seuerall supplications to the Parliament Martyns vnhallowed Imitations of Passauantius The humble motion to the Lords of the Councill and diuers other of the like nature in manner of Register collected into one volume These many such for it were infinit and of small vse to reckon all were the chiefe and the best meanes their learning wisedome and holinesse thought fit for the gaining of Authoritie to this new discipline but if these immodest libelles had beene the worst fruites
our next desire is they may bee censured by all that haue Vnderstanding and Conscience as the intemperate and extrauagant conceits of some giddie headed persons and that men beware except they meane to aduenture to depriue themselues of all sence of Religion and to paue their owne hearts and make them like the high way how they bee consuersant in them and giue credit or beliefe vnto them Therefore to conclude this poynt seeing contentions are of that daunger and that zeale is no warrant to ouerthrow the Church let vs all follow the counsaâ—le which the Angel gaue vnto Agar Returne vnto thy dame and humble thy selfe vnder her hands There is no vertue that better beseemeth vs that are inferiors than Patience and Humilitie Therefore we exhort with the Apostles But God be thanked that ye haue beene the seruants of sinne but ye haue obeyed from the heart vnto the forme of the doctrine whereunto ye were deliuered Being then made free from sinne ye are made the seruants of righteousnesse Let vs not bee desirous of vaine glory prouoking one another enuying one another For where enuying and strife is there is sedition and all maner of euill workes But the wisedome that is from aboue is first pure then peaceable gentle easie to bee intreated full of mercie and good fruits without iudging and without hypocrisie And the fruite of righteousnesse is sowen in peace of them that make peace CHAP. VI. Of Ceremonies WHere men are apt to mislike things of necessarie vse the entrance for the most part into that contempt is through the distasting of those things which are of a meaner nature and serue but in the opinion of wise men onely to make the act of deuotion to be more solemne Solemnitie in some measure being a necessarie adiunct to all publike seruice And whilst it stirreth men with greater holinesse to become outwardly religious whilst it stayeth men from wauering in that they do and others from contempt of that which is done all being by these outward SoleÌ„nities better prepared we cannot but account them the hedge of deuotion and though not the principall points yet as some of the fathers call them the second Intentions of the law Intermeditate meanes not to be despised of a better and more religious seruice This whilst some in our Church haue either not vnderstood or not much regarded they haue earnestly laboured as for a matter of great moment that because the Iews had a religioÌ„ ful of Ceremonies the most part whereof being types are in their particular so far ceased beâ—â—use the Church of Rome hath not limited the infinit burden in this kind partly idle partly needles the greatest part through the corruption of â—lme being growen superstitious these in opposition to all the rest onely misunderstanding the time of Grace are desirous to haue Religion without any Ceremonies at all As if the same God who seeing the weakenesse of his owne people and therefore ledd them as if it were by Ceremonies to that worship which was fittest for them and for that time and who euer since hath beene the Author and approouer of solemne order especially in the publike action of Religion did now eyther see vs to bee so absolute as that these outward helpes were of no vse or that all Ceremonies were but shadowes of things to come not ornaments and helpes to things present did meerely with the passion of his Sonne cancell all kinde of worship that had any solemnities or Ceremonies how vertuous soeuer annexed to it But as to think that Ceremonies without true and inward holinesse could cleanse them from their sinne were to erre and to be Iewish and superstitious so to account them of no vse were to be meerely prophane Wee call them Ceremonies properly all such thinges as are the externall act of Religion which haue their commendation and alowance from no other cause but onely that in Gods worship they are vertuous furtherances of his honour For Religion which is the height and perfection of all Morall vertues conteyneth in it three actes as all other vertues doo the first the Internall which is the willing desire to giue vnto God his due worship and honour secondly the externall aunswering to this which is no otherwise good or commendable than that it vertuously serueth to this end thirdly the commaunded act that is the act of euery vertue ordained by religion to Gods honour so fasting almes and such like are tearmed the Actes of Religion when they are done for Gods worship howsoeuer otheâ—â—ise they are properly the actes of other vertues This the Apostle calleth pure Religion and vndfiled bofore 〈◊〉 the Father to visit the fatherlesse and widowes in their adâ—â—rsity and to keepe himselfe vnspotted of the world Saint Austine saith that God is worshipped with Faith Hope and Charity of these three the first is no way Ceremoniall The third likewise is no Ceremonie but as it is an act inioyned by Religion but the second is properly that which concerneth the Ceremoniall part of Gods worship All antiquitie was euer so farre from misliking of those that they had almost placed Religion in them onely The name which the Hebrewes gaue vnto Ceremonies signifieth not so much the externall act as the law and the precept by which is was commaunded so that in the new Testament euen those which had no longer continuaÌ„ce but vntill Iohn for then began the Iewish Ceremonies to decline are tearmed by our Sauiour by the name of the Law and the Prophets Saint Paule calleth them Iustifications because they were Rites instituted ordayned to that end With them they were the Images of heauenly things opposite to the Images of the Heathen howsoeuer we follow neither of them in the particular the one being the Idolatrous prophanation of an Heathenish superstition the other but the externall seruice appropriate to that people and to that time yet wee dare not seeing no Religion can want all Ceremonies fall so headlong to the error on eyther side as to embrace or refuse all those Ceremonies that the Church hath Now as it is the vnhappinesse of Religion to bee ouerloaden with Ceremonies so in those that haue authoritie not to establish by law such as are needefull is a defect to neglect them in those that ought to bee obedient is a fault but to contemne them in any that liue in the bosome of the same Church must needs bee the manifest argument of their pride and in the end the vtter ruine of Religion it selfe For in the Ceremonies of the Law there were three things to bee obserued first that they were all ordayned for the expressing of the inward and morall worship to serue to true holinesse Fayth Hope and Charity without which all the rest were reiected euen as a burthen by him that commaunded them saying I will haue mercy but not sacrifice for obedience is better than sacrifice and to hearken
the statute required in this kinde It is like he rather desired to tell the world that he was an actor in the troubles of that time then to giue reasons for that which he and they did or to craue with submission pardon of the Church for that which they did not Aboute the yeere saith one 1571. subscription was inforced vpon the Ministerie for which cause in that time certaine men wrote an admonition to the Parliament opening diuers things worthie of reformation whereupō arose great volumes of prouing defending c. But in the middest of these fiery contentions a goodly space of quietnes about the time that the reuerend father Maister Grindall was Archbishop of Canterburie c. after the said archbishops death there came forth a new fresh assault of subscription vniuersally imposed and againe inforced vpon all the ministers in three articles first of the Queenes maiesties soueraigne authoritie ouer all persons c. secondly that the booke of common prayer and of ordayning Bishops Priests and Deacons containe in it nothing contrarie to the word of God c. thirdly to allowe and approue all the articles of religion agreed vpon by the Archbishop and Bishops c 1562 and to beleeue all therein contained to be agreeable to God The Ministers offered freely and willingly to subscribe to the first article of her Maiesties most lawfull authoritie and for the other two they refused to doe any further then by law they were bound and namely according to the statute made for that purpose Anno 13. Hereupon many in diuers shires were suspended from the execution of their ministery and some depriued And in another place We cannot tell whether we might by the lawes and order of this realme subscribe although it were otherwise lawfull by Gods word it concerneth the whole state aduisedly to consider that the holy ministers of God be not oppresse lwith an vniust subscription This the author calleth in another place the first great storme that fell vpon them and in another place this he maketh to be the fruites of subscription that the unpreaching minister and the non-resident are both warranted by it and in another place it is meaning subscription against many good and learned ministers and some it thrusteth out Others before this author both for time and worthines haue stifly but I doubt scarse considerately refused obedience in this point The some of all their reasons tending to this end that many obscure vntruthes were contained in those things whereunto they required that they should subscribe all aiming at this that nothing was euer so greeuous in the Church to the humours and dispositions of these men as to giue by subscription their allowance vnto that which the lawes had done One of them to the Lords of the councell speaking of subscription when D. Whitgift was made Archbishop and set forth his vnaduised deuise of subscription it seemed as a strong pot of brasse that would soone haue broken in peeces all the power of poore ministers and made discipline in vtter contempt I will only put the reader in minde that though it were no dishonor vnto his grace to be the author of so wise an order for the Church yet the same by their owne confession was a lawe before her Maiestie had called him to be a Bishop another for it were endlesse and of little vse to alleage the reasons of Iohnson preacher at Northhampton of Grayer and many besides published to this end being more learned yet in my opinion lesse religious thē the rest hath set downe some reasons why the Bishops doc vrge subscription t◠her Maiesties authoritie in causes ecclesiasticall first for a hope of a more sure setlednes to themselues and their followers that none may hereafter preach against the lordlynes of prelates that none may preach against ciuill offices in a preiate that none may speake against baptisme by women that none may preach against an vnlearned ministerie that none may preach against any corruption yet established whatsoeuer A strange collection thus to aime at the intention of making lawes But we say no otherwise of him then a father did in the like case His words showe vs wholy what he is and if we therefore know him not because we haue not seene his face neither doth he knowe himselfe because he doth not see his face But these doubtles and such like are but as Saint Hierome calles them the hissings of the old serpent For wise men would haue thought that these had had nothing to haue spokē vnlesse they had propounded this to thēselues to haue spoken euill But seeing the tenor of them all is all one an vnreuerent estimation and speaking of men in authoritie and lawes that are made by them a fault surely not small nor easily forgiuen if the cause were vertuous I must needes before I answere them giue them this aduise which I hope some will follow they that do as Gennadius reporteth of one Seuerus seduced to bee a pelagian acknowledge their loquacitie with him and keepe silence vnto death that they may recompence by their silence what they haue offended in speaking Now before we answere this which they haue alleadged against subscription the consideration of the nature of that doubtles must be fittest which in all reason ought to be accounted the best warrant to excuse them both in this and the rest which they doe refuse a reason which cannot be the same to all and in those in whom it is found without deceite they are rather to be pittied and instructed then to be vrged to that which how lawfull so euer their conscience gainesaying they doe make a sinne For though the conscience of man allowing cannot make that to be no sinne which the lawe doth yet the conscience forbidding may make that to be a sinne which the lawe doth not And therefore amongst men of wisedome and vertue there is no Plea that ought to be heard with so much attention as when men for that which they doe or doe not truely and sincerely doe alleadge their conscience Now as the coullorable excuse for refusing to subscribe must be the weaknes of such mens conscience who were perswaded in themselues the things to be vnlawfull whereunto they were required to giue allowance so surely a double fault must lie vpon them if there be any such who making no conscience of those things pretend only the greatest bond vpon earth to be the lawfull warrant of refusing of that which they would not doe And surely where feare and humilitie are both wanting there it is ouer much charity to thinke that they make a conscience All men vnderstand not aright what that is which they alledge for themselues when they say their conscience There is naturally ingrafted in the heart of man that light of nature which neuer can be put out that telleth him that no euill is to be done Now reason according to the knowledge that it hath
themselues which they doe refuse The conscience which doth erre though it binde vntill it be reformed ought notwithstanding to be reformed because either ignorance negligence pride inordinate affection faintnes perplexitie or selfe loue are the corrupt and originall causes of the errors of it So that if none of these haue ouerruled the conscience of these men but that knowledge with due consideration hath directed them in that they did we haue great reason to harken to their excuse and to regarde them with more attention whilest with reuerence and humilitie they alleage their conscience In the meane time for remedie against these errors let them not disdaine the counsell which wise men haue found to be most safe if it be of ignorance to say with Iehosaphat we know not what to doe but our eyes are towards thee if of negligence to come without partiallitie or preiudice as Nichodemus to Christ to those that for knowledge are fit to teach them If of pride to submit our selues one to another and especially to those that haue more learning do rule ouer vs for he that praiseth himselfe is not alowed but he whom the Lord praiseth A singularitie in this kinde hath been the originall of most heresies in all ages and not the least occasion of the troubles of these times for he that walketh vprightly walketh bouldly the rest are presumptuous but he that peruerteth his waies shall be knowne If from inordinate affection making that lawfull which we haue a minde to doe we must harken to iudgement and refuse our affections in this case for iudgement turned into affection doth all perish If from faintnes then onely to be scrupulous feareful when we haue cause least we thinke it lawfull because we streane a knat for to swallow a Cammell If of perplexitie when a man is closed as it were betwixt two sinnes where he is not able though willing to auoyde both that which will not make either to be lawfull will make one of them directly a lesse sinne This is not euer to do euill that good may come of it for though the casting away of things profitable for the sustenance of mans life be an vnthankfull abuse of the fruites of Gods good prouidence towards mankinde yet this consideration did not hinder Saint Paul from throwing corne into the sea when care of sauing mens liues made it necessarie to loose that which else had been better saued For of two such euils being not both euitable the choyse of the lesse is not euill and euils as a wise man noteth must be in our construction iudged ineuitable if there be no apparant ordinarie way to auoyde them because where counsell and aduise beare rule of Gods extraordinarie power without extraordinarie warrant wee cannot presume Last of al if of humility an error surely of least daunger we wish them onely to take heede of to much feare else we say it is the propertie of good mindes there to acknowledge a fault where no fault is For whilest the conscience of man is troubled in this manner grace repaireth in man the excellent image of his first maker Thus giuing our simple direction and not daring to censure the consciences of such as thinke their refusall to be warranted with pretence of conscience we will examine a little what they haue said and done and whether the exacting or refusing of subscription was a greater sinne If the vrging of subscription which the law required was the cause of those seuerall admonitions which the Parliament had surely a worse effect could not haue proceeded from so good a cause then that which was a vertuous inuention to make peace by the vnquiet disposition of some few should become the originall fountaine of so much warre And surely that mildnes which that reuerend Archbishop Grindall vsed in those times little auailed with those men for to make them better which in wisedome euer since hath caused others in that place for to vse the lesse For experience euen in them findeth it to be most true that fauour in that kinde they esteeme but desert and the patience of others but their owne merit Yet wise men in the same place at diuers times to the same persons may vse direct contrarie courses and both well The second inforcing of subscription in the three articles of supremacie the booke of common prayer with those things annexed and the booke of articles made in the Synode 1562. the first they allowe but as for both the other they esteeme them vnlawfull and such as the statute requireth not of them where me thinkes it is strange that men which doe not so much as the lawe requires will alleadge notwithstanding the lawe for their warrant in that which they doe not For if either the vrging of law by the vertue of law or not against law could in wisedome haue serued to make peace those men had little reason to haue been against it who were not able to proue that it was vnlawfull and knew the authoritie to be lawfull that required it of them Neither was there any great reason to hope for obedience in subscribing to the articles if the lawe required it seeing they are not willing towards the communion booke to affoord that allowance which the law required And howsoeuer I take not vpon me to interpret the meaning of that statute yet surely the pretended exception of law is of little force seeing both the Archbishops and Bishops and al the clergie in the conuocatiō subscribed vnto them and that all Canons which the Church doth make haue either confirmation vnder the great seale or the parties that make them haue warrant by the statute for that they doe And if it had not been euer their practise to make a pretence of law for that for which they haue no warrant neither would they doe it if the law commaunded it were better to be excused in that they refuse with pretence of law With the same boldnes some haue affirmed that the present gouernment of the Church of England by Archbishops and Bishops vnder the Prince is to be accounted vnlawfull by the statutes of this land and that to be a Lord Bishop is directly against the statute Eliz. 13. A practise like this some of the Church of Rome haue lately vsed against vs as though our oppositiō against them were beyond law and the instruments made for our defence and to cut them off were intruth the safest protection their actions had But haue these men that thus earnestly pretend law either neuer subscribed to any thing of their owne without law or euer been obedient to the lawes of others surely if they had the contention in this kinde had been buried that day when it was first borne But the English when they came to Franckeford were tied to subscribe to the same confession of faith which the French had after they themselues enioyned all to subscribe to their