ye not read that he which made them at the beginning made them Male and Female And said for this cause shall a Man leave Father and Mother and shall cleave to his Wife and they twain shall be one Flesh Matth. xix 4 5. And St. Paul in like manner to shew that the Woman ought not to usurp Authority over the Man proves it by this Argument For Adam was first formed then Eve 1 Tim. ii 13. and in another place and upon another occasion he observes that the Man is not of the Woman but the Woman of the Man 1 Cor. xi 8. And long before the Prophet Malachi had Argued from the same Topick Malach. ii 15. And Hebr. iv 4. it is noted that God did rest the Seventh day from all his Works from whence the Apostle concludes that he that is entred into his rest he also hath ceased from his own Works as God did from his Vers 10. Now as these and whatever other Arguments are to be found in the Scriptures of the like Nature do evidently suppose the Creation of the World in the same manner as it is related in the Book of Genesis so they explain to us the Reasons why it was thus Created For all these Arguments had been lost and there could have been no ground for them if the World had been otherwise created As certainly therefore as this Arguing from the manner of the Creation is good So certain it is both that the World was so Created and that there was great Reason for it But whatever some Philisophers may think now there is nothing which would have been more disagreeable to the Notions of the Generality of the wisest Men in all Ages than that the World should be made upon Mechanical Principles He spake and it was done he commanded and it stood fact Psal xxxiii 9. He Commanded and they were Created Psal Cxlviii 5. This expresses not only the Truth of the History but the general sense of Mankind who have ever had this Notion of God that to command and to do is the same thing with him And therefore the Objection till of late has run the other way that God did rather Create the World in an instant than in six days It was little suspected formerly that divers Years or many Ages were spent in the Creation It was in the Description of the Creation of the World that Longinus observed the sublime Style of Moses and if the Relation of it be admirable the Creation it self in such a manner as is there related must be much more admirable For it is proper for it to be thus described for no other Reason but because it was proper for it in this manner to be done But what would Longinus have said if the Creation had been related to have been performed not by any command which had its immediate effect but by the tedious Process of Mechanical Causes What Grandeur what evidence of the Divine Power and Majesty is there in this more than in any Chymical Operation if the Mechanical Hypothesis were true It were strange Presumption to demand of Almighty God a Reason of all his Actions and not to believe him upon his Word that he has done any thing but when and how some Men conceit it ought to have been done But what I have now said may at least serve to silence the Cavils of such Men. 2. The Preservation of the World is not performed according to Mechanical Laws or Principles The Mechanical Hypothesis supposes that Bodies act upon Bodies or Actives upon Passives in a certain course and according to such Laws as that being left to themselves they necessarily produce their Effects without any immediate Interposition of a Divine Power But this Notion is grounded wholly upon mistakes 1. It supposes that there was at first a certain quantity of Motion infused or impressed upon Matter which still continues passing from one Body to another according to certain Methods or Rules prescribed But this Supposition that there is always the same Quantity of Motion in the World is wholly precarious or rather notoriously false and the best Philosophers have been able to give no Account how Motion can be Communicated without an immediate Impulse or Concourse of the Divine Power 2. By the Mechanical Hypothesis it is supposed as a thing certain that there is a Plenum which at least is very uncertain or rather it has been demonstrated by Mr. Newton that there is a Vacuum not only interspersed but of a Prodigious and almost incredible extent at the distance of the Earths Simidiameter from us And by his Principles Gravitation must proceed from an immediate and constant Impression or Impulse of God For it proceeds from no Action of one Body upon another but is a Quality belonging to all Matter alike and to every particle of Matter however separate and distant from all others The Projectile Motion and that Attractive Force by which the Planets are carried in their Orbits cannot be communicated or performed according to any Mechanical Laws whereby they are determined from a Rectilinear to an Orbicular Motion For Bodies can act upon Bodies only by Contract and therefore cannot Communicate their Motion or any way determin or affect the Motion of each other in a Vacuum so vast as it must be near the Circumference of the several Orbits so that the old occult Qualities and Substantial Terms were not more repugnant to the Mechanical Hypothesis than these Principles are The being of a Vacuum must suppose an immediate Divine Power necessary to keep the System of the World in that order in which we see it continue For otherwise by this Principle of Gravitations being inherent in every Part of Matter all Bodies would press towards the Center and in a Vacuum there can be nothing to hinder their tendency towards it till they come crowding the upon another so that all the Order of things would soon be reduced to one confused Heap or Moss unless some immaterial Power interposed to hinder it It is evident then that the Mechanical Hypothesis is quite destroyed by these Principles For by these here is no Connexion of Causes and Effects according to any Laws of mere Matter and Motion but all must be done by the immediate Power of God Gravitation and the Projectile Motion must be impressed and suspended without any dependance upon surrounding Bodies they must produce their Effects thro' prodigious void Spaces where Bodies have no Communication of Motion from one to another And all being performed by the immediate directing and assisting Hand of God a Man may as well pretend to solve a Miracle Mechanically as to give any Account of the Phaenomena of Nature by Mechanical Laws according to these Principles 3. The Abetters of the Mechanical Hypothesis argue that God acts in the most General and Uniform ways that it is more becoming his Wisdom to let Nature have its course and that constantly to interpose would be a disparagement to the Order
and Instruments whereby he is pleas'd to convey into our Souls the blessed Influences of his Holy Spirit Or lastly they may be consider'd as visible Rites whereby we are admitted into the visible Society of Christ's Church or profess our Communion with it And in all these respects it will appear how beneficial and requisite the Institution of Sacraments is and how fitting it is that God in his Dispensations with Men should appoint something outward and visible to be done or received by them I. Ceremonies and Rites of Initiation and of Worship have been Instituted in all Religions which is Evidence sufficient that the Nature of Man requires them and that our Worship cannot be wholly Mental and Spiritual And God is pleas'd in his Dealings with Mankind to condescend to their Capacities to ascribe to himself their Passions to allude to their Customs and to make use of such Means and Methods as Men are accustomed to in their Dealings with one another He best understands Humane Nature and knows all the dispositions and tendencies of it he knoweth our frame he remembreth that we are dust Ps ciii 14. He considers that we are Flesh as well as Spirit he fully comprehends the strict Union between the Soul and the Body and the cause and manner of it and how great influence the one hath upon the other in their several Operations he planted in us all our Powers and Faculties and sees all their Motions and Inclinations the secret Springs of Action and Passion and has accordingly fitted and proportioned the Institution of his Laws and Ordinances We see among Men that they are not content only to understand one anothers Meaning or to express their Minds in words tho' they be the most solemn and significant but are wont to use some Ceremony and Solemnity of Action and Circumstances in matters of great Importance because this makes greater impression upon the Mind and lays upon it a more forcible and lasting engagement by taking in the Senses and Passions as Parties concerned with it and this is by experience found to have the best effect to all the ends and purposes of Agreement and Obligation between Men. Oaths themselves are not found to be so secure to be rely'd upon when they are only pronounc'd as when they are taken with such Circumstances of words and gesture as may create an awe and reverence in those who take them For the manner and circumstances in which any action is done raise and fix the Attention and express the Mind and Design of the Doer and are better retain'd in the Memory and work more upon the Will and Affections than the Action of itself can do This Orators very well understand for the Art of Rhetorick is almost nothing else but a skilfull management of the circumstances of actions to the advantage of a Cause And Philosophy informs us that the evil or goodness of Actions depends chiefly upon their Circumstances from whence we learn what the intention of the Mind is and to what degree of Resolution it came in the performance of any Action If an Action be performed at a solemn time and place in the presence of Witnesses met together for that very purpose upon great deliberation with such words and gestures as are very significant to express our full Design and Intention all these Circumstances consider'd make it much more our own proper Act and Deed than if it were done without them tho' the Intention were the same For what we declare before others to be our mind and purpose to do or undertake we cannot but think our selves bound to under more obligations than if we barely design'd it or promis'd it only to the Persons concern'd because the design of declaring it is to lay upon our selves a farther obligation to perform it and to call others as Witnesses against us if we neglect the performance of it and since our Resolution may be declar'd as well by Actions as by Words he that expresses his Resolution both these ways shews a farther design to oblige himself than if he should only use words to express it and if the Circumstances of Actions be stated and solemn and significant then all the ways and means concurr by which it is possible for Men to declare and express their Minds in any Case and to oblige themselves to the performance of any Covenant Now Sacraments are the Seals of the Covenant between God and Man and when God is pleas'd to receive Men into Covenant with himself it is requisite that Men should not barely give their assent to the Terms and Conditions of it and declare that they will undertake them but it is farther necessary that this should be done with all the Solemnity of Words and Actions that may engage them to the performance of it and render them inexcusable if they transgress it it is fitting it should be entred into and renewed in the presence of Witnesses that the Words should be Solemn and the Actions Significant and that nothing should be wanting which may testifie the Sincerity and secure the Fidelity of the Undertakers For if Covenants between Man and Man be made with all the formality of Witnesses and Hands and Seals and Delivery in solemn and express words if Men know themselves too well to trust one another without all this Solemnity it may well be expected that when God is pleas'd to permit them to enter into Covenant with himself he should not receive them under less Obligations of Caution and Security for their Integrity than Men are wont to use amongst themselves For every breach of Covenant with him is infinitely more affronting and sinful than any breach of Covenant with Man can be and therefore God who will not be mocked has appointed the most effectual Means to secure his Laws from contempt he knows the deceitfulness of Man's heart how perverse and stubborn it is especially in things of such a Nature as these are of to which Men are obliged by that Promise and Vow that they are required to make to him and that all the Restraints and all the Remembrances which Words or Actions can afford are little enough to keep Men in any tolerable measure to their Duty God was pleas'd to confirm his Promise to Abraham with an Oath and therein shew'd himself willing to give all the assurance that the most Incredulous Man can desire of the fix'd and unalterable stedfastness of his purpose and the Immutability of his Council that we might have a strong Consolation Heb. vi 17 18. And when God himself is pleas'd so far to condescend for our comfort and satisfaction it is most reasonable that he should oblige us to perform our part of the Covenant by all the ways that may put us in remembrance of our Duty and make us faithful and constant in the performance of it And this could be effected by no better Means than by outward Acts and visible Signs to testifie and profess in the most serious and solemn
for the Oath which secur'd their Lives to them had forfeited that Right which otherwise they might have had to their Lives by a Peace fairly obtained and they lost all other Advantages of the League but only the securing their Lives But that the Canaanites if they had submitted and owned the God of Israel were not to have been destroyed but to have been received to mercy is evident from Josh xi 19 20. There was not a city that made peace with the children of Israel save the Hivites the inhabitants of Gibeon all other they took in battel For it was of the Lord to harden their hearts that they should come against Israel in battel that he might destroy them utterly and that they might have no favour but that he might destroy them as the Lord commanded Moses Which necessarily supposes that if God in his just Judgment upon them for their heinous Provocations had not hardned their Hearts but they had submitted themselves and sought Peace of the Children of Israel they ought to have had favour shewn them It doth therefore sufficiently appear that the Canaanites themselves after all their Provocations against both the Mercy and Justice of God were not excluded from all the Benefits of Strangers and Proselytes amongst the Jews and that all other Nations were encouraged and invited to become Partakers of the Privileges of the Law of Moses and acquaint themselves with the Service and Worship of the True God is notorious and as evident as any thing in the Law and the Prophets But after the Canaanites had fill'd up the measure of their Iniquities God manifested his Almighty Power and Justice upon them and he was pleased to do it by the Sword of the Children of Israel rather than by Pestilence or any other Judgment both to raise the greater abhorrence of Idolatry in his own People and in the neighbouring Nations and because those rude and warlike Nations could observe the Power of God no where so much as in the success of War they chiefly implored their own Gods for success in their Wars and when they were overcome by any People they concluded that the Gods of that Nation were too hard for their own Gods 1 King xx 23. 2 King viii 34. whereas if they had been destroyed by Famine or Pestilence they would have ascribed these Judgments no more to the God of Israel than to any of the Heathen Gods But God got him honour upon these Nations as he did upon Pharaoh and upon all his host when Jethro said Now I know that the Lord is greater than all gods for in the thing wherein they dealt proudly he was above them Exod. xviii 11. from whence he is so often styled the Lord of Hosts in the Old Testament 2. The Providence of God did so order and dispose of the Jews in all their Affairs as to afford other Nations frequent opportunities of becoming instructed in the true Religion and multitudes of Proselytes were made out of all Nations Moses dwelt in Midian and there marry'd an Aethiopian Woman Exod. ii 15. Num. xii 1. his Wife's Father Jethro the Priest of Midian and his Family became converted And the Deliverance of the Children of Israel out of Aegypt magnify'd the Power of God in all Countries where the Report of a thing so wonderful and notorious came The miraculous Victories which the Israelites gained over the Canaanites where-ever they came struck a mighty Terror into all those Nations as we see by the Fear of Balak Num. xxii and from the Speech of the Gibeonites Josh ix 9 10. who were glad to make use of any Pretence as an Expedient to save themselves Rahab with her Family and Kindred and the Gibeonites were early Accessions to the Israelites and Rahab was marry'd to a Man of Israel and the Babylonian Gemara (p) Lightfoot Hebr. and Talmud Exercitat in Mat. i. 5. reckons up Eight Prophets who were likewise Priests descended from her This is certain that our Saviour himself was pleased to derive his Genealogy from her The various Successes of the Israelites in the land of Canaan their Victories and their Overthrows and the miraculous Power of God visibly appearing either in their Defeat and Punishment or in their Conquest or Deliverance must need raise a mighty Fame and Admiration of the God of Israel in all those Countries for they proclaimed a Religious War upon these Nations they destroyed their Images and Groves and Alters where-ever they came and the People plainly perceived that their Gods could not help them The Taking of Jericho not by Storm but only by the meer Sound and Alarm of War the Lengthning of the Day to favour their Conquests and the Destruction of so many Kings by Moses and Joshua were undeniable Evidences of a Divine Power and must awaken Men to make enquiry into that Religion which could inspire such Courage and work such Wonders And these Nations among whom the Patriarchs had sojourned and so many Wonders and Judgments had been wrought were dispersed in Colonies over all Parts of the World as Bochart has proved at large in a most learned and elaborate Work some them if we may believe Procopius erecting a Pillar in Africk as a Monument of Joshua's Victories with an Inscription declaring that they were driven out of their own Countrey by him And S. Augustine says (q) Aug. Exposit Epist ad Rom. that in his time the Country People about Hippo called themselves Canaanites After the Death of Joshua the Israelites were in subjection to the King of Mesopotamia eight Years to the King of Moab eighteen Years Judg. iii. 8 14. to Jabin King of Canaan chap. iv 1. to the Midianites seven Years chap. vi 1. to the Philistines forty Years chap. xiii 1. And still it was because they had done evil in the sight of the Lord that they were given up into the hand of their Enemies and upon their Repentance a Deliverance was wrought for them 1 Sam. xii 10. And when they were so often and for so long a time subdued by their Enemies round about them for their Idolatries and other Transgressions and then again upon their Repentance were rescued from their oppression by Gideon and Jeptha and Samson all raised up for that purpose this must give great occasion and opportunity to all the bordering Nations to know and consider that Religion the observation or neglect whereof had such visible Effects upon its Professors for under their Affliction and in the time of their Repentance the Israelites declared the cause of their Misery and made known the Power of their own God and the Vanity and Sinfulness of Idolatry And therefore their being so often and so long time under the Oppression of their several Enemies was a merciful Providence to the Nations who had them in subjection as well as for the Punishment and Amendment of the Israelites themselves What good use was made of these Methods of the Divine Providence doth not appear to
and Contrivance in his Establishment of the Laws of Motion that Matter and Motion are with that Wisdom set to work that they can perform all without any more than preserving and sustaining them in their Being and Operations and that he is the best Artist who can contrive an Engine that shall need the least medling with after it is made But it ought to be considered what the Nature of the Engine is and what the ends and uses of it are and if the Nature of it be such that it cannot answer the ends for which it was framed without sometimes an assisting Hand it would be no point of Wisdom in the Artificer for the Credit of his Contrivance to lose the most useful Ends design'd by it As if among other uses this curious Engine were design'd to reward the Good and punish bad Men to remove the punishment upon Amendment and to renew it upon a Relapse Since Brute Matter is uncapable of varying its Motion and suiting it self to the several States and Changes of Free Agents he must assist it unless he will lose the Chief end for which it is to serve It is no defect in the Skill and Wisdom of the Almighty that Matter and Motion have not Free will as Men have But it would be a great defect in his Wisdom not to make them the Instruments of Rewards and Punishment because it is impossible for them of themselves to apply and suit themselves to the several States and Conditions of Free Agents The Nature of Matter and Motion is such that they cannot serve all the Designs of their Creator without his Interposition and therefore he constantly doth interpose according to a certain Tenour which he has prescribed to himself but this Tenour and Course is altered upon some important Occasions In a natural and ordinary way he Cures Diseases sends Rain or dry Weather or else our Prayers to him would be insignificant upon such Occasions and there would be no room left for his inflicting these Temporal Rewards and Punishments He feeds the Hungry that cry to him and he punishes the Wicked when he sees it fitting by Famine or Drought or Pestilence in the ordinary Methods of his Providence But sometimes he alters these ordinary Methods and acts above them or contrary to them to signalize his Mercy or his Judgments And thus Christ fed so many thousands in the Wilderness and God Rained down Fire from Heaven upon Sodom and Gomorrah by a particular and miraculous Dispensation Miracles are the particular Appointment of God in peculiar Cases and Occasions and the course of Nature is his general and perpetual Appointment at all other times God at no time leaves Nature to it self but ever concurs with it by assisting its Power and directing its course he ordinarily interposes in the constant course of Things according to established Laws But Miracles are his wonderful Work when he interposes in an extraordinary manner and alters that Method which he has prescribed to himself to observe in the common course of Nature God doth not in an extraordinary manner interpose to prevent the irregular or unusual productions of Nature as in mostrous Births c. For how irregular soever these may seem yet they are according to this standing Rule that they shall be suffered to happen in certain Cases and they rarely happening serve to illustrate the Divine Wisdom in contriving Nature so that in its general Course all its Operations should be regular and uniform and from hence it appears that God doth not extraordinarily interpose to alter the Course of Nature but for great Ends Superiour to those which concern only the material World We may well suppose that God has at much regard to his Wisdom in his Government of the Moral as of the Material Part of the Creation and yet he has added supplemental Laws to enforce the Moral Laws and these additional Laws have been changed as the Circumstances and Condition of Men required Why then should the Laws of the Material World be so much more sacred as that he should never intermeddle with them He assists Moral Agents with the continual supplies of his Grace and natural Agents with that help which is needful for them to perform his will God may hasten and assist natural causes upon our Prayers he may quicken the Motions and enforce the Powers of Nature and remove secret Impediments to help and make way for natural Operations or he may slacken or retard natural Causes To say that God has so ordered the course of Nature as upon the fore-sight of Mens Prayers to him to grant them what they Pray for and upon the fore-sight that they will not Pray to withhold from them what they want by Mechanical Laws is by no means satisfactory For there is neither Proof nor possibility of Proof of it it is merely a Supposition without any ground of Reason but only this that the Mechanical Notion cannot otherwise be maintained But I will suppose with much more Reason that two Men are Sick of the same Disease that the Circumstances of the Disease are all the same and all outward Accidents likewise the same till the Prayers of one of them make a Difference For one of these Men upon his Prayers Recovers the other neglecting to Pray Dies The natural Causes are supposed to be the same excepting only so far as Prayer moves God in his Mercy to make a Difference in their Case To say that this never happened is wholly precarious and hard to believe since it probably may often happen in Epidemical Distempers but it is much harder to believe that it can never happen and if this either have or can happen it is not upon fore-sight of their Prayers by the contrivance of Mechanical Laws in their first Establishment but by an immediate Act that God assists Men upon their Prayers to him The strange Providential Deliverances of some certain Persons are observable in every Age and all Histories mention them But how shall particular Men amidst the greatest Dangers be preserved in the common Calamities of the Sword and Famine and Pestilence but by a particular interposing Providence Were these Men who have been so remarkably preserv'd all of one Constitution or do Soldiers Slay Mechanically tho' the Plague and Famine should be supposed to do so I wonder it should be thought less agreeable to Philosophy for God to interpose in directing natural Causes than in over-ruling Moral Agents where the Designs of the Providence equally require it The same Providence delivers both from the snare of the Hunter and from the noisome Pestilence A thousand shall fall besides thee and ten thousand at thy Right Hand but it shall not come nigh thee Psal xci 3.7 4. The Mechanical Philosophy proceeds upon a wrong Notion of God supposing it unworthy of him to be concerned immediately in every thing which is done We may as well imagine it below him to know every thing as to suppose it unworthy of him
could not deny the Evidence of the Fact supposing the thing possible but they would not own it possible that such a thing should be and upon that account rejected all the Evidence that could be produced as tending only to prove an Impossibility and so not to be regarded I shall therefore shew the possibility of the Resurrection of the Dead and that it is unreasonable to think it incredible that God should raise the Dead If it be incredible that God should Raise the Dead it must be upon one of these Two Accounts either because he cannot or because he will not do it For what God both can and will do is so far from being Incredible that it is a most undoubted Truth Therefore I shall First Prove that God is certainly able to Raise the Dead and Secondly That he certainly will do it 1. That God is certainly able to Raise the Dead is a thing credible in it self and therefore ought to be esteemed incredible by no sort of Men whatsoever tho' they have no Knowledge of any Revealed Religion if they have but right Apprehensions concerning God No Man can have a true Notion of God but he must know that God is a Being of Infinite Power and Wisdom that he made the World and all things therein that he preserves and sustains all Creatures and that all things are wholly at his Will and Disposal to do with them as he pleases that nothing can oppose or resist his Will or give him the least hindrance in any thing which he is pleased to undertake How then can it seem incredible that God should raise a Dead Man to Life again when he at first gave him his Life And is it not as easie to restore it to him as to give it him at first Might we not as well dispute that it is impossible for a Man to be Born as that it is impossible for him to be Raised from the Dead if our own experience did not convince us of that but not of this God who gave all that Power and Ability which Natural Causes have to produce their Effects may if he pleases produce the same Effects immediately by himself For it is not because he stands in need of any help from Natural Causes that he has appointed them but because it seemed best to his Infinite Wisdom to appoint this Course and Order in the World And it is evident even to Natural Reason that there must have been some who were immediately Created by God and were not born of others as Men are since that there must have been some First Parents some who had no Parents themselves but were of Gods immediate Creation that there must have been some who were the First of all Mankind and therefore could be born of no others Since then Man must of necessity have been first formed by God himself and not have come by a Natural Birth into the World it is evident that God might have made as many Men and Women after this manner as he had pleased and he who is the Author of our Nature may act without it and as much beyond and above any Natural Powers and Faculties in his Creatures as it seems best to him And it may as well be thought incredible that God should at first make Man as that he should be able to raise him up again after Death for Death is only the End of Nature's power of working not of the Power of God himself who as he originally made the Race of Mankind so he appointed the Nature of Things and gave it a stinted Power which it cannot exceed but his own Power is Infinite and no Bounds can be set to it When a Man is once Dead Nature has done with him and can never recover him to Life again for God ordained at first that according to the Course of Nature he should only be born and live here a while not that his Life should be restored again to him after Death But he is not so confined himself that he cannot give Life to the Dead but has reserved this as his own Prerogative and above any thing in Nature's Power God who formed Adam of the Dust of the ground might have formed all Mankind so if he had pleased and he can as easily raise all Mankind to Life again out of the Dust as he made the first Man out of it And the Atheist one would think has of all Men the least pretence to scruple the Resurrection of the Dead who must suppose that Mankind at first sprung out of the Earth as Plants do by a Spontaneous Production and for him to pretend that the Bodies of Men cannot be raised to Life again by an Almighty Power is as unreasonable as any thing in Atheism it self can be When at certain Seasons every Year we see things receive a New Life as it were according to the Course of Nature we may well conclude that if so strange an Alteration can proceed from Natural Causes then surely God is able to effect that which is much more wonderful and to raise even these Bodies of ours after they are dead and rotten in the Grave to Life again And since the Corn which is Sown in the Earth is not quickned except it die and will not revive and grow again and come to perfection unless it be first buried in the Ground and undergo great Alterations there it is a foolish thing as the Apostle argues to doubt of the Resurrection of the Dead because we cannot understand the way and manner of it Let Men Answer all the Difficulties in Nature and it will be time enough afterwards to dispute with them about a Resurrection but when we are at a loss about the most common and obvious things it must be great Presumption to deny the Resurrection because we cannot comprehend it when alas what is there besides that we are able to comprehend Will we presume to say that God can do nothing but what we understand how it may be done when every thing we see may inform us that his Wisdom is Infinite and his ways past finding out Indeed if we understood every thing else there might be some pretence to scruple the Resurrection because we do not understand how it shall be But when our Ignorance is so notorious in all other things it is the heighth of Folly and Perverseness to think our selves competent Judges of such a Mystery as this So far are we from being able to make any Estimate of God's Power and so far is the Resurrection from being Incredible because there may be Objections made about it which may seem unanswerable that if no other Answer could be given this would be sufficient that God can do more than we can have the least Thought or Conception of and that it is no Argument that he cannot do what we cannot conceive how it should be done so long as there is nothing contrary to the Divine Nature in it nor which implies a Contradiction the
him out of their sight he was not snatch'd away from them by a swift and violent motion like Elijah and carried up in a fiery Chariot which might dazle their sight that they could not discern him in his Ascent but he was lifted up and removed from them leisurely and by degrees they looked stedfastly towards Heaven as he went up by a visible and easie motion and they had a clear view of him 'till at last a Cloud received him out of their sight It is probable that all the Disciples to the Number of about an hundred and twenty mentioned Acts i. 15. were present to behold the Ascent of our Saviour (q) Apud Euseb Hist lib. 1. c. ult The Apostle St. Thaddeus declared tho' this as well as many other things is not inserted into the Scriptures that a great multitude of the Saints and Heavenly Host went up with him we read of the Appearance of two Angels upon this Occasion who acquainted the Disciples that this same Jesus whom they had thus evidently seen taken up from them into Heaven should so come in like manner as they had seen him go into Heaven And St. Paul informs us that the manner of his Coming at the last Day will be with his mighty Angels or the Angels of his Power 2 Thes i. 7. From whence we may conclude according to the Account of St. Thaddeus that the Holy Angels visibly attended him in his Ascension The Disciples were all much surprized at a thing so wonderful and stood gazing up into Heaven after him 'till they were certified not only by their own Senses but by the Message of the Angels that he was gone from them into Heaven no more to be expected from thence till the Day of Judgment We have therefore the plainest and fullest Evidence that can be desired both of the Resurrection and Ascension of our Saviour He shewed himself alive to his Disciples after his Passion by many infallible Proofs he was seen of them forty days and Conversed and Discoursed with them tho' we are not told after what manner and by what Intervals of time he was pleased to vouchsafe them his Presence this being concealed from us as very many of the Particulars are of his former Life before his Crucifixion But at the end of the space of forty days whilst he was in the midst of them he ascended into Heaven in the sight of them all in such a manner that they distinctly saw and beheld him and kept their Eyes fix'd upon him in his Ascension and a Vision of Angels besides informed them that he is to return in the like manner when he shall come to Judge the World CHAP. XXVIII Why some Works of Nature are more especially ascribed to God why Means was sometimes used in the working of Miracles and why Faith was sometimes required of those upon whom or before whom Miracles were wrought I. ALL the Powers of Natural Causes proceeding from God that may justly be ascribed to him which is wrought by them for he works as truly by Second Causes as by his own direct and immediate Power in producing any Effect The Order and Frame of Nature was Originally by his Appointment and by his Care and Providence and Influence it is upheld and therefore the Scriptures ascribe the effects of Natural Agents to God as the Author of them because these can do nothing but by his Support and Influence and the continuance and preservation of Natural Causes in the production of their Effects for so many Ages in one constant Tenour is a manifest and wonderful Demonstration of the Divine Power and Wisdom But those things may be said more especially to be done by God himself whereby upon some extraordinary Occasion his Power and his Will are more particularly manifested or his Promise is fulfilled for in those things his Care and Providence is more concerned to bring them to pass and therefore God may employ a more than ordinary concourse to sustain and influence the Powers of Nature that they may not sail in such Cases to produce their Effects according to their usual and setled Course II. Miracles are more peculiarly the Works of God because they are wrought without the concurrence or subserviency of Natural Means For tho' sometimes outward Means were used in the Miraculous Curing of Diseases yet they were such as could have no effect in the Cure but rather the contrary as when the Man that was born blind recovered his Sight by washing in the Pool of Siloam at our Saviour's Command after his Eyes had been anointed with Clay made of Dust and Spittle The Ointment made of Dust and Spittle was so far from having any effect towards the Cure that it would have been much more likely to have put out the eyes of a Man that had seen and the washing afterwards could only remove that which was so far from being a Remedy that it must have been an obstruction to the best sight As many Miraculous Cures were wrought by our Saviour without any more than a word speaking and sometimes even without so much as that to shew that he had no need of Means so when any Means were used they were such as apparently could not tend to the Cure and were not used as Remedies but as Circumstances in the working his Miracles to raise the Attention of the Beholders to imprint what was done the deeper upon their Memories and to give the greater Credibility to the History of his Miracles For all matter of Fact is to be proved or disproved by Circumstances and the more Circumstances concurr in any Action the less liable it is to Mistake or Imposture Our Saviour therefore was pleas'd that his Miracles should always be accompanied with remarkable Circumstances which were sometimes of one kind and sometimes of another the better to work upon the variety of Mens Tempers and Dispositions but whatever outward Means was at any time used by him it could have the Nature only of a Circumstance and was no more proper and effectual to produce the Miracle than any other might have been Some he touched some he only spoke to and others he sent to the High-Priest that he might be a Witness of the Cure Now the touch the speaking or the sending could have no effect as outward Means but only as they were attended with an inward and Divine efficacy But all these were considerable Circumstances to excite the Observation of those who were present at these Cures and to preserve the Remembrance of them to Posterity III. Tho' our Saviour had the most absolute and unconfined Power of working Miracles at all times and before all Persons whensoever he pleased yet we may observe that he sometimes refused to exercise it For tho' he could always do his Marvellous Works yet it was not fit that they should be always done but then only when they might be useful and serviceable to the Ends for which they were wrought and to his Design of coming
unbelief the evil Spirit was cast out of his Son Mark ix 23.24 The End and Design of Christ's Miracles required that those who were Cured by him should believe in him For they were wrought with a design to convince Men that he was the Son of God and that he was come not so much to Cure their Bodies as to save their Souls and he forgave their Sins at the same time that he healed them of their Diseases Mark ii 5. And since Faith is so necessary a Doctrine of the Gospel it was as requisite that Christ should teach this as any other Doctrine But how could he do it more properly and more effectually than by requiring Faith in those who came to be healed If they would partake of his Mercy they must qualifie themselves for it by believing that he was the great Prophet and Messias who was then so much expected and of whom it was foretold that he should make the Blind to see and the Lame to walk and the Deaf to hear c. Luke vii 22. Isa xxxv 5. And unless their Bodily Cure did conduce to the Cure of their Souls by Faith and Repentance it would be but ill bestowed upon them and therefore with great Reason might be denied them And upon this Account we find our Blessed Saviour both requiring Faith in some and rewarding it in others to whom his miraculous Power was extended Luke viii 48. xviii 42. And St. Paul perceiving that the Cripple at Lystra had Faith to be healed immediately healed him without being ask'd to do it Acts xiv 9. 2. Faith in the Miracles of Christ is required of Men in all Ages of the World though Miracles are ceased and if this be Reasonable now it could not but be fitting then that those who came to Christ should believe in him for the sake of the Miracles which they had been certified that he had done upon others For Miracles when they are fully attested are as sufficient a Ground of Faith as if we had seen them done and to manifest that they are so our Saviour might require Belief in his former Miracles of those who expected any Advantage from such as they desired him to do If they would give no Credit to the Miracles which were so notorious and so abundantly testified by Multitudes who saw them done how should others believe in Times to come when no more Miracles should be wrought for the Conviction of Unbelievers Might no Man be required to believe unless he saw the Miracles himself Then how should the the Church subsist in future Ages when Miracles would be no longer wrought but were for great Reasons to be with-held We must now believe upon the Account of the Miracles which were then done and why therefore should they not be required to believe upon the Account of them who lived at the very Time and in the same Country where they were wrought though they had never seen them Our Saviour in these Instances might introduce that Method and establish the Evidence and Certainty of those Means and Motives whereby Faith was to be produced in Men of all succeeding Ages and might hereby signifie and declare that he requires the same Faith of us from the Testimony of others that he would do if we had seen and experienced his miraculous Power our selves CHAP. XXIX Of the Ceasing of Prophecies and Miracles PRophecies are generally of more Concernment and afford greater Evidence and Conviction in future Ages than when they were first delivered For it is not the Delivery but the Accomplishment of Prophecies which gives Evidence to the Truth of any Doctrin The Events of Things in the Accomplishment of Prophecies are a standing Argument to all Ages and the length of Time adds to its Force and Efficacy and therefore when all that God saw requisite to be foretold is deliver'd to us in the Scriptures there can no longer be any need of New Prophecies which would be of less Authority than the ancient ones inasmuch as their Antiquity is the thing chiefly to be regarded in Prophecies For if to foretel Things to come be an Argument of a Divine Prescience the longer Things are foretold before they come to pass the better must the Argument needs be He therefore that requires New Prophecies to confirm the Old little considers the Nature of Prophecies and wherein the Evidence and Use of them lies but in great Wisdom and Caution will give no Credit to the best Evidence unless there were something less evident to prove it by The chief Enquiry then seems to be concerning the Cessation of Miracles but from what has been elsewhere said the Reason may appear why the miraculous Power which the Apostles received by the descent of the Holy Ghost was not to be of perpetual continuance in the Church but was to cease in future Ages For the Cause and End of the Gift of Miracles bestowed upon the Apostles was to make them capable of being Witnesses to Christ and when the Gospel of Christ was sufficiently testified there could be no longer need of such a Power which was given to enable Men to bear Testimony to it For what is once effectually proved by sufficient Witnesses is for ever proved and needs no after Evidence if this Proof be preserved and transmitted down to Posterity The Power of Miracles continued till the Gospel had been Preached not only in Jerusalem and in all Judea and in Samaria but unto the utmost Parts of the Earth which was the declared Intention of our Saviour in bestowing it Acts i. 8. And when the Gospel had stood at the Tryals and conquered all the Opposition that could be made against it by Jews and Heathens and Apostates themselves when Miracles had been wrought for several Ages before all sorts of Men upon all Occasions and had extorted a Confession from the Devils themselves of the Divine Power by which they were wrought when the Books of the Apostles and Evangelists in which these Miracles are Recorded had been dispersed in all Nations and Languages so that it was impossible that the Memory of them should be lost whence once the Gospel was thus divulged and attested to the World it could not be necessary that this miraculous Power should be any longer continued Because this is the only Reason and Design why Miracles should be wrought to awaken Mens Attention and prepare them for the Reception of the Doctrin which is revealed and convince them of the Truth of it If then it be enquired Why the miraculous Gifts which were at first bestow'd upon the Church were not continued to it in all succeeding Ages The plain Answer is Because this Power was bestowed for the Establishment of the Christian Religion in the World by convincing Men of its Truth and Authority and therefore when a sufficient Evidence had been given in all Parts of the World of the Divine Authority of that Religion upon the Account whereof these Gifts were bestowed the Reason for the bestowing
of them must cease and the Reason why they should be bestowed ceasing these miraculous Gifts must of consequence cease with it And thus it was likewise under the Law It is observable that we read of no miraculous Power bestowed upon any Man before Moses The Creation of the World was dilivered down with undeniable Certainty and the miraculous Judgments of God in Drowning the Old World in the Confusion of Tongues and in the Punishment inflicted upon Sodom and Gomorrah were sufficient to keep up a Sense of the True Religion But when a new Institution of Religion was to be introduced by Moses miraculous Gifts were necessary to give Authority to it and to oppose those false and lying Wonders which were in use among the Magicians in Egypt and other Places In the former Ages Predictions were very frequent and they were delivered by the Patriarchs who were Men of unquestionable Credit and Authority and could have no need of Miracles to confirm the Truth of their Prophecies which were so usual in those Times and when the Lives of Men were so long divers Prophecies of the same Persons had been verified by the Event But Moses had a New Law to deliver and both He and the Prophets had a a stubborn People to deal with to whom the Message they were charged withal was commonly very unwelcome so that till this Institution was fully settled Miracles became necessary But when the Old Testament had been sufficiently authorized and established by Prophecies and Miracles and when by the Captivities and Dispersions of the Jews the Divine Mission of their Prophets became known among so many other Nations when the Jews were reduced from Idolatry which they never practised after their Return from their Captivity in Babylon and when they had made numerous Conversions amongst the Heathens then these miraculous Gifts were no longer continued as they had been before in the Jewish Church insomuch that it became a (a) Lightf Glean out of Exod. §. vi Harm of the Evang Luke i. 18. Joh. ii 18. Maxim among them that after the Death of Zechariah and Malachi and the rest of the Prophets who returned from Babylon the Spirit of God departed from Israel and ascended and for above Four hundred Years together the Gifts both of Prophecy and Miracles had been with-held from them before the Manifestation of Christ For though there were gross Errours and dangerous Corruptions among the Pharisees and Sadducees and other Sects of the Jews yet since the Truth and Certainty of that Revelation from whence these Errours might have been confuted had been so throughly confirmed all their Corruptions and Errors were not a sufficient cause for the continuance of miraculous Gifts and the Pharisees and other Sects who were most fond and zealous of their several Tenets and Traditions yet never durst pretend to a Power of Miracles or Prophecy but endeavoured to support themselves upon the Authority of Moses and the Prophets What they sometimes spake of (b) id Fall of Jerus §. IX Harm of the N. T. §. LXXIII the Bath Col or Voice from Heaven deserves but little Credit and amounts but to a Confession that the Spirit of Prophecy had failed under the Second Temple as the Jews themselves expressly acknowledge it to have done (c) More Nevock Part. 2. c. 36 41. Maimonides declares that the Bath Col did not denominate Men Prophets and therefore it is not reckoned by him among the Degrees of Prophecy I have already Proved at large Book 1. that the Evidence of those Miracles which were wrought in the Primitive Times affords as much certainty to our Faith as if we our selves had seen them wrought And our Saviour plainly says notwithstanding his Works which bore Witness of him that it was not to be expected that his own Words should be rather believed than the VVritings of Moses For had ye believed Moses ye would have believed me for he wrote of me But if ye believe not his VVritings how shall ye believe my VVords Joh. v. 46 47. And when once the Gospel had been attested by Miracles as the Law had been and rendred as certain to all succeeding Ages as a constant Power of Miracles could have made it there could be no Reason why such a Power should be any longer bestowed Miracles were wrought in Evidence of the Truth of Revelations made to Mankind in the Old and New Testament not to decide any Controversies arising amongst those by whom the Scriptures are received For to whom the Scriptures are the Rule by which all Disputes ought to be determined and therefore the Gifts of Miracles were sometimes manifested among (d) Ad Orthodox inter Justin Martyr Oper. Respons v. Hereticks for the Conviction of Infidels which is the true end and design of Miracles and not to be any Note of Distinction between the Orthodox and Hereticks The learned (e) In Irenae Dissert 11. §. 28. c. Mr. Dodwell by an historical Account of Miracles from the Times of the Apostles through the Ages next succeeding has shewn that they were always adapted to the Necessities of the Church being more or less frequent as the State of the Church required till they at last wholly ceased when there was no longer any need of them For the only end and use of miraculous Gifts is the Confirmation and Establishment of Religion and therefore when this is once fully confirmed and established they can be no longer needful But it seems rather necessary that they should afterwards cease than that they should be continued I mean as to any constant Power of working Miracles residing in the Church For tho' there may possibly be some extraordinary Cases in which it may please God to manifest a miraculous Power yet there is no Reason to conclude that a constant Power of working Miracles should be continued to the Church but rather that those Gifts should cease when Religion has been confirmed by a perpetual Course of Miracles for some Hundreds of Years together Because I. Miracles when they became common would lose the design and end and the very Nature of Miracles For the Nature of Miracles consists in this that they are an extraordinary VVork of God not that they are more difficult than the ordinary works of Nature All things are alike easy to God and Miracles are as easy as any thing in the constant course of Nature can be the only difference is that Miracles are his wonderful Work they are more apt to raise our Wonder and Admiration and to put us in mind of a Divine Presence For we wonder at strange and unusual things and suppose a more than ordinary Reason for them But if Miracles had continued in all Ages this Effect of Miracles would have ceased and they would no longer have been Miracles but a kind of different Course of Nature For according to the best and most accurate Philosophy nothing in the settled Course of Nature can be performed without an
immediate Influence of the Divine Power but in Miracles this Power manifests its self in an extraordinary manner above and contrary to the Established Laws or Rules which God has in all other cases prescribed for the producing Effects II. Men would fancy to themselves some kind of Scheme or other and would frame some Notions and Conceits to give an Account of Miracles or they would imagin them to return of Course at certain Periods or upon some Accidents if they saw them frequently done or perhaps they would suppose them to proceed from some Defect in the Nature of Things which could not always keep its course but made many Deviations from it But when Miracles were wrought only in some Ages for peculiar Reasons this shews that they were done by an immediate Divine Power with a particular Design which could be no other than the Confirmation of Religion since they ceased both under the Law and the Gospel when both were fully declared and confirmed III. A perpetual Power of Miracles in all Ages would give occasion to continual Impostures which would confound and distract Mens minds and would make the true Mircles themselves suspected We see now that the Dreams of every Enthusiast and the Pretences of every Impostor are apt to startle weak minds tho' we have so much Reason not to expect Miracles or Revelations But if we were in constant expectation of True Miracles the False would be much more likely to mislead many and to make others reject the Belief of any Miracles at all If Prophecies and Miracles had been frequent in the Jewish Church to the coming of our Saviour his Prophecies and wonderful Works had not so well distinguished and manifested him to be the Christ But when after so long an Intermission they were again revived in him this shewed him to be the great Prophet and Messias who was expected And it is very observable that as Miracles had been discontinued for a long time among the Jews so St. John Baptist who was more than a Prophet and one of the greatest of all the Men that had been before him yet wrought no Miracles that he might be the better distinguished from the Messias and that there might arise no doubt in the Minds of any which of them was the Christ And when our Saviour had been acknowledged to be the Christ in all Parts of the World it was fit that Miracles should cease to preserve the Authority due to the Miracles wrought by himself and his Disciples it being more for the Honour of Christ that the Miracles wrought in his Name should cease when his Religion had been fully Established than that Men should be tempted to doubt who was the true Christ and which was the true Religion upon the account of false Miracles wrought in opposition to the True IV. Another Reason why the Gift of Miracles has been with-held in latter Ages may be this because since there has been a general depravation of Manners among Christians it would have proved a great occasion of Pride and Vain-Glory to those who had possest it as we find it was to some even in the times of the Apostles 1 Cor. xii xiv And our Saviour saw it requisite to give Caution to his Disciples Notwithstanding in this rejoice not that the Spirits are subject unto you but rather rejoice because your Names are written in Heaven Luke x. 20. It must be an eminent and truly Primitive Piety that could bear the having of such Gifts with an humble and Christian Temper of Mind V. It is an Observation of (f) Advan of Lâ—arn l. iii. c. 2. my Lord Bacon's That there was never Miracle wrought by God to Convert an Atheist because the Light of Nature might have led him to confess a God But Miracles are designed to Convert Idolaters and the Superstitious who have acknowledged a Deity but erred in his Adoration 〈…〉 Light of Nature extends to declare the 〈◊〉 and true Worship of God For the same Reason when once the true Religion is confirmed in such a manner as to have the same Evidence for it which there is for the Existence of God himself Miracles are no more to be expected to convert an Infidel than to convert an Atheist Among Men of Learning and Reason there ought to be no more doubt of the Truth of the Gospel than of the Being of a God and they without the help of Miracles may instruct others (g) De Procur Indor Salute Lib. ii c. 9. Acosta enquiring into the Cause why Miracles are not wrought by the present Missionaries for the Conversion of Heathen Nations as they were by the Christians of the Primitive Ages gives this as one Reason because the Christians at first were ignorant Men and the Gentiles learned but now on the contrary all the Learning in the World is employ'd for the Defence of the Gospel and there is nothing but Ignorance to oppose it and there can be no need of farther Miracles in behalf of so good a Cause when it is in the Hands of such able Advocates against so weak Adversaries However though there be no such change as was wont formerly to be wrought in the visible Course of Nature in Confirmation of our Religion yet there is still a Divine Power evident among Christians living in Heathen Countries For the Devil who tyrannizeth over the Heathens has no Power over Christians dwelling among them of which the Indians have taken great Notice and have (h) Lerii Histor Navig in Brasil c. 16. declared the Christians happy in being freed from the Tortures of Wicked Spirits by which they find themselves often seized on the sudden in a terrible manner and stand in perpetual fear of them (i) Capt. Knoxe 's Hist of Ceylon Part iii. c. 4. Christians they do acknowledge have a Prerogative above themselves and not to be under the Power of these Infernal Spirits It is so generally related by Travellers of all Professions both Protestants and Papists that the Devil exercises a manifest Tyranny over the Heathens but is able to do nothing to the Christians abiding amongst them that this cannot be denied to be a plain Argument of a Divine Power discovering it self in Confirmation of the Christian Religion though not by such Miracles as were formerly wrought because there is no longer any need of them CHAP. XXX Of the Causes why the Jews and Gentiles rejected Christ notwithstanding all the Miracles wrought by Him and his Apostles THough the Christian Religion be most certain in it self yet there is a Supernatural Grace required to make us throughly and effectually convinced of the certainty of it No Man can come to me says our Saviour except the Father which hath sent me draw him and this is declared to be the Reason of the Infidelity of such as were offended at his Doctrin and departed from him But there are some of you that believe not for Jesus knew from the beginning who they were that believed not
caused the Christians in their Apologies to press earnestly for a fair and impartial Hearing of their Cause beseeching their Enemies that they would not be so injurious to the Truth and to themselves as to despise and condemn what they did not understand They were desirous to undergo any Tryal if they might but be admitted to be heard 6. Yet many who did not actually become Christians had more favourable and just Thoughts of the Christian Religion (l) Ael Lamprid. in Alex. Severo Alexander Severus had the Effigies of Christ in his Chappel and had designed to erect a Temple for the Worship of him and to insert his Name among the Heathen Gods As it is reported that Adrian likewise with the same Intention had commanded Temples to be built without Images in all Cities but was dissuaded by some who consulted the Oracles about it which gave out that all Men would then become Christians and the other Temples would soon be forsaken This which is related concerning Adrian has been by some supposed to be a mistake because the Fathers say nothing of it But Ael Lampridius or rather Spartianus who mentions it being a Heathen might perhaps have it from the Gentiles for it was only in Adrian's Intention to set up the Worship of Christ which might be unknown by the Christians of his time the design being laid aside upon consulting the Oracles It was certainly reported in the Historian's time as he declares and yet this Objection lies as well against the Report as against the Reality of the thing For it is strange that a Report of this nature should be mentioned by no Christian Writer though there had been no Truth in it (m) Euseb Hist lib VII c. 11 Aemilianus the Prefect of Egypt asked Dionysius Bishop of Alexandria when he was brought before him why if he whom the Christians Worshipped be God they could not Worship him with the other Gods Many admired the Doctrin and were convinced of the Truth of the Christian Religion who could not free themselves from the Prejudices of their Education they would have been willing to have it taken in among others but could not bring themselves to relinquish all their old Religions for it The Calumnies raised against the Christians had caused the popular Odium and Rage against them but they were Vindicated by (n) Plin. lib. X. Epist 97. Just Mar. Apol. 2. Eus Hist lib. IV. c. 8 9 13. Pliny in an Epistle to Trajan by Serenius Granianu◠Proconsul of Asia in his Epistle to Adrian by Adrian himself in his Rescript by Antoninus Pius in his Epistle to the Common Council or the Community of the Estates of Asia though some ascribe this Epistle to M. Antoninus not to mention his Epistle to the Senate of Rome (o) Just Martyr Dial. Trypho the Jew likewise frees them from the Crimes commonly laid against them and owns the Excellency of their Precepts contained in the Gospel And it is observable that those Crimes which had been wont to be objected against the Christians by their former Adversaries were not mentioned by Julian in Discourses written to oppose them who (p) Epist 49. Fragm Epist p. 305. elsewhere speaks of them in such a manner and so much to their commendation as shews the mighty force of Truth which could extort it from him But the Fear and Shame of Men hindred divers from embracing the Christian Religion who had a truer Notion of Things than to approve of their own (q) Aug. Civit. Dei lib. VI. c. 11. Seneca exposed the Heathen Worship and express'd himself with bitterness against the the Jews but being able to find nothing to blame in the Christian Religion nor daring to commend it for fear of giving Offence to the Heathens he made no mention of it at all These and such as these were the Occasions of the Unbelief of the Jews and Gentiles Though it must be confessed that there is nothing more difficult to be accounted for than the Notions and Actions of Men it is as hard to give an Account how (r) Senec. de Ira. lib. I. c. 25. Plut. in Lycurg Seneca and Plutarch should allow of the Murdering or Starving of poor Infants as they certainly did as why they were not Christians No Phaenomena in Nature can be more variable and uncertain in their Causes than the Opinions and Practices of Men which differ according to their Tempers and Capacities and Circumstances it is sufficient if we can find out any probable Solution and have several to offer which might take place according to several Cases But the Writings of such as opposed the Christian Religion were very slight and frivolous containing a Confession for the most part of the principal Matters of Fact upon which our Faith is established and raising only some weak Cavils which never came up to the main Cause or undertook to disprove the Truth of the Miracles and Prophecies upon which it is founded They could not deny the Miracles upon which our Religion is established and then let any Man judge what Reasons they could have for their Infidelity And indeed the prevaling of the Christian Religion under all manner of Disadvantages as to Humane Means shewed that the Adversaries of it had little to say against it For they must be but poor Arguments which could not dissuade Men from becoming Christians when they must incurr all the Dangers and Sufferings of this World to be so The Books of the first Heathen Writers against the Christian Religion are frequently cited by St. Jerom and St. Austin and other Authors of their Time as commonly known and probably they were extant long after So that their Arguments were baffled and destroyed long before the Books themselves and they had Time and Opportunity enough to do all the Mischief that they were capable of And their Writings are not yet so far lost but that we still know their Principal Arguments which the Christian Writers have not concealed but have given them their full Force and commonly in their own Words Origen was so careful to omit nothing considerable which Celsus had alleged that he was often forced to make Apologies for mentioning the same things over again rather then he would seem to let any things pass which was Material that his Adversary had said without taking Notice of it (s) Ambr. lib. 2. Epist 11. Aug. Epist 43. And some Pieces are preserved entire as the Petition of Symmachus among the Epistles of St. Ambrose and the Epistle of Maximus Madaurensis among those of St. Austin The Arguments of Julian are set down at large by St. Cyril and we Learn from (t) 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Vid. Spanhem in Julian oper Praefat St. Chrisostom that the Books of the Philosophers against the Christian Religion were neglected and despised by the Gentiles themselves and were scarce to be found but among the Christians before the Edict of Theodosius Junior to prohibit them There
was a long Succession of Philosophers and Sophists who made it their business to oppose the Christian Religion The Shool of Platonists which continued at Athens for some Ages would revive or reinforce any Arguments that had been used by their Predecessors in Opposition to Christianity Proclus and Damascius who were of this School lived about the middle of the Sixth Age and the Writings of Damascius were extant (u) Phot. cod CLXXXI CCXLII. LXXVII in Photius's time in the middle of the Ninth Age the History of Eunapius was then likewise extant and is (x) Voss de Graec. Hist said to be preserved at Venice We have the Abridgment of it by Zosimus and a sufficient Specimen of his malicious Invectives in his other Writings And it is probable that these and many other Books of the like nature which are now lost continued much longer than any Accounts which we have now remaining of them mention Of about Thirty Answers (y) Holstein de Vit. Script Porphyt c. 10. which were written to Porphyry by several Authors not one of them is now to be found When the World was satisfied of the insufficieny of his Objections the Answers to his Books were as little regarded as the Books themselves but underwent the same Fate with them The Jews who from the beginning of Christianity before but especially since the Destruction of Jerusalem have in vast Numbers been spread all over the World and have ever been the most implacable Enemies of the Gospel had the greatest Opportunity to detect any falshood in it and have never omitted any Advantage of improving and enforcing the Arguments against it and and therefore would be sure to retain any thing considerable which had been objected by their Fore-Fathers or by the Heathens with whom they conversed The Jews have been a perpetual restless Enemy in all Parts and Ages of the World and nothing material in this Case would escape their Observation But out of the Writings of the Ancient Jews which are still extant many things have been alleged by many Learned Men of our own and other Nations in confirmation of our Religion from the Confession of the Jews themselves The Unbelief therefore both of the Jews and Gentiles of those Ages is no material Objection nor altogether so unaccountable as the Unbelief of too many now who were born among Christians and have had their Education in the Christian Religion The Truth is Example is always the weakest Argument in any Case and can be of no Force or Authority against the clearest rational Evidence CHAP. XXXI That the Confidence of Men of false Religions and their Willingness to suffer for them is no Prejudice to the Authority of the True Religion THE Christian Religion doth infinitely surpass all others in the Number of its Martyrs of both Sexes of every Age and Nation and Rank and Condition Mistaken ignorant Zealots may often have suffered for other Religions but Men of the highest Station and Worth and inferiour to none in the Knowledge and Experience of every thing that the World esteems Excellent have renounced all and upon choice and after a full consideration of the Merits of the Cause have laid down their Lives for the sake of the Gospel Tyrants of the greatest Power and Cruelty have made it their Aim and Ambition by all sorts of Tortures to extirpate the Christian Religion they esteemed their Persecutions matter of Triumph and a fit subject for the (a) Gâ—uter Inscript p. 238 280. Inscriptions of Monuments erected to their Memories But the invincible Patience and glorious Sufferings of the Christians prevailed against all the Rage and Force of their Enemies If the Martyrologies of all Religions were to be compared there would soon appear so manifest a difference between the Christian Martyrs and the Sufferers for other Religions that nothing would be needful to be said upon this subject But remembring with whom I have to deal I am resolved to take every thing at the lowest and argue with them upon their own Terms Let us for a while set aside whatever of this nature might be said in preference of the Christian Martyrs and suppose the Numbers and Zeal of the Martyrs for so we must call them at present of other Religions to have been as great as can be imagined yet the Cause it self makes a plain difference between them An ignorant Zeal in a wrong Cause is no Argument against the Goodness of any Cause which is maintained and promoted by such a Zeal as is reasonable and proceeds upon sure Grounds Indeed it were very hard and very strange if that which is true should be ever the less certain or the less to be regarded and esteemed because there may be other things that are false of which some Men are as firmly persuaded and are as much concerned for them as any one can be for the Truth it self And yet this is the wisest thing that many have to pretend against the certainty of the Religion in which they were Baptised that there are many Impostures in the World and none is without its Zealots to appear in Vindication of it I am confident no Man ever parted with any thing but his Religion upon so weak a Pretence A false Religion is not the only thing for which Men are wont to have an undeserved Value but their Country their Friends and themselves they are commonly as much mistaken in and do as highly overprize Is there then no real difference or solid worth in any of these Some of the most unlikely Countrys in the World have been admired by the Natives as if they were the Garden of Eden and the Place of Paradise Though there is nothing easier than to make a distinction concerning different Countrys And it is as easie to distinguish between the Elysium of the Heathens or Mahomet's Paradise and the Kingdom of Heaven and between the Ways which lead to them There is nothing especially if it be of any Moment and Consequence to them for which Men have not shewn themselves passionately concerned and it is not to be expected that they should be so much more infallible in Religion than in other things or should be so much less in earnest about it as not to discover the same Frailties and the same Affections which are visible in all the other Actions and Business of their Lives It is often seen in most Cases that some are as earnest and zealous in a false Cause as others are in a True but doth this prove that there is no difference between Falshood and Truth When two Men of opposite Parties are equally confident of the Goodness of their Cause it is certain that but one of them can be in the right and it is as certain that one of them must be at least so far in the right as he contradicts the other because as the two Parts of a Contradiction cannot be both True so they cannot be both False If then a confident and zealous