The best Fence against Popery OR A VINDICATION OF THE Power of the KING IN Ecclesiastical Affairs Being an ANSWER to the PAPISTS Objections against the Oath of Supremacy To which is added Queen Elizabeth's Admonition declaring the Sense of the said Oath and King James's Vindication of the Oath of Allegiance By a Learned Divine London Printed for J. Robinson in St. Paul's Church-Yard and S. Crouch in Cornhill THE LAWFULNES OF THE Oath of Supremacy c. THE Supremacy of the Kings of England being eclipsed by the Bishop of Rome in both parts of it the State thought fit to enjoin a Provision of equal extension In relation to the Civil Rights of the Crown is the Oath of Allegiance and against the Encroachments upon the Ecclesiastical this of the Supremacy which being first enjoined containeth in a manner both This Oath hath given the Papists such a Blow as they could not but strike again and have poured out a Flood of Arguments and Absurdities against submitting to it which hath been a long time scattered and stick in the Minds of divers of his Majesty's Loyal Subjects who tho otherwise well affected yet by reason of some Doubts and Tenderness are at a stand to this day and scruple the taking of this Oath For whose satisfaction and clearing the Lawfulness of this Supremacy is the ensuing Discourse CHAP. I. §. 1 The Oath it self as now enjoined §. 2 The Occasion of this Oath §. 3 Various Forms of it and Alterations about it §. 4 Interpretations given of it in our Laws and Writers of Note §. 5 The Nature of our Assent and Stipulation The Oath of Supremacy I A.B. do utterly testify and declare in my Conscience that the King's Highness is the only Supreme Governor of this Realm and of all other his Highness's Dominions and Countries as well in all Spiritual or Ecclesiastical Things or Causes as Temporal And that no Foreign Prince Person Prelate State or Potentate hath or ought to have any Iurisdiction Power Superiority Preeminence or Authority Ecclesiastical or Spiritual within this Realm And therefore I do utterly renounce and forsake all Foreign Iurisdictions Powers Superiorities and Authorities and do promise that from henceforth I shall bear Faith and true Allegiance to the King's Highness his Heirs and lawful Successors and to my power shall assist and defend all Iurisdictions Privileges Preeminences and Authorities granted or belonging to the King's Highness his Heirs and Successors as united and annexed to the Imperial Crown of this Realm §2 For many Years there hath been a Contest about Jurisdiction and Supremacy in Ecclesiastical Matters between the Bishop of Rome and the Kings of England who hath got ground herein according as our Princes were found more weak necessitous or devoted to his Holiness Rome was not built in a Day By William the Conqueror Legates from the Pope to hear and determine Ecclesiastical Causes were admitted Henry the First after much Contest yields to the Pope the Patronages and Donations of Bishopricks and all other Ecclesiastical Benefices it being decreed at Rome that no Lay-Person should give any Ecclesiastical Charge King Stephen grants that Appeals be made to the Court of Rome In Henry the Second's Days the Pope gets the Clergy and Spiritual Persons exempted from Secular Powers The Bishop of Rome is now over all Ecclesiastical Persons and Causes even in these Dominions Supreme Head And having upon the matter made Conquest over more than half the Kingdom in the Times of King John and Henry the Third sets on for the whole and obtains of King John an absolute Surrender of England and Ireland unto his Holiness which were granted back again by him to the King to hold of the Church of Rome in Fee-farm and Vassalage Being now absolute and immediate Lord over all be endeavours to convert the Profits of both Kingdoms to his own Use so that Prince and People were hereby reduced to very great Poverty and Servitude Such Ruine being brought upon both Kingdoms by this Device and Engine the Claim and Exercise of Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction over Persons and Causes by a Foreign Power the Nation was awakened both King Lords and Commons yea the Spiritual Lords themselves to join with more Vigor against this Foreign Usurpation To this purpose severe Laws were made in the Time of Edw. 1st 2d 3d. Richard the 2d and Hen. the 4th Notwithstanding these Laws and some formerly as the Constitutions of Clarendon by Hen. 2. partly by Sufferance and partly by Negligence the whole Nation being Catholick and held under a devotional Slavery there was no thorow or successful Contest against these Oppressions They remained unto and were complained of in Henry the Eighth's Days as of Appeals to Rome in Causes of Matrimony Divorce Tithes c. to the great Inquietation Vexation and Trouble Costs and Charges of the King's Highness and many of his Subjects 24 Hen. 8. cap. 12. In a further Complaint Anno 25 cap. 21. it is declared how that the Subjects of this Realm have been greatly decay'd and impoverished by intolerable Exactions of great Sums of Money claimed and taken out of this Realm by the Bishop of Rome as well in Pensions Censes Peter-Pence Procurations Provisions Delegacies Rescripts in Causes of Contention and Appeals as also for Dispensations Licenses Faculties c. who assumed a Power to dispense with all humane Laws Vses and Customs of all Realms And many the like Complaints were made to King Henry by his Parliament at several times as it appears in the Statutes of that Age In which Statutes as in that of the 24th of Hen. 8. c. 12. 25. c. 21. 26. c. 1 3. Anno 28. c. 1 7 10 16 and 35 c. 1. you have the whole Fabrick of Romish Usurpation laid level and all Ecclesiastical Power reduced within his Majesty's Dominions and placed in the Arch Bishop and other Ecclesiastical Persons under him by firm and severe Laws This being done the King is petitioned by his Lords and Commons That for further Corroboration of those Acts and utterly to exclude the long usurped Power Authority and Jurisdiction of the Bishop of Rome that an OATH containing the Substance and Effect of those Statutes be limited and tendred to his Subjects This Parcel of Sacred Worship an Oath is indulged to Mankind in Civil Affairs Such is the Falseness Unrighteousness and Uncertainty of Men as that human Societies could hardly subsist without it The Lord to repair our Credit hath formed Mens Hearts generally to a great and apparent Religion and Reverence of this Ordinance The Heathens themselves termed it Sacramentum as if the most eminent or only Thing Sacred and religiously to be observed It is so effectual a Means to establish a Reformation as Men will be kept firm by Oaths saith one Liv. Hist tho there were neither Laws nor Magistrates We are exposed to more Variety and Changes from Vnsteadiness in the Mind than from any thing that is without us Fix the
the Pope but a Power or Prerogative justly and rightfully belonging to him claimed and exercised by his Predecessors some hundreds of Years before his Time being anciently annexed to the Crown 2. In the latter part of the Article it is also evident For tho a Power in spiritual Causes be given to a Secular Prince yet it is not a spiritual Power and such a Jurisdiction as the Pope claims but such a Power only and in such a way as is put forth and exercised in ordinary Civil Affairs and the same in respect both to Ecclesiastical and Temporal Persons namely a restraining with the Civil Sword the Stubborn and Evil-doers So to restrain or coerce is an Authority or Jurisdiction peculiar to Civil Magistrates and by Christ himself denied to the highest Ecclesiastical Powers Ye know saith Christ Mat. 20,25,26 the Princes of the Gentiles exercise Dominion over them and they that are great exercise Authority upon them but it shall not be so among you you Apostles and threatens the Use of the Sword in such Persons Mat. 26.52 King James speaking of the Oath of Supremacy ' In that Oath saith he is contained only the King 's absolute Power over all Persons as well Civil as Ecclesiastical excluding all Foreign Powers and Potentates to be Judges within his Dominions ' In his Apol. pag. 76. And more fully afterwards pag. 164. ' It implies saith he a Power to command Obedience to be given to the Word of God by reforming Religion according to his prescribed Will by assisting the spiritual Power by his temporal Sword by Reformation of Corruption by procuring due Obedience to the Church by judging and cutting off all frivolous Questions and Schisms as Constantine did and finally by making a Decorum to be observed in all indifferent Things for that purpose which is the only Intent of our Oath of Supremacy ' My Lord Coke out of 1º Eliz. and in the Words of the Statute gives this Interpretation ' There is saith he no Jurisdiction by this Act affixed to the Crown but was of Right or ought to be by the ancient Laws of this Realm parcel of his Jurisdiction and which lawfully had been or might be exercised within the Realm The End of which Jurisdiction and of all the Proceedings thereupon is that all Things might be in Causes Ecclesiastical to the pleasure of Almighty God Increase of Vertue and the Conservation of the Peace and Unity of the Realm as by divers places of the Act appears And therefore by that Act no pretended Jurisdiction exercised within this Realm being ungodly or repugnant to the ancient Law of the Crown was or could be restored to the Crown according to the ancient Right and Law of the same ' Coke de Jure Ecclesiastico fol. 8. Bishop Bilson a great Searcher into the Doctrine of the Supremacy of Kings gives this as the Sence of the Oath ' The Oath saith he expresseth not Kings Duty to God but ours to them As they must be obeyed when they join with Truth so must they be endured when they fall into Error Which Side soever they take either Obedience to their Wills or Submission to their Swords is their due by God's Law and that is all which our Oath exacteth ' And in a few Lines following he interprets what is meant by Supremacy ' We do not saith he give Princes Power to do what they list in the Matters appertaining to God and his Service Indeed we say the Pope may not depose them nor pull the Crown off their Heads In this only Sence we defend them to be Supreme that is not at liberty to do what they list without regard of Truth or Right but without Superior on Earth ' Dr. Morton against the Pope's Supremacy out of an Epistle of Leo to the Emperor speaking thus You must not be ignorant that your Princely Power is given unto you not only in worldly Regiment but also spiritual for the Preservation of the Church ' As if he had said not only in Cases Temporal but also in Spiritual so far as it belongeth to the outward Preservation not to the personal Administration of them And this is the Substance of our English Oath and further neither do our Kings of England challenge nor Subjects condescend unto ' pag. 26. Mr. Mason in his Vindiciae Ecclesiae Angliae Lib. 3. c. 5. speaking of Calvin's being offended verum si intellexisset nihil aliud sibi voluisse hunc Titulum c. ' Calvin would never have disallowed this Oath if he had understood by the Title of supream Governour in Ecclesiastical Things that nothing else had been claimed but an exclusion of Popish Tyranny and a lawful Power in the King over his Subjects which stands not in coyning new Articles of Faith or Forms of Religion such as were Jeroboam's Calves but in defending and propagating that Faith and Religion of which God in the Scripture is the undoubted Author In this sence and no other that ever we have heard of is the Title of Supream Governour given to and accepted by the King ' §. 5 This Oath hath matters contained in it as you may perceive that are not of one nature and kind the Assent and Stipulation required of us in respect to the several parts of it is likewise various and different As our Creed according to the different nature of the Articles is believed by the different Acts of Faith To what is contained in the former part of the Oath in these Words I do utterly testify and declare in my Conscience that the King's Highness is the only Supream Governour of this Realm c. Herein is required a true real and cordial Assent to and Profession of what is mentioned as also to give this Testimony with such Sincerity of Heart as in the Presence of God To swear positively to any dogmatical Assertion is not required it would be taking the Name of God in vain for if it be a certain and undoubted Truth in it self and to others as are Principles in Reason and Articles of Faith an Oath is vain for it ends no Strife Heb. 9. 2. If doubtful and a question whether true or not though such an Oath puts it out of question that I believe so yet not that it is a Truth My Belief though ever so much evidenced and confirmed doth not make a doubtful matter it self more credible nor is one Man's believing an Assertion any just ground for another Man to believe the same such an Oath is therefore in vain it 's not a fit medium to end such a Controversy 2. It is further said I do utterly renounce and forsake all Forreign Iurisdictions c. This requires not only the Sincerity of my Perswasion and Profession against the Title and Claim of all foraign Powers but upon Oath to forsake that is to abjure we abjure when we swear to quit and forsake To forsake a Power or Jurisdiction is to refuse and not to receive submit or
yield Obedience to any Commands given by it or make any Appeals or Complaints to it 3. That which followeth and wherein the main of this Engagement lieth is in these Words I do promise that from henceforth I shall bear Faith c. and to my Power shall assist all Iurisdictions c. Herein is required a Promissary Oath swearing Allegiance to the King as a Loyal Subject to submit to his Laws as also if there be occasion to my Power to assist and defend him and all Jurisdictions and Priviledges belonging to him Though my Perswasion be ever so right my Resolution ever so sincere at the taking of this Oath that 's not all is required In an Assertory Oath if there be Truth and a right Frame of Heart in time I swear and give my Testimony it sufficeth But a Promissory Oath is not discharged by this that I sincerely intend what I say and promise for I engage to Action and for the time to come I must not only promise but if it be lawful and possible I must act and do accordingly Numb 30.2 If a Man swear an Oath to bind his Soul with a Bond he shall do according to all that proceedeth out of his Mouth CHAP. II. What is meant by Persons and things Spiritual or Ecclesiastical in the proper as also in the vulgar use of these Terms IF this Expression Spiritual be interpreted by the Contradistinct Member Temporal it seems to direct us to understand such matters as concern Eternity for that is the true Opposite to what is temporal 2 Cor. 4.18 The things that are seen are temporal and the things that are not seen are eternal now in strictness of Speech carnal not temporal is the opposite Member to spiritual I could not speak unto you as spiritual Men but as to carnal 1 Cor. 3.1 and 1 Cor. 9. If we have sown unto you spiritual things is it a great matter if we reap your carnal things But this is too narrow and strict a Sense There are matters vulgarly termed Spiritual or Ecclesiastical being such in Name and Title only having nothing of a spiritual Nature in them Such a Distinction of spiritual things you have in a Letter written by Henry the 8th to his Clergy of the Province of York in the Year 1533 who were offended at his Title of being Supream Head of the Church ' Men saith he being here themselves earthly and temporal cannot be Head and Governour to things eternal nor yet spiritual taking this word Spiritual not as in the common Speech abused but as it signifies indeed ' By spiritual things as abused in common Speech he means what is given to all such Persons and Causes as belong to the Spiritual Court and are termed by Civilians causae vel res contentiosae vel judiciales matters of contest inter partes actorem reum and come to be determined by Sentence of the Judg in those Courts By those things that are indeed spiritual is meant res extra judiciales or non contentiosae that is such things as are determined not in a Judicial or Court-way of Tryal by Witnesses Oaths Interpleadings Sentences and the like but in a more deliberate and synodical way having the Word of God for Witness and Judg both in respect of what we do and what we may do in things of this Nature Causes Ecclesiastical saith Dr. Field Field of the Church p. 680. are of two sorts for some are originally and naturally such and some only in that they are referred to the Cognizance of Ecclesiastical Persons as the probat of the Testaments Matrimony c. Those Spiritual Courts being continued and the same Causes tried in them as before when this Jurisdiction was usurped the matters that were then are still vulgarly reputed Spiritual Emperors receiving the Christian Faith honoured the learned and godly Bishops antiently with some Jurisdiction in the cases of Tythes Matrimony Wills and the like which are termed Ecclesiastical or Spiritual not from their own Nature but from the Quality of the Persons who were made Judges of them They being spiritual Men the Causes come to be called spiritual Causes after their Names and Quality that were set over them These Causes growing and increasing in after-times according as spiritual Persons were able by the Popes assistance to rifle from Princes the managing of them require more hands than those to whom first committed namely the Bishops and such as were in holy Orders they therefore took in for Assistants a great number of others as Archdeacons Chancellors Commssiaries Officials c. and these are denominated Spiritual from those Causes and their assistance of Bishops in the managing of them and their Courts Spiritual Courts There are Persons that are truly spiritual The spiritual Man saith Paul judgeth all things 1 Cor. 2.14 and Gal. 6.1 Ye that are spiritual c. That is such as have Grace and Holiness He also that hath spiritual Gifts and in a Gospel-Office or Calling is a spiritual Person 1 Cor. 14.37 a Man of God 2 Tim. 3.17 1 Pet. 2.5 And there are Matters or Causes that are truly spiritual as the Law is spiritual Rom. 7. The Gospel and preaching of it is a sowing of spiritual things 1 Cor. 9. the Worship and Service of God 1 Cor. 12. and 14.12 and all Gifts and Ordinances of Christ are spiritual Yea whatsoever things natural or moral that are helps to the Persons worshipping and by which the Worship it self becomes more orderly and to Edification and in the defect whereof the Name of God is taken in vain and Ordinances of Christ become less acceptable and effectual these Things and Circumstances in some sence may be termed Spiritual or Ecclesiastical Persons and Causes of each sort whether vulgarly or properly termed Spiritual or Ecclesiastical are some way or other under the Magistrates Government The former of these those spiritual Persons and Courts and Causes appertaining to them in the first framing of this Oath were principally if not only intended and aimed at as appeareth in the Statutes before mentioned And indeed the greatest Contention between the Pope and our Princes in all time hath been about Ecclesiastical Matters of that nature being then judged of greatest prejudice in respect both to the Honour and Wealth of this Nation For those matters more truly spiritual and nearly relating to God and his Service the Ignorance of the times was such his Impositions both in Doctrine and Worship though very sinful unsound and superstitious were generally received by Prince and People in this Nation without resisting or complaining There can be no question but these matters being indeed temporal properly belong to the Secular Powers For for the space of three hundred Years this Distinction was not known saith Sir John Davis Sir J. D. in his Reports the Case of Premunire or heard of in the Christian World the Causes of Testaments Matrimony c. termed Ecclesiastical or Spiritual were meerly Civil and
determined by the Civil Laws of the Magistrate And for Persons and Causes Spiritual or Ecclesiastical that are properly and indeed such as first-Table-Duties which contain matters of Faith and Holiness and what conduceth to the eternal Wellfare of Mens Souls an Interest and Duty there is in the Civil Magistrate more suo to give Commands and exercise lawful Jurisdiction about things of that nature And for Persons there is no Man for his Graces so spiritual or in respect of his Gifts and Office so eminent but he is under the Government of the Civil Powers in the Place where he lives as much in all respects as any other Subject CHAP. III. 1. Of Power its rise and original 2. Two sorts of Power in Ecclesiastical or Spiritual Things 3. Their Agreement and 4. Difference of the one from the other §. 1 THere is a difference between Potentia and Potestas Potentia 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Strength Force Robustness Such a Power is found not only in Men particular Persons as Sampson Goliah c. but in other inferior Creatures Potestas 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Jurisdiction Authority Job 40.18 this is peculiar to rational Creatures and as they are a Commonalty and in Society one with another Though Force and Strength as in singular Persons be sufficient for publick Actions yet without Authority we act not lawfully and having Authority if we have not Power and Strength sufficient we cannot act effectually therefore joyned together in a King Dan. 2.37 All Men by Nature are equal yet in the first forming of Man a Capacity is found in him with some remote Disposition to rule and obey as 1. A Sociableness let us make Man in our Image Vs and Our a Trinity in One his Creator Hence in each Man's Constitution a Propension and natural bent to Union This God himself observes It is not good for Man to be alone the Woman is created not only for a Companion but that Men and Women might increase and be multiplied 2. Multitudes of Men if not reduced into Subordination and Order having lost their original Righteousness will be a greater Evil than if each were alone by himself One Man will exalt himself over others and according to that brutish Force and Strength wherein he excelleth rob oppress murther and pillage others 3. Hence a necessity of Republicks and Commonweals that some Rules and Laws may be provided not only for Direction but for Correction if need be 4. Such Laws imply Authority and a Supremacy also in it for such Authority or Jurisdiction only is Legislative Man consists of Soul and Body This Principle of Civility or Sociableness whence Authority hath its Original and Rise is placed primarily in the Soul Society and Republicks are for the moral Good of Mens Souls therefore and not to accommodate the Body only The Powers also that are being ordained of God Rom. 13. who is the Father of Spirits ought to be managed and directed to Matters wherein our Souls and Spirits are concerned The Good and Evil for which these Powers are ordained is not limited to the Body or outward Man The Power of Parents and Masters in the Family it is civil not sacred yet ordained for the bringing up Children and Servants in the Nurture of the Lord. Ephes 6.4 There being a new Creation in and through the Lord Jesus Christ These Persons created of God partake of a Divine Nature and thence the like Propension to Union and a holy Fellowship with those whom Christ hath redeemed out of the World Therefore a special Provision is made by the Lord Jesus for such to joyn together in particular Societies or Churches Himself being appointed by his Father to be their King and Law-giver who hath left them Rules and Laws for managing the Affairs of these spiritual Corporations or Brotherhoods as the Scripture terms them Power also and Authority for putting these Laws in execution is given unto Churches So that there is a twofold Power or Authority to be exercised in Causes and over Persons Ecclesiastical or Spiritual the one placed in the Princes the other in the Churches of Christ 1. The difference betwixt these two Powers 2. The Necessity if the Civil Power in Ecclesiastial Matters notwithstanding Church-Power §. 2 What is common to both and wherein each of these Powers differ from the other shall briefly be shewed 1. They are Powers both a Subordination or Policy in the Church as well as in the Common-weal and an 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or Jurisdiction exercised in each You read of Authority or Jurisdiction not only in Civil Assemblies as Rom. 13. John 19.11 but also in Churches 2 Cor. 10.8 and 13.10 the word is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in both places 2. They are both from God and the Ordinance of God and ought to be submitted to for Conscience sake and are for Encouragement to those that are Good and for Wrath upon him that doth Evil and he that resisteth this Power in either resists the Ordinance of God and they that resist receive to themselves Damnation as the Apostle speaks as well in respect to the one as the other And both being from God they are also both Powers under God that is under his Designment and Limits as also his Direction and Guidance for his Glory as the ultimate and the good of Mankind as the penultimate end of both 3. This Power of Princes is termed spiritual Ratione objecti because it hath to do with Spiritual Persons and Causes In such like a sense and manner of Speech if it had the stamp of vulgar Use the Church-Power may be termed Civil or Temporal because all sorts of Persons and Causes without Difference are under the Power of it That as the secular Power is Custos utriusque Tabulae matters of Holiness and what 's opposite to it Blasphemy Heresy Perjury c. as well as Righteousness so Church-Power is Custos utriusque Tabulae Righteousness and second-Table-Duties and what is opposite as Rebellion Sedition Lying Stealing if any Man that is called a Brother be a Fornicator or a Drunkard or an Extortioner c. In all these and such Cases the Church-Power is applied in an Ecclesiastical or Spiritual way as in a Civil and Secular way the Magistrate deals with what are Duties of the first Table The Powers do mutually further each other and so ordained by God from whom they are both originally as they sweetly comply and agree being kept in their just Bounds each with other as Moses and Aaron David and Nathan Zerubbabel the Son Shealtiel and Joshua the Son of Josedech Jungamus Gladios said the Emperor to his Bishop let us joyn our Forces and purge the Land of Wickedness And our Senators in Parliament speak thus of these Both Authorities and Jurisdictions joyn together and the one helps the other Stat. 20. Hen 8. c. 12. §. 3 Their Differences are in these Particulars 1. Though both have in their respective way to do with
them And if any Person that hath conceived any other Sence of the Form of the said Oath shall accept the same Oath with this Interpretation Sence or Meaning her Majesty is well pleased to accept every such in that behalf as her good and obedient Subjects and shall acquit them of all manner Penalties contained in the said Act against such as shall peremptorily or obstinately refuse to take the same Oath In the fifth Year of her Reign there is by Act of Parliament a Confirmation of this Sence by way of Proviso in these Words The Proviso in the Statute of 5 Eliz. cap. 1. Provided also That the Oath expressed in the said Act made in the said first Year shall be taken and expounded in such Form as is set forth in an Admonition annexed to the Queen's Majesty's Injunctions published in the first Year of her Majesties Reign That is to say to confess and acknowledg in her Majesty her Heirs and Successors none other Authority than that was challenged and lately used by the Noble King Henry the Eighth and King Edward the Sixth as in the said Admonition more plainly may appear There may be a Doubt made about this Interpretation as whether it be not inconsistent with the Words of the Oath it seems to be rather a material Change of them than an Interpretation In the Oath it is All Spiritual or Ecclesiastical Things or Causes in the Interpretation it is All manner of Persons of what Estate either Ecclesiastical or Temporal soever they be The Oath seems to speak of one thing and the Interpretation of another the one of Causes and the other of Persons Ad leges per se requiritur potestas in persinam secundario â—…res 〈◊〉 Suarez 〈…〉 lib. 1. cap. 8. Answ There is no opposition or Inconsistency between these two Persons and Causes The principal Object of a Law is a Person and a Person with respect to his Actions a Person morally considered for a Person physical that is in his Being only and Nature as Man without moving or acting any thing good or evil is not the Object of a Law nor Actions of any kind or sort whatsoever as Actions and in that general Consideration do come under a Law but as they respect Persons and are some way or other the Actions of reasonable Creatures Tho a Law be made to punish the Exod. 21.29 Ox which goreth a Man that he dieth yet it is with respect to Man to let him know how much God is provoked by shedding Man's Blood as Gen. 9.5 1 Cor. 9.9,10 Doth God care for Oxen Doth God in his Law respect the Beast for it self is it not that Man may be instructed and restained Verse 10. He saith it altogether for our sakes The mentioning of Ecclesiastical Causes therefore doth imply Persons and Persons of the same Denomination to whom such Actions are peculiar that is Ecclesiastical Persons 2. And that this latter is an Interpretation of the former will thus appear The Oath in giving a Supremacy in all Spiritual or Ecclesiastical Causes might seem to imply Spiritual Things to be the immediate and proper Object of the Magistrates Power and spiritual Persons only for this because they had to do in spiritual Matters and to infer thence that the Christian Magistrate hath Power in spiritual Administrations as the Word and Sacraments after the same manner as hath the Ministers of Christ who have Power in these Things as the principal and immediate Object of their Function Which this Form af Expression in the Admonition doth clearly take away 1. In asserting that by the Words of the said Oath Kings or Queens of this Realm may not challenge Authority and Power of Ministry of Divine Offices in the Church 2. The mentioning Ecclesiastical Persons and not Spiritual or Ecclesiastical Causes at all implieth that the Persons of Bishops Presbyters and such like are primarily and immediately the Object of this Supreme Power and the Laws made by it upon another Consideration than as Bishops c. namely as being born within these her Majesty's Realms and Dominions and such Persons of what Estate either Ecclesiastical or Temporal soever they be She hath the Sovereignty and Rule over them Spiritual and Ecclesiastical Things are mentioned in the Oath upon a twofold Account 1. Because the Civil Magistrate's Power and Jurisdiction really extends it self to the Duties of both Tables and hath to do with Matters and Causes as well as Persons that are spiritual as hereafter we shall shew but 2. Principally that a Calling or Employment in Church-Affairs whatsoever hath been formerly judged and practised doth no more exempt a Person and his Actings that is a Subject to the Queen upon any other account from her Secular Power than doth a Temporal Calling or Employment in any worldly Affairs There is something of Explication further in the Articles of Religion concluded in the Year 1562. The 37th Article is this The 37th Article professed in the Church of England The Queen's Majesty hath the chief Power in her Realm of England and other her Dominions unto whom the chief Government of all Estates of this Realm whether they be Ecclesiastical or Civil in all Causes doth appertain and is not nor ought to be subject to any Foreign Jurisdiction Where we attribute to the Queen's Majesty the chief Government by which Titles we understand the Minds of some slanderous Folks to be offended we give not to our Prince the ministring either of God's Word or of the Sacraments The which thing the Injunctions also lately set forth by Elizabeth our Queen do most plainly testify But that only Prerogative which we see to have been given always to all Godly Princes in Holy Scriptures by God himself that is that they should rule all Estates and Degrees committed to their Charge by God whether they be Ecclesiastical or Temporal and restrain with the Civil Sword the Stubborn and Evil-doers The Bishop of Rome hath no Jurisdiction in this Realm of England It is mentioned in the Admonition that the Queen 's Ecclesiastical Power is the same that was challenged and used by Henry the Eighth c. Which is supposed by some to be the same that was in the Pope the Person only and not the Power changed so that our Princes are but Secular Popes This Objection was strengthned by the Subtilty of Gardiner Whom Calvin terms Impostor ille in Am. 7.13 abroad and at home by a Sermon preached at Paul's-Cross in the Year 1588 by Dr. Bancroft who calls Queen Elizabeth a petty Pope and tells us her Ecclesiastical Authority is the same which the Pope had formerly This 37th Article removes the Scruple sufficiently 1. In asserting the Authority given to her Majesty to be no other but what we see to have been given to all Godly Princes in holy Scriptures c. And for what Power Henry the Eighth challenged 26 Henry 8. cap. 1. it was no new Jurisdiction wrested from
Pet. 2. Church-Power and Government being spiritual hath all particulars for substance both in respect of Persons and Administrations for matter and manner appointed by Jesus Christ and in all Nations to be the same Civil Power even in Ecclesiastical Matters in many things for substance is left to the Prudence of the State in which it is exercised and in the Forms of it various according to the manner of the Nation As for Instance Inspection into Religious Assemblies visiting and observing their Demeanour receiving Complaints by reason of Wrongs Disorders c. These things may be done by the Civil Magistrate in his own Person or by Persons authorized from him these Persons may be many or but one in a Division these Divisions of larger or less Compass And for the manner of Procedure it 's various as Ecclesiastical Courts differ in their manner of Process from Civil or of a Method or Way of handling Causes different from each be established by Law it is equally warrantable There are particular Directions left by Christ according to which the Officers and Persons more especially entrusted with this Power are designed to and invested in their Places and Charge as Election Ordination c. with Fasting and Prayer The other Powers are setled upon and claimed in such ways as the respective Law of Nations design as by Birth Lot Victory Donation or the like as well as Election insomuch as a Woman or Child may have a rightful Claim to this Supreme Trust and the Management of it by themselves or others as shall be appointed CHAP. IV. §. 1 Of the Necessity and Vsefulness of a Jurisdiction over Persons and in Causes Ecclesiastical besides what is in Churches §. 2 This Power is placed in Kings and such as are the Supreme Governors in a Common-Wealth §1 FOr the second we shall shew how necessary and useful Civil Power is even in Ecclesiastical or Spiritual Matters notwithstanding the other It is not to be denied that Souls were converted and Churches established and kept up when there was no Assistance but rather Opposition from the Princes of the Earth as in the Apostolick and Primitive Times The Benefit we have now by Christian Mgistrates was then more abundantly supplied the Infancy of Christianity requiring more by the Miracles wrought and the constant Direction and Care of Apostolick and extraordinary Persons who were gifted by Christ for that purpose All the ordinary Helps that now we have by external and more sensual or carnal Means contributing any thing to these great Works is only a pious and Christian Magistracy where a Nation is blessed with it The Benefit hereof is much in a spiritual respect both to the World as likewise to the Church 1. It is tho remote a great Help to bring Men out of their natural Condition unto Life and Salvation We are exhorted to pray for Kings and such as are in Authority 1 Tim. 2. The reason v. 4. For God will have all Men to be saved and to come to the knowledg of the Truth As the Knowledg of the Truth is a means to bring a Soul into a saving State so is the Magistrate being enlightned himself a great Means to bring us to the knowledg of the Truth Those Men were in a great Distance from God in a Rage against Christ and Religion Psal 2.1 they did combine against the strict Ways of the Gospel these poor Heathens being notwithstanding given to Christ by Election v. 8. David useth a twofold Method for reducing them The first is a representing their wretched and miserable Condition while in this State of Enmity ver 9. Then 2. deals with their Princes and Rulers to be forthwith instructed and serve the Lord i.e. as Kings and Magistrates in their publick Capacity But must not the People be instructed also Such Magistrates will speedily provide and take care for their People that they may be brought to the knowledg of the Truth and therefore it needs not to be mentioned The Magistratical Power conduceth to this Work divers ways 1. By setting up and protecting a Gospel-Ministry He only can subserve Providence by sending or giving way to others to send forth fit Persons and enforce a Maintenance for their Encouragement in this Worâ—… By such a Woâ—d of Providence it is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 we come to hear and by hearing we believe Rom. 10.17 He can urge his People to come to the Means and outwardly conform to the same and so bring them to the Knowledg of the Truth the very Knowledg whereof tho not saving is a means at least to restrain our inbred Corruption and to work preparatively to Conversion bringing Men into a Condition not far from the Kingdom of Heaven as Christ speaks 2 Pet. 2.20 2. The Civil Magistrate hath Power to punish and reward and so to work upon the Passions of Fear Desire Hope c. Man even in his Natural Estate hath free Will in Moral Actions if it be excited and drawn forth The Passions are so seated betwixt the Will and Senses that outward and sensual Objects work effectually upon it the Motions of the Will in this our State of Corruption depending more upon the visions of what is sensual than what is a rational Good or Evil. The most commanding and stirring Passion and with most â—…fe and vigour in a natural Man is Self or Self-Love it is the first Principle usually that God excites in us towards Conversion as in the Parable of the Prodigal and divers other Scriptures Sickness Poverty and the like Occurrence of Providences Punishments for Sin being sanctified by the Lord work much upon us so Miseries inflicted upon the more obstinate from Magistrates in Justice for evil-doing have the same Operation and by reason hereof gross Corruptions are kept in and restrained whereby the Habits of Sin decrease and become less rank in the Soul Hominem etsi timore poenae fugiat peccatum paulatim affectum animum ad illud amittere è contrario concipere odium â—…tus ideoque etiam vitare peccatum Aâ—iag de Leg. Disp 13. §. 9 It is a hedging our Way with Thorns as the Prophet speaks Hos 2.6 A great part of the World lies without the Pale of the Church and the severity of its Judicature reacheth them not This Power is exercised only on Church-Members 1 Cor. 5.12,13 we have nothing to do to judg them that are without tho they be Fornicators or Covetous or Idolaters or Drunkards or Extortioners Churches in respect of Censures and Punishment leave them to God by the Magistrate or the like Providential way to judg them vers 13. 3. Impedimenta removendo he removes corrupt Teachers that slay Mens Souls by crying Peace prophesying of Wine c. Mich. 2.11 indulging Sinners in their Security and such as by Errors and false Doctrine poyson Mens Souls to their eternal perdition by restaining Stage-Plays not permitting Brothel-Houses and the like Fomenters of Sin Now
Jurisdiction or Compulsion Such persons interpose by way of Intreaty Perswasion Pleading the Cause of the wronged Reproving Threatning or in such way as a single Pastor may deal with any of his people Thus Paul often in a difference between Philemon and Onesimus Philem. vers 10. I beseech thee for Onesimus Phil. 4.2,3 I beseech Evodias and Syntiche It was upon some breach in the Church 1 Cor. 1.10 Now I beseech you Brethren that there be no Division This interposition of the Apostle with the Corinths was upon the desire of the House of Cloe ver 11. There may also be more earnest Pleadings Reasonings Rebukes Hos 2.2 yea openly and before others The Apostles were equal in Authority yet Paul did not only Reason and Plead with Peter but Rebuke and Reprove him publickly and before others Gal. 2.11,14 And in his dealing with Barnabas Pauls spirit did rise higher and yet no Power or Jurisdiction exercised or might be by one Apostle over another Act. 15.39 If Synods be applyed unto only for Counsel and advice in differences and difficult cases it is a provision not to be despised Scripture-light in an instruction or reproof is cogent by what hand soever administred but more especially when in the way of an Ordinance or Appointment of Christ As are Pastors and Synods though intrusted with a Declarative Authority only Let it be consider'd how the greatest reformation made in the Hâ—…s and Lives of men and women is ordinarily by the applicatiâ—…â—f the Word of God in the Ordinance of Preaching which is the instruction Reproofs c. of a single Minister who hath not power to Excommunicate such as despise his Doctrine Faith comes by Hearing not by Discipline Until they be judged believers they are without 1 Cor. 5. If this means or such a Doctrinal Application by a single Minister be sufficient to make such Reformation upon single persons and those that as yet own not Christ or have Conscience of an Ordinance why should we not expect the like fruit where many Ministers are Synodically gathered for the Reformation of whole Churches persons professing to understand and reverence so solemn an Ordinance of Christ though there be no coercive Power intrusted with it to enforce Submission 2. There may be Appeals though not in the same Series but to a Tribunal extrinsecal and not meerly Spiritual as when we appeal to the Civil Magistrate or such as are appointed by him over Ecclesiastical matters For 1. if the King in his Laws and the Church in their Synodical Canons command and forbid one and the same things as is asserted And 2. if the persons commanded stand as much in a Civil Relation to their Prince being Subjects as they do in a spiritual Relation to the Church as Members Doubtless the Christian Magistrate having a Supremacy in Ecclesiastical matters as in Civil and especially being assisted by the Councel and Advice of Synods is a sufficient and â—…ectual means to reform the miscarriages of particular Churches if appealed unto Receptum est in Gallia ab Ecclesiasticis posse provocari ad ad carias supremas Parliamentorum P. Gr. Tholos l. 50. c. 2. §. 36 Ruther Due Right cap. 6. §. 5 pag. 396. The truth is though Churches were threatned or struck with the highest censures being meerly Spiritual and from a National Synod the highest Throne Were it not from foresight that if such Discipline be despised the Magistrates Sword by some Corporal punishment will second it there would be little fear or dread of those Synodical censures And if so as it is apparent to the most in a National or Provincial Church as ordinarily constistituted it is no otherwise Common Reason will direct us rather to go immediatly by Appeals to the Civil Magistrate or his Delegates than in such a compass as to drive the cause from a Consistory to a Classis from thence to a Provincial Synod and after that to a National Assembly and when all this is done there is little to any purpose done if not seconded by a secular arm Hence our learned Brethren formerly admitted no other Appeals of this nature but to the Civil Magistrate as we have fully shewed in the former Digression To which we add what is by that Author further said Cap. 2. If the Brethren or Officers in a Church be perverse and will not hearken to Reason they that are wronged are to crave the assistance of the Civil Magistrate who alone hath Power and who ought by the Civil Sword and Authority procure to all Members of the Church Governors or others freedom from all manifest injuries and wrongs The manner how the Civil Magistrate is to proceed in church-Church-causes is there also described to us in the words following Though the Civil Magistrate cannot absolve the Excommunicate person c. or take away this power from the Church yet when they or any of them shall apparently abuse the same he is bound by the Law of God and by virtue of his Office grounded upon the same to punish them severely for it and to force them by Civil Mulcts to rectify c. THus I have done with that first Consideration upon the account whereof the Vsefulness and Necessity of the Civil Magistrates Ecclesiastical power is affirmed Which is in respect to the well-being of Churches There is another consideration remaining now likewise to be prosecuted shewing the like necessity of this Power in respect and relation to the well-being of the Commonwealth The Knowledge and true Worship of God and the means hereof the word of God is a national gift He hath given his Law to Jacob he hath not dealt so with other Nations Psal 147. It was true then for Israel had this priviledge as a peculiar but now it is otherwise And where the Lord is so bountiful to a Nation thus to give the means of Life and Salvation it is a Depositum Governors must account for The whole Nation becomes peaceable prosperous or otherwise according as the matters of God and his Worship are more or less Religiously attended by the Governors and People thereof This Consideration is urged by Bishop Davenant to this purpose Daven de judu cont ca. 36. p. 91. Regis potestas judiciaria se extendit ad ea omnia sancienda quae rem publicam florentem conservant atque ad ea tollenda c. The Kings Legislative power extends to the establishming of whatsoever may preserve a Commonwealth in a flourishing State and the taking away of all such things as may prejudice or ruine it But the Religious Worship of God is granted of all even of the very Heathens as of concernment to the well-being of the Republick and the neglect of it to the eversion of it The careful and orderly management of Religious affairs being a special means and way to make the Republick prosperous the care whereof lieth upon the Magistrate It is necessary that he both judge of and