proceed but from Heaven or the Elements there is no probability in attributing them to these latter otherwise they would be both Agents and Patients together And besides if the Elements were the Efficient Cause of the Mutations which come to pass in Nature there would be nothing regular by reason of their continual Generation and Corruption Wherefore 't is to the Heavens that it ought to be ascrib'd And as the same Letters put together in the same order make alwayes the same word So as often as the principal Planets meet in the same Aspect and the same Coelestial Configuration the Men that are born under such Constellations are found alike Nor is it material to say though 't is true that the Heavenly Bodies are never twice in the same scituation because if this should happen it would not be Resemblance longer but Identity such as Plato promised in his great Revolution after six and forty thousand years Besides there is no one so like to another but there is alwayes found more difference then conformity The Sixth affirm'd That the same Cause which produceth the likeness of Bodies is also that which rendreth the inclinations of Souls alike seeing the one is the Index of the other Thus we see oftimes the manners of Children so expresly imitate those of their Parents of both Sexes that the same may be more rightfully alledged for an Argument of their Legitimacy then the External Resemblance alone which consists onely in colour and figure This makes it doubtful whether we may attribute that Resemblance to the Formative Virtue Otherwise being connex'd as they are it would be to assign an Immaterial Effect as all the operations of the Rational Soul are to a Material Cause The Seventh ascrib'd it to the sole vigour or weakness of the Formative Virtue which is nothing else but the Spirits inherent in the Geniture and constituting the more pure part of it The rest serving those Spirits for Matter upon which they act for the organizing it and framing a Body thereof Now every Individual proposing to himself to make his like he arrives to his End when the Matter is suted and possess'd with an Active Virtue sufficiently vigorous and then this likeness will be not onely according to the Specifical Nature and the Essence but also according to the Individual Nature and the Accidents which accompany the same This seems perhaps manifest enough in that First Degree of Children to Fathers but the difficulty is not small how a later Son that hath no Features of his Fathers Countenance comes to resemble his Grand-father or Great Grand-father The Cause in my Judgement may be assign'd thus Though the Geniture of the Ancestor was provided with sufficient Spirits to form a Son like himself yet it met with a Feminine Geniture abounding with qualities contrary to its own which infring'd its formative vertue and check'd the Action thereof hindring the Exuberance of its Spirits from attaining to frame such lineaments of the Countenance as Nature intended or else it met with a Matrice out of due temper by some casual cold though otherwise both the Genitures were laudably elaborated For when those Spirits or Formative Virtue become chil'd and num'd they shrink and retire into their mass as he that is cold to his bed and wanting heat in which their Activity consists they remain in a manner buried and without Action in reference to this Resemblance And nevertheless there is left enough to make a Male like to the Father as to the species This Son thus form'd comes to Age to Generate and meeting with a Feminine Geniture proportion'd to his own in vigour and strength and a Matrice proper to receive them those Spirits of his Father which till then lay dormant are awaken'd to Action and concurring from all parts of the Body suddenly impregnate the Geniture of the Immediate Father having by their long residence in the corporeal mass been recruited refined and elaborated And as old Wine surpasseth new in strength and vigour of Spirits because it hath less Phlegme so those Spirits of the Grand-father having digested all the superfluous Phlegm wherewith those of the Father abound are more strong then they and win possession in the Geniture for the forming and organizing of it according to the shape of the Body from whence they first issued The Eighth said That he was very backward to believe that any Thing of our Great Grand-fathers remaineth in us seeing it is doubted upon probable grounds whether there remaineth in our Old Age any thing of our Child-hood and that the Body of Man by the continual deperdition of its Three-fold Substance Spirits Humours and solid parts is like the ship Argo which by the successive addition of new matter was the same and not the same That he conceiv'd not yet how the Geniture can proceed from all the parts seeing Anatomy teacheth us that the Spermatick Veines derive it immediately from the Trunk of the Hollow Vein Vena Cava and the Emulgent and the Arteries from the great Artery Aorta conveying it to be elaborated in the Glandules call'd Prostatae from whence it is set on work by Nature The solid Parts can have no Influence upon it for what humour or juice is brought to them for their nourishment goeth not away naturally but by sweat insensible transpiration and the production of hair The Spirits are too subtle and dissipable to preserve in themselves a Character and imprint the same upon any Subject That Resemblance in my Judgement proceedeth from the natural heat which elaborateth and delineateth the Body of the Geniture and by it the Embryo First with the general Idea of its species and then with the accidents which it hath and which it borroweth from the Matrice from the menstruous blood and the other Circumstances requisite to Generation and when chance pleaseth there is found a likeness to the Father Mother or others Which Circumstances being alike in the Formation of Twinns cause them to resemble one another unless when the Particles of the Geniture which is sufficient for two are of unlike Natures and are unequally sever'd by the natural heat So that for Example the milder and more temperate Particles are shar'd on one side and on the other the more rough and bilious As it hapned in Jacob and Esau the former of whom was of a sweet and the other of a savage humour and then Bodies as different as their Manners One the contrary many resemble one another in Countenance who are nothing at all related as Augustus and that young Man who being ask'd by the Emperour whether his Mother had never been at Rome answer'd No but his Father had And the true and false Martin Guerre who put a Parliament their Wife and all their kinred to a hard task to distinguish them II. Whether Letters ought to be joyned with Armes The Second Hour design'd for treating of the Conjunction of Armes and Letters began with this discourse That Armes seem not
not attribute this impediment of generation to charms and enchantments but rather to the power of the Imagination which is of great moment in this case as we see also in Love or Hatred which though by several ways render a man incapable of this action For if one be sollicited by a woman whom he thinks unhandsome and hates he cannot satisfie her because sadness makes his spirits to retire Another being surpriz'd with the enjoyment of some rare beauty becomes alike impotent because joy dissipates the same spirits The desire of doing well and the fear of failing are also frequently obstacles to it witness the impotence of Ovid Regnier the man mention'd in Petronius the Count spoken of by Montague and many others Now these passions making an impression in the Phancie disturb and hinder it from moving the Appetite and consequently the motive faculties depriving them by this means of their ordinary functions The Third said There are two sorts of Impotence one natural and the other supernatural The first happens two ways either through want of matter which is the geniture and spirits or through defect of emission The former not to mention the parts serving to generation happens through the extinction of virility and that by reason of old age sickness violent exercises aliments or medicaments cold and dry and generally by all causes which dissolve the strength and dissipate the spirits and flatuosities as Rue according to Aristotle The second defect proceeds from the obstruction of the Vessels or from a Resolution or Palsie befalling the foresaid parts That which is supernatural is acknowledg'd according to the Canon by the practise of the Church which ordains the two parties to be unmarried if at the end of three years they cannot undo this Gordian knot in the presence of seven witnesses It is made by Sorceries and charms which indeed have no action of themselves yet when men make use of them the Devil according to a compact either tacite or express acts with them imploying to that end the natural things whereof he hath perfect knowledge and hinders generation in two manners either by disturbing the phancie with some images and species of hatred and aversion or else by suspending the generative faculty by the dissipation of flatuosities retention of spirits and concretion of the geniture Now natural impotence is discern'd from supernatural because the first is alwayes alike towards all sort of persons but the second is onely in reference to some particular Woman the Man being well enough dispos'd for all others But change is to no purpose when the impotence is natural The Fourth said That Ligature is a subverting of the order establish'd in order by which all things are destinated to some particular action and are lead to what is sutable for them 'T is an impediment whereby the actions of agents as it were repress'd and restrain'd and 't is either Physical or Magical The former proceeds from a particular Antipathy between two Agents the stronger whereof by some occult contrary property extinguishes and mortifies the virtue of the weaker Thus Garlick or a Diamond hinder the Loadstone from attracting Iron Oyle keeps Amber from drawing straw and the spirits of the Basilisk fix those of a Man The second of which kind is the tying of the Point is done by Magick which thereunto employes certain words images circles characters rings sounds numbers ointments philtres charmes imprecations sacrifices points and other such diabolical inventions but especially barbarous names without signification yea sometimes to that degree of impiety as to make use of sacred things as the divine appellations prayers and verses taken out of the Holy Scripture which it prophanes in its charmes and fascinations Because as Saint Augustine saith the Devils cannot deceive Christians and therefore cover their poyson with a little honey to the end that the bitterness being disguis'd by the sweetness it may be the more easily swallow'd to their ruine These Magical Ligatures if we may credit those who treat of them are almost infinite For there are some particularly against Thieves restraining them from carrying away any thing out of the house others that hinder Merchants from buying or selling in certain Faires and retain ships in the Port so that they cannot get out to sea either by wind or oars or keep a mill from grinding the fire from burning the water from wetting the Earth from producing fruits and upholding buildings swords and all sorts of weapons and even lightning it self from doing mischief dogs from biting or barking the most swift and savage beasts from stirring or committing hurt and the blood of a wound from flowing Yea if we believe Virgil there are some which draw down the Moon to the Earth and effect other like wonders by means for the most part ridiculous or prophane Which nevertheless I conceive are to be referr'd either to natural causes or to the credulity of those who make use of them or to the illusions of the Devil or to the hidden pleasure of God sometimes permitting such impostures to deceive our senses for the punishing of the over-great curiosity of Men and chastising of the wicked For I see not what power of action there is in a number even or odd a barbarous word pronounc'd lowdly or softly and in a certain order a figure square or triangular and such other things which being onely quantities have not any virtue power or action for these belong onely to Qualities The Fifth said That we ought not to do as the vulgar do who refer almost every thing to supernatural causes If they behold a Tempest or Lightning fall down upon any place they cry the Devil is broke loose As for effects which are attributed to Occult Properties 't is Sorcery as they say to doubt that the same are other then the works of Sorcerers But we must rather imitate true Philosophers who never recurr to Occult Properties but where reasons fail them much less to supernatural causes so long as they can find any in nature how abstruse soever they may be Those of this knot or impotence are of three sorts Some proceed from the want of due Temper as from too great cold or heat either of the whole constitution or of the parts serving to generation For a good Temperature being requisite to this action which is the most perfect of any Animal immoderate heat prejudices the same as much as cold because it dries the Body and instead of producing consumes the Spirits The Second Cause is in the Mind for the Body is of it self immoveable unless it be agitated by the Soul which doth the same office to it that a Piper doth to his instrument which speaks not a jot if he blow not into it Now the Phancy may be carri'd away else where or prepossess'd with fear or some other predominant passion Whence he that imagines himself impotent and becomes so indeed and the first fault serves for a preparatory to the second Hereupon
nothing can be annihilated so nothing can be made of nothing Which was likewise the error of Aristotle who is more intricate then the Stoicks in his explication of the first matter which he desines to be almost nothing True it is they believ'd that every thing really existent was corporeal and that there were but four things incorporeal Time Place Vacuum and the Accident of some thing whence it follows that not onely Souls and God himself but also the Passions Virtues and Vices are Bodies yea Animals since according to their supposition the mind of man is a living animal inasmuch as 't is the cause that we are such but Virtues and Vices say they are nothing else but the mind so dispos'd But because knowledge of sublime things is commonly more pleasant then profitable and that according to them Philosophy is the Physick of the Soul they study chiefly to eradicate their Vices and Passions Nor do they call any wise but him that is free from all fear hope love hatred and such other passions which they term the diseases of the Soul Moreover 't was their Maxime that Virtue was sufficient to Happiness that it consisted in things not in words that the sage is absolute master not onely of his own will but also of all men that the supream good consisted in living according to nature and such other conclusions to which being modifi'd by faith I willingly subscribe although Paradoxes to the vulgar II. Whence comes the diversity of proper names Upon the Second Point 't was said That a name is an artificial voice representing a thing by humane institution who being unable to conceive all things at once distinguish the same by their differences either specifical or individual the former by appellative names and the other by proper as those of Cities Rivers Mountains and particularly those of men who also give the like to Horses Dogs and other domestick creatures Now since conceptions of the Mind which represent things have affinity with them and words with conceptions it follows that words have also affinity with things by the Maxime of Agreement in the same third Therefore the wise to whom alone it belongs to assign names have made them most conformable to the nature of things For example when we pronounce the word Nous we make an attraction inwards On the contrary in pronouncing Vous we make an expulsion outwards The same holds in the voices of Animals and those arising from the sounds of inanimate things But 't is particularly observ'd that proper names have been tokens of good or bad success arriving to the bearers of them whence arose the reasoning of the Nominal Philosophers and the Art of Divination by names call'd Onomatomancy and whence Socrates advises Fathers to give their Children good names whereby they may be excited to Virtue and the Athenians forbad their slaves to take the names of Harmodius and Aristogiton whom they had in reverence Lawyers enjoyn heed to be taken to the name of the accused in whom 't is capital to disguise it and Catholicks affect those of the Law of Grace as Sectaries do those of the old Law the originals whereof were taken from circumstances of the Bodie as from its colour the Romans took those of Albus Niger Nigidius Fulvius Ruffus Flavius we those of white black grey red-man c. from its habit Crassus Macer Macrinus Longus Longinus Curtius we le Gros long tall c From its other accidents the Latines took Caesar Claudius Cocles Varus Naso we le Gouteux gowty le Camus flat-nos'd from Virtues or Vices Tranquillus Severus we hardy bold sharp from Profession Parson Serjeant Marshal and infinite others But chiefly the names of places have been much affected even to this day even since the taking of the name of the family for a sirname And if we cannot find the reason of all names and sirnames 't is because of the confusion of languages and alteration happening therein upon frequent occasions The Fourth said That the cause of names is casual at least in most things as appears by equivocal words and the common observation of worthless persons bearing the most glorious names as amongst us a family whose males are the tallest in France bears the name of Petit. Nor can there be any affinity between a thing and a word either pronounc'd or written and the Rabbins endeavour to find in Hebrew names which if any must be capable of this correspondence in regard of Adam's great knowledge who impos'd them is no less an extravagance then that of matters of Anagrams In brief if Nero signifi'd an execrable Tyrant why was he so good an Emperor the first five years And of that name import any token of a good Prince why was he so execrable in all the rest of his life CONFERENCE LXXXIX I. Of Genii II. Whether the Suicide of the Pagans be justifiable I. Of Genii PLato held three sorts of reasonable natures the Gods in Heaven Men on Earth and a third middle nature between those two whose mansion is from the sphere of the Moon to the Earth he calls them Genii from their being the causes of Generations here below and Daemons from their great knowledge These Genii whom his followers accounted to be subtile bodies and the instruments of Divine Providence are according to them of three sorts Igneous Aereous and Aqueous the first excite to contemplation the second to action the third to pleasure And 't was the belief of all Antiquity that every person had two Genii one good which excited to honesty and virtue as the good Genius of Socrates whom they reckon'd in order of the Igneous and the other bad who incited to evil such as that was which appeard to Brutus and told him he should see him at Philippi Yet none can perceive the assistance of their Genius but onely such whose Souls are calm and free from passions and perturbations of life Whence Avicenna saith that onely Prophets and other holy Personages have found their aid in reference to the knowledge of future things and government of life For my part I think these Genii are nothing else but our reasonable souls whose intellectual and superior part which inclines us to honest good and to virtue is the good Genius and the sensitive inferior part which aims onely to sensible and delightful good is the evil genius which incessantly sollicites us to evil Or if the Genii be any thing without us they are no other then our good and evil Angels constituted the former to guard us the second to make us stand upon our guard Moreover 't was expedient that since inferior bodies receive their motion from the superior so spiritual substances inherent in bodies should be assisted in their operations by superior spirits free from matter as 't is an ordinary thing in Nature for the more perfect to give law to such as are less in the same kind And not onely men but also all other parts of the world have Angels deputed
cannot be known because knowing presupposeth being Formes and Specifical Differences are hidden to us The Matter is so unknown and so little a thing that even Aristotle could not define it saving by what it is not or by Analogy and Proportion to other things But since Proportion cannot be but between two things equally known and the First Matter being not so so much as the Wax to which for Example it is compar'd our Mind cannot comprehend that Analogy The Ninth said That the Elements which he held to be the First Matter are ingenerable and incorruptible Mixt Bodies being nothing else but those Elements united in sundry fashions That this Harmonical Vnion and Symmetry is the form of Mixts which is nothing but a certain Mode or Fashion of Being Whence in all kind of Generation there being no Substantial Mutation but onely a Conjunction and Separation of the Elements there is no other Cause but their Matter Which is thus prov'd to be the First because if there be a second granted then as Brass being the Matter of a Statue that Brass must have another Matter and this is a Third and so to Infinity unless one First be acknowledg'd The Tenth said That if a Material Cause be admitted the Three other must be admitted also For Matter naturally desiring Formes it is alter'd from one into another and that Alteration cannot arise from it self For Nothing is altered by it self but by an other It comes then from some Agent which moves that Matter and which is the Efficient Cause which cannot do any thing in vain but for some End and this is the Final Cause This End is in Natural Things the same with the Form and differs not from it but according to our manner of Understanding For the End of Generation is the Form of the Thing generated and that very Formis the End of Generation Wherefore admitting the Matter the other Three cannot be excluded II. Whence it is that we are zealous for out own Opinions Here they pass'd to the Second Point design'd for this Conference upon which many Opinions of divers Authors were alledged Some attributing the Zeal for our own Judgements to the Antipathy which is found in contrary Humours caus'd by the diversity of Temper and these by the opposition of the Heavenly Bodies Especially when Saturn that obstinate and melancholly Planet is predominant there Others refer'd it to Ambition following the conceit of those who think there is a Heap of Honour in the world to which every one hath his right and of which there is less left to others when some are suffer'd to take a great deal One ascrib'd it to the subtilty of the Mind which seeks to sport it self in new conceits and having produc'd them will not seem to want means to defend them And he observ'd that this Cantharides of Opinastry adheres usually to the goodliest flowers there being otherwise nothing more necessary to the evidencing of Truth then contest in which we propose to our selves to find it After this One explicated that which gave occasion to the Question in this manner Men desire nothing but Good distinguish'd into Honour Profit and Pleasure None of which Three are gotten by obstinacy in an erronious conceit especially when it is known for such But on the contrary there is shame in it one loseth his credit by it many times but alwayes the time and renders himself unacceptable to the hearers as 't is seen in Scholastick Disputes Whence it comes to pass that a Scholar brought up in these wranglings never begins to be esteem'd in company till he has laid aside that ill quality of Never-yielding Whereas on the contrary the more Ingenuous decline those Asperities by words of yieldance even in things wherein they have apparently most of Reason on their side And whon they are mistaken as a metled Horse rather rids himself out of the Plough then stayes there So 't is proper to a strong Mind to betake to a better Sentiment then its own without sticking at the fear which the weaker are possess'd with lest they should be blam'd for having been subject to err either in fact or in right Remembring that 't is incident to Humanity to err but Diabolical to persevere in a fault Hippocrates hath freely told his own St. Augustin hath made a Book purposely of his Retractations and after him Cardan and many other great personages Every one knows this every one commends it rather then Opiniastry but when it comes to the effect very few people practise it Which might be excus'd by the strong Passion for particular interests if Men gave their Opinions in a Matter which concern'd their or their Friend's Estate c. But I account it strange in a Question which imports no benefit at all to any person as in that about the Idea's which we were newly speaking of The next found some scruple in the Thesis for that it seem'd impossible to him for a Man not be concern'd for his Good Now his Good is that his judgement be alwayes esteemed Nor matters it that he may be mistaken in his conceit of that Good for it sufficeth that he judge it such Objects of the Will being to the Understanding as Colours are to Light this doth not give them their Essence of Colour but they hold that from their own Principle but it imparts the being visible or visibility to them So the Understanding gives not to the Objects of the Will that sutableness wherein the Nature of Good consists they have that from their own stock and Nature but it gives them Amability or Appetibility or to speak better the being amiable or desirable For knowing such convenience or sutableness it judgeth the sutable thing amiable So that as soon as 't is judg'd such 't is desired as a Good Now Man judging it a Good to have his Opinion follow'd willeth it as such and as a thing wherein he hath the highest interest For Man as Man hath no Good more Eminent then to Know Judge and give his Sentence of Things 't is his utmost Natural End Moreover Truth which is the Result of that Good is defin'd a Measure Adequateness and Correspondence of our Understanding and the Thing known attributing to it nothing Extrinsical and abstracting from it nothing that is its own Now a Man that hath judg'd and given his advice at least according to his Apprehension seeing that advice rejected falls into a double interest One arising from the charitable inclination which he hath for the good of him that consults him whom he seeth likely to miscarry by not following his advice The other being his own proper interest for that the sleighting his advice is a tacite accusing him of failing in a Thing Essential to his End and calling him a Monster or Fault of Nature For as a Monster is call'd a Fault of Nature because the Agents producing it have slipt and gone awry out of the way which she had prescrib'd and scored out to
follow For in such cases there are instances of great forgetfulness or Folly as Gaza forgot even his own Name It is divided into Deliration Phrensie Melancholy and Madness Though the word Deliration be taken for all sorts of Folly yet it more strictly signifies that which is caus'd by rising of the hot humours and vapours to the Brain and frequently accompanies Fevers and Inflammations of the internal parts Phrensie is an Inflammation of the membranes of the Brain caus'd by the bilious blood or humour usually with a Fever and a languid Pulfe in regard such phrenctick persons are intent upon other things whereby their respiration is less frequent Melancholy both the Ideopathical which is in the Vessels of the Brain and the Sympathetical or Hypochondrical which ariseth from the Liver the Spleen and the Mesentery ariseth from that humour troubling the Brain and by its blackness making the patients sad and timerous or as Averroes will have it by its coldness because Heat emboldens and Cold makes fearful as we see in Women As this humour causeth Prudence and Wisedom when it is in its natural quality so when it is corrupted it produceth Folly there being as little distance between the one and the other as between the string of a Lute stretch'd up to the highest pitch and the same when it is broken Which made Montaigne say That there is but one turn of a peg between Wisedom and Folly If this Melancholy humour be moveable and bilious it will cause imaginations of various absurd things like to those of Dreams Wherefore Aristotle compares the fame to waters in motion which alwayes represent objects ill If it be more fix'd it causeth insuperable Opiniastry As is observ'd in those who phancy themselves Pitchers Cocks Geese Hens Glass Criminals Dead Damned and so in infinitum according to the diversity of Phancies Conditions and Inclinations The Folly of Love is of this kind which hath caus'd desperation and death to many Lastly Mania or Madness is an alienation of the Mind not mingled with fear and sadness as Melancholy is but with boldness and fury caus'd by the igneous and boyling Spirits of the other Choler which possessing the Brain and at times the whole Body by their immoderate heat render Men foolish furious and daring Such a heat that they are insensible of cold in mid Winter though stark naked sometimes so excessive that it degenerates into Lycanthropy rage and many other furious diseases By the induction of all which species of Folly it appears that whence soever the matter which causeth Folly ariseth it makes its impression in the Brain For though the Soul be as much in the heel as the head yet it is improper to place Wisedom in the heel but it may reasonably be assign'd to the Brain Yet to circumscribe it to a certain place excluding any other me-thinks ought no more to be done then to assign some particular corner of a Chamber to an Intelligence of the Nature of which the Soul participates The Third said Melancholy is the cause of Prudence onely by accident hindring by its dryness the too great mobility of the Blood and by its coldness checking the too impetuous sallies of the Spirits but it is by it self the cause of Folly and also of the two other Syncopies Eclipses and Alienations of the Judgement which are observ'd in the Apoplexy and the Epilepsie or Falling-sickness If Melancholy abound in the Brain it either possesses its ventricles or predominates over its temper If it be in the ventricles it either molests them by its malignity and acrimony and causeth the Epilepsie or else it fills them and causeth the Apoplexy For as we put Oyl upon a piece of Wine that is prone to decay and sowre which Oyl being aerious and consequently humid by its subtile and unctuous humidity keeps its particles so united that the Spirits of the Wine cannot penetrate through it and so being cover'd by it they are restrain'd and tarry in the Wine In like manner Melancholy by its tenacious and glutinous viscosity like black shining pitch keeps its particles so conjoyn'd that the Spirit contain'd in the ventricles cannot issue forth into the Nerves to serve for voluntary motion and the functions of sense whence followes their cessation But if the Melancholy Humour presseth the ventricles by its troublesome weight then they retire and by their retiring cause that universal contraction of the Nerves If this Humour prevail over its temper then it causeth deliration or Dotage and that in two manners For if it exceed in dryness which is a quality that admits degrees then by that dryness which is symbolical and a kin to heat it attracts the Spirits to it self as it were to make them revolt from their Prince and to debauch them from their duty employes them to fury and rage and causes madness making them follow its own motions which are wholly opposite to Nature For being cold dry black gloomy an enemy to light society and peace it aims at nothing but what is destructive to Man But if the cold in this humour exceed the dry then it will cause the disease called Melancholly which is pure Folly and makes the timerous trembling sad fools for cold not onely compresseth and incloseth the Spirits in the Brain and stupifies them so as to become unactive but hath also a back blow upon the Heart the reflux of its infection exhaling even to that seat of life and streightning it into it self whereby its Spirits become half mortifi'd Moreover this Humour sometimes piercing through the Brain comes about with a circumference and lodges amongst the Humours of the Eye placing it self before the pupil and the Crystalline under the Tunicles which cover it by which means the Melancholy persons seem to behold dreadful Objects abroad but it is within his Eye that he sees them As for the same reason they who have the beginning of a suffusion imagine that flyes flocks of wool or little hairs because of the Humour contain'd there which if it be Blood they seem red if Choler yellow if Melancholy black But in all the cases hitherto alledg'd me-thinks the Seat of Folly is the same with that of Imagination which is the Brain and not any of the ventricles in particular for since the Intellect acteth upon the phantasmes of the Imagination this upon the report of the Common Sense and this upon the information of the External Senses which are diffus'd throughout all the Brain and each possesseth a part of it the whole Brain must necessarily contribute to Ratiocination II. Whether Women or Men are more inclin'd to Love Upon the Second Point the First said Women are of a more amorous complexion then Men. For the Spirits of Women being more subtile according to Aristotle's Maxime That such as have more tender flesh have more subtile Spirits they are carri'd with more violence to amiable Objects And Love being according to Plato the off-spring of Plenty and Indigence that of Women
before-hand of things to come nor admonish us thereof but by the representation of certain Images which we have some resemblance and agreement with those Accidents These Images are different in all Men according to their several Sympathies and Antipathies Aversions and Complacencies or according to the different beliefs which we have taken up by a strong Imagination or by hear-say that such or such Figures represented in a Dream signifie such or such things For in this case the Soul conjecturing by those impressions which are found in our Temper is constrain'd to represent the same to us by the Images which our Imagination first admitted and apprehended either as unfortunate or lucky and of good Augury But if there be any Dreams which presage to us Accidents purely fortuitous and wholly remote from our Temper Manners and Actions they depend upon another Cause The Sixth said That as during sleep the Animal and inferior part of Man performs its office best concocting the nourishment more succesfully so his superior part being then according as Trismegistus saith more loose and unlinked from the Body acts more perfectly then during the time we are awake For being freed and loosned from the senses and corporeal affections it hath more particular converse with God and Angels and receives from all parts intelligence of things in agitation And according to Anaxagoras all things bear the Image one of another whence if there be any effect in Nature which is known in its cause as a tempest in the Sea a Murder in the Woods a Robbery or other accident upon the High-way the Power which is to be the original thereof sends a Copy and Image of the same into the Soul The Seventh said That he as little believ'd that the Species and Images of things come to the Soul as that the Soul goes forth to seek them during sleep roving and wandring about the world as it is reported of the Soul of Hermotimus the Clazomenian Aristotle indeed saith that there are some subtile natures which seem to have some pre-science of what is to come but I think it surpasseth the reach of the Humane Soul which being unable to know why a Tree produceth rather such a Fruit then another can much less know why those species are determin'd rather to signifie one thing then another The Eighth said He could not commend the superstitious curiosity of those who seek the explication of Dreams since God forbids expresly in the Law to observe them and the Wise-man assures us that they have caus'd many to stumble and fall And why should the things which we fancy in the right have more signification then if we imagin'd them in the day For Example If one dream in the night that he flyes is there any more reason to conjecture from thence that he shall arise to greatness then if the thought of flying had come into his Mind in the day time with which in the dayes of our Fathers an Italian had so ill success having broken his neck by attempting to flie from the top of the Tower De Nesse in this City a fair Example not to mount so high II. Why Men are rather inclin'd to Vice then to Virtue Upon the Second Point it was said That our Inclinations tend rather to Vice then to Virtue because Delight is alwayes concomitant to Vice as Honesty is to Virtue Now Delight being more facile and honesty more laborious therefore we follow rather the former then the latter Moreover the Present hath more power to move our Inclinations because it is nearer then the Future which as yet is nothing Now Delight is accounted as present in a Vicious Action and the reward of Virtue is look'd upon as a far off and in futurity Whence Vice bears a greater stroke with us then Virtue If it be objected that a Virtuous Action hath alwayes its reward inseparable because Virtue is a Recompence to it self I answer that this is not found true but by a reflection and ratiocination of the Mind which hath little correspondence with our gross senses and therefore this recompence which is onely in the Mind doth not gratifie us so much as the pleasures of the Body which have a perfect correspondence with our corporeal senses by whom the same are gusted in their full latitude But why doth Vice seem so agreeable to us being of its own nature so deformed I answer that it was necessary that it should be accompani'd and sweetned with Pleasure otherwise the eschewing of Evil ond the pursuing of Virtue would not have been meritorious because there would have been no difficulty therein Moreover Nature hath been forc'd to season the Actions of Life with Pleasure lest they should become indifferent and neglected by us Now Vice is onely an Excessive or Exorbitant exercising of the Actions of Life which are agreeable to us And Virtues are the Rules and Moderators of the same Actions But why are not we contented with a Mediocrity of those Actions 'T is because Life consists in Action which is the more such when it is extended to the whole length and breadth of its activity and ownes no bounds to restrain its liberty The Second said All would be more inclin'd to Virtue then to Vice were it considerd in it self there being no Man so deprav'd but desires to be virtuous The covetous had rather be virtuous and have wealth then be rich without Virtue But its difficulty the companion of all excellent things is the cause that we decline it And we judge this difficulty the greater for that our Passions carry the natural and laudable inclinations of our Soul to Vice which is much more familiar and facile to them then Virtue Wherefore Aristotle saith all Men admit this General Proposition That Virtue ought to be follow'd But they fail altogether in the particulars of it Besides Man is able to do nothing without the Ministry of his Senses and when in spight of difficulties he raises himself to some Virtuous Action presently the Sensitive Appetite repugnes against it and as many inferior Faculties as he hath they are so many rebellious and mutinous Subjects who refuse to obey the Command of their Sovereign This Intestine Warr was brought upon Man as a punishment for his first sin ever since which Reason which absolutely rul'd over the Sensitive Appetite hath been counter-check'd and mast'red by it The Third said As there are a thousand wayes of straying and erring from the mark and but one and that a strait line to attain it so it is possible to exceed or be deficient in Virtue infinite wayes but there is onely one point to acquire its Mediocrity The Fourth affirmed That the way of Vice being more spacious then that of Virtue yea Evil according to Pythagoras infinite and Good bounded it follows that there are infinitely more Vices then Virtues and therefore is not to be wondered if there be more vicious persons then virtuous The Fifth said We are not to seek the cause of
our vicious inclinations other where then within our selves it being deriv'd from the structure and composition of our Bodies For he who hath not what to eat and wherewith to defend himself from cold or who fears distress finds the seeds of theft in his natural inclination of self-preservation The same Fear makes him become covetous When any thing obstructs the accomplishing of his wishes if he be weak he becomes sad thereupon if strong he falls into Choler This Passion leads him to revenge the height of whose violence is Murther If the enjoyment thereof be free to him the pleasure which he takes therein produceth Luxury and debaucheries and thus 't is with all Vices On the contrary poor Virtue meets with nothing in us but opposition The Stomack the Intestines and all the natural parts revolt against Temperance and Continence The Cholerick Humour fights against Clemency Covetousness inciteth to Injustice the Comparison of our condition with that of our betters to Ambition and Envy with that of our Inferiors to Pride and Disdain In brief Virtue finds nothing in us that makes for her interest which seems to me the reason why it is less familiar to us then Vice The Sixth said No person is either vicious or virtuous of his own nature but he becomes so by Instruction and Custome Instruction is so powerful that it makes even Beasts capable of Discipline Custome is of such influence that it is rightly term'd an other nature Wherefore our being rather vicious then virtuons is not from any natural inclination For on the contrary we have the seeds and sparks of Virtue within us and I almost believe with Plato that when Men become vicious it is by force and against their nature But the fault proceeds from our bad Education and corrupt Customes which become yet worse by the conversation of vicious persons who are very numerous The Seventh said Though we consent more easily to Virtue then to Vice yet the number of the good and virtuous being less then that of the wicked and vicious hath caus'd the contrary to be believ'd The reason whereof is not the difficulty of doing well but because Vices are esteem'd and rewarded instead of being punish'd and Virtue instead of Recompence receives nothing but Contempt So the Exorbitancy of Clothes instead of being punish'd causeth him to be honoured who is unworthy to be so Wherefore if there were a State in which Reward and Punishment were duly dispens'd from the Cradle it would be a rarer thing to see a wicked man there then a black Swan because the good which we love and the evil which we hate would be inseparably joyn'd together the one with Virtue and the other with Vice CONFERENCE XXII I. Of Judiciary Astrology II. Which is least blameable Covetousness or Prodigality I. Of Judiciary Astrology THe weakness of our reasoning is a strong argument to abate the presumption of our being able to judge of the power of the Stars For if we are ignorant of the nature of the least Herb we tread upon we must be more so of that of the Celoestial Bodies which are so remote from us and our knowledge that the greatest masters of this Art dispute still whether every Star be a several world whether they are solid or not what qualities they have and which are the true places Besides the local motion of Animals may wholly frustrate the effect of their influences And if Xanthus hindred the Sun from making his head ake when he walk'd abroad and the Moon doth not chill those that are in the house certainly the effects of less active and remoter Stars may be declin'd by the same wayes since Fire the most active thing in nature doth not burn if the hand be mov'd swiftly over it And what more was to be fear'd by Americus Vesputius Ferdinand Magellan and others who sail'd round the Earth one way whil'st the Heaven turn'd the other Why should we seek in Heaven the Causes of Accidents which befall us if we find them on Earth And why should we look so far for what is so near Is it not more fit to refer the cause of Knowledge to study of Riches and Honour to Birth Merit or Favour of Victory to the dexterity and diligence of the General who cast his contrivance well to surprize his Enemy then to attribute these Events to the Planets If experience be alledg'd to manifest the effect of many Predictions I answer that as the Animal which is said to have made a letter by chance with its Hoof in the dust was no Scribe for all that so though amongst a thousand false predictions one by chance proves true yet is not the Art ever the more certain Yea I will urge it against themselves for it is not credible that we should see so many unfortunate Astrologers if they could fore-see their own infelicity or else they must acknowledge themselves fools since they grant that the Wise-man rules over the Stars The Second said That every thing here below suffers mutation and nothing is able to change it self whence it follows that that which is the cause of Alteration must it self be exempt from the same Whence consequently the Heavens which are the sole Body that suffer no change must be the cause of all mutation For the Elements are the material cause thereof and therefore cannot be the Efficient And as the Stars are the thickest and onely visible part of Heaven so they have most light and influence by which assisted with their motions they communicate their qualities to the Air the Air to the Bodies which it toucheth especially to the humours in Man over which it hath such power that its diversity diversifyes all the complexions of Man-kind Now our Humours model our Manners and these our most particular Actions They may talk that the Wise-man over-rules the Stars but Experience shews that the Stars guide the Will not by compelling it but by inclining it in such a manner that it cannot resist because they subminister to it the means determined to the End whereunto they incline it whence it is as hard yea impossible for it to draw back as for a Drunkard to forbear drinking when he is very thirsty and hath the bottle at his command The Impostures which are affirm'd of the Casters of Nativities can no more prejudice or disparage Judiciary Astrology then Mountebanks do Physick Yea though the state of Heaven be never twice the same yet is it not so in the subjects of all other Disciplines Never were two diseases found altogether alike in Physick nor in Law two Cases alike in all their circumstances yet the Precepts of thse Sciences are nevertheless true because it sufficeth that the principal conditions concur as it is also sufficient that the same principal aspects and situations of the Stars be found in Heaven for the making of Rules in Judiciary Astrology The Third said Every Effect followeth the Nature of its Cause and therefore the Actions and
Inclinations of the Soul cannot be ascrib'd to a corporeal cause such as the Stars are For if all were govern'd by their influences we should see nothing but what were good as being regulated by so good causes I acknowledge but two virtues in the Heavens Motion and Light by which alone and not by any influences of occult qualities they produce corporeal effects Thus ought Aristotle to be understood when he referreth the cause of the continual Generation of Inferior things to the diversity of the Motions of the First Moveable and the Zodiack And Hippocrates when he foretelleth the events of Diseases by the several Houses of the Moon The Fourth said It is impossible to make an Art of predicting by the Celoestial Motions for five reasons besides the dominion which our Will hath over Effects without which it were free 1. The Connexion that is between the Celoestial Bodies and the Sublunary is unknown to Men. 2. The diversity of the Celoestial Motions causeth that the Heaven is never in the same posture as it ought to be for the making of a sure and certain Art grounded upon many repeated Experiments according to which like Effects are to be referr'd to like Causes 3. The extreme rapid and violent turning about of the Heavens doth not afford to find the precise minute of a Nativity for drawing the Theme or Figure of the true state of Heaven which they say is necessary 4. As of sixteen Consonants joyn'd with five Vowels are made words without number so of a thousand and twenty two Stars and more with seven Planets may be made Conjunctions and Combinations to infinity which surpass the comprehension of humane wit there being no Art of things infinite 5. Two persons or more born at the same time under the same Elevation of the Pole and disposition of the Heavens as they speak yea two Twins as Jacob and Esau are found oftentimes different in visage complexion inclination condition and end But is it probable that a hundred Pioneers stifled in the same Mine or ten thousand Men dying at the same battle have one and the same influence The Fifth said God having from all eternlty numbred the hairs of our Heads that is to say foreseen even the least Accidents which ought or may befall Men he hath establish'd an order for them in the Heavens disposing the course aspects and various influences of the Stars to draw out of Nothing those accidents at the time that they are to happen to Men whom they incline to meet the same yet so as to leave it in the power of their Free-will to avoid or expose themselves unto them without any constraint This truth is sufficiently confirm'd by the exact and admirable correspondence which is found between the most signal accidents of our lives and the hour of our Nativities so that Astrologers not onely conjecture by the time of the Nativity what is to come to pass but they also come to the knowledge of the true minute of the Nativity by the time at which accidents arrive and take this course to correct Horoscopes and Figures ill drawn And although long Experience may attest the certainty of this Art yet I confess since the faculties and qualities of the Stars are not perfectly known to us and we cannot alwayes precisely know the disposition of Heaven much less all the combinations of the Stars Astrology in respect of us is very uncertain and difficult but not therefore the less true and admirable in it self It is like a great Book printed in Hebrew Letters without points which is cast aside and sleighted by the ignorant and admir'd by the more intelligent So the Heavens being enamel'd by Gods Hand with Stars and Planets as with bright Characters which by their Combinations figure the various accidents which are to befall Men are never consider'd by the ignorant to dive into their Mysteries but onely by the Learned who themselves many times commit mistakes when they go about to read them because those shining Characters have no other Vowels or rather no other voice but that of God who is the true Intelligence thereof The Sixth said Three sorts of persons err touching the credit which is to be given to Astrological Predictions Some believe them not at all others believe them too little and others too much As for the first since they cannot deny that the Stars are universal causes of sublunary effects that such causes are of different natures and virtues and that their action and virtue is dispens'd by the motion which is successive and known they must of necessity confess that knowing the disposition of sublunary subjects the nature of the Stars and their motion many natural effects may be fore-seen and fore-told from them The Devil himself knows no future things certainly but by foreseeing the effects of particular causes in their universal causes which are the Stars They who believe too little confess that the Stars act upon the Elements and mixt Bodies for very Peasants know thus much besides many particular effects of the Moon But as for Man whose Soul of it self is not dependent upon any natural cause but free and Mistress of its own actions they cannot or for Religion's sake dare not affirm that it is subject to Coelestial Influences at least in reference to manners Yet it is no greater absurdity to say that the Soul is subject to the Stars then to say with Aristotle and Galen that it is subject to the Temperament of the Body which also is caus'd by the Starrs from the influence and action whereof the Soul cannot exempt its Body nor the Temperament thereof by which she acts Lastly they who give too much credit to the Stars hold that all things are guided by a fatal and irrevocable order of Nature contrary to Reason which admits the Author to be the Master of his own work and to Experience which assures us of the standing still of the Sun for Joshuah of his going backward for Hezechiah and of his Eclipse at full Moon during the Passion The Fourth Opinion is certain that there is truth in Astrological Predictions but it behoveth to believe them onely in a due measure since the Science of it self is but conjectural II. Whether is less blameable Avarice or Prodigality Upon the Second Point it was said That Avarice is less blameable then Prodigality For the latter is more fertile in bad actions then the former which though otherwise vicious yet refrains from the pleasures and debaucheries in which the Prodigal usually swims The Holy Scripture intending to set forth an example of Infinite Mercy relates that of the Prodigal Son who obtain'd pardon of the sin which is least worthy of it Moreover Prodigality doth far less good then Covetousness for this always looks at its own profit and takes care for its own benefit and the preservation of its dependents so that it exerciseth at least the first fundamental of Charity which is to do well to those who are nearest
good examples who may innocently follow their inclination because it will lead them only to vertuous or at least indifferent things And for the vicious 't is certain the evil which they do not by reason of the repugnance which they have to it and the fear of punishment cannot be imputed to them for vertue nor consequently make them happy CONFERENCE XXXII I. Sympathie and Antipathy II. Whether Love descending is stronger then ascending I. Of Sympathy and Antipathy WHat a Father once said That the first second and third Point of Christian Philosophy was humility meaning that it all referr'd thereunto the same may be said of Sympathy and Antipathy which is the Similitude or Contrariety of Affections For the generation and corruption of all things is to be referr'd to them The sympathy of the simple qualities and the Elements wherein they are found are causes of the temperament of mixt bodies as the antipathy is of their dissolution 'T is they who unite and dis-unite those compound bodies and by approximating or removing them one from another cause all their motions and actions When these causes are apparent to us and may be probably imputed to qualities we recur to them as the most easie general and common But when we find bodies whose qualities seem alike to us and nevertheless they have very different effects we are then constrain'd to seek the cause thereof elsewhere and finding none we call it an Occult Propriety whose two daughters are Sympathy and Antipathy For Man being a reasonable creature is desirous to know the reason of every thing and when he cannot attain to it he becomes as much tormented as a Judge whose Jurisdiction is retrench'd and this through want of apprehending that what he knows hath no other proportion to what he ignores then finite yea very little hath to infinite And being unable to find the true reason of an infinite number of effects which ravish him with admiration yet resolving to have some one he feigns one under these names of Sympathy and Antipathy those two Hocus Pocus's to which he refers the cause why Corral stays bleeding Amber draws straw the Loadstone Iron which the Theamede rejects why the Star-stone moves in Vinegar the Cole-wort is an enemy to the Vines Garlick a friend to the Rose and Lilly increasing one the others ' odour why a man's fasting-spittle kills the Viper why Eeles drown'd in Wine make the drinker thenceforward hate it why Betony strengthens the Brain Succhory is proper to the Liver Bezoar a friend to the Heart and infinite others But because general causes do not satisfie us no more then Definitions whose Genuses are remote and the Differences common it seems we are oblig'd to a particular inquisition of their causes The Second said The Subjects in which Sympathies and Antipathies are found must be distinguish'd in order to assign their true causes For in things alike we may refer their effects to the similitude of their substances and accidents Thus the Lungs of a Fox are useful to such as are Phthisical the intestine of a Wolf is good for the Colick Eye-bright for the Eye Solomons's-Seal for the Rupture the black decoction of Sena for Melancholy yellow Rhubarb for choler white Agaric for Flegm Yet 't is not requisite that this resemblance be total for then a man's Lungs should rather be serviceable to the Phthisical then that of a Fox and the Load-stone should rather draw a Load-then Iron which yet do's not hold because there 's no action between things perfectly alike Antipathy also arises from the contrariety of Forms their qualities and other accidents Now we are much puzzl'd to assign the causes of this Sympathy and Antipathy in things which have nothing either of likeness or contrariety as when I see two unknown men play at Tennis the one with as good a grace as the other I have a kind of desire that one may rather win then the other Is it not rather chance which causes this Our will though free being always oblig'd to tend this way or that way and cannot chuse the worst or else all things being made by weight number and measure those affect one another most who have the same proportion in their composition or who had the same configuration of heaven at their birth Or every thing naturally affecting to become perfect seeks this perfection in all the subjects which it meets and when the same disposition is found in two several bodies or minds if they would arrive at that perfection by one and the same way this meeting serves for the means of union which is our sympathy and their different disposition or way the contrary The Third amongst sundry examples of Antipathy said That if we believe Apuleius the Look-glassing us'd by an incontinent woman spoils the visage of a chast that it is manifest between the horse and the Camel the Elephant and the Swine the Lyon and the Cock the Bull and the Fig-tree the Adder and a naked man the Ape and the Tortois the Serpent and the shadow of the Ash. For that which is observ'd amongst Animals who devour and serve for food to one another as the Wolf and the Sheep the Kite and the Chicken or amongst those who always offend and hurt one the other as Man and the Serpent deserve rather the name of Enmity whereof the causes are manifest But to speak truth all these effects are no more known to us then their causes are unknown He who endu'd them with Formes having annex'd Proprieties thereunto both the one and the other impenetrable to humane wit The Fourth said That for a lasting order amongst the creatures it was requisite that every one were naturally lead to its own preservation by adhering to what was conducible thereunto and eschewing the contrary Now to do this they needed instruments whereby to act which are their qualities either manifest which proceed from the Temperament and are either First or Second or else occult which proceed from every form and substance to which the Sympathies and Antipathies correspondences and contrarieties of all natural Bodies ought to be referr'd from whence issue some spirits bearing the character and idea of the form from which they flow These spirits being carried through the air just as odours are if their forces and vertues be contrary they destroy one another which is call'd Antipathy If the same be friendly they unite and joyn together the stronger attracting the weaker Hence Iron doth not attract the Load-stone but the Load-stone Iron So when a Wolf sees a man first the man loses his voyce or at least becomes hoarse because venomous spirits issue out the Wolfe's eyes which being contrary to those which issue out of the man inclose the same and by hindring them to flow forth hinder them from forming the voyce But when the man spies the Wolf first his effluvia being foreseen hurt less and have less power upon him because the man encourages himself against them The
said That as health is a Symmetrie and fit proportion of all the humours while they continue in society one with another so a Fever is a discomposure thereof when some one comes to infringe the obedience which it owes to the laws of the Compositum and to usurp a Tyranny over the rest In which case they do as States who apprehend their own ruine by the too great increase of a potent neighbour they unite against it and go to assail it all together Upon this shock the natural heat retires to the Heart which is the centre of the Body as if it call'd its Councel hence proceeds the cold fit of the Fever during which the extreme parts destitute of their ordinary heat fall into trembling shivering and chattering as it comes to pass upon the Earth when the Sun is very remote from it But Nature at length getting the mastery is not contented to return the Blood to the parts who were depriv'd thereof in the same condition that they lent it to her she drives it into them with a new heat acquir'd by the vicinity of the Heart which is the source thereof and augmented by the reciprocation of its motion But as no violent thing is of long continuance this heated Blood causing its sharpest serosities to pass through the skin by sweat becomes asswaged and as water remov'd from off the fire ceases to boyle it no longer extends the Veins nor stimulates the Arteries whether this Crisis perfectly terminates the disease as in Continual Fevers or the Fit onely as in Intermitting which leaving a leven of the Fever how little soever in the humours and an empyreuma or combustion in the parts the best Aliments yea the most laudable humours if any such remain in the Body are as easily turn'd into the matter of the Fever as the best Wine is spoyl'd when it is pour'd upon a corrupted lee in a musty vessel And 't is not so much to be wonder'd that this corruption is made regularly in the time of half a day in Quotidians of one day in Tertians and of two in Quartans as that the Periods of Fevers are sometimes irregular as is seen in Erratical Fevers considering that all generations and corruptions are reciprocal and have their limited time Thus 't is a less wonder that Women are ordinarily deliver'd of Children likely to live in the ninth and seventh moneths then if they were deliver'd so in all the other moneths indifferently which hath place in all other motions of Nature who doth every thing according to number weight and measure II. Of Friendship Upon the Second Point the First said Friendship is a powerfull and streight Union which conjoynes the lover and the loved party together making one whole of these two parts like that bond which in Nature unites the Matter and the Form the Accident and the Substance The cause of it is Goodness which being proportionate to the Body produceth a natural Amity to the Passions an Animal Amity to the Understanding a Rational one to the Laws a Political or Civil to Religion a Divine one This Goodness consisting in a Proportion and Symmetry is not different from Beauty and therefore we apprehend Beauty in good things and goodness and convenience in such as are handsome and gracefull The Second said besides goodness which is the cause of Friendship and towards which our will is as necessarily carry'd as the Intellect is towards Truth and all the Senses towards their proper objects Resemblance and Friendship it self are the causes of Friendship The first is founded upon the Love which we bear to our selves For as we love our selves above any thing else in this world so we love those who resemble us and symbolize with our humours and inclinations Hence it is that one of the most common courses to please is to conform our selves to those by whom we desire to be affected we never contradict their Judgement we have no other Will but theirs we frame our selves to their gestures and actions without excepting those which are imperfect Then Friendship the second means of acquiring Love is no less effectual it being almost impossible not to love them who love us Whence the Ancients feign'd Love to be the most ancient of all the gods intimating that Love hath no other Principle or Origine but Love it self And they who assign'd him a Companion which they styl'd Anteros signifi'd thereby that Friendship cannot last unless it be mutual The Third said That Friendship must be distinguish'd from Love For Love is a Passion of the Concupiscible Appetite arising from the imagination of a sensible good and is found even in brute beasts But friendship is one of the most excellent vertues or rather the fruit of accomplish'd and perfect vertue 't is indeed very rare because it hath place only amongst excellent persons who are very few uniting and making them conspire together in the exercises of vertue But being once establish'd it is very durable inasmuch as its cause and foundation Vertue always remains and may be exercis'd Therefore Seneca pronounces that the friendship which knows an end was never true Some friendships there are indeed the most whose foundation is Profit and Pleasure but they are always imperfect Whence it is that old men and young men are ordinarily accounted incapable of true friendship the former because they scarce regard any thing besides Profit and the latter because their minds are more set upon what is pleasant and agreeable then upon what is honest or vertuous Nor is it ever found amongst wicked persons For 1. a perfect friend must love another as much as himself And although the affection we bear to our selves be not true friendship because this must always have reference to another yet it is the most certain yea the measure of perfect friendship and God hath appointed it as the rule of our love to our Neighbour Now how can he be a perfect friend who doth not love himself How can he agree with another who accords not with himself and how will he do good to another who doth none to himself for a vicious man is his own chiefest enemy whilst he pursues the false and imaginary good in stead of the true vice instead of vertue the shadow for the body and many times he becomes his own murderer by intemperance and other vices He hath always a civil war within himself his Reason is never at peace with his Appetite what one desires the other rejects Consequently he hath never any inward joy but he is greatly displeas'd with being alone and for that reason always seeks the company of those like himself to divert his sad thoughts The Fourth said There is nothing comparable to Friendship which is the salt and seasoning of humane life the presever of societies and the most agreeable and sweetest consolation that persons of vertue and honour can have by help of which a man finds another self to whom he may entrust his most secret
the subtilest sense to wit the Sight The Fifth said That the nobleness of the Touch appears principally in that 't is the most infallible of all the senses as the most honourable persons are accounted most worthy of credit Therefore our Lord being to convince S. Thomas at that time incredulous caus'd him to feel his side and manifest things are call'd palpable because the Touch is the last sense that is deceiv'd Whence they who dream do not frequently find their errour till putting forth their hands to the phantasin they begin to be convinc'd that it is nothing but air The Sixth said That as 't is a common vice to all the Senses to be deceiv'd so that of Touch is not more exempt from it then the rest and the less because it judges of the quality of its objects only by comparison according to the diversity of which one and the same thing diversly affects it and is sometimes apprehended one way sometimes another A man that comes out of a hot Bath shivers in the same air which he accounted warm before he enter'd into the water and when he that learns to dance puts off his leaden soles he thinks his feet lighter then he did before he put them on The Seventh said The Touch is an external sense terrestrial and gross it perceives hot and cold dry and moist heavy and light hard and soft smooth and rough or unequal acide viscous or slippery thick and thin tough and friable or brittle and other such tactile and earthy qualities For as there are five simple Bodies in Nature namely the Heaven and the Elements so each of the five external Senses corresponds to one of them the Sight to Heaven in regard of its transparence and lucidity the other four to the Elements of which the Earth symbolizeth with the Touch because every thing that is felt must have some solidity and consistence which proceeds from the Earth otherwise it could not make it self felt by it self but only by some predominant quality as we feel not the air when it touches us unless it be extreamly cold or hot The Organ of Feeling is inward skin which incompasses the whole body of a creature by reason of its so perfect and equal temperature that it is neither hot nor cold dry moist but equally partakes of all these qualities a requisite condition in the Organs of the senses which must be unprovided of all the qualities whereof they are to judge So the Crystalline humour is without colour the tongue without sapour the nostrils without scent the ears without any sound And the skin is neither hard like the bones nor soft like the flesh but of a temper between both being therefore call'd a Nervous flesh and a fleshy Nerve which skin never so little touch'd feels perfectly which would not come to pass if it were not the Organ of the Touch. 'T is therefore woven of infinite nerves terminated in it and bringing the animal spirits to it which are the efficient causes of the Touch as well as of all the other Senses For what the Philosopher saith That a sensible object apply'd upon the Organ is not perceiv'd must be understood only of the three Senses which are for the convenience of an animal to wit the Sight Hearing and Smelling not of the other two which are for its absolute necessity upon which consideration Nature hath appointed them to judge more neerly exercising these two Senses by a medium internal and inseparable from the Organ II. Of Fortune Upon the second Point it was said Fortune is a cause by accident in things which are done for some end by an Agent that makes use of Reason So 't is fortune when one walking for his health or divertisement finds a Purse but chance hazard or adventure is in things which act for some end without election as brutes mad people and children who are not fortunate or unfortunate unless in hope The difficulty of understanding the nature of Fortune ariseth from the infinite abundance of things which may be causes of things which befall men And as 't is proper to man to admire what he understands not upon the observation of the many strange and unforeseen accidents in the world some say that they come to pass by a fatal destiny necessarily guiding every cause to its effect others that they fall out by chance to which the ancient Philosophers ascrib'd so much that Empedocles accounted the situation of the Elements fortuitous Democritus and Leucippus thought the production of all things was effected by the casual concourse of their atomes flying in the vacuum insomuch that out of a blind superstition they erected Temples and Altars to Fortune For indeed there is nothing divine in Fortune since there is not any cause by it self but may be a cause by accident and consequently Fortune Nor is it the Divine Providence since that which is foreseen cannot be call'd fortuitous But we give the appellation of Fortune to any cause which missing of its proper effect produceth another which it intended not The Second said 'T was the ignorance of men that invented Fortune which hath no other existence but in their imagination For every thing that is hath a certain cause determined to its effect But Fortune and Chance are uncertain and indeterminate therefore not causes And although the proximate cause of every thing be unknown to us yet 't is not the less certain for all that in respect of God who ignores nothing Therefore if there be a fortune in respect of us 't is an effect of our ignorance The Third said We must establish in Nature either Destiny or Fortune The former seems to fasten man to Ixion's wheel which permits him not to do any thing of himself and takes from him the commendation of good and blame of evil rendring him by this means guiltless of whatever he do's and laying all upon universal causes whatever distinction may be made of God's will in general and particular it not being conceivable that two contrary wills can at the same time proceed from the same source The second is more correspondent with the daily events which produce effects whereof no necessary cause can be found Indeed if effects are to be divided according to their causes 't is certain that some are necessary and some contingent whereof the latter being fortuitous cannot be referr'd to any thing but to Fortune Yea of the things which come to pass in the world some always arrive in the same manner as day and night when the Sun rises and sets others fall out ordinarily but not always as that a child is born with five fingers on a hand there being some that have six and others on the contrary arrive very rarely as Monsters But if this variety of causes and effects hath place in natural things 't is found much oftner in humane actions whose constancy is unconstancy it self there being not any whose effect is certain For what man can promise himself
and their duration is their age the second are successive whose duration is time For duration follows the existence of every thing as necessarily as existence follows essence Existence is the term of production Duration is the term of conservation So that to doubt whether there be such a real thing in Nature as Time is to doubt of the duration and existence of every thing although the Scripture should not assure us that God made the day and the night which are parts of time Moreover the contrary reasons prove nothing saving that time is not of the nature of continuous beings but of successive which consists in having no parts really present This Time is defin'd by the Philosopher The Number of Motion according to its prior and posterior parts that is to say by means of time we know how long the motion lasted when it begun and when it ended For being Number may serve for Measure and Measure for number therefore they are both taken for one and the same thing Indeed when a thing is mov'd 't is over some space whose first parts answer to the first parts of motion and the latter parts of the space to the latter parts of the motion and from this succession of the latter parts of the motion to the former ariseth a duration which is time long or short according to the slowness or quickness of this motion And because by means of this duration we number and measure that of motions and of all our actions therefore it is call'd Number or Measure although it be onely a Propriety of Time to serve for a Measure and no ways of its essence The Fourth said That to understand time 't is requisite to understand the motion and two moments one whereof was at the beginning of that motion and the other at the end and then to imagine the middle or distance between those two extreams which middle is Time Therefore man alone being able to make comparison of those two extreams only he of all animals understands and computes time Hence they who wake out of a deep and long sleep think it but a small while since they first lay down to rest because they took no notice of the intermediate motions and think the moment wherein they fell asleep and that wherein they wak'd is but one single moment The same also happens to those who are so intent upon any action or contemplation that they heed not the duration of motions Now not only the motions of the body but those of the mind are measured by time Therefore in the dark he that should perceive no outward motion not even in his own body might yet conceive time by the duration of his soul's actions his thoughts desires and other spiritual motion And as Time is the Measure of Motion so it is likewise of rest since the reason of contraries is the same And consequently motion and rest being the causes of all things time which is their duration is also their universal cause The Fifth said That 't is ordinary to men to attribute the effects whereof they know not the causes to other known causes though indeed they be nothing less so they attribute misfortunes losses death oblivion and such other things to Heaven to Time or to place although they cannot be the causes thereof Hence some certain days have been superstitiously accounted fortunate or unfortunate as by the Persians the third and sixth of August in regard of the losses which they had suffer'd upon those days the first of April by Darius and the Carthaginians because upon the same day he had lost a Battle to Alexander and these were driven out of Sicily by Timoleon who was always observ'd to have had some good fortune upon his birth day Moreover the Genethliacks affirm that the day of Nativity is always discriminated by some remarkable accident for which they alledge the example of Charles V. whose birth day the 24th of February was made remarkable to him by his election to the Empire and the taking of Francis I. before Pavia Such was also that day afterwards solemniz'd in which Philip of Macedon receiv'd his three good tidings But as there is no hour much less day but is signaliz'd by some strange accidents so there is not any but hath been both fortunate and unfortunate As was that of Alexander's birth who saw Diana's Temple at Ephesus burnt by Herostratus and the Persians put wholly to the rout Yet the same Alexander as likewise Attalus Pompey and many others dy'd upon the day of their Nativity so did Augustus upon that of his Inauguration Wherefore 't is no less ridiculous to refer all these accidents to Time then to attribute to it the mutation oblivion and death of all things whereof it is not the cause although for this purpose Saturn was painted with a sickle in his hand with which he hew'd every thing down and devour'd his own children For Time as well as Place being quantities which are no ways active they cannot be the causes of any things The Sixth said Time is diversly taken and distinguish'd according to the diversity of Professions Historians divide it into the four Monarchies of the Medes the Persians the Greeks and the Romans and the States and Empires which have succeeded them The Church into Working-days and Festivals the Lawyers into Terms and Vacations the Naturalists consider them simply as a property of natural body Astronomers as an effect of Heaven Physitians as one of the principal circumstances of Diseases which they divide into most acute acute and chronical or long which exceed 40 days and each of them into their beginning augmentation state and declination as distinguish'd by the common indicatory and critical days II. Whether 't is best to overcome by open force or otherwise Upon the second Point it was said That Force being that which first caus'd obedience and admiration in the world the strongest having ever over-mastered others it cannot enter into comparison with a thing that passes for a Vice and even amongst Women as sleight and and subtlety doth and crafts in any action otherwise glorious greatly diminisheth its lustre So Hercules is more esteem'd for having slain the Nemaean Lion with his club then Lysimachus for having taken away the life of another by dextrously thrusting his hand wrap'd up in a piece of cloth into his open'd throat and so strangling him of which no other reason can be given but that the former kil'd him by his cunning and the other by plain strength Moreover General things are made of Particular duels and single fights are little pictures of battles Now every one knows what difference there is between him that overcomes his Enemy without any foul play and another that makes use of some invention or artisice to get advantage of him For though Duels are justly odious to all good men yet he that hath behav'd himself gallantly therein even when he is overcome gains more Honour then he that by some fraud
have been seen to make good Verses others to discourse learnedly of the sublimest matters some to speak languages and tell things to come Which may naturally proceed from the souls being capable of it self to know every thing the past by help of the memory the present by all the senses and the future by the Understanding and meeting with a brain whose temperature is by disease render'd proper for such actions the same being possible to befall it by such accidents as happens by age which changing the temper of the body is also the cause of the diversity of actions Therefore children cannot perform the functions of the reasonable soul because they are of a hot and moist temper unapt for the actions of the actions of the Understanding as on the contrary very fit for the actions of the vegetative and sensitive soul. So that if men were born cold and dry they would come into the world perfectly wise and judicious but because they acquire this temperature of brain only with time therefore they are not knowing but with time II. Whether the Husband and Wife should be of the same humor Upon the second Point it was said That it might be handled either physically or morally If it be demanded upon the former principles whether the Husband and Wife should be of the same temper 't is answer'd that as Nature hath distinguish'd the Sex so she hath assign'd to either its peculiar temperament if a woman which should be cold and moist be hot and dry she is unapt for generation as the husband also is when being ill qualifi'd with hot and dry he falls within the Law de Frigidis But if it be question'd morally whether conformity of manners be more requisite to Matrimony then their diversity and difference then since diversity of actions is necessary in a family the office of the husband being other then that of the wife it seems they ought to be as different in manners as they are in the temper which produces such manners and these the inclinations and actions The Second said Those Philosophers who held that the Male and Female were each but one part of man which name is common to both would have concluded for resemblance of humours and manners for they said that either sought his other half till they found it Which made the friendships so boasted of in pass'd ages and so rare in this and likewise marriages of which they that take more notice find that but few married couples have no resemblance even in their countenance Moreover marriages being made in heaven and the most considerable accidents of life the same influence which makes the marriage of the husband must also make that of the wife and if all actions here below borrow their force from the heavens as Astrologers hold the husband and wife having the same universal cause of so great and notable a change whereon depends almost all the welfare and misery of either cannot but resemble one another And therefore those who resemble one another most will agree best with their universal cause and consequently the Stars will find less resistance to produce their effects upon them and so they will live more sweetly then if by contrariety of manners they should do as the Traveller at sea who walks in the ship contrary to its course or who attempts to sail against wind and tyde or rather like those that draw several ways whereby the cord is sooner broken then any advancement made of the load so during this contrariety of manners nothing can go forward in the management of domestick affairs Hence the Proverb that we must eat many a bushel of Salt with a man before we chuse him for a friend is interpreted that by semblance of food a similitude of manners with him must be acquir'd which if requisite between two friends how much more between two married persons who ought not to have greater friends then they are one to the other being in society of all the goods and all the evils of this life Imagine one of a pleasant the other of a melancholy humour one loving company the other solitude the opposition of these contrary inclinations will render the presence of the one as insupportable to the other as Musick and Dancing are displeasing to a sad man or tedious complaints for one dead are to him that is dispos'd to mirth For by this disproportion the mind receives a check which is very disagreeable to it If one be young and the other old one handsome the other deformed one of an amorous complexion and the other not the mischiefs which follow thereupon are too common to be enumerated If one be nimble and the other slow the actions of the one will displease the other whereas that which pleases being or appearing good and nothing next our selves being so acceptable to us as what resembles us two persons who shall agree to do something or not to do it shall have peace and tranquillity of mind The Third said That in Oeconomy as well as Policy there ought to be a harmony which consists in diversity and not in unisonance or identity which is every where disagreeable and dull This made Aristotle desire that the man were at least ten years elder then the woman the disparity of age causing that of humours and this makes the difference which is found between individuals one of the greatest wonders of the world Therefore the husband and wife ought to be unlike in their manners and actions to the end either may keep their station the one above the other below one command the other obey Moreover the husband and wife that always agreed would have no matter to talk of Be the man a great talker and the woman too the house will be always full of noise on the contrary the silence of the one will give place to the other's talkativeness and excuse it If both be knowing or skilful they will not esteem one another but if one admire the other there will be greater love between them If both be prodigal they will quickly see the bottom of the bag whereas the thriftiness of the one will make amends for the expensiveness of the other If one be sad the other being pleasant will divert him if not they will both fall into the excess either of sadness or joy If one be prophane the party that is devout will convert him by good example In brief if one be severe 't is good that the other be gentle if one be passionate that the other be patient otherwise the house will be always in an uproar The Fourth said If Justinian or rather his Wife Theodora had not abolish'd the laudable custom of divorcing wives introduc'd by Spurius Carrilius to abate their pride and malice or at least if the wives of these times were of the humour of those Roman women who having displeas'd their husbands ask'd them pardon in the Temple of a Goddess call'd for that reason Viriplaca it would not
of the radical moisture of plants and animals For they alone are capable of dying as they are of living what they attribute to Fire the Load-stone and some other inanimates being purely Metaphorical Violent death is produc'd either by internal causes as diseases or by external 'T is caus'd by destroying the harmony of the parts and humours which constituted life after which destruction the Soul not finding the organs longer meet for exercising its functions as Fire that wants unctuous and combustible humidity forsakes its matter to retire into its own sphere And though the corruption of one be the generation of another there being no matter but hath alwayes some form as Bees are generated out of dead Oxen yet there is this distinction that the progress of a form less noble to one that is more is call'd generation or life as when an Egg is made a chick but when this progress is made from a more noble form to a less as from a man to a carcase then 't is call'd Corruption and Death if the form preceding were vital Thus all are wayes of Death which lead to corruption The first of these wayes is life for nothing comes under its Laws but is subject to those of Death considering the wayes that we dye as we are borne and that our end depends on our original as there is no harmony but must end in discord the latter note not being capable to accord with the first rest which is the end or death of harmony whereunto our life is not onely compar'd but may be fitly defin'd by it that Galen enlightned by Reason alone conceiv'd the Soul to be nothing else The Third said That onely in the death of men there is a separation of the Soul from the Body seeing that after the death of animals and plants there still remain faculties in their bodies which cannot depend on the sole mistion of the Elements but must be referr'd to some internal principle which can be no other then their Soul Yet with this difference that as during life these faculties were as formes in their matter so after death they are as substances in their place though without any activity for want of necessary dispositions which return afterwards by generation or the action of the celestial bodies producing wormes and other animals which come of themselves and never but from a nature formerly animated not receiving by this new generation any substantial form but onely making the Soul appear which was kept as 't were buried before this resuscitation Thus the death of plants and beasts is the privation of their vegetative and sensitive actions the principle of those actions alwayes remaining But that of men besides this privation of their actions causes the dissolution of the Soul from the Body which is properly death The inevitable necessity whereof is by Avicenna deriv'd from four chief causes I. From the Air which alters and dryes us II. From our own heat which by accident destroyes it self III. The continual motion of our bodies furthers the dissipation of that heat IV. The various Inclination of the Elements some of which are carry'd upwards others downwards and so break the union which preserves our life Albert the Great assignes a fifth cause namely the contrariety of forms and qualities death happening when humidity hath given place to drynesse But because this excesse of drynesse might be corrected by its contrary therefore the Moderns lay the fault upon the radical moisture Which some of them say we receive from our Parents and is continually impair'd without being at all recruited from the birth But this is absurd for then the Son must have infinitely lesse then his Father because he receives but a very small portion which besides cannot be distributed through a great body nor afford supply to so many actions Others more probably affirm that the Humidum which is repair'd is not of the same purity with that which we derive from the principles of our birth by reason of reaction and its being continually alter'd by our heat But that which indubitates this reason is that the Elements do not maintain themselves but by reaction notwithstanding which they cease not to be alwayes in the same state Fire as hot Air as moist as ever it was Inasmuch as the substantial forms expell all Qualities which are not suitable to themselves and recover their natural ones without other assistance Moreover when old men beget children they communicate to them an excellent radical humidity otherwise there would be no generation and consequently they can do as well for themselves as for their posterity But if they give them such as is bad and corrupt it follows that their children who live after their death re-produce much better by their nutrition then that which they had receiv'd and consequently the radical humidity may not onely be repair'd but meliorated And there 's no reason why an exact course of dyet may not keep a man from dying as the Chymists promise I had therefore rather say that as the union of the Soul with the Body is unknown to humane wit so is their disunion which I ascribe rather to the pleasure of the supreme Ruler who causes us to abide sentinel as long as he thinks meet then to any natural thing which is the reason why those that deprive themselves of life are justly punish'd because they dispose of what is not their own although it seemes to the vulgar that they do wrong to none but themselves because 't is by their own will and act The Fourth said What is compos'd of contraries between which there is continual action necessarily receives sundry changes and alterations in its being which by degrees bring it to a total corruption This is conspicuously seen in the life of man the ages and all other mutations whereof are as so many steps towards death 'T is the most worthy employment of a man to consider that he dyes every day For as Seneca saith that which deceives us is that we consider death as afar off whereas a great part of it is already pass'd for it already possesses all the time that we have been which is the cause that instead of employing our time profitably we consume a great part of it in doing nothing a greater part in doing ill and all in doing other things then ought to be which proceeds from not thinking often enough upon death as which no Preacher is so powerful For the fear it imprints in the soul vertue it self cannot wholly eradicate the sole aspect of the shades of the dead or their voices imprinting paleness upon the countenance of the most resolute Therefore the Philosopher holds that the fear of death is not only competible with courage but that he who fears it not at all rather deserves the name of mad then valiant The Fifth said That they who have had recourse to death to deliver themselves from their miseries as Brutus Cato his daughter Portia and some others have
And as gesture is more expressive then words so á contempt signifi'd by it touches more to the quick then any other because he that contemns us with a simple gesture accounts us unworthy of all the rest Now if this contempt be offer'd in the presence of those that honour us or by whom we desire to be valu'd and admir'd it excites our choler the more if it be truth which always displeases us when it tells our defects especially by the mouth of our enemy But none are so soon provok'd as they that are desirous of some good For then the least things incense because desire being of an absent good cannot subsist with the least present evil the object of anger because of their contrariety importuning the actions of the soul which is troubled in the pursute of good by the presence of evil Whence saith Aristotle there needs but a small matter to anger Lovers sick people indigent those that miscarry in their affairs and are excruciated with hunger or thirst 'T is therefore an error to say that choler is the cause of anger and 't is vain to purge this humour in order to remedy this passion since the cause is external not internal and is form'd first in the brain by the imagination of an injury receiv'd after which the Soul desirous of revenge stirs the motive power this the blood and spirits which cause all the disorders observ'd in angry persons The Fourth said That disorders caus'd by Anger are not to be wonder'd at since 't is compos'd of the most unruly passions love hatred grief pleasure hope and boldnesse For the source of anger is self-love we hate him that doth the injury we are troubled at the offence and receive contentment in the hope of being reveng'd and this hope gives boldnesse Now Anger is one of the most deform'd and monstrous passions so violent that it enervates not onely the contractive motion of the Heart by dilating it too much and sending forth the blood and spirits which cause an extraordinary heat and force in all the members and sometimes a Fever but also that of dilation by shutting it too much in case the grief for the evil present be great and there be hopes of revenging it The Countenance looks pale afterwards red the Eye sparkles the Voice trembles the Pulse beats with violence the Hair becomes stiff the Mouth foams the Teeth clash the Hand cannot hold the Mind is no longer in its own power but is besides it self for some time Anger not differing from Rage but in duration Which made a Philosopher tell his servant That he would chastise him were he not in Anger And the Emperor Theodosius commanded his Officers never to execute any by his command till after three dayes and the Philosophers Xenodorus to counsel Augustus not to execute any thing when he found himself in choler till after he had repeated softly the twenty four letters of the Greek Alphabet The truth is if this passion be not repress'd it transports a man so out of himself that he is incens'd not against men onely but even against beasts plants and inanimate things such was Ctesiphon who in great fury fell to kicking with a mule and Xerxes who scourg'd the Sea Yea it reduces men to such brutality that they fear not to lose themselves for ever so they may but be reveng'd of those that have offended them as Porphyrie and Tertullian did the former renouncing Christianity and the other embracing Montanus's Heresie to revenge themselves of some wrong which they conceiv'd they had receiv'd from the Catholicks And our damnable Duels caus'd by this passion have oftentimes to satisfie the revenge of one destroy'd two Body and Soul CONFERENCE LXIX I. Of Life II. Of Fasting I. Of Life THe more common a thing is the more difficult it is to speak well of it witnesse sensible objects the nature whereof is much in the dark to us although they alwayes present themselves to our senses Thus nothing is more easie then to discern what is alive from what is not and yet nothing is more difficult then to explicate the nature of Life well because 't is the union of a most perfect form with its matter into which the mind of man sees not a jot even that of accidents with their subject being unknown although it be not so difficult to conceive as the first Some have thought that the form which gives life is not substantial but onely accidental because all except the rational arise from the Elementary Qualities and accidents can produce nothing but accidents But they are mistaken since whereas nothing acts beyond its strength if those forms were accidents they could not be the causes of such marvellous and different effects as to make the fruits of the Vine Fig-tree c. and blood in Animals to attract retain concoct expell and exercise all the functions of the Soul which cannot proceed from heat alone or any other material quality Besides if the forms of animated bodies were accidents it will follow that substance which is compounded of Form as well as of Matter is made of accidents and consequently of that which is not substance contrary to the receiv'd Axiom Therefore Vital Forms are substances though incomplete whose original is Heaven the Author of Life and all sublunary actions The Second said That the Soul being the principle of Life according to the three sorts of Souls there are three sorts of Life namely the Vegetative Sensitive and Rational differing according to several sublimations of the matter For the actions of attracting and assimilating food and the others belonging to Plants being above those of stones and other inanimate things argue in them a principle of those actions which is the Vegetative Soul Those of moving perceiving imagining and remembring yet nobler then the former flow from the Sensitive Soul But because the actions of the Intellect and the Will are not onely above the matter but are not so much as in the matter as those of Plants and Animals being immanent and preserv'd by the same powers that produc'd them they acknowledge for their principle a form more noble then the rest which is the Rational Soul the life of which is more perfect And as the Plantal Life is the first and commonest so it gives the most infallible vital tokens which are nutrition growth and generation Now that all three be in all living bodies For Mushrooms live but propagate not as some things propagate yet are not alive so bulls blood buried in a dung-hill produces worms others are nourish'd but grow not as most Animals when they have attain'd their just stature yea not every thing that lives is nourish'd for House-leek continues a whole year in its verdure and vivacity being hung at the seeling Nor dos every thing grow alike for we see Dodder which resembles Epithymum clinging to a bunch of grapes or other fruit hanging in the Air grows prodigiously without drawing any nourishment from it
a good while And whereas the air kills fishes when they are long expos'd to it it cannot serve for the support of their natural heat which is very small Wherefore they respire with water which is more natural and familiar to them causing the same effects in them that the air doth in land-animals The Second said As the aliments ought to be sutable to the parts of the body which they nourish the soft and spungy Lungs attracting the thin bilious blood the spleen the gross and melancholy so the spirits of the animal must be repair'd by others proportionate thereunto and of sutable matter for recruiting the continual loss of that spiritual substance the seat of the natural heat and radical moisture Wherefore animals which have aqueous spirits as fishes repair the same by water which they respire by the mouth the purest part of which water is turn'd into their spirits and the more gross omitted by their gills But land-animals whose spirits are aerious and more subtile and whose heat is more sensible have need of air to serve for sutable matter to such spirits for which end nature ha's given them Lungs Yet with this difference that as some fish attract a more subtile and tenuious water to wit that of Rivers and some again a more gross as those which live in Lakes and Mud So according as animals have different spirits some breathe a thin air as Birds others more gross as Men and most Beasts others an air almost terrestrial and material as Moles and amongst those which have only transpiration flyes attract a thin air and Worms a thick The Second said That our natural heat being celestial and divine may indeed be refresh'd by the air but not fed and supported as the parts of our body are by solid and liquid food For food must be in some manner like the thing nourish'd because 't is to be converted into its substance Now there 's no proportion between the gross and impure air which we breathe and that celestial and incorporeal substance Nor can nutrition be effected unless the part to be nourish'd retain the aliment for some time to prepare and assimilate it but on the contrary the air attracted by respiration is expell'd as soon as it hath acquir'd heat within and is become unprofitable to refresh and cool This respiration is an action purely animal and voluntary since 't is in our power to encrease diminish or wholly interrupt it as appears by Licinius Macer and Coma who by the report of Valerius Maximus kill'd themselves by holding their breath The Fourth said That Respiration being absolutely necessary to life is not subject to the command of the will but is regulated by nature because it doth its actions better then all humane deliberations Nor is it ever weary as the animal faculty is whose action is not continual as this of respiration is even during sleep which is the cessation of all animal actions and wherein there is no election or apprehension of objects a necessary condition to animal actions yea in the lethargy apoplexie and other symptoms wherein the brain being hurt the animal actions are interrupted yet respiration always remains unprejudic'd The Fifth said That respiration is neither purely natural as concoction and distribution of the blood are nor yet simply animal as speaking and walking are but partly animal partly natural as the retaining or letting go of urine is 'T is natural in regard of its end and absolute necessity and its being instituted for the vital faculty of the heart which is purely natural animal and voluntary inasmuch as 't is perform'd by means of 65 intercostal muscles the organs of voluntary motion whereby it may be made faster or slower II. Whether there be any certainty in humane Sciences Upon the second Point 't was said That all our knowledge seems to be false First on the part of the object there being but one true of it self namely God whom we know not and cannot know because to know adaequately is to comprehend and to comprehend is to contain and the thing contain'd must be less then that which contains it To know a thing inadaequately is not to know it Secondly on the part of our Intellect which must be made like to what it knows or rather turn'd into its nature whence he that thinks of a serious thing becomes serious himself he that conceives some ridiculous thing laughs without design and all the longings of Child-bearing-women end where they begun But 't is impossible for us to become perfectly like to what we would know Thirdly this impossibility proceeds from our manner of knowing which being by some inference or consequence from what is already known we can never know any thing because we know nothing at all when we come into the world And should we acquire any knowledge it would be only by our internal and external senses Both both are fallacious and consequently cannot afford certain knowledge For as for the external the eye which seems the surest of all the senses apprehends things at distance to be less then they really are a straight stick in the water to be crooked the Moon to be of the bigness of a Cheese though 't is neer that of the Earth the Sun greater at rising and setting then at noon the Shore to move and the Ship to stand still square things to be round at distance an erect Pillar to be less at the top Nor is the hearing less subject to mistake as the Echo and a Trumpet sounded in a valley makes the sound seem before us when 't is far behind us Pronuntiation alters the sense of words besides that both these senses are erroneous in the time of their perception as is seen in felling of woods and thunder The Smell and Taste yea the Touch it self how gross soever it be are deceiv'd every day in sound persons as well as in sick and what do our drinkers in rubbing their palates with Salt and Spice but wittingly beguile it grating the skin thereof that so the wine may punge it more sensibly But the great fallacy is in the operation of the inward Senses For the Phancy oftentimes is perswaded that it hears and sees what it doth not and our reasoning is so weak that in many disciplines scarce one Demonstration is found though this alone produceth Science Wherefore 't was Democritus's opinion that Truth is hidden in a well that she may not be found by men The Second said That to know is to understand the cause whereby a thing is and to be certain that there can be no other but that the word cause being taken for principle Therefore when men know by the Senses by effects by external accidents or such other things which are not the cause they cannot be said to know by Science which requires that the understanding be fully satisfi'd in its knowledge wherein if there be any doubt it hath not Science but Opinion This scientifical knowledge is found in
crowned Or. Holland Or a Lyon gules Bavaria fuselé argent and azure of twenty one pieces placed bendwise Ireland gules a Harp Or. CONFERENCE XCVIII I. Of the causes of Contagion II. Of the ways of occult Writing I. Of the causes of Contagion DIseases being accidents must be divided as other accidents by their first subjects which are the solid parts the humours and the spirits and by their several causes some of which are manifest others unknown the malignity of the causes which produce them and the manner whereby they act being inexplicable Which diversity of causes depends upon those of mixtions which are of two sorts one of the qualities of the elements which makes the difference of temperaments the other of the elementary forms which being contrary only upon the account of their qualities when these put off their contrariety by alteration the forms easily become united and as amongst qualities so amongst forms one becomes predominant the actions whereof are said to proceed from an occult property because the form which produces them is unknown to us So Arsenick and Hemlock besides the power which the first hath to heat and the second to refrigerate have a particular virtue of assaulting the heart and killing speedily by a property hitherto unknown Such also are contagious and venomous diseases some whereof are caus'd by the inspir'd air as the Pestilence because air being absolutely necessary to the support of our natural heat if when it is infected with malignant and mortal vapours it be attracted by the mouth or the pores of the skin it corrupts the mass of the spirits as a crum of bread or other extraneous bodies makes milk or wine become sowre Others infect by bodily contact as the Itch the Pox the Measles and the Leprosie A third sort proceed from a venomous matter either communicated outwardly as by poyson and the biting of venomous beasts or generated in the body as it may happen to the blood black choler and the other humours being extravasated The Second said That diseases proceed either from the corruption and vitiosity of particular bodies some of which are dispos'd to the Pleurisie others to the Flux others to the Colick call'd therefore sporadical or dispers'd and promiscuous diseases or else from some common vitiosity as of the air aliments waters winds or other such common cause whereby many come to be seiz'd upon by the same disease at the same time so after Famines bad nourishment gives a great disposition to the Pestilence These maladies are fix'd to a certain Country seldom extending beyond it as the Leprosie to the Jews the Kings Evil to the Spaniards Burstenness to Narbon the Colick to Poitou the Phthisick to the Portugals the Pox to the Indians call'd by them Apua and brought by the Spaniards into Europe and such other diseases familiar to some particular Country and call'd Endemial Or else they are Epidemical and not ty'd to a certain region but produc'd by other external causes as pestilential and contagious diseases which again are either extraordinary as the Sweating-sickness of England the Coqueluche which was a sort of destillation or ordinary which manifest themselves by purple spots carbuncles and buboes But as the causes of the Small-pox and Measles are chiefly born within us being produc'd of the maternal blood attracted in the womb and cast forth by nature when become more strong so though the seeds of contagious diseases may come from without yet they are commonly within our selves The Third said That Contagion is the communication of a disease from one body to another the most violent so communicable is the Pestilence which is defin'd a most acute contagious venomous and mortal Fever accompani'd with purple spots Buboes and Carbuncles 'T is properly a species of a Fever being a venomous and contra-natural heat kindled in the heart manifesting it self by a high frequent and unequal pulse except when nature yields at first to the violence and malignity of the disease and then the pulse is slow small and languishing but always unequal and irregular Oftentimes it kills the first or second day scarce passes to the seventh if it be simple and legitimate but when 't is accompani'd with putrefaction it reaches sometimes to the fourteenth It s malignity appears in its not yielding to ordinary remedies which operate by their first qualities but only to medicaments which act by occult properties an argument that the cause of these diseases is so too Now four things are here to be consider'd 1. That which is communicated 2. The body which communicates the same 3. That to which it is communicated 4. The medium through which the same is done A thing communicated against nature is either the disease or the cause of the disease or the symptom Here 't is the cause of the disease which is either corporeal or incorporeal The incorporeal in my opinion are the malignant influences of the Stars as of Mars and Saturn and during Comets and Eclipses For since their benigne influences preserve motion and life in all things of the world by the reason of contraries the malignity of the same aspects may be the cause of the diseases and irregularities which we behold in it The corporeal cause must be moveable an humour a vapour or a spirit which malignant evaporations kill oftentimes without any sign of putrefaction or if there be any it proceeds not from the corruption of the humours but from the oppression and suffocation of the natural heat by those malignant vapours and then the humours being destitute of the natural heat and of that of the spirits which preserv'd them turn into poyson There must be some proportion between the body which communicates this vapour and that which receives it but the same is unknown to us and this proportion is the cause that some Contagions seise only upon some animals as Horses Dogs and Cattle others upon Men alone Children Women old Men Women with Child and their burthens others seize only upon certain parts as the Itch is communicated only to the skin the Phthisick to the Lungs the Ophthalmia to the eyes and not to the other parts The medium of this communication is the air which being rare and spongy is very susceptible of such qualities which it easily transmits by its mobility And these qualities happen to it either extrinsecally as from faetid and venomous vapours and fumes exhal'd from carrion marshes impurities and openings of the ground by Earth-quakes which are frequently follow'd by the Pestilence or else they arise in the Air it self in which vapours may acquire a pestilential malignity of which a hot and moist intemperature is very susceptible The Fourth said That the Pestilence is found indifferently in all seasons climates sexes ages and persons which argues that its proximate cause is not the corruption of the humors and intemperature of the first qualities Otherwise the Pestilence should be as other diseases whereof some are hot others cold and be cur'd
it It is wholly necessary to Merchants for their selling Upon which score possibly Mercury was made the Patron of Negotiators For perswasion which is the end of it needs not alwayes an Oration complete in all its members the greatest pitch of an Orator is to contract himself according to time place and persons A General of an Army animates his Souldiers more with three words as he is going to charge the Enemy then a Preacher doth his Auditors in a whole Lent Even Gestures are sometimes eloquent so the Curtesan Phryne carry'd her law-suit by discovering her fair bosome as also did a Captain by shewing his scars to their Judges who intended to condemn them Whereby it appears how great the power and extent of Eloquence is The Second said Since some were so hardy the last Conference as by speaking ill of Poets to disparage the language of the gods let us examine that of men that Pallas may not complain of the same treatment that was shew'd to the Muses For not to strike the same string twice the lasciviousnesse imputed to them seems more justly to belong to Orators and Poets since Meroury the god of thieves as well as of Eloquence and not Apollo was the messenger of the amours of the gods Now 't is hard for the Disciples not to retain some thing of their Master Moreover Socrates and Plato define Eloquence the art of deceiving or flattering and this latter banishes Orators out of the excellent Common-wealth which he took so much pains to contrive But other real States have done them more evil driving them effectively out of their territories rightly judging with Aeschylus that nothing is more pernicious and prejudicial then an affected language embellish'd with the graces of Eloquence which the more florid it is the more poyson it hides under its flowers which have nothing but appearance Therefore the Romans the wisest Politicians in the world drave them so often out of their Common-wealth as during the Consulship of Fannius Strabo and Valerius Messala when Cneus Domitius and Q. Licinius were Censors and under the Emperor Domitian And 't is one of the surest foundations of the Turkish Empire and by which they have found most advantage their forbidding the having by this means instead of an Army of talkers good for nothing but to multiply noises and divisions by disguising the Truth innumerable stout fellows of their hands who have learn'd no other lesson but Obedience By which from a small beginning they have subdu'd a great part of the world particularly Greece which alwayes made profession of this talkativenesse Yea in Athens it self the cradel of Eloquence the Orators were forbidden the Court the Palace and other publick Assemblies because they perverted Right and Timagoras was there condemn'd to death for having made Complements to Darius according to the mode of the Persians The ancient Republick of Crete and that of Lacedaemon the School of Virtue were not unmindfull to provide against these Sophisters the latter opposing their design by the brevity of its Laconick stile and having banish'd Ctesiphon for boasting that he could discourse a whole day upon what ever subject were propounded to him What then would it have done to Demosthenes who commonly brag'd that he could turn the balance of Justice on which side he pleas'd Is not Eloquence therefore more to be fear'd then the musick of the Syrens or the potions of the inchantresse Circe being able to involve innocence in punishment and procure rewards to crimes Moreover 't is a Womans Virtue to talk And therefore Caesar disdain'd this present which Nature had given him and few people value it but such as have nothing else to recommend them Volaterranus observ'd few persons both virtuous and eloquent nor do we find famous Orators in Macedon which gave birth to Alexander and so many other great Captains 'T was with this Eloquence that Demosthenes incens'd Philip against his own City of Athens that Cicero animated Marcus Antonius against that of Rome that of Cato was one of the causes that incited Caesar against the liberty of his Country and yet Cato hated this art of Oratory so much that he once caus'd audience to be deny'd to Carneades and his companions Critelaus and Diogenes Ambassadors from Athens to Rome upon no other reason but because they were too Eloquent And not to speak of the vanity of Orators a vice more incident to them then to Poets witnesse the boastings of Cicero their art is altogether unprofitable since it serves onely to paint and deck the truth which hath no need of ornaments and ought to be plain pure simple and without artifice In a word to represent truth adorn'd with flowers of Rhetorick is to lay Fucus upon a fair Complexion to paint Gilly-flowers and Anemonies and to perfume Roses and Violets But what may it not falsifie since it disguises it self covering its figures with the hard words of Metonymy Synecdoche and other barbarismes to make them admir'd by the ignorant The Third said That there being nothinb but is lyable to be abus'd both they speak true who commend Eloquence and they who decry it When this faculty of speaking well undertakes to make great things little and the contrary it frustrates their wish who would have things themselves speak Nor is there any lover of eloquent discourses but prefers before elegant speaking the plainesse of a good counsel when some serious matter is in debate either touching health businesse or the good of the Soul And therefore I conclude that Eloquence is indeed more graceful but simplicity and plainesse more excellent and desirable CONFERENCE LVII I. Of the Hearing II. Of Harmony I. Of the Hearing THe Hearing is the Sense of Disciplines the inlet of Faith which the Apostle saith comes by Hearing the judge of sounds and their differences the cognition whereof is the more difficult for that they are the least material qualities of all considering that they are neither the First as the Tangible nor the Second as Colours Odours and Sapours depending upon the various mixture of the first but of another kind of qualities which have scarce any thing of the grossnesse of matter The little corporeity they have not proceeding from that but from the Air which enters with it into the Eear Neverthelesse sound is not wholly spiritual for it presupposes in the bodies collided together hardnesse smoothnesse and such other second qualities without which the collision of two bodies is not audible But the chief cause of the difficult cognition of sounds is that they are produc'd of nothing namely of Local Motion which by the testimony of the Philosophers is a pure Nothing Motion being rather a way to being then a true being Not that Motion produces something that is real of it self since Nothing cannot produce any thing but onely by accident and by another So by friction attenuating the parts it generates heat and by the meeting of two bodies it makes sound which lasts as long
as its cause and ceases when this fails contrary to other qualities which have a fix'd and permanent existence in Nature For the tingling of a bell which continues some while after the stroke is not one single sound but many the parts of the bell being put into a trembling motion by the blow and communicating the same to the parts of the Air contain'd in the cavity of the bell which Air is so long clash'd together till all the insensible parts of the bell be return'd to their first rest and therefore the laying of the hand upon it hinders this motion and consequently stops the sound And 't is for this reason that it resounds more when it hangs freely then when it is held in the hand and some bells have been seen to fly in pieces upon the application of a piece of Iron to them whilst they were trembling The cause whereof is this if while all the parts of the bell tremble and equally move from their place one part be check'd it becomes immoveable and so not following the agitation of the rest is separated from them The Second said Though sound the object of the Hearing containing under it Voice and Speech is oftentimes accompany'd with three things the body striking the body struck and the Medium resounding yet these three do not alwayes meet in all sort of sounds as we see in that which is made by our bellows the noise of a Petar Salt Chestnuts and other aerious and flatuous bodies cast into the fire because these flatuosities being rarifi'd require an outlet and therefore impetuously break forth out of their restraint which eruption striking the neighbouring Air produces a sound The same is seen also in the Voice which is form'd by collision of the Air in the Lungs against the Larynx the palate and the teeth So that the proximate cause of sound is not the shock of two bodies but the breaking of the Air when its motion is hindred A piece of cloth makes a noise in the tearing but not in the cutting because of the sudden separation of the parts of the Air which on the other side for fear of Vacuum are impetuously carry'd towards the place of their separation and the wind whistles by reason of the violent motion which it causeth in the Air sometimes driving the same before it sometimes pressing and wracking it or because it meets some other wind or body that opposes its natural motion The Third said A perfect sound cannot be made without the encountring of two bodies and Air between them for want of which there would be local motion but no sound in a Vacuum and the motion of those great celestial orbes is not audible Now these bodies must be hard and solid either of their own Nature as Copper and Silver or by the union and construction of their parts which makes them act and resist as if they were solid such are the Air and Water agitated Moreover that this sound be perfect 't is requisite that the bodies be large and smooth for if they be rough and scabrous the Air which is compress'd finds means to expand it self in the interstices of the higher parts if they be acute and pointed they cut and divide but do not break it So a needle striking the point of another needle makes no noise because it onely cuts the Air but do's not compresse it If these solid bodies be hollow and dry the sound is made the better and yet more if they be aerious Hence among metals Brass Silver and Gold resound more then Lead and Iron which are of a terrene nature Among Trees the Sallow and the Fig-tree have a sound and the leaves of Laurel crackle in the fire by reason of their aerious parts Lastly the bodies must be friable that is to say divisible at the same time into very small particles as Air Glass and Ice or in case they break not at least they must tremble in all their parts as bells do Therefore Water not being friable by reason of its tenacious humidity which keeps the particles together cannot be the subject of sounds that of running Water being made by the occurse of the Air upon its surface not in the Water it self in which no sound can be made although it may be somewhat confus'dly transmitted as 't is to fishes whom the noise makes to abandon the shore The Fourth said Hearing was given to Man to satisfie his natural inclination to understand the thoughts of his species by the utterance of words which would be useless to conversation if they were not receiv'd by this faculty whose dignity appears chiefly in the structure of its Organ the Ear both external and internal which is destinated to the reception of sounds Therefore the Philosopher derides Alcmaeon for saying that Goats respire at the ears The external is Cartilaginous and tortuous unmoveable in man alone always open on each side the head to receive sounds from all parts which are carri'd upwards in an orbicular figure The internal situate in the os petrosum or bone of the Temples hath four passages viz. the auditory meatus clos'd with a membrane call'd the Drum behind which is a cord fastned to the stirrup the anvil and hammer small bones as dry and big in children as in old men 2. That which incloseth the natural and immoveable Air the principal Organ of hearing 3. The Labyrinth 4. The Cochle or Shell-work But the passage which goes from the Ear to the Palate and the orifice of the Wind-pipe is most remarkable by which the inspir'd air doth not only refresh the Lungs but also the natural implanted air in the ear Hence ariseth that sympathy of the Palate and the Ears and to hear well we sometimes hold our breath for fear of disordering the species of sounds and those that gape or yawn hear little or not at all because the vaporous spirit which causeth oscitation so puts up the drum of the ear that it cannot well receive sounds and for the same reason they that yawn dare not pick their ears at that time for fear of hurting the inflated Drum which if it come to be touch'd the yawning ceaseth those that scratch their ears put themselves into a hawking or coughing And lastly 't is for this reason that such as are born deaf are also dumb because of the straight connexion of the auditory Nerve being of the fifth conjugation with the seventh which is at the root of the Tongue The Fifth said Sounds are carri'd to the ear in the same manner as they are produc'd namely by a fraction of the air adjoyning which hath a sphere of activity and is like that which is caus'd in the water by casting a stone into it but without any intentional species Otherwise sounds would be heard at the same time and in the same manner by those that are neer and those that are far off in regard the intentional species being spiritual is carri'd in an instant being caus'd by
which makes water ascend in the Pneumaticks whereof Hero writ a Treatise rendring the same melodious and resembling the singing of birds in the Hydraulicks It makes use of the four Elements which are the causes of the motions of engines as of Fire in Granadoes Air in Artificial Fountains both Fire and Air by their compression which water not admitting since we see a vessel full of water can contain nothing more its violence consists in its gravity when it descends from high places The Earth is also the cause of motion by its gravity when 't is out of Aequilibrium as also of rest when 't is equally poiz'd as is seen in weights The Second said The wit of Man could never preserve the dominion given him by God over other creatures without help of the Mechanicks but by this art he hath brought the most savage and rebellious Animals to his service Moreover by help of mechanical inventions the four Elements are his slaves and as it were at his pay to do his works Thus we see by means of the Hydraulicks or engines moving by water wheels and pumps are set continually at work the Wind is made to turn a Mill manag'd by the admirable Art of Navigation or employ'd to other uses by Aealipila's Fire the noblest of all Elements becomes the vassal of the meanest Artisans or serves to delight the sight by the pleasant inventions of some Ingineer or employes its violence to arm our thunders more powerfully then the ancient machines of Demetrius The Earth is the Theatre of all these inventions and Archimedes boasted he could move that too had he place where to fix his engine By its means the Sun descends to the Earth and by the artificial union of his rayes is enabled to effect more then he can do in his own sphere The curiosity of man hath carry'd him even to Heaven by his Astrological Instrumens so that nothing is now done in that republick of the stars but what he knows and keeps in record The Third said That since Arts need Instruments to perform their works they owe all they can do to the Mechanicks which supply them with utensils and inventions 'T was the Mechanicks which furnish'd the Smith with a hammer and an anvil the Carpenter with a saw and a wedge the Architect with a rule the Mason with a square the Geometrician with a compass the Astronomer with an astrolabe the Souldier with sword and musket in brief they have in a manner given man other hands Hence came paper writing printing the mariner's box the gun in these latter ages and in the preceding the Helepoles or takecities flying bridges ambulatory towers rams and other engines of war which gives law to the world Hence Archimedes easily drew a ship to him which all the strength of Sicily could not stir fram'd a heaven of glass in which all the celestial motions were to be seen according to which model the representation of the sphere remains to us at this day Hence he burnt the Roman ships even in their harbour defended the City of Syracuse for a long time against the Roman Army conducted by the brave Marcellus And indeed I wonder not that this great Archimedes was in so high in Reputaion For if men be valued according to their strength is it not a miracle that one single man by help of mechanicks could lift as much as ten a hundred yea a thousand others And his pretension to move the whole Earth were a poynt given him out of it where to stand will not seem presumptuous though the supposition be impossible to such as know his screw without-end or of wheels plac'd one above another for by addition of new wheels the strength of the same might be so multiply'd that no humane power could resist it yea a child might by this means displace the whole City of Paris and France it self were it upon a moveable plane But the greatest wonder is the simplicity of the means employ'd by this Queen of Arts to produce such excellent effects For Aristotle who writ a book of mechanicks assignes no other principles thereof but the Lever its Hypomoclion or Support and a balance it being certain that of these three multiply'd proceed all Machines both Automata and such as are mov'd by force of wind fire water or animals as wind-mills water-mills horse-mills a turn-broch by smoak and as many other inventions as things in the world CONFERENCE LXXXVII I. Whether the Soul's Immortality is demonstrable by Natural Reasons II. Whether Travel be necessary to an Ingenuous Man I. Whether the Soul's Immortality is demonstrable by Natural Reasons NAtural Philosophy considers natural bodies as they are subject to alteration and treats not of the Soul but so far as it informes the Body and either partakes or is the cause of such alteration And therefore they are injust who require this Science to prove supernatural things as the Soul's Immortality is Although its admirable effects the vast extent of its thoughts even beyond the imaginary spaces its manner of acting and vigor in old age the terrors of future judgement the satisfaction or remorse of Conscience and Gods Justice which not punishing all sins in this life presupposes another are sufficiently valid testimonies thereof should not the universal consent of heathens themselves some of which have hastned their deaths to enjoy this immortality and man 's particular external shape infer the particular excellence of his internal form So that by the Philosophical Maxime which requires that there be contraries in every species of things if the souls of beasts joyn'd to bodies die there must be others joyn'd to other bodies free from death when separated from the same And the Harmony of the world which permits not things to pass from on extreme to another without some mean requires as that there are pure spirits and intelligences which are immortal and substances corporeal and mortal so there be a middle nature between these two Man call'd by the Platonists upon this account the horizon of the Universe because he serves for a link and medium uniting the hemisphere of the Angelical Nature with the inferior hemisphere of corporeal nature But there is difference between that which is and that which may be demonstrated by Humane Reason which falls short in proving the most sensible things as the specifical proprieties of things and much less can it prove what it sees not or demonstrate the attribute of a subject which it sees not For to prove the Immortality of the Soul 't is requisite at least to know the two termes of this proportion The Soul is immortal But neither of them is known to natural reason not immortality for it denotes a thing which shall never have end but infinitie surpasses the reach of humane wit which is finite And the term Soul is so obscure that no Philosophy hath yet been able to determine truly whether it be a Spirit or something corporeal a substance or an accident single
or triple The Second said That every thing that is mortal and corruptible is such in that it hath in it self some cause of this corruption All mortal bodies being compos'd of contrary ingredients have in themselves the principle of corruption from which as well simple bodies as the Elements and Heavens as Spirits and separate intelligences are free because a thing simple in its own nature cannot act upon it self by a destructive action though even those Spirits have but an arbitrary existence from their first cause on whom they depend But in the first sence and of their own nature they are absolutely incorruptible for were they corruptible then must some new substance be generated out of that which is corrupted which is absurd because they are simple and free from composition and consequently from corruption Now were reasonable Souls which are part of man who is compounded of matter and form again compounded of matter and form there would be a progression to infinity in causes which is contrary to natural reason Moreover nothing is corrupted but by its contrary and therefore that which hath no contrary is free from corruption But such is the rational soul which is so far from having any contrary that the most contrary things in Nature as habits and their privations being receiv'd in the Understanding are no longer opposites or enemies but friends and of the same nature whence the reason of contraries is alike and there is but one Science of them The Third said That such as a thing is such is its action A corporeal and material substance cannot produce an action which is not corporeal and an immaterial action owns no other principle but what is immaterial and incorruptible Hence the same reasons which prove the souls of brutes mortal because their operations exceed not the bounds of the body and tend onely to self-preservation and sensible good conclude also though by a contrary sense for the immortality of the rational soul whose operations are spiritual and abstracted from the body For nutrition concoction assimilation sense motion and other such actions being corporeal because terminated upon sensible and corporeal objects must consequently be produc'd by a faculty of the same nature corporeal and material But the reasonable soul besides those actions which are common to it with those of beasts hath some peculiar and much more sublime as by the Intellect to understand eternal truths to affirm deny suspend its judgement compare things together abstract them from matter time place and all other sensible accidents by the will to love and embrace vertue in spight of the contrary inclinations of the sensitive appetite to do good actions though difficult to avoid the evil which flatters the senses and the like which actions being above the body and material objects cannot be produc'd but by an immaterial and incorruptible substance such as the reasonable soul is Moreover since the soul can know all sorts of bodies it must consequently be exempt from all corporeal entity as the tongue to judge aright of sapours must have none and the eye to discern colours well The Fourth said That Nature which makes nothing in vain hath imprinted in every thing a desire of its end whereof it is capable as appears by induction of all created Beings Now the greatest desire of man is immortality whereunto he directs all his actions and intentions and therefore he must be capable of it But since he cannot accomplish this end in this life as all other things do it must be in another without which not only good men would be more unhappy then wicked but in general the condition of men would be worse then that of beasts if after having endur'd so many infelicities which brutes experience not the haven of our miseries were the annihilation of the noblest part of our selves Yea if the soul could not subsist without the body its supream good should be in this life and in the pleasures of the body and its chiefest misery in afflictions and the exercises of vertue which is absurd For whereas 't is commonly objected that the soul cannot exercise its noblest functions but by help of corporeal organs rightly dispos'd and that when it is separated from those organs it can act no longer and consequently shall exist no more action and subsistence being convertible this is to take that for granted which is in controversie namely that the soul cannot act without the organs of the body when it is separated from the same since it operates sometimes more perfectly when 't is freest from the senses as in Extasies burning Fevers in the night time and in old age The Fifth said As in Architecture the principal piece of a building is the Foundation so the most necessary of a Science is to lay good Principles without which first establish'd all our Sciences are but conjectures and our knowledge but opinion Now in order to judge whether the souls immortality be demonstrable by natural reasons 't is to be enquir'd whether we can find the principles of this truth whose terms being known may be naturally clear and granted by all The most ordinary are these 1. Every thing which is spiritual is incorruptible 2. That which is material is mortal 3. That which is immaterial is immortal 4. That which God will preserve eternally is immortal 5. A thing acts inasmuch as it exists and some other principles by which this so important verity seems but ill supported For the first is not absolutely true since habits of grace and natural habits which are spiritual are annihilated and corrupted those by sin these by intermission of the actions which produc'd them Then for the second 't is notoriously false since not only the forms of the Elements which are material and the Elements themselves consider'd according to their whole extent but also the first matter are incorruptible and eternal and according to the opinion of many Doctors of the Church 't is not an article of faith that the Angels are incorporeal although it be de fide that they are immortal to say nothing of igneous aerious demons and other corporeal genii of the Platonists As for the third the actions of the understanding and the will are immaterial and nevertheless perish as soon as they are conceiv'd and the intentional species are not incorruptible though not compos'd either of matter or form on the contrary the Heavens which are so compos'd are yet incorruptible Whereby it appears that immortality depends on something else As for the fourth 't is as difficult to prove that God will eternally preserve reasonable souls as that they are immortal And for the last 't is certain that many things act above their reach and the condition of their nature since that which exists not as the end nevertheless acts by exciting the efficient cause motion begets heat which it self hath not and light a corporeal quality is mov'd in an instant which is the property of incorporeal substances as also