persons in the place both Citizens and Strangers who were acquainted with calling on God long before they came into this distress these prayed without ceasing and the hearer of Prayer did graciously so far condescend unto some of them that during the whole Siege and in greatest extremities were comforted by the hope of deliverance in Gods due time and some of them being Ministers of what perswasion I shall not so much as name that all may joyn together in due praises not unto us O Lord not unto us but unto thy Name give glory for thy mercy and for thy truths sake for when humane strength was gone then did the God of mercy appear and his own Arm brought Salvation sending food to the fainting remnant thorow the Fire of their Enemies on every side they gnashing their Teeth and melting away and thus by Divine Power and Mercy the place of Deaths was made a beginning of Reviving and Life to the whole Nation Who at this day out of their graves have it to say they came out of their graves as the remnant of Derry when this people were as if their bones had been scattered at the graves mouth who could have answered that question but God can these dry bones live who but he alone could put flesh sinews and skin upon them and breath Life into the dead making them to stand up as an Army so terrible that their besiegers were frighted from their Walls hastning far away when nothing pursued them but the Terrour of God Shall he remember us in our low estate and we forget him shall he to whom it 's a humbling of himself to behold the things that are in Heaven and earth look down and send from above drawing us out of these depths and we not so much as look up to the hand doing it Hath God appointed Salvation for Walls and Bulwarks when there was no strength to defend our walls of Stone and Clay shall it be said of this City thou hast forgotten the God of thy Salvation and hast not been mindful of the Rock of thy strength Hath God frustrated and rejected the confident expectations of our enemies hath he given them wine of astonishment to drink and taken the cup of trembling out of our hand hath he amuzed and confounded them with his works of wonder for Derry insomuch that some of the besiegers being surprized that the gates were not opened unto them and afterward finding that the flower of their Army fell before these walls said God doth fight for Derry but blasphemously added God was not just in so doing this I can instruct by some of deserved reputation to whom it was spoken and yet alive Oh! that men would Praise the Lord for his Goodness and for his Wonderfull Works and not be as these who Sung his Praise but soon forgot his Works For Preventing of this Forgeting Chrysost on Math Homil. 25. Saith that great Mercies and Deliverances should not only be Carefully committed to the Memory but actual Praises Rendered to God for them every day and the same Author on Tit. Hom. 1. If Saith he we receive a Benefit from a Friend or if we but know he hath spoken a Seasonable Word for us with what Warmth of Love do we Remember him How much greater love should we have to God who hath delivered us from the greatest dangers It is great Mercy to be helped of God to understand the Depth of our Mercies for some are Preserved who were not ready to Die if by the Furnace we have been in our Dross be not Purged away and we become not a Refined People meet for the Master's Use we have reason yet to fear a Furnace more hot where God in his Justice may Melt and leave us Let us therefore fear him and his Goodness let us Live to him who made us Live in the Jaws of Death let us take Pleasure to speak of his Mighty Acts and testifie our Gratitude by an Holy Just and Exemplary Conversation provocking one another unto Love and good Works walking by the same Rule minding the same Thing as men of one heart and one way Our Gracious God hath not only Delivered but put severals of you in Places of greatest Trust and Honour in this City and as by the Grace of God ye have happily begun so go on in the strength of the Lord God by your Authority and Example to promove the Power of Godliness and the publick Good of the City Ministring Justice to all of all Perswasions Impartially which I know to be your Principle and to maintain by all Laudable Means Peace Love and Concord in the Place that so all the Inhabitants may find you a Blessing from God and that the whole City now raised from it's Ruines and Desolations may Flourish in all Godliness Righteousness and Felicity is the Prayer of Much Honoured Your Servant in the Gospel ROB. CRAGHEAD London derry April 18 1694. The BOOK now under Consideration Is Intituled A DISCOURSE Concerning the Inventions of Men in the VVorship of GOD But after Perusal appeareth A Discourse for the Inventions of Men in the Worship of GOD. THE whole Scope being a Tenacious Defence of such Inventions and Commandments of Men in the Worship of God as he hath no where prescribed in his Word nor are warrantable by the general Rules of Scripture and such Acts of Worship maintained as are forbidden by the Word of God and these only accused as guilty whose conscientious abstaining from such Inventions hath occasioned their sufferings for many years By this Araignment the Author hath cast himself into some Labyrinths out of which the Egress may not be so easie as the Ingress nor so pleasing to his Friends as if he had imployed his Pen some other way since by his Discourse Dissenters are necessarily engaged to discover the firm Foundation of their Principles and practice in the Worship of God and the infirmness of all the Author's Arguments said against them Whereby some by a more explicite knowledge may be fully fixed and determined to the Communion whereof they are now Members INTRODUCTION THE Author beginneth his work with a Scripture so awful and apposite that it would have been a singular help to his memory if the same had been written on top of every Page before his Book had been filled up the words are Mark 7. 7. In vain do they worship me Teaching for Doctrines the Commandments of men this obligeth every man who hath a concern for his Soul to examine the Worship he offers to God whether it be such as God hath instituted c. Ans All this is good and necessary wanting nothing but due observation for all of us should testifie the veneration we owe to so important warning from the Mouth of Christ. Let us come then to a fair Tryal who are most guilty of teaching for Doctrines the Commandments of men and what he offereth according to reason shall be admitted whether it breath a Spirit of
meekness or not which is rather desirable than discernable in his Book The Author cometh more closs to his Work Page 3 and there placeth two sound Positions first in these words That it belongeth only to God to give Rules how he will be worshipped The 2d That the Holy Scriptures contain the Revelations of God's will concerning his Worship Ans I can desire no more of the Author but that the Superstructure be fitted to these Foundations they are so sure that God willing I shall stand by them to the end of this Discourse But if he who asserteth them be found going off or building Hay or Stuble upon them let him not take it ill if I help his memory as occasion offereth 3ly His Inference from these two viz. That from these two we may reasonably infer that it concerns us to keep as close as we can to those directions which God hath afforded us in his word without adding to omiting or altering any thing he hath there laid down for since God hath vouchafed us a certain direction for his worship in the holy Scriptures It 's to be supposed that all wayes of worship are displeasing to him that are not either expresly contained or warranted by Examples of holy men mentioned therein Ans This also is found provided alwayes that what is said of the examples of holy-men be duely cautioned for all the examples of holy-men mentioned in Scripture are not obligatory Some of them being â—ad even in the matters of God as Peter's dissembling for fear of the Jews here was a hurteful example of an holy man for Barnabas was carried away with this dissimulation Some of them affected Preheminency disputing who should be greatest these are no warrands for us to do the like seeing we are to follow them but as they were followers of Christ again some of their practices were by extraordinary gifts wherein they are above our Imitation Some of them were by special direction hic nunc for avoiding offence as Paul's circumcising Timothy such was his purifying of himself in the Temple according to the Ceremonial law these practices were not patterns for other holymen tho' contemporary with themselves nor do the practices of any men oblidge others without either some antecedent or concomitant evidence that it 's the revealed will of God such practices should be followed otherways men should be Idols to us making them Fathers of our Religion in which respect we are to call no man Father Page 3d. The Author distinguisheth worship into either inward or outward Ans The subject in hand requireth more distinctions of worship as into civil and Religious for many worshiped Christ on earth with civil worship only as a great Prophet and fame in the world intending no Divine Adoration next Ceremonial worship should have also been distinguished from Evangelical for by Levitical worship Sacrifices the observation of feasts divers washings were required which by the coming of Christ are abrogated these being carnal Ordinances and some better things provided for us our Saviour principally requiring such worship as is in Spirit and Truth not excluding external Adoration as it 's required Page 4. We have a Description of inward and outward Worship The inward Worship of God consists in the inward Homage and Subjection of our minds to him the outward consisteth of such acts and duties as serve to express this inward subjection of our Souls or that promote increase or contribute towards it Ans I pass the Description of the inward but the Description of the outward Worship is unsound and of dangerous consequence and had been easily helped if the Author had said it consisteth of such Acts and Duties as God hath appointed for his Worship but according to his Assertion there is an open Gap made for all the Humane Inventions that the fertile imagination of man can devise providing he but think they will serve to promote or contribute to inward Homage thus the Papists have brought in most of all their Idolatry and Superstitions and others may do the like if they but apprehend what they do may promote inward Worship Here my Author goeth off his Foundation that the Scriptures contain the Revelations of God's Will how He will be Worshipped and if I were of the Author's Judgment declared by this Description I would never have put Pen to Paper against the Inventions of Men in the Worship of God for it 's vain to open a wide Door for them and then forbid men to come in Page 4. We must remember that it 's in these outward Acts that we are more immediatly concerned as publick Worshippers Ans I do not take the Authors meaning to be so bad as his words in what is here asserted supposing the sense of his Words to be that men disputing of Worship they are more immediatly concerned in outward Worship than inward for certainly as acting Worship we are most concerned in the inward Adoration of the Soul as Christ hath taught that the Father seeketh such to worship as worship him in Spirit and Truth The last thing in the Introduction is the Distribution of Worship into its parts Praises Prayers Hearing Bodily Worship and Celebration of the Holy Sacrament of the Body and Blood of CHRIST Ans This Enumeration is not sufficient for why the Sacrament of Baptism is omitted no reason is given but the Author intending to Treat on no other Heads but such as he hath named I shall pass it though other substantial parts of Worship are also left out CHAP. I. Of Praises PAge 6. The Author doth forthwith fall upon the offering up of Praises to God by the use of Psalms and for its Authority quoteth 2 Chron. 29. 30. Hezekiah the King and the Princes commanded the Levites to sing praises to the Lord with the words of David and Asaph and they sang with gladness and Ephes 5. 19. and Col. 3. 16. Ans To all this we agree knowing it our duty to praise God by singing the Psalms of David But Page 7. Though the Scriptures recommend to us singing of Psalms yet in some cases they allow us to say them Ans 1. Who doubteth but we may Read or Say Psalms either in publick or privat But 2ly This saying Psalms is not to turn out singing of Psalms which is the ordinance of God I often read of singing but no where in Scripture of saying Psalms what induceth the Author to make so great a trouble to himself and his Reader I understand not only I know Papists have a way of Singing and muttering Psalms and Songs in their Worship But I find our Author resolved to prosecute this Saying instead of Singing for Page 8. 'T is certain the Word of God recommends to us Psalms and Hyms in prose c. and as to the Hebrew Psalms it's evident they are Poetical but the Poetry of them consists rather in the stile and manner of expression than in any certain measures or Verses And afterward we cannot find that
God in Body and in Spirit as he requireth us and therefore are far from understanding that Scripture to be exclusive of external Adoration Page 135. The second pretence alledged against bodily adoration is that God has no value for it Ans If ever the Author heard any such Objection against external homage from any of our perswasion it would be justice and we would take it for kindness if he would discover them and if no such person can be found amongst us it will be necessary to mind the Words of God Psal 15. 3. It sufficeth us that God hath commanded external worship but we will yield Gods Prerogative to no man in prescribing it Page 173. The Author speaking of outward performances saith But you are taught that in no cases they may be lawfully practised Ans Who are these Teachers Teaching that outward Performances may in no cases be practised The Book being now in my hand I see on the head of the Page how Bodily Worship is practised by Dissenters And is it the deliberat thoughts of the Author that Dissenting Teachers Teach this Do we teach that in no cases the people may read or hear the Word of God read which is an outward performance Do we teach that they should not be Baptized or partake of the Lords Supper Do we teach that in no case they should bow their knees to God their Maker all these and many moe are outward performances this needeth no confutation repeating the words will be sufficient to any reader tho of mean sense The Author addeth in the same Page you are taught rather to stay at home and not to worship God at all publickly than to conform in their outward gestures and circumstances Ans There are some bodily jestures that render a man guilty by breach of the second Command as bodily bowing is a gesture of the body but being performed religiously to any Creature is forbidden by the express Command of God and therefore should not be enrolled with Circumstances nor is it to be practised by Christians any where but God willing more of this afterwards In the same Page 137 You are advised rather to abstain all your lives from the Lords Supper than receive it kneeling Ans Blessed be God who hath given most of us opportunity of receiving ever since we were capable without kneeling even when persecuted by the rigid imposers of kneeling who yet dare not assert that the Scriptures require it 2ly But that the Reader may understand that it s neither ignorance obstinacy nor affected separation that causeth the fixedness of our practice in sitting at the Lords Table which we cannot resile from and being obliged to render a reason to such as ask know therefore first That the blessed example of Christ and his Apostles of choice using this posture of sitting is our Scriptural Precedent and no reason can be given why the example should not be imitated the Apostles were sinful men as others yet all the four Evangelists are divinely inspired and therefore commanded to publish their being set down with Christ at his holy Table 3ly No other Scripture either expresly or by due consequence prescribeth or alloweth any other posture when we receive at the Lords Table than sitting 4ly Our Saviour and his Apostles as they followed him are proposed as our examples in all things imitable and this practice is imitable yea Christ himself maketh this his Argument Do as I have given you example Joh 13. 14. 15. v. Lest any should say we are not Apostles and must not presume to sit at Table as they did But Christ requireth a regard to the Example he giveth 5ly The Disciples being fet down at Table with Christ are not raised again by him when the Lords Supper is celebrated which he would have done if sitting when they received had been a profanation of that Ordinance but when the Supper is over they are found still sitting and then and not until then they are commanded to arise Joh. 14. 31. 6ly If this example be not followed in receiving as our pattern then we shall follow either devices excogitated by our selves or follow the Dictates and Commandments of others neither of which are safe and warrantable Christ having proposed his imitable practice for our example and the worship performed by our own invention or the Commandments of Men is already declared vain 7ly When we once give way losing our ground by neglecting Christs example we wander vainly after our own imaginations not knowing where to fix and if at length we should pitch upon the most humble like way of receiving imagining a humble way cannot be displeasing to God which prevaileth with many inadvertent tho sober persons The very thought of this that they cannot be too humble and that kneeling in receiving is an expression of this humility that humility is pleasing to God and rendereth glory to him this taking root enclineth many to think and tenaciously to hold by it that tho Christ gave example for sitting at his Table yet this devised humble way will expiat any guilt by neglect of his example because they intend to give him glory by kneeling This is the very best that I imagine can be made of the practice of many well meaning people as to their kneeling in receiving But that which should be observed with care is that once leaving Christs way the very best and purest like Inventions of our own obtruded on God as Worship will not be accepted seing by them we shall never be able to make answer when we are charged Who hath required this at your hands we may call it humility but he will call it a presumptuous voluntary humility we may call it Worship but he will call it Will-worship there being no Command of God for it 8ly This religious kneeling is Adoration and therefore due only to God 9ly We are instructed by the second Command that God will not be adored or worshipped by Images representations or the likeness of any thing in Heaven or Earth we must not bow down before them 10ly The signs of Christs Body and Bloud are set before the receiver in a religious state as representing Christ and these who kneel must do it directly before these Signs as memorials of Christ if they should go aside and kneel praying to God yet they shall not receive until they come and kneel before these Signs and hereby the Signs have Co-adoration with Christ partaking of the same Worship seing the signs are designedly set before the Receiver in the act of Adoration which is forbidden by the second Command neither can the intention of the Worshipper prevent it seing the Worship is directed first to the signs as representing Christ. 11ly Tho the Arguments given be sufficient to vindicat our practice in sitting at the Lords Table yet we know also that kneeling in the Sacrament is but a novelty in the Church of God not being in practice before the thirteenth Century when Pope Innocent the 3d
due worship as commanded of God Page 23. There is nothing but what is already answered only two unjust Imputations 1. That for as much as appears we have laid aside the Psalms in Prose Ans Can the Author keep a good Conscience in Transmitting this to strangers and following Generations Let the Reader therefore if a stranger for no other will give it credit know that we read frequently the Psalms in Prose from the beginning to the end in our publick Lectures that we often choose our Texts in the Book of Psalms and most frequently quote them in Preaching for clearing and confirmation of our Doctrine we are ready to give many thousands of unexceptionable Witnesses to attest it how then doth it appear that we have altogether laid aside the Psalms in Prose The next assault is that we sing but a few Verses of a Psalm Page 23. Ans The Author hath brought no light how many should be sung and they are never like to be the moe for what he hath said seing he neither hath nor can warrantably prescribe the quantity Yet 2ly For the undeceiving of Strangers let the Reader know that commonly we sing the Praises of God with the words of David four times each Lords day in Publick and at each time commonly much more for quantity than the Author nameth 3. That for ordinary we sing these Psalms in our Families dayly and orderly from the beginning to the end of that Book We wish we could say as much of those of another perswasion and that they were taught by word and example so to do For in dwellings of the righteous should be heard the voice of melodie and Praise and now being thus provoked I am free to assert and that not at random that there are moe of the Psalms of David sung in one of our Congregations every day than in the Authors whole Diocese as his in a week Churches and altogether and 't is no wonder when I remember the words of the Author Page 180. In his epistle to the conforming laity of the Diocess of Derry wherein he saith and therefore I would advise you to make use of the words with which our Church hath furnished you in your houses as well as in the Church c. and at more Solemn times I conceive our Litany is as full and proper a service as any master of a Family can desire to offer to God Here is no advice to use the word of God as immediatly dictated by him either in reading or singing of Psalms 4ly But singing is not all our praising in Publick finding it our duty Solemnly to give thanks to God for the great Salvation by Christ which in our Publick worship is commonly practised There is no more in this Head but what is answered already nothing being ommitted that hath the colour of an argument the Author concludeth this chapter perswading himself his arguments will prevail let him please himself with his own thoughts only I must say that since I begun to Examine what is said I have not found one argument that he can rationally expect will prevail with any judicious reader so that the Author by all his Elaborat discourses hitherto hath instead of promotting his cause done considerable disservice to his friends in urging 1 Saying in place of singing Praises in publick 2ly Responses in singing 3ly The use of Instruments in Gospel worship 4ly Intermixing these words Glory to the Father c. With the immediate words of God all which he hath exposed as naked and destitute of Divine Institution and therefore will be judged by the indifferent Reader the meet Inventions of men in the worship of God the Author bringing no Scripture Proofs for them CHAP. 2. Of Prayer SECT 1. ANd if we consider what rules directions and examples the Scriptures afford us for the performance of this duty we shall find that they direct us to offer up our Prayers in a Set and prepared form of words Ans It 's necessary I premit a few things before the particular parts under this Head be considered And next draw together some Concessions of the Author whereby he cutteth the Nerves of all his own arguments As to the form of Prayer observe First thar some are by Divine Institution some only by humane Authority all Divine forms we own and honour but humane forms require Examination 2ly Forms of Divine Institution were either occasional according to the present Exigencies of the Church or permanent as the pattern of the Lords Prayer Occasional forms of words must be considered whether apposite to our State and Circumstances as for the Lords Prayer we judge all Ages bound to it as a pattern since it was prescribed 3ly Forms of Prayer must be considered first as to the matter and substance next as to the precise words wherewith the matter is cloathed the Scriptures warranting this distinction Mat. 6. 9. after this manner praâ—ye Numb 6. 23. On this wise shall ye bless the children of Israel as to Humane forms some Churches have been so low by the Paucity of able Ministers that Humane Composures were for that time expedient as in the beginnings of Reformation when Priests could perform little more than read but that is no warrant for the continuation of such forms when God hath provided qualified Ministers for Ministerial duties and far less can it be a warrant for Imposing such Humane Composures on all Ministers of the Gospel as terms of Communion Next observe some Concessions of the Author on this Head of forms Page 26. Having mentioned many Forms as prescribed hath these words Tho' other words might be joyned with them when there was occasion to enlarge or vary the Form A 2d Concession is Page 29. In these words from whence it appears that God approves the use of one set constant Form of words as long as the occasion of repeating them is the same A 3d. Concession is Page 49. And therefore the Spirit of Prayer is the grace the heart the disposition and ability to pray and whether it be with or without a Form such a mans prayers are acceptable to God A 4th Concession is Page 54. But in as much as God has not expresly forbidden all extemporary prayers I would not be understood by this to condemn all such as unlawfull A 5th Concession is Page 51. And to pray with this grace is to pray in and with the Spirit whether we use words or no and if we do use them whether we reduce them into a Form first or pour them forth as they present themselves to our minds A 6. Concession is Page When a man has not time allowed him to reduce his desires into Form before he offers them he may depend on the assistance of God's Spirit These ample Concessions appear to me as a retreat and full yielding the cause nor can I possibly free them from a contradiction to the Author's Scop in this Chap. So that for particular answers I have no more to
immediatly after their praying they were filled with the Holy Ghost Act. 4. 30. Yet in all these Prayers we find not the Form of the Lords Prayer used by any of them as to it's words tho' none should doubt their keeping by the matter Now let the Author say plainly whether the Apostles sinned in not using that Form of words or if they did shake off the badge of their profession by omitting to use these words For the Author calleth this Form of prayer the badge of our profession If he say they got extraordinary help for Prayer I would soon answer that the more bountieful their Master was to them they should have been the more tenacious of any thing concern'd his honour as a Badge of their profession Add to all this our Authors Concession above-mentioned that the practice of the Apostles is the best way to know the meaning of a positive command let him now make application for the constant manner of the Apostles praying was by using other words Object But the Apostles might pray this Form in words tho' it be not recorded to us Ans De non existentibus non apparentibus idemest judicium that which appeareth not is to us as if it did not Exist Page 32. He saith that which the Disciples desired of Christ was not to teach them absolutely or in general to pray but as John taught his Disciples that is to give them a Form of prayer Ans All this is gratis dictum without any proof for first to say that the Disciples were so self-conceited that they needed no Instruction from Christ as to the matter of Prayer but only a Form of words is unwarrantablly asserted 2ly That John gave his Disciples a Form of words is but the Authors conjecture for he might give them direction as to the matter of Prayer without restricting them precisely to words as Christ himself did teach his Disciples not limiting them to words Page 33. Saying the substance of it in other words will not answer the intent of this command Ans I have proved the contrary already that when the substance of that prayer is observed the Institution is observed though the words differ Ibid. We are sure the substance of the prayer is put by Christ in the most apposite words c. Ans I am sure of the same that there are no words better but I we lay not aside these words for we use these words and are both constrained and allowed to enlarge upon these words according to our various necessities and the vast treasure of matter comprehended in each petition of the Lord's Prayer It 's neither contempt noâ— neglect of these very words but rather that each of these most excellent words is as a Store for many necessary words of our own For the Author to call all other words Invention by way of contempt is groundless if he mean all other words are unwarrantable Invention then let him speak out plainly and if he stand to this then he chargeth the Apostles with unwarrantable Invention in the Worship of God then he chargeth the Church of England with the same guilt for she alloweth frequently other words in Prayer then he contradicteth some of his own words mentioned already saying that he doth not condemn extemporary Prayers as unlawful yea his own words in the next foregoing Page 33. where he sayeth whatever other prayers we offer to God this ought not to be omitted where the Reader may observe by the way that the Author by these words other prayers goeth farther from the Lords Prayer than we allow for we disown other prayers than the Lords Prayer tho' we use other words we are oblidged still to pray the same prayer not other prayers Page 34 When we take the liberty to word our own prayers we may forget some things Ans No doubt but we often forget and so stronger Christians than we know not sometimes what to ask as they ought But 2ly Do not you also sometimes forget hath a Form made you perfect Is the repeating of these words a remembring all that is contained in the Petitions of the Lords Prayer and when you have remembred a part may you not forget what is most necessary for you to insist upon was not the great Apostle sensible of this when he knew not what to ask No doubt he knew the Lords Prayer as well as you it he had been of your mind he would not have been so pinched since the Form of words would Cure all 3. This trusting to words savoureth too much of the opus operatum that Papists lean to judging the efficacy of prayer to be only in the words and therefore regard not what their minds be exercised with and in the very time of their prayers can Salute or speak to one another providing they get the Task of so many words said out at length Page 34. He objecteth again they who lay aside the words of the Lords Prayer are in danger to lay aside some of the substance of it also particularly the substance of that Petition forgive us our trespasses as we forgive c. And some saith he publickly dispute against the Form for this very reason Ans Whether men use the words or not they are ready to forget as all should acknowledge 2. That which is said of some mens omitting that Petition forgive us as we forgive c Doth not appear a forgeting as it 's represented by the Author but a Stated quarrel with the prayer it self this we abhor as a presumptuous challenging of the Author of that Form and therefore disown and Declare against all Disputes which Reflect or accuse any of Christ's Institutions or any part of them Yet 3. Since Forgiveness is to be sought on these Terms as we forgive others â—t concerneth all narrowly to search their Conscience whether from their hearts they forgive others as they would be forgiven of God for if this be not endeavoured men do but proâ—ane that Prayer men should also examine their Actions lest by these Malice be discovered and so their professing to forgive others be found a deceiving of themselves and Hypocrisie in the sight of God If I should be found Persecuting others with all the power I could and would not endure their Neighbour-hood tho' sober and peaceable men I would be obliged to Charge my self with Malice against them and therefore had not forgiven them and so could not but profane that prayer if I did not repent and amend Page 35. This prayer being given us as a Badge of our profession a Summary of our duty as Christians and a Form of sound words it 's no more lawful to alter it than lay it aside and it would be the same presumption and hazard to substitute other words in stead of Christ's and therefore the words must no more be altered than the words of our Creed Ans 1. That the Lords Prayer is given as a Badge of our profession is spoken without Book it 's given
the unsearchable Riches of Christ to preach wherein they are to continue from age to age until Believers be presented perfect Col 1. 28. Whom we preach warning every man and teaching every man in all wisdom that we may present every man perfect in Christ Jesus Ephes 4. 11. is to the same purpose Page 73. We find in holy Scripture that the publick reading of the Word of God was with great solemnitie it is observed Neh 8. 5. when Ezra opened the Book all the People stood up c. Ans 1 How this can be pertinently brought in here I see not the Author hath another Chapter for Bodily Worship but 2. When God speaketh unto us by his own immediat Dictates and we attending thereupon as a part of our Worship no doubt but we ought to render External Signs of Reverence but the Author will give occasion for more of this in the next Chapter Page 75. The Author doubteth whether after reading the Word of God there was any Comment or Enlargement he granteth sometimes it was 2. But it doth not appear that this was constantly done on the contrary it s rather probable it was not for had there been a constant provision for such enlargment there had been no occasion for the ruler of the Synagogue Acts 13. 15. To send to Paul and Barnabas after the reading the Law and Prophets that message we find there men and brethren if ye have any word of exhortation for the people say on St. Paul supposes him that teaches and him whose office it was to exhort distinct from him that ruled and him that ministred Rom 12. And it doth not appear that every Church was furnished with all these Officers Ans 1. To what purpose all this is brought forth I cannot perceive except to prove that in publick Assemblies for worship there was no preaching or expounding but only reading 2ly but the Levites expounding what was read is one proof there was more then reading 2ly Our Saviours practice is another instance Luke 4. 16. Where he is found reading a Text Isa 61. 1. The spirit of the Lord is upon me because he hath anointed me to preach the Gospel to the poor c. I hope the Author will allow Christ's following discourse the name of preaching seing he was anointed to preach the Gospel 3. All the recorded Sermons of the Apostles were properly preaching whether there was any publick reading preceded their Sermons or not making it alwayes their work to preach Christ rather than to read to the people 3ly The rulers of the synagogue Acts 13. 15. Sending to the Apostles to speak a word of exhortation after the reading of the Law doth not prove that such exhortation was not in use but rather the contrary that because it was used the Rulers gave notice that the opportune time for exhortation was then after the reading of the Law and it 's observable that upon this invitation the Apostle had a large successful Sermon which we may well call preaching for verse 32. The Apostle himself saith we declare unto you glad tidings c. Page 76. Lastly we find that they had a summary of the principal doctrines of the Gospel which they delivered to the people and by which they ordered their own discourses and judged of what was delivered by others thus St. Paul to Timothy 2 Tim. 1. 13. Hold fast the Form of sound words which thou hast heard of me Chap. 2. 2. The same commit thou to faithful men who shall be able to teach others perhaps this may be that proportion of Faith according to which the Prophets are exhorted to prophesie Rom. 12. 6. I think it is not doubted but this Form of sound words contained the main foundamentals of Christianity and Paul tells us what those were Heb. 6. 12. Therefore leaving the principals of the Doctrine of Christ c. Ans 1. What that Form of sound words was the Author cannot tell and therefore saith Perhaps this may be that proportion of Faith c And so leaveth it as dark as he found it 2ly The Author appears to understand this of some written Form otherwise it maketh not for his purpose and that it was delivered to the people as a Form but this is said without proof Timothy was to hold them fast in Faith 3ly The Form of sound words is as our best Commentators expound them the Gospel preached by the Apostles and that the same to be committed to faithful men able to teach others and these six Heads or foundamentals were this Form is meer conjecture therefore the Author sayes modestly in all probability it was so the naming of principles doth not prove all are there SECT 2. Page 77. These are the rules and examples the Scriptures propose let us compare the practice of our Church with them and surely no copie can come nearer the Original for first our Ministeres are expresly oblidged in their ordination diligently to read all the Canonical Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments unto the people assembled in the Church where they shall be appointed to serve Ans If none can come nearer the rules of Scripture then they are at the utmost point of perfection attainable in this life The Author hath now surmounted the Apostle Paul who acknowledged he did but know in part and prophesie in part then all the prophesies and promises for greater Puritie and that the light of the Moon shall be as the light of the Sun and the light of the Sun shall be seven fold as the light of seven days in the day that the Lord bindeth up the breach of his people I say all such promises are fully accomplished and no more to be expected by such as worship after this manner 2ly Why then saith the Author Page 159. Tho' we are yet too far short of the Primitive practice and institution can none come nearer Scripture rules and Institution and yet yourselves too far short of the Institution Let any who can reconcile these 3ly This importeth no less than a limiting of God what doth blind mortals know of what is to come and what the power of God can yet bring his Churches unto had he said no Copie hath come nearer the Original he had said too far himself confessing they are far short of Primitive practice but to say none can come nearer is intollerable 4ly The reason the Author giveth for this is because they read much Scripture but if another Church should read more Scripture which can be then which of the Copies is nearest the Original It cannot be your Copy for others read more nor can it be these who read more for according to the Author none can come nearer the rule than you and yet the reason he giveth for this is much reading only 5ly If the quantitie or how much reading be the reason why men come nearest the rule then God hath prescribed by some rule how much we should read at once or in one day but God hath
no where prescribed to us such a rule Therefore mens reading much cannot be the reason why they are nearest the rule if there be any such rule make it appear and if there be no rule prescribing how much with what colour can it be said you come nearest the rule for it 's yet under debate but that less reading and expounding what is read to edification will be found nearer the rule than much reading where no help is given for peoples understanding the Scriptures 6ly These come not nearest the rule who read too much and more than God hath given direction to read as any part of his Service or Worship but you know who read Apocrypha in God's publick Service which he hath given no rule for therefore such come not nearest the rule 7ly These cannot be said to come nearest the rule who read too little or may be never that which God hath prescribed to be read but you know who lay aside a considerable part of the Scriptures from their publick Service Worship and then those who do so are not nearest the rule If it be said that no Scriptures are left out but such as are less proper and profitable for ordinary Assemblies yet the word of God saith all Scripture is given by inspiration and is profitable for Doctrine reproof c. Again if it be said that Ministers are allowed to read all the Scriptures in publick and yet if men be tasked every Lords day and Holy day they must hold by their Task Page 78 For the more Solemnity of these readings our Church joyns with each of them Praises Thanksgivings or Confessiones according to what we find practiced in the Holy Scriptures Ans If what they joyn to these readings be not Instituted of God then let the Author conscientiously mind his second position Page 3. That the Holy Scriptures contain the Revelations of God's Will concerning his Worship and beware of adding or joyning what is not prescribed by these Scriptures Page 79 It 's ordered in our Church that the Ministers shall explain some part of the Holy Scriptures every Lords day and exhort their Congregations in a Sermon Ans If there be no more Scripture explained but the Text before a Sermon your hearers are at a great loss tho' you should read twenty Chapters every Lords day and explain nothing but a Text. SECT 3. Page 82. The Author chargeth dissenters with the neglect of teaching the principles of Religion saying That tho' a man frequent your meetings all his life yet he has no security or hardly possibility of Learning from your publick teachings all the great mysteries of his Religion or the necessary principles of his Faith And hence it happens that hardly any one man in his life ever goes through the necessary articles of Faith or of practice in his publick Sermons and for the truth of this I appeal to your selves Ans The Reader who is a stranger to us may readily think how can this be false being asserted by a person of such Note and with such confidence appealing also to our selves for it's truth and seing he hath appealed to our selves I declare upon certain knowledge that what he hath asserted is a most unjust imputation for which he hath cause to ask forgiveness of God and I do appeal to many thousand now living who are ordinarly witnessess to the contrary and many of the Authors own perswasion know the contrair with what peace of conscience can any man thus impose upon strangers And impress future generations with that which is so far from truth it being publickly known that we ordinarly and orderly go through all the Heads of our Christian Faith in our publick Sermons Page 82. You have no Summary of principles injoyned either to be read or taught in your publick Assemblies tâ— aâ— Catechism you have but neither your directory nor practice make it any part of your Lords-days-Service and besides your Catechism is such that it no wayes answers the design of a Form of sound words I have already shewed that such a Form should contain only the first and necessary principles of the Oracles of God in such words and methods as may make it easily apprehended and retained by the weak and unlearned which make up the bulk of the people but your Catechism is full of hard words School Terms and abstruse notions no wise necessary to be known by the generality of Christians c. Ans Our Catechism is above the Authors censure and men of as great Authority and abilities as he of his own perswasion have still spoken of that Book with regard and recommended it to others as sound and profitable he doth but lessen himself by his Reflections against that Composure let the Reader judge what mean arguments he hath against it only he sheweth what Spirit he is of 2ly Whereas it 's not injoyned as any part of our Lords-days-Service Ans Tho' our Catechism be a sound and full Summary of Christian principles yet we know it to be but a humane Composure and therefore make it no part of our worship if by Service he understandeth worship as he frequently useth these words Service and worship Promiscuously we must have Institution for what we offer to God in his Service yet these principles are frequently explained on the Lords day and that not only occasionally but in order according to the method of our Catechism 3ly But the Author hath shewed that such a Catechism should contain only c. Ans The Author hath said but not shewed to his Reader that it should be as he saith except all he saith must be taken for demonstration 4. But our Catechism is full of hard words Ans It s good the Author hath no worse to say otherways we should hear of it 2. But why doth he not give instances of these hard words Some who have read our Catechism say They find not such a hard word in it all as god father and god-mother nor such words as God the Son hath redeemed me and all mankind 3. It was necessary our Catechism should have words significant and expressive of the matter and if any of these words be less obvious to the capacity of young or ignorant people we are at pains to explain such words 5ly But our Catechism is too long Ans And what if the Catechism of some others be too short give instances of what is redundant or superfluous we would think our Catechism very defective if it wanted the Doctrine of the Creation and of Mans Fall from God the Attributes of God the Natures of Christ and his Offices the nature of Justifying Faith and Sanctification c. Page 83. Besides all this it is so long and intricat even the shorter that not one Child in ten ever gets it by heart nor one in five hundred retains it as I have found by experience Ans I would gladly be acted by the Spirit of meekness but the Author's words are so provocking even in
Private reading of Scriptures hath been signally blessed of God as to the Bereans who daily searched the Scriptures that they might understand what they heard in publick and know whether it were the truth of God or not this their private diligence was so blessed of God that there is a remark put upon it by the Holy Ghost Acts 17. 11. therefore many of them believed Page 88. It is therefore a great temptation to the people to be negligent and a great want of care in a Church to leave so material a thing as the reading of the word of God to private diligence Ans It 's great want of care in a Church when people are not exhorted to read Scriptures in private and to tell them as the Author doth Page 180 of his Book that some parcels of the Book of Common Prayer is as full and proper a service as any Master of a Family can desire to offer to God and no exhortation to read any portion of the Scriptures as immediatly Dictated by him But 2ly This is no pretence of ours against publick reading the Author misseth his mark He addeth That many of the common people of our perswasion are ignorant of the very History of the Bible Ans The Lord in mercy grant the people both of your perswasion and ours more true knowledge but some times there is a beam in a mans own eye when he challengeth a mote in anothers For the 2d pretence Page 89. That copies of the Bible are now common and easie to be had and most Families have some in them that can read Ans We have great reason to give thanks to God that it is so and the greater fault it is to neglect reading of Scriptures in Families seing God hath dealt so bountifully with us Page 90. And to rely upon peoples procuring and reading copies of the Bible privatly is to leave Gods way and presumptuously depend on that which has no promise annexed to it Ans If privat reading of the Scriptures have no promise annexed to it then what profit is it for any man to read the Scripture if no blessing be promised his labour is lost if I had not read this expression in the Author's Book it would been hard believing any report that such dangerous unwarrantable words could have dropt from his Pen. 2ly God hath commanded privat reading of the Scriptures as expresly as he hath commanded publick reading whereby it becometh the Ordinance of God no less than publick reading let the Reader observe what God speaketh Deut. 6. from verse 6. and downward The Laws of God were to be written on the very posts of their houses that they might read them frequently 3ly Seing then this privat reading of the Word of God is his Ordinance no less than publick reading by what warrand can the Author say there is no promise annexed to it But besides this 4ly I will prove from the Word of God that promises are annexed to the People of God's privat Diligence in reading the Scriptures Let the Reader observe Deut 6. verse 3 where we have these words Hear therefore O Israel and observe to do it that it may be well with thee and that ye may increase mightily as the Lord God of thy fathers hath promised thee in the Land that floweth with milk and honey Here is a comprehensive promise containing many blessings That it may be well with thee and next the qualifications of the persons to whom this Promise belongeth followeth verse 5. Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thine heart Verse 6. and these words which I command thee this day shall be in thine heart and verse 7. And thou shalt teach them diligently unto thy children and shalt talk of them when thou sittest in thine house And verse 9 Thou shalt write them upon the posts of thine house and one thy gates By which Scripture its evident that such as diligently make use of the Word of God in their Houses have the promise of God that it shall be well with them Let the Author find out a more express promise made to publick reading than is here to privat reading then it s no presumption to depend on this promise annexed to privat reading Ibid There are still many families even amongst Protestants that can neither compass a Bible or get any to read it Ans Blessed be God that even poor people among us will pinch themselves rather than want a Bible and such as are so very poor that they cannot procure one it were charity in the Author who is able to provide some Bibles for such indigent persons As for these who cannot read where God giveth a heart for it they take help of their Neighbours who can read 2. The Author injuriously supposeth them to be deprived of all publick reading of the Word of God which I have proved already to be an unjust imputation ibid and there are at this day too many of all parties that neither read themselves nor hear one Chapter read in a whole year except at Church Ans And no great wonder if they never be exhorted to privat reading in their Families and withal told that there is no promise annexed to privat reading which is not only comfortless and discouraging Doctrine if they have no promise of God to be bettered by their reading but pernitious to the souls of men Page 92. The Author saith That the word of God cannot be presumed to have the same efficacy when read privatly as it hath when read in the Assemblies of Christians since he has given us a peculiar promise to be present in such Assemblies Ans The promise of this peculiar presence is Matth. 18. 20. Where two or three are met together in my name c. The presence promised in this Scripture belongeth not only to publick Assemblies but even to two or three meeting in Christs Name for his Worship then a privat Family if they were but two if they meet together for his Worship agreeing together to ask of God according to the Command of God these few Christians thus met together have the promise of Christs presence no less secured unto them than if the Assembly were greater Christs own words prove this to be undenyable Page 92. The third pretence alledged is that reading takes up too much time and is a hinderance to the more profitable Duty of what you commonly call preaching Ans It s tedious to be always put to declare that not one of these pretences are ours The Author may debate against himself if he will yet Page 93. The Author giveth a new Concession which is in my opinion too ample and more than we desire or resolve to practise when he saith Suppose that upon some extraordinary occasion it may be lawful to omit reading of Gods Word in our Assemblies that we may have the more time to manage a Discourse for the instruction of the people Ans If there be time to manage a Discourse I do
not think it lawful altogether to omit reading of the Word of God in a publick Christian Assembly conveened for the Worship of God for we are to expect the Assembly sanctified by the Word and Prayer to pass from much reading to no reading is too great haste Page 94. His fourth pretence is That the Scriptures are hard to be understood or applyed and therefore only so much of them ought to be read at a time as the Minister may apply to his Auditory Ans Albeit this pretence or Objection hath more to say for it self than the rest Yet we pretend to no manner of Reason against publick reading seing its both our principle and practice therefore it s not candide to represent us to the World as enemies to it and disputing against our common practice 2ly To Explain Scripture to the people we judge necessary and the very way of God fitted for Edification practised by our Saviour himself the Levites the Prophets and the Apostles and to represent us as Expounding or applying only a Verse is not fair that being your own way not ours to explain but a verse or two on the Lords Day it being common with us to expound ten times more Scripture every Lords Day than you do conceiving it a very mean discharge of a Ministers duty only to read and so have done and never found to be the way of Christ or any of his Apostles whose work in publick was always to Expound and apply Scripture and therefore our way in publick Gospel administrations is more agreeable to Christ and his Apostles way than yours Page 94. It s the opinion of the Reformed Churches that the Scriptures are plain in all things necessary to Salvation Ans And yet it s the general opinion of the Reformed Churches that Scripture should be Expounded to the people 2ly Though God in his mercy hath made the Essentials of Christianity plain yet nevertheless the Apostle made it his care to make known the whole counsel of God we are obliged to make full proof of our Ministry in helping the people to know their whole duty to God revealed in the Scripture 3ly If this argument of the author hath any strength it militateth against all Ministerial Instructions and that no more is necessary but read the Foundamentals of the Christian Religion to the people and so have done 4ly Do not some wrest the Scriptures to their own destruction and whose duty is it so much as Ministers to prevent this danger by explaining these things that are hard to be understood But the Author still appears out of Charity with this Explaining and applying for Ibid The holy Scriptures when heard with humility and attention apply themselves better than any man can do Ans If it were as the Author saith then there is little use for a Ministry in the World and at most a reading ministry might do all let them but read well and the Scriptures will apply themselves the Christian World then is but cheated to be at so vast a charge for maintaining Ministers only to read 2ly To say that Scriptures apply themselves without any adventitous help or assistance is not sound the Author should leave place at least for the help of the Spirit of God without which Scripture will never apply themselves 3ly The Author here disputeth against the very Examples that Christ and his Apostles hath given us in applying of Scriptures not being of his mind that the Scriptures would apply themselves 4ly If the Scriptures apply themselves How was it then that the Disciples of Christ who cannot be said to want humility and attention and had often heard the Scripture yet continued so slow either to understand or believe the Scriptures they could never find the Scriptures applying themselves until Christ opened the eyes of their understanding Page 95. It ought therefore to be our first care to read them to the people often and solemnly that they may be acquainted with the whole body of them and then one word of Application may do more good than many Sermons Ans Besides all the Scriptures that we solemnly read and make use of in our publick Assemblies wherein we are not behind with our neighbours I say besides it s our care to exhort our people to diligence in reading Scriptures in privat for the increase of Scripture knowledge the performance whereof they find to be blessed of God according to his promise Wishing our Neighbours were more exhorted to the same duty this serveth also to refel the Calumny insinuated in the Authors following words saying That our not reading looketh like a design on the people and is agreeable to the artifices of Romish Priests This Suggestion is irrational to say that Ministers are on a design of concealing Scriptures who exhort beseech and obtest the people to diligence in reading them in so much that its censurable amongst us if there be a known and common neglecter of this duty I wish these words Psal 15. 3. be dayly considered What the Author Pages 96 97 and 98 delivereth requireth no answer containing no new Argument and for calling the Scriptures a dead letter we abhor it tho the Author makes it the fifth pretence against reading Page 99. The pretence is That a Child may read the Scriptures and so perform this Duty Ans Neither do we make this a pretence against publick reading for tho it be true upon the matter that a Child may read yet we know that reading the Word of God in publick Christian Assemblies belongeth to the Ministers of the Gospel and accordingly we practise and employ no Children for that Work Page 100. The Author giveth instance of an advice in our Directory To read over all the Canonical Books of Scripture in order Ans Let the Reader observe that there 's no Apocripha to be read by this Advice 2ly That they directed no Canonical Scripture to be lest out of publick Gospel administrations so that they were on no design to conceal Scriptures from the people 3ly I know where this of reading the Scriptures in order was not only designed but begun by some of our number and considerable progress made but Persecution driving them from publick work and the people of our perswasion under great sufferings their Ministers were constrained to select such Scriptures as were most apposit for instructing exhorting and comforting an afflicted people All that I find further to the end of this Chapter beareth no argument but are meer groundless Invectives and I shall only say that if I found my self so keen for much publick reading and inclined to discourage privat reading of the Word of God I could not but suspect my self to be acted by a Pharisaical Spirit CHAP. 4. Of Bodily VVorship SECT 1. I Find a great Defect in all the Authors Discourse by his not stating the question betwixt Dissenters and him upon any of the Heads he Treateth which method requireth to be first done that so the Reader might know
they are ready to erre not knowing the Scriptures yea to wrest them to their own destruction as others have done before them 3ly They find by the Book ground to fear dangerous Doctrine concerning Prayer observing how frequently conceived prayers are exposed as meer invention which they know to be allowed by Christ practised by his Apostles and generally all the godly whose prayers are recorded in Scripture and themselves by experience finding the gracious promised help of the spirit of Grace and Supplications assisting them in Prayer softning their hearts and bringing them into Communion with God without the words of any Form 4ly By the Book they are discouraged to read the Scriptures in privat seing its alledged there 's no promise to such reading they know not but they might hear as they read and have no mind to be tempted to negligence in reading the Scriptures knowing that God hath both promised a blessing to such reading of his Word and actually blessed their own Souls in performing that Duty yea the greatest Lights of all the antient Fathers have left it on record that privat reading the Scriptures was the very mean God blessed for their conversion to Christianity 5ly That assertion that such as cannot fit themselves for receiving at the Lords Table thrice a year must needs think themselves out of a state of Grace and so deserve to be excommunicated Is such a Thunder Bolt as hath frighted many into a greater distance than ever lest themselves should be so served and that only for their weakness because they cannot fit themselves many are ready to look upon it as having too direct a tendency to desperation if poor Souls should be cast out of the Church for their weakness for some well meaning people might be tempted to think they were cast out of Gods favour because cast out of the Church 6ly Many Readers find in the Book Scriptures quoted for that which they do not prove and sometime that called the Command of God which he never commanded this also frighteth from hearing lest they hear as they read 7ly We are told that the mode of entring Churches is with some bodily Worship but this being religious Worship we must know what is its Object for the second Command dischargeth our worshipping of God by Images or the likeness of any thing but this worship as hath been proved in its due place is first directed to the Fabrick of an House 8ly We are told by the Book that we must kneel in the act of receiving Bread and Wine at the Lords Supper but the second Command standeth in our way here also discharging religious Worship designedly before any Creatures this also I have proved in its proper place I shall forbear though I might add moe instances whereby its evident we are bolted out from that joyning in Worship and Sacraments which is required of us There is no more in this Epistle but what is particularly answered already in the proper places but Page 175. Complaint is made that many Children die un-baptized for want of Ministers of our own Communion Ans The Parents of these Children have much more ground of complaint against those who deprive them of that benefit by appointing two Sacraments of Baptism whereas Christ did institute but one the sign of the Cross being used a humane Sacrament who can blame conscientious Parents rather to suffer to their grief than countenance such an encroachment on Christs prerogative and so partake of other mens sins Ibid We have a warning against our Brethren of the Congregational-way and page 177 Now we think in justice to your own cause as well as to us ye ought to warn your people against these Books that maintain principles contrary to us both Ans Overtures of this nature are unseasonable since God in his great mercy is hearing the Prayers and granting the long hoped for desires of his people in healing the breaches between them us which we take as a token for good from the hand of our God wishing that none may envy so great a benefit to the Church of God Page 178. The last thing required is to beat down vices and immoralities Ans This is the duty of all Christians in their several stations but especially the Ministers of the Gospel who are obliged to rebuke with all authority and themselves to be so blameless that they may not be ashamed to reprove others not more guilty than themselves 2ly Confâ—â—â—nce also should be made that the greatest severity be exerted against the greatest offences it being an inaccountable abuse of discipline when its severest lashes are on the most conscientious 3ly â—ough we have no cause to pretend to that piety of conversâ—â—â—â— which is commanded which we should be daily breathing after perfecting holiness in the fear of God yet its observeable that the most vitious are the greatest haters of our assemblies the profligat debauches God-dammes the Bloud and Wounds where they go we know not but they never come near us To the Dissenting Laity of the Diocess of Derry PAge 181. I beseech you in the spirit of meekness as one that is appointed by the providence of God and the care of a Christian Magistracy to watch over your souls that you will seriously consider and lay to heart what I have here tendered to you Ans As for the Authors Title to the charge of Souls in this Diocess whatsoever he hath by Christian Magistracy I dispute not but what is said to be by the Providence of God shall be considered A Title by meer Providence is very bare and insufficient for an Officer in the House of God who should be instructed with a commission from Christ for watching over Souls Providence not being our Bible where only such commissions are registred 2ly It 's said he is the one that is appointed to watch then he is the one Pastor of the whole Diocess sure so vast a district must be at a great loss to have but one Pastor and his Clergy under great grievance and discouragement since none of them can speak to the people where they officiat with Ministerial authority as their Pastors though some of them may be found knowing and moderat men of as good qualifications for Pastoral Charge as some of their betters 3ly If it be said that the sole Pastor of the Diocess doth communicat and devolve on the Inferiour Clergy some parts of his Pastoral power I then demand where we shall find in any Gospel record such a sett of ordained Ministers of the Gospel that are half Pastors having some parts but not intire Ministerial power for feeding and overseeing their flock 4ly I desire therefore in few words to know whether any of the Clergy under the Author be Pastors yea ar not If they be Pastors according to Christs institution then the Author is not the sole Pastor in the Diocess if they are not Pastors then the Diocess should be inavoidably miserable having but one Pastor who is