whole Duty of Man If one that holds all necessary Christian Truths happen yet to be in some Error we are not for this to despise his Person or forsake his Communion Bishop Reynold 's Brotherly Agreement In the case of unavoidable Differences amongst good Men there ought to be mutual Charity c. not to judge despise reject insult over one another not to deal with the weaker as Aliens but as Brethren not to proceed presently unto Separation Rejection Anathematization but to restore those that are overtaken with an Error in the spirit of Meekness Dr. Alestry Serm. 9. pag. 170. Censuring the abuse of Excommunication If they be not so happy as to be Orthodox sending them down to Hell directly Dr. Barrow In his Vnity of the Church Speaking of the Roman Churches If Churches do maintain impious Errors if they do prescribe naughty practices if they do reject communion and peace upon reasonable Tearms if they vent unjust and uncharitable censures c. If they damn and persecute all that refuse to be their Subjects in such cases we may Reject such Churches as Heretical or Schismatical or wickedly uncharitable and unjust in their proceedings Dr. More in his Pref. to the Mistery of Godliness pag. 19. The Object of Church discipline ought to contain nothing but the indisputable Truths of our Religion namely the generally acknowledged Articles of the Christian Faith and plain indispensable Duties of Life for these are such as deserve to be held up with all possible care and strictness Other things so gently recommended that no conscientious man may be pinched by them Dr. Stillingfleet 's Preface to Irenicum What possible Reason can be assigned why such things should not be sufficient for communion with a Church which are sufficient for Eternal Salvatition And certainly those things are sufficient for that which are laid down as necessary Duty 's of Christianity by our Lord and Saviour in his Word Dr. Cave 's Gospel preached to the Romans Serm. 4. pag. 89. God be thanked such is the present Moderation of our Churches Ecclesiastical constitutions our penalties are not for Destruction but for correction and amendment we punish none for their bare opinions and readily embrace every Returning Penitent Item pag. 87. We must above all things put on Charity and when we come to reprove rebuke and to inflict Spiritual Censures and Punishments we must distinguish as tenderly as we can between the wilful and the weak the obstinate and the Ignorant the obstinate we must endeavour to save with Fear plucking them out of the Fire with them we must be more sharp and severe in our Admonitions and Threatnings But on the weak we must have Compassion who may be supposed to Err through simplicity or the fervors of Devotion and ought to be treated with a fatherly Tenderness for to be restored if possible conformable unto the Doctrine of St. Paul to Timothy with the Spirit of meekness Stop to the Course of Separation The just Reasons of Excommunication are the same all over the World which is obstinate persisting in great Transgressions of the general Precepts of the Gospel At the end of the Book Vnion of the Catholick Church pag. 10. Every difference in Judgment when no violence is offered to the Catholick Faith and Unity must not break this Communion according to that profession of St. Cyprian judging no man nor excluding him from the Right of Communion if he think otherwise where the dispute was thought of no mean concernment Which St. Augustine often alledgeth against the Donatists and condemns Victor pag. 11 th who was hastening to Excommunicate the Asian Churches for their difference in Celebration of Easter True State of the Primitive Church Be charitable to the weak proceed not so severely against them in your Courts of Judicature but Remember what St. Paul says Col. 2. in respect of Ceremonies Let no man judge you c. Will you in respect of such shadows judge Excommunicate Sentence to Everlasting Flames the Soul that holds of the Body of Christ believes all his Holy Gospel accords with you in one Faith one Baptisme c. Will you condemn such an one to Eternal Death God Forbid Conformists Plea for the Nonconformists Part 4. pag. 101. We can represent and inveigh against Schism as the sin against the Holy Ghost A Sin unto Death indeed in some sence because it is so contrary to Charity and Peace and destructive of the Life of Saints which doth much consist in their Communion But were we impartial we should as warmly admonish our own hearts to take heed of Schismatical Passions and excommunicate them from within us as admonish and cast out others that differ from us Idem pag. 20. We are forward to blame the more rigid sort of Separatists for not coming to our Worship and why are we so rigid as to forbear all Christian Communion with them as if Christianity were all lost among them I do declare that I hold Mental Communion with all the Holy Brethren and am prepared for Local and External Communion with them in all Christian Duties and Ordinances Dr. Hammond 's Annotations on the New Testament Rom. 14.17,18 Christianity consists not in such External Matters as Meats but in the practice of Christian Vertues such are Mercifulness and Peaceableness c. not dividing and hating and Excommunicating one another and 14. chap. ver 13. And therefore let this Fault be mended do not any longer Censure and seperate from one anothers Communion for such things as these Doctor Hammond of Schism p. 16. Because the Governours being men may possibly Err and consequently censure and Excommunicate the innocent its possible the person excluded may be innocent he that is Excommunicate unjustly cannot be rendred criminous by that misfortune p. 17. he cites Photius Patriarch of Constantinople the Excommunication of the Jewish Sanhedrim sent out against Christs Disciples brought them so much nearer to their Lord and Master and Alien'd the Jews themselves removed them so much the farther from the Kingdom of Heaven and so doth all unjust Excommunication unite us to the Apostles by this Conformity with and participation of their sufferings Bishop Jewels defence of the Apol. p. 583. Brings in St. Augustine saying Quid obest homini What is a man the worse if the ignorance of a man strike him out of the Book of the Church if ill conscience strike him not out of the Book of Life In this case St. Augustine saith it cometh sometime to pass Vt plurimae sint foris oves intus Lupi That there be many Sheep without the Church and many Wolves within And in your own Law Mr Harding it is written thus Qui illicite alium Excom c. He that unlawfully Excommunicates another condemneth himself and not another That our Love must be Catholick HOmily of Christian Love and Charity p. 36. Charity is to love every man good and evil friend and foe and whatsoever Cause be given to the Contrary yet
agree upon such things as might conduce to the maintenance and defence of the Reformed Protestant Religion with due consideration for all just and reasonable ease to tender Consciences Item in the Kings Second Message for Peace January 29 1645. That by the Liberty offered in the fifteenth present for the ease of their Consciences who communicate not in the Service already established by Act of Parliament in this Kingdom he intends that all other Protestants behaving themselves peaceably in and towards the Civil Government shall have the free exercise of their Religion in their own way Item to the Prince of Wales The charitable connivance and Christian Toleration often dissipates their strength whom rougher opposition fortifies Dr. Hammond 's Sermons pag. 72. I am confident there were no such way of designing a prosperous flourishing durable Kingdom as to found its Polity upon Gospel Principles and maintain it by the Gospel Spirit id est of Love and Meekness I have Authority to think that was the meaning of the Prophesie of Christs turning Swords into Plough-shares c. Advice to the Church of England Roman Catholicks and Protestant Dissenters tells us pag. 23. Dr. Hammond left it to the Witnesses of his End as his dying Counsel to the Church of England that they displaced no man out of the Universities or present Church but that by Love and an Holy Life they should prevail upon those in possession then to come into their Church Which he had as he tells us from an eminent hand in Oxford a year or two after the Doctors Death Mr. Hales of Erring Christians pag. 26. Edit 2. The Christians were called Chrestiani from a word signifying benignity and sweetness What reason is there why that should not be one of the chiefest notes of the Church of Christ which did so especially characterize a Christian man except there were a decay of it at this day in the Church Georgius a Factious Bishop of Alexandria is said oblitus professionis suae quae nil nisi justum suadet bene Quite besides his profession whose especial notes were Gentleness and Equity in the sense of the Heathen Ammianus Marcellinus King Charles the Second in a Declaration from Breda was for Liberty to Tender Consciences and sayes that no man shall be disquieted for Differences in Opinion in Matters of Religion which do not disturb the Peace of the Kingdom pag. 5. and 18. This Declaration his Majesty afterwards May 8. 1661. tearms a Promise solemnly made This Declaration or Promise he tells both Houses July 8 1661. that so oft as he comes to them he mentions his Declaration from Breda that himself as well as they might mind it In his Majesties Declaration of Decemb. 26 1662. He tells us that he remembers the very words of the Promises from Breda that concern'd Liberty of Conscience and the confirmations he hath made of them since upon several Occasions and that he is still firm in Resolution of performing them to the full He tells what hindered But it must not be wondered at since that Parliament to which those promises were made in relation to an Act never thought fit to offer us any to that purpose His Majesty publickly declared his avowed readiness in his Proclamation July 16. 1669. to indulge Tender Consciences Bishop Bramhall 's Just Vindication c. pag. 279. Men may vary in their Judgments and yet preserve Christian Unity and Charity in their Affections one towards another so as Errours be not destructive to Fundamental Articles Bishop Gauden of slight Healing pag. 102. That Lenitive of Equanimity Forbearance and Moderation in respect of Conscientious Dissenters from the publick Consent Customs and Constitutions in the Church which Christian Charity requires and publick peace with safety may bear Idem pag. 93. Scandalous for any to plead that they may have Liberty or Toleration for that which by publique Advice and upon due search is found to be such as is prone to endanger or disorder and infect the whole Bishop Reynold 's Brotherly Reconciliation pag. 19. In this case of unavoidable differences among good men there ought to be Mutual Charity Meekness Moderation Tolerance Humanity used Idem pag. 25. Brings in a saying of Mr. Calvin such a man saith he is a sincere Minister of Christ a godly and a moderate Man therefore though he dissent from us I will not cease to love him still Bishop Taylor 's Collection of Discourses pag. 603. To refuse our Charity to those who have the same Faith because they have not all our Opinions and believe not every thing necessary which we over-value is Impious and Schismatical and to this sense is that of St. Paul If I had all Faith and have not Charity I am nothing c. Idem If men please what-ever advantages would be consequent to an Unity of perswasion may be supplied by a charitable compliance and mutual permission of Opinion prescribed us by the Lawes of Christianity Idem Epist before Lib. of Proph. in Collection of Discourses c. I thought it might not misbecome my duty and endeavours to plead for Peace and Charity and Forgiveness and Permissions mutual And in Defence of that Piece in the Second Edition Now I have done all that I can do onely I cannot repent me of speaking Truth or doing Charity I Answer whatsoever is against the Foundation of Faith or contrary to good Life and the Lawes of Obedience or destructive to humane Societies and the publick and just interests of Bodies Politick is out of the limits of my Question for Toleration Idem I think I have spoken reason in my Book and examined it with all the severity that I have I writ this because I thought it was necessary and seasonable and charitable and agreeable to the great precepts and design of Christianity consonant to the practice of the Apostles and of the best Ages of the Church and of the nature of the thing Bishop Hacket 's Sermon on Acts 5.39 p. 22. An Unanimity of Opinions is not necessary to Friendships saith Aristotle very well Dear Friends may retain the sweetness of love together and yet vary in some conclusion of Judgments a little more may be granted that each may be earnest to win the other to assent Idem pag. 25. But if sundry shapes and appearances of reason will not suffer us all to enjoy the same Knowledge and the same Conscience yet let us Dissent as Brethren and not as Enemies Bishop Saunderson 's Serm. 9. ad Aulam Sect. 23. We see Philosophers Lawyers and Physitians confuting one anothers Opinions in great Volumes and we allow it in them but difference in Opinions is more tolerable in Divinity by how much the things about which we are conversant are of a more sublime mysterious and of an incomprehensible Nature than are those of other Sciences Bishop Wilkins Sermons on Rom. 14. p. 57. There are several Truths which are not of so great consequence as Unity Peace and Charity and