Doctrine and Ceremonies which they have added in the latter hundred yeers without and against Gods Word Also there are two sorts of people amongst them The One who in their Christianity onely and principally cleave to the indubitable universal Apostolick Creed which they with us are baptized unto so that they seek onely 〈◊〉 salvation in Jesus Christ the crucified as their own Mediator and Saviour and testifie such beleef of theirs in the effect by Christian charity and godly conversation who also consequently will not condemn us as Hereticks who are united in spirit with them in such universal saving Faith working through love much lesse persecute us with hostility unlesse it were out of meer ignorance because they have no true information of our Doctrine and Faith How should we then condemn them Much more reason have we to account such Catholicks for true Evangelical and not for Popish Christians because their salvation is grounded not upon their own merits and satisfaction or upon other Popish traditions and Auxiliary concomitant means but onely upon the meer grace of God and the precious Redemption of our Lord Jesus Christ And that there hath been at all times a great number of such people and are still at this present even in the midst of Popery not onely the experience of them that live amongst them but their own Books before and after Luther's times do testifie it As Bernardi Anselmi Gersonis Tauleri Thomae de Kempis Erasmi Cassandri Feri Cardinalis Contareni Hosij Pighij Coloniensium in Anti-didagmate Enchiridio and of a great many more Especially their ancient Manuals concerning Meditations upon death which were commonly used a great while before Luther's times wherein the dying persons from all meritorious works and satisfaction and from all other humane means of salvation are onely directed to the precious merit and intercession of the onely Mediator and Redeemer Jesus Christ Formulae interrogandi infirmos inter Epistolas Anselmi Ars benè moriendi Monachi cujusdam Cisterciensis Hortulus Animae Georg. Cassander in Append. Opusc Joh. Roffensis Hosius in Confess Petricov cap. 73. Sacerdotale Roman Edit Venet. Ann. 1555. fol. 116. Sacra Institutio baptizandi Edit Paris Ann. 1575. fol. 35. Ordo baptizandi cum modo visitandi Edit Venet. Ann. 1575. fol. 34. In which Book the Spanish Inquisitors have ordained in their twofold Indice Expurgatorio Annis 1584. 1612. to deface and omit these Questions and Answers following Sacerdos Credis non propriis meritis sed Passionis Domini nostri Jesu Christi virtute merito ad gloriam pervenire Respondeat infirmus Credo Sacerdos Credit quòd Dominus noster Jesus Christus pro nostra salute mortuus sit quod ex propriis meritis vel alio modo nullus possit salvari nisi in merito passionis ejus Respondeat infirmus Credo By the Omission of which words they testifie against themselves that those amongst them who examined the dying persons upon this beleef wherein the principal fundamental Doctrine of salvation consisteth and died upon it have been verily addicted to our Evangelical Faith and Doctrine of the Church and not to their Popish beleef and doctrine And although such men have also adhered in their ignorance to some erroneous opinions according to the common course of those times out of want of better information yet they cannot be condemned or accounted for non-Evangelical because they fixed their comfort and hope of their salvation not upon such erroneous Doctrines not upon merits and invocation of Saints not upon Masses for the souls of the deceased 〈◊〉 â—pon Indulgences not upon Monastical orders and such other like things but onely upon Gods meer grace and mercy in Christ Jesus the crucified To the Objection that may be made That they neverthelesse went to Masse which we count Idolatrie and consequently must condemn all those as meer Idolaters We answer That such men went to Masse in the simplicity of their heart not even according to the new Masse-doctrine which but in the Councel of Lateran Ann. 1218. and after in the Councel of Trent was canonized but according to the pure ancient and simple beleef of Christs words in the holy Communion wherein even yet the moderate Papists so far must agree with us that it is Sacrificium commemorativum A Commemoration and Remembrance of Christs Sacrifice finished upon the Crosse and a spiritual meat of our souls Wherefore there is no doubt but many religious and pious hearts have at all times understood and eaten it after a spiritual sort who heard little or nothing of the Scholastical disceptations of Transubstantiation and had not yet known the depths of Satan as was said of those in Thyatira Revel 2. v. 24. Or have expresly rejected them and beleeved nothing else concerning the Holy Communion but what next to Augustine and other ancient Fathers and Doctors of the Church Bertramus or Ratramus in the times of Carolus Calvus when the disputes of this subject had their first beginning hath declared in his Book De Corpore Sanguine Christi who at all times was accounted for a true Catholick Teacher And though some had beleeved the real and corporal presence and oral manducation of Christs Body in the Masse Yet we should have as little reason to condemn them as the Lutherans if they have but grounded the principal comfort and hope of their salvation not upon the carnal but spiritual eating of Christs Body as being the onely Sacrifice and Propitiation for their sins Likewise though they have much declined in the Ceremonies of the Masse from Christs first Institution and have added thereunto many humane partly superstitious partly idolatrous Ceremonies Yet all those cannot presently be accounted for damnable Idolaters who in those times and places where the Supper of the Lord was not otherwise to be had nor the errour made yet so apparently evident went to the common Masse in their simplicity because of the remnant of Christs Institution therein to the end that they might be made partakers of Christs Body and Blood for the quickning of their souls Like as they used the Holy Baptism for to cleanse and wash them from their sins notwithstanding the superstitious humane Ceremonies that were added thereunto Who also though they kneeled down before the consecrated bread and wine being a Sacramental token of remembrance and exhibitive signe of Christs Body and Blood like as the Lutherans also at the administration of their Communion and the Reformed Protestants in England use to do Yet have not fixed the Adoration and confidence of their hearts on the bread and wine but on Christ himself sitting on the right hand of his Father in Heaven And therefore are much lesse to be esteemed Idolaters then for their kneeling and bowing down before painted 〈◊〉 carved Crucifixes which Christ never ordained for signes of remembâ—◠〈◊〉 instead of adoring Jesus Christ in Heaven Though we must confesse that all such things have been used in Popery at
A TREATISE TOUCHING THE Peace of the Church OR AN APOSTOLICAL RULE how to judge aright in Differences which concern Religion JOHN 7. v. 24. Judge not according to the appearance but judge righteous Judgement PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY LONDON Printed for George Thomason and are to be sold at his Shop at the Rose and Crown in Pauls Church-yard 1646. To the Reverend Pious and Learned Assembly of Divines conven'd at Westminster by the Authority of the Parliament for consultation in matters of Religion REVEREND SIRS COnsidering with my self with a charitable and tender commiseration the pestiferous and pernicious Heresies Schisms Divisions and Sects wherewith since the Apostles times the Christian both Eastern and Western Churches were ever continually infested distracted and torn in peeces I make no question but you will confesse that the latter two rents the One between the Christian-Protestants and Roman-Catholicks the Other between us and the Evangelical-Lutherans which in our Predecessours dayes sprung originally in Germany then were dispersed over the face of the Universal-Occidental-Christian-World and at this present are grown to the highest pitch of desolation and devastation of Christendom were fomented with more unchristian and inhuman cruelty bitternesse calumnies slanders oppressions persecutions and effusion of blood then ever you heard or read in Ecclesiastical Histories of any other Religion in the World And consequently acknowledge that such distractions and disorders of the Christian Church proceed from no other ground then from an unseasonable uncharitable rash presumptuous and unjust judging and condemning one another Wherefore we shall do very well exactly to search and inquire which of these three principal divided and dissenting Churches is guilty or innocent of such a prejudicial Schism and Separation to the end that we may know and discern which side to imbrace and give assent unto and which not And that the true undeniable orthodoxal Doctrine and Religion of the true Evangelical Reformed Protestants may not be condemned and rejected by any incompetent Judge as false erroneous heretical and damnable in regard that Spiritual and Ecclesiastical matters are commonly as much obnoxious to ill managing as Civil and Temporal It is by all means expedient and requisite for us to repaire to such a Judge who betwixt us and others may determine and decide the Controversie and Difference by an infallible Sentence from which we cannot appeal And whereas the Papists do attribute such full and absolute determination to the Catholick Church or as they declare it themselves to the Pope as the Supream Head of the Church either himself alone or with assistance of a Councel of Cardinals Bishops and Prelates depending on him and representing the whole Universal Church I am perswaded we with all Christian Protestants cannot nor will submit to any other Judge in matters of Religion but to the Holy Scripture or to the Lord our God himself who in his Sacred Word hath prescribed his Will and Decision to the Christian Church which we onely closely and positively must adhere and stick unto For this Volume of the Holy Scripture I mean not any other Books more or lesse then those that by inspiration of the Holy Ghost were written of the Prophets and Apostles and left to the Primitive Church which from it were spred amongst all Nations and in the middest of darknesse and unfaithful heresies by Gods singular Providence preserved and in their original Tongues conveyed unto us being the indubitable Word of God whose Divine Power Light Vertue and Operation all true Beleevers feel in their hearts and consciences and containing though not the decision of all Theological Questions and Controversies yet all Articles of Faith and Doctrine necessary for every true Christians Salvation It is manifest that the Church or they that have the charge over it whether they be called Popes Cardinals Bishops or Divines and Teachers or general Councels have not any power and jurisdiction to decide determine and wrest the Doctrines to their arbitrary judgement and pleasure but onely a ministerial function to teach and demonstrate by Warrant from the Word of God whether and how they are decided in it neither to force their doubtful and undecided Opinions upon any man sub Anathemate or Excommunication unlesse he should reject the Word of God in any fundamental and necessary Article of Faith or plain Declaration thereof or cry up his own erroneous and controverted opinions interpretations consequences and inferences for the Word of God it self and necessary Articles of Faith to the disturbance and distraction of the Christian Church And this is that the Papists cast continually into the Lutherans and Reformed Protestants teeth That notwithstanding they still refer themselves to the perfect and infallible Rule of the Word of God yet for all this they will be themselves infallible Judges by obstructing and imposing their own particular expositions and inferences on others The Lutherans indeed especially which are called Lutherani rigidi the grosser sort who are so strictly addicted Formulae Concordiae Saxonicae that they bind not onely their Faith and Doctrine unto it but also all others that dissent from them in their particular interpretations and opinions principally in the Point of Consubstantiation and Omnipresence of Christs Body and its oral manducation by excluding them from the Communion of the Christian Church and depriving them of Publick Offices and Dignities as long as they do obstinately persist in their arrogant judging and condemning will have a very hard task to clear themselves of this charge The Vindication of the Protestant Reformed Churches how that they onely depend on the Word of God and not on any mans interpretation and opinion much lesse presume to impose them on others as necessary unto Salvation but impart and permit to every one the due Libertie of Conscience without transgressing the true Limits and Rules of Gods Truth and the Christian Charity hath been of late sufficiently and punctually for the true and better information of them that are misinformed exhibited in high Dutch by D. John Bergius Chaplaine to His Highnesse the Prince Elector of Brandenbourg Author of this Treatise One of the best Learned Divines Germany at this present affordeth a primitive Catholick Christian and down-right Protestant in such a plain and perspicuous way that even the most ignorant and unlearned who are not able to peruse great Volumes may palpably see and perceive the falsehood and slanders that are laid at all Christian Protestants doors And withall since the Reformed Protestant Churches cannot hope for any Ecclesiastical Peace and Unitie both in Church and Common-wealth whilest the vehemency and fiercenesse in judging and condemning of the said Papists and Lutherans is not appeased and mitigated He representeth and declareth to them an Infallible Apostolical Direction and Rule in general what and how far men are bound in conscience to judge and not to judge in matters of Religion and then by way of application How far they ought to judge the Roman-Catholicks and Lutherans
in their Doctrine and Religion or to separate themselves from them or to reform them Which Treatise having been so happy to peruse by the communication of my worthy Friend and Countrey-man Master Jaspar Godeman whom I always in his frequent conversation perceived a singular Well-wisher to an Ecclesiastical Unitie I have immediately betaken my self to the Translation thereof much animated and incouraged by his and divers others good advice accompanied with these two pregnant Motives The One That this subject is the most necessary and profitable of all Theological Controversies and Questions that now adayes are in agitation and may much conduce if not to the advancement of an Universal Peace and Unitie of all Churches which though it was always earnestly desired of men truely zealous and Christians so that Learned Calvin offering his Service therein to that worthy man Doctor Cranmer said It would not grieve him to saile over ten Seas to such a purpose yet proved a work of insuperable difficultie and altogether impossible in mens eyes at least to promote the Christian agreement and reconciliation or mitigation of the distractions of all Kingdoms Principalities and Free-States that have abandoned the Superstitions and pernicious Leaven of the Romish Church For the effecting whereof not onely the Protestant Churches and Divines in Germany have had in former times several Conferences at Marpurg Wittenberg and of late at Leipzig but also at these present times that Famous and Reverend Divine Master John Durey first stirred up by that excellent Instrument Master James Godeman Father of the worthy Gentleman aforementioned One of His Majesty the King of Sweden's Privy Counsellor and President of his Court of Appellations in the Precinct of Prussia and then seconded with hearty wishes tnd prayers of many pious and learned Divines in England France and Scotland hath these fifteen yeers to my knowledge imployed his indefatigable endeavours and singular industry in Germany Sweden Denmark and Low-Countreys and not without hopeful successe having at length prevailed so much with the Lutherans especially in Sweden that they not onely have given over their slanders and calumniations in the Pulpit but also are contented to be called Evangelical Protestants agreeing with us in the mean time in the name and walking by the same Rule so far as they have already attained till God reveal unto them what is remaining The Other Motive is That also this subject would be most seasonable for these tempestuous and turbulent times which the Church and State of England at this present groaneth and laboureth under and which if we will seriously inquire into doth proceed originally from no other cause then uncharitablenesse and acrimony in judging and condemning one another And consequently Reverend Sirs it will be useful and profitable for every one in particular whereby being peradventure carried away with rashnesse and vehemency as naturally all men are inclined and prone unto to judge and condemn others as unfaithful that erre rather out of humane weaknesse and meer ignorance then obstinacy and malice in indifferent matters and in the circumstance much good he may here learn and be advised how to moderate and temperate his passions and affections with more charity and peaceablenesse and stedfastly maintain the benefit of the substance viz. the Universal Christian saving Faith and sincere love and obedience of Christ as the onely fundamental and necessary Doctrine unto Salvation lest in rashly presumptuously and rigorously condemning others he may be inexcusable and condemn himself And contrarywise being either thrust out of the way which the Lord our God hath commanded him to walk in or falsly and contumeliously judged slandered reviled excommunicated and persecuted for the true Orthodoxal Doctrine Faith and Religion by an incompetent Judge on Earth he may know without beleeving and obeying their words and offending thereby both his own and other true beleeving or erring consciences how to appeal first to the Word of God it self and unanimous consent of the Primitive Apostolical Church or to any legal and impartial Ecclesiastical Convocation Synod or Consistory or if he cannot be heard there to the Supream Judge in Heaven himself being the onely Law-giver who is able to save and destroy and in his good time will judge those Judges themselves and pronounce a definitive Sentence against all Heresies Schisms and Divisions and establish an Universal Harmony and Unitie in the Christian Church Whereas now these two Motives have induced me to this slender endeavour without regard to any other interest or respect but that which might be conducible to the advancement of an Ecclesiastical Peace and Unitie amongst Evangelical Protestant Churches lest the Wel-wishers and Furtherers thereof might not be too long debarr'd from the lustre and use of so rare a Jewel I thought fit and expedient to dedicate it to your Patronage as being suteable and adequate to your zeal and piety relying herein upon Sir Edwin Sandys judgement delivered in his Book called A View of the state of Religion in the Western parts of the World pag. 173. where he writeth thus The end of the differences between the Evangelical Protestant Churches will be that their enemies shall laugh when themselves shall have cause to weep unlesse the graciousnesse of God stir up some worthy Princes of renown and reputation on both sides to interpose their Wisdom Industry and Authority for the uniting these Factions or at least for reconciling and composing those differences in some tolerable sort A work of immortal fame and desert and worthy of none but them of whom this wicked base World is not worthy And hoping that this weak attempt of my labour though some of the Vulgar sort will perhaps either carelesly or censoriously entertain it will be neverthelesse as favourably accepted by you as it is affectionately and heartily tendred by REVEREND SIRS Your humble and devoted Servant PHILIP FREHER London the 23th of March 1646. The Contents of this Book are reduced to these twelve Chapters I. Of judging one another in general II. Wherein we ought not to judge one another in matters of Religion III. What is necessary and not necessary unto Salvation IV. That the Roman-Catholick Church hath no ground to judge or condemn the Protestant Reformed Evangelical Churches as Heretical V. That the Lutherans have no ground to judge the Reformed Churches to be Heretical VI. Which is the chief and principal Question in this present difference of Religion and what are the safest means for the settlement of a Christian Vnitie VII That even these are the safest meanes to restrain all Erroneous Sects VIII That in the Reformed Churches no new Doctrine as necessary to Salvation is taught IX Whether and how far we ought or are bound in conscience to judge others in matters of Religion X. Whether or how far Protestant Churches ought or are bound to judge the said Roman-Catholicks in their Doctrine or Religion or to separate themselves from them or to undergo any Reformation XI Whether or how
mistake should they judge us presumptuously in our misconstruction of their pretended understanding neither should they bewray any malice and obstinacie in their contradictions But also that they together with us should adhere to the words and meaning of the holy Scripture as far as they are clear and plain to all And diligently enquire further in the fear and worship of God into the true understanding of whatsoever they do not comprehend yet or doubt of And in the mean time walk by the same rule as far as we have already on both sides attained minding the same thing and giving no offence till God reveal unto them and us even what is remaining Phil. 3.15 16. And this doubtlesse is the safest and onely way What are the best and safest means to settle and maintain a true Unitie amongst all true Christians whereby the true unitie of Spirit may be maintained amongst all pious and religious Christians For all those that now adays have the name of Christians on earth do agree therein to this very hour that they acknowledge and receive the Canonical Books of the Prophets and Apostles whereof those of the Old Testament were originally written in Hebrew those of the New Testament in Greek for the Word of God and oblige themselves with one consent to submit their Faith and Consciences unto it So that those that practise it not onely with words but also with true and sincere hearts may without any difficulty in all things agree that are plainly and expresly taught therein nay they are already united therein by the holy Ghost and those that agree in one minde have all whatsoever is necessary to believe and to do unto salvation and are true fellow-members of the Onely Apostolike Catholike Church if together with this Universal Christian Faith they do but tolerate and receive one another as weak Brethren in Faith and other things Chap. 5. that are not so manifest in the Scripture wherein they may thorowly and generally agree Besides this we know no other means on earth that either God hath given and ordained for us or may be invented by mans wit whereby a true Universal Unity may be setled and maintained The pretended Supremacy and Infallibility of the Pope is no fit means for Unity but rather the principal cause of all the Divisions in the Christian Church For as much as concerneth the Supreme Jurisdiction and Infallibility of the Pope which the Jesuites cry up for the onely means of the Catholike Uniformitie That same is rather the principal cause and impediment whereby the Unitie amongst all Christians both in the Eastern and Western Churches is cut off and made impossible in mens eyes Seeing that it is absolutely impossible and inexcusable withal that all Churches and all men of the world should subject and submit in every thing their consciences who acknowledge no other Lord and Master but Jesus Christ to One man Solely who hath no charge and warrant for the same from God Which though they urge and presse as the most necessary point to Salvation and Unitie yet could not obtain it of some Romane Catholikes themselves who extol the General Councels above the Pope Neither the general Councels are sufficient means for Unity in these last times Nor are Concilia Vniversalia in these last times the true means for Unitie For it hath been a meer Impossibilitie in these last thousand yeers since the Ancient Romane Empires destruction and division in the East and West and shall be impossible till the end of the world to indict and gather any true Universal Councel composed of all Christian Churches of the whole world And grant that they could be called yet they could not establish any other Unitie then by reiteration and renovation of that which with one accord hath been taught in the Primitive Universal Christian Church out of the evident and undoubted Word of God For the whole Christian Church on earth though its meeting at once in one place were possible could not presume to take upon it self such power to astrain and oblige its posterity to any other Doctrine and Religion further then they are bound by their Predecessors or rather by God himself through our Lord Jesus Christ and his Apostles If any man though an Angel from heaven preach any other Gospel unto you then that ye have received let him be accursed Gal. 1.8 9. Nor the Confessions formulae of any particular Church And so shall neither the Protestants or any other particular Churches in any place of the world and much lesse other dispersed Sects to and fro be able to establish a tolerable Ecclesiastical Peace and Unitie either by their vehement disceptations and disputes or exhortations to Peace or by Colloquia and conferences or by National and Provincial Synods or per Synodales formulas or any other means as long as they insist and adhere to their own particular Interpretations Consequences and manner of expressions and will of necessity judge others thereby Seeing chiefly it is not to be expected nor desired nor approved that all Christians of the whole world should submit and agree unto any particular Church or to the Interpretations of their Teachers which are not manifest and evident to all by warrants from the Scripture But far more will thereby the Divisions and Separations about the Interpretations and Inferences in making necessary Articles of Faith thereof by endlesse altercations and disputes as woefull experience doth sufficiently testifie increase and grow dangerous even to their final ruine and destruction For Chap. 7. if you bite and devoure one another take heede that yee be not consumed one of another Gal. 5. v. 15. And how many thousand Christians yea whole Churches are in the East South and West which know nothing or can know any thing either of the Decrees of the Popes or of the Councell of Trent nor of the Confession of Augspourge or of other confessions of the Protestant Churches in Europe much lesse of the Formula Concordiae Saxonicae how is it then possible that we should undergoe to settle by such meanes and writs a true Unity in the Universall Church of Christ or to bind and oblige other Churches thereunto Now notwithstanding wee conceive also no hope to obtaine a totall and universall reconcilement of the modern unhappy differences and divisions in matters of Religion Even by an Vniversall consent and agreement upon the holy Scripture as far as it is plain and evident to all sides Amongst those that are inclined and given to contradictions and contentions because God himself by his just judgement sendeth Divisions Heresies and Sects partly for punishment partly for triall 1 Cor. 11. v. 19. Yet I make no doubt In what manner how far the manifest word of God is the onely meanes of Vnitie but all Pious and religious hearts which love Truth and Peace whereof yet a great number is to be found every where and even in the middest