operations of the Holy Spirit in their own Hearts Know then that we do believe know and witness it to be Truth that when God's Holy Spirit inspireth us immediately and moveth us to Preach or Pray or give Thanks as it did Holy Men of God of old and Holy Women also even Daughters as well as Sons and Maid-servants as well as Men-servants and so doth at this day the said Holy Spirit worketh upon our Understandings and Reasons as we are Men and reasonable Creatures and upon all the powers and abilities of our Souls according to their several capacities and the Graces and Spiritual Gifts we have received from God and all that is in us of parts whether natural or acquired or supernatural and maketh them serviceable to us and active in the work and service of God more or less as he pleaseth And thus when we pray or give thanks in Words as we receive these words from the Lord when the Prayer and Thanksgiving is purely and rightly performed so they also spring up in us from the fruitfulness of understanding and those parts and graces which God hath given us and our Hearts and Souls and Spirits are the Mothers that bring them forth and the good matter and purposes whereof they declare together with the good life vertue and force or energy that is in them or doth accompany them Hence true and right Prayer in Scripture is called A pouring out of the Soul and Heart so that somewhat of the very inward strength vertue and power of the Soul and Heart of man yea of his Spirit or what is most noble and excellent in him goeth forth in words whether of Preaching or Praying or giving of Thanks as he is truly and fervently exercised in the same by the moving and enabling of the Holy Ghost according to which David Psal. 103. 1. stirred up not only his Soul to praise the Lord but all that was within him note to bless his Holy Name Which tender and sensible hearers whose Souls and Hearts God hath quickned and made alive are well sensible of and can and do well distinguish betwixt a dead and a living or a barren and fruitful Ministry whether in Preaching or Prayer Habet enim nescio quid latentis energiae viva vox transmissâ— per aures in animos audientium fortius sonat Which is in English thus The living Voice saith he hath I know not what something of a secret energy or power and being transmitted through the Ears of the Hearers into their Hearts and Minds doth sound the more effectually And if this be true of a natural Speech when it comes from a mans heart and is spoke but with a natural Fervency that it reacheth forcibly the natural Faculties of the Hearers which borrowed speeches or those which come not from the heart but from the bare understanding and memory cannot do How much more is it apparent in words and speeches that are Spiritual which come both from the Heart livingly touched and affected with the sense of the things whereof the words declare and also from the Spirit of the Lord Hence it is said that Christ spoke as one having authority and not as the Scribes and the Apostles Preaching was with power and the Holy Ghost and so no doubt was their Praying Q. Is it any part of Gospel Worship or Prayer to read set forms of Prayer out of a Book whether in private or publick or whether all Vocal Prayer used either in private or publick in Families or large Congregations should not be as the Spirit of God helps the Speakers to conceive and gives them an utterance to bring forth Words of Prayer or Thanks giving we cannot believe nor are we convinced in Conscience A. To read set forms of Prayer out of a Book whether in private or publick and call that reading Prayer is any part of Gospel Worship or true and real Prayer but rather one of the many Inventions and Traditions of Men since the Apostacy and falling away from the true Faith did enter among those called Christians who retained the Name but losed the power and Spirit of the true ancient and primitive Christians For surely if it had been any part of Gospel Worship Christ or the Apostles would have mentioned it and the Scripture would have born record of it as they do of all the parts of Gospel Worship and true Christian Religion And if it had been the Will of God that such a way of Worship should have been used in the true Church as a common Liturgy or set Form of Prayers it would have been used in the Apostles days for none were so fit to have given forth such forms of Prayers after Christ his Ascension and giving of the Holy Ghost as the Apostles were who were so abundantly replenished with the Holy Spirit But neither the Apostles nor their immediate Successors either made or used any such set Forms of read Prayers Nothing of this kind was known in the Church either in Iustin Martyr or Tertullian his time who lived above Two Hundred Years after Christ for Tertullian telleth plainly the manner how Christians Prayed in his time Ex pertore sue Monitore per Spiritum Sanctum i. e. From the Heart without a Monitor or any thing outwardly to teach them and by the Holy Spirit But Secondly They who plead for using read set Prayers in the Church do acknowledg they were not in use nor practised in the Apostles days nor in the days of their immediate Successors for they grant that in those early and primitive times they who prayed in the Church as the mouth of the whole Congregation were assisted and guided by the Holy Spirit and that their Words both of Prayer and singing Psalms were by immediate Inspiration So that it is as clear as the Noon-day that when these Divine Gifts of Praying and Singing by the Spirit were lost and the Holy Spirit himself the Author and Fountain of those Gifts was in great measure departed from the invention of reading ser Forms of Prayer took place The first Instance that I find of Peoples being put to use a composed or set Form of Prayer made by another was that Form of Prayer which Constantine the great composed and gave to his Soldiers to say but yet they were not to read it but get it by Heart and we must consider that Constantine himself at this time was but a young Christian and the purity of Spiritual Worship began to decline apace even in his daies and most of his Souldiers were Heathens and no Christians so that what they did was no president to us But neither in Constantine's time nor a considerable space thereafter do I find that any made or composed Prayers before-hand were used in the Church It seemeth the Third Council of Carthage about the year after the Birth of Christ 397. did first ordain Set Forms of Prayer in the Church to prevent or hinder mens uttering any thing either ignorantly or rashly
working of the Holy Spirit which may have its visible Effects even the shedding of Tears in him that Preacheth or Prayeth and that more or less abundantly yet the hypocritical show and affection of such a thing without the reality thereof is loathsome and abominable and as great a Transgression against the Law of Heaven as false and counterfeit Money or Coin is against any Earthly Law And yet such hypocritical Tears and Flashes of fained Devotion kindled up by Sparks of their own raising abounding among too many of that Tribe and Generation as if they were the effects of Gods Holy Spirit when alass it is far the contrary But to such as have any measure of Sobriety and Ingenuity among them I propose this Question to be answered in plainness and simplicity by them 1. How can they pretend to pray by the Spirit in words and yet they deny all immediate Inspiration and Revelation which alone guided and assisted those who prayed by the Spirit in words recorded in the Holy Scriptures 2. By what Rule or Touchstone do they know when they are assisted and helped by the Spirtt to pray in words and when not seeing they deny the Holy Spirit as he doth inwardly reveal himself in Mens Hearts to be the rule in any case 3. When they are not moved by the Holy Spirit and that they do not find themselves so moved as to pray in words whether in that case seeing they will needs pray as well when they want the Spirits help as when they have it and that they plead Natural Men who have not the Spirit of God may be true Ministers of Christ and may and ought lawfully to Preach and Pray if they have an outward Call from them they should not rather use the set Forms of Prayer than their own bare invention and wandring imagination for here their great Argument against set Forms of Prayer hath no place to wit the limiting or stinting the Spirit of God because he who prayeth in words without the Spirit whether by a Book or ex tempore without a Book is in one and the same case if none of them pray by the Spirit for he who hath not the Spirit cannot properly be said to limit or stint it But to this I know they will reply that natural and unconverted men though they have not the Grace of the Holy Spirit to sanctifie and saye them yet they have a Gift of Preaching and Praying by the Spirit that may be useful and edifying to the Church they have Gratia gratis data as they call it but not Gratia gratum faciens i. e. Grace freely given them but not Grace rendring them acceptable unto God and for this they give the instance or Example of Balaam To this I answer this distinction used so much of Gratia gratis data and Gratia gratium faciens hath not any warrant from Scripture but is borrowed in express words from popish School-men and Jesuits whom at other times they call Locusts Come out of the bottomless Pit. And as for Balaam it was somewhat an extraordinary case whereby God shewed his mighty Power that he had over his Spirit to cause him to Prophecy good things concerning Israel contrary to his own inclinations and to bless instead of cursing them but an extraordinary Example is not to be made a Rule or President unto us And indeed they have but a sad pattern of him whom rather they follow and imitate for most part in loving and taking the wages of Unrighteousness then in Prophecying or speaking by the Spirit of God as he did at these few extraordinary times And though he prophesied some words by the Spirit yet we do not read that ever God made him the Mouth of the Congregation to pray by the Spirit which is the present case And besides though he Prophesied twice or thrice by the Spirit of God which was extorted from him contrary to his own evil mind and inclination yet he was no true Prophet of God but beareth the infamous mark of a false Prophet to this day and we do not read that ever any one Soul was converted to God by his Prophecying or Ministry God can command the Devils if he please to confess to Christ as some of them did of old which yet is no president for wicked men in whom the Devil rules to Preach and Pray in the Church Now whereas they say Men may have a Gift of Prayer to use it in the Church from the Spirit of God and yet be not sanctified by the Spirit I ask them Is it such a Gift as can secure them from speaking impertinent and unsound words contrary to the truth if yea then they have an infallible Gift which seeing they will not grant unto themselves no more will they unto these others And if it cannot secure them from unsound and impertinent words but leaves them at liberty as much to use unfound words as sound and that the corruption of their Hearts who are but meer Natural Men will soon cast the Ballance and byass them rather to use the unsound words than the sound Is it not more safe in that case at least the less inconveniency of the two rather to be tied and limited to use 2 form of sound words then that their corrupt and unrenewed Hearts However so much they imagine it is to be helped with an unsanctified Gift of an abused Eloquence should be left at liberty to speak unto God and utter before him whatever it pleaseth But if we shall search to the bottom what this Spiritual common Gift of the Spirit is we shall find it to be no other but some meer Natural Gift of Memory Elocution and a ready or quick Fancy and Imagination which many Heathenish Idolatrous Priests have had as much as any of them improved with some acquired Arts of Grammar Logick and Rhetorick and words of Scripture abused and misapplied by them and that which crowns all some more than ordinary degree of confidence that when they are thus furnished and can or do Preach and Pray by those meer natural and artificial helps at best to call them and baptize them into the name of a Spiritual Gift or the Spirits help and assistance But leaving these men and their ex tempore praying without the Spirit which thus far I found my very Soul and Spirit concerned to discover in true love and compassion to their abused and betrayed Hearers and Followers and to them also if they can receive it I shall return to plead a little further for the true and right manner of praying in words by the Spirit as he is pleased to give assistance both in the conceiving and utterance without any set Form either read out of a Book or repeated from the Memory without a Book Because 3. This way of Praying doth alone and only answer to the liberty of the Spirit which is free even the Holy Spirit of Truth and neither will nor can be limitted and who seek to limit
words and a sutable degree and measure of life to accompany them wherewith to minister in Prayer and whereby the faint and weak desires of the Hearers many times are enlarged and strengthened But it can never be supposed that he who only reads a Set Form of Prayer out of a Book according to the order of the Calendar or repeats it from his memory can Pray with either such fit and sutable matter of words or can minister that sutable degree and measure of life that the Hearers require and stand in need of for where the words are not seasonable life will not join with them to make them effectual and profitable to the Hearers I know it will be hard for these who have not the inward experience of the workings of the Divine Life and Spirit in their own Souls to believe or imagine how the Speaker who is assisted to Preach or pray with the Spirit of God can have a distinct and clear feeling of the several states and conditions of the people and in that sense and feeling be enabled by the same Spirit who gave this sense to him to minister to them all that which is seasonable both for matter and life However this is abundantly known and witnessed to those who have an inward experience of life and its workings in themselves to be a truth for as in the natural body one member hath a sence of its fellow members and the more noble that one member be its sence of the other members is the more universal full and comprehensive Even so is it in the Body of Christ which is his Church and how can it be otherwise when as the Scripture saith All the single hearted and upright minded Professors of Christ are of one heart and soul as expressing a greater unity and sympathy or fellow feeling than that of the body as if to be of one Soul were more than to be of one Body for if the parts of the Body have a sence one of another much more the powers and faculties of the Soul have a discerning and sympathy one with another 6. And lastly To add no more here altho many more reasons might be brought against the using of Set Forms of Prayer the whole Superstructure dependeth upon a false and wrong bottom or foundation viz. an Opinion that immediate Inspiration and Revelation is ceased or discontinued in the Church and in and among true Christians as well as false for I dare say If they who are so zealous for using Set Forms of Prayer did but believe that Immediate Inspiration and Revelation did remain in the true Church of God and in and among true Christians this would presently end the dispute and determine the Controversie betwixt them and us for when Immediate Inspiration and Revelation was in the Church as in the Apostles daies and for some considerable time thereafter they readily grant that men then prayed and sung Psalms ex tempore without Book by the Spirit and therefore if they did now believe that such a dispensation is restored and restoring again and was never altogether lost among true Christians although much impaired and diminished by reason of the general Apostacy and prevailing power of darkness that was over the greatest part of those called Christians they would lay aside their Set Forms and wait for this Divine Gift But it were too long and unseasonable a labour in this place to prove that Immediate Revelation and Inspiration doth remain in and among all true Christians I shall therefore refer the Readers to what our Friends have writ on that subject and particularly to two Treatises of mine And withal I beseech all sober and impartial people laying aside all prejudice to weigh and consider upon what slender and weak Arguments that Opinion is built which saith That Immediate Inspiration and Revelation is ceased in and among all true Christians And above all I recommend them to the Light of Christ Jesus and the manifestation of his holy Spirit of Truth in every one of their hearts and Consciences that bears witness to every necessary Truth as they hearken to it and with their minds turned to the said Light and Spirit of Truth to read and search the Scriptures diligently in that very respect as the Noble Bereans did of old and the Lord give them understanding in that and all other necessary things I shall now proceed to Answer the most ordinary Objections that seem to have most weight for using Set Forms of Prayer whether in the Church or in private 1. It is Objected That Set Forms of Prayer and Blessing the People were used in the Iewish Church under the Law as Numb 10. 35. when the Ark set forward Moses commonly said Arise O God let thine Enemies be scattered let them also that hate thee flee before thee and when it rested he said Return O Lord to the many thousands of Israel And Numb 6. 23. Aaron and his Sons were on this wise to bless the people saying The Lord bless thee and keep thee the Lord make his face to shine favourably on thee And Joel the Prophet taught the People to pray saying Spare thy People O Lord give not thy Heritage to reproach that the Heathen should rule over them wherefore should they say among the people Where is their God Ioel 2. 17. And yet under the Law people had the Spirit of God and were to pray by the Spirit and Moses and Aaron who were to use these Forms of Prayer and Blessing were endued wiih a great measure of the Spirit and able enough to have conceived other Forms of Prayer and Blessing Ans. From their using Set Forms of Prayer and Blessing under the Law to argue for the use of them under the Gospel will not hold good for not only Sacrifices and Offerings of Beasts but many other things were both commanded and allowed under the Law which are not under the Gospel And although Moses and Aaron and many others in those daies had great plenty of the Spirit yet for the sake of the people who generally were weak and rude they were to go along with them in those Rudiments No doubt Moses and the Prophets saw to the substance and end of those Shadows and Figures and knew well enough that the blood of Bulls and Goats could not wash or purifie the Conscience and yet because of the general dispensation of the Law which was to continue until the fulness of time wherein Christ should be revealed they were to remain in the practise of these things which were afterwards to be abolished And though under the Law some Forms of Prayer and Blessing the People were to be used yet they were but few and very short and such as did proceed from the Spirit of God the matter and words of such Forms seem to carry in them some extraordinary Majesty or Glory and to have some deep and profound signification and force with them more than ordinary as we know some Scripture words and