Mr. T. Sect. 3. 1. Mr. Gataker interprets the Words of Corporal Adultery Answ 1. It may be so I have not that Author to converse with 2. He is no Oracle that his Dictates must be subscribed to 3. The Adultery mentioned in the Text is made a Character of a false Prophet which corporal Adultery Mr. T. saith is noâ— He saith 2dly Every departure from the Institutions of the Lord in Worship to the inventions of men is not any where committing Adultery Answ Of this matter we have treated chap. 1. sect 12. whither we refer the Reader 3dly Walking in lies he tells us is a character of a false Prophet but they are lies in Doctrine not Worship that is intended in the places cited Answ 1. Of the Annotators he cites not one of them is of his mind Diodati interprets the Phrase of false worships and superstitions as do the Assembly in their Annotations on Am. 2. 4. 2dly We have manifested from other Scriptures that the expression is used by the Spirit of the Lord in this sense both heâ—e and Sect. 10. p. 96. to refute which he offers nothing and his own Dictates will never pass for proof 3dly We demonstrate the present Ministers walk in lies in the sense contended for by this Animadverter chap. 10. of S. T. 4thly To the Qâ—eries he answers The Institution of Preaching the Gospel they have not mixed with their own inventions Answ But this they evidently do whilst none must be allowed to Preach the Gospel but such as subject to Episcopal Ordination promise Canonical Obedience to their Ordinaries observe the Regulations for Preaching given forth by the Pope of Canterbury they are bound to omit the preaching of the Gospel when they have not time to Preach and read Service too Wherein Divine Institution must give place to humane inventions In Baptism he will tell you they mix an Institution of Christ's with the inventions of man in respect of the wrong Subject and they evidently do so whilst they sign with the sign of the Cross and make it such an essential part of Baptism that it is not lawful to be omitted The Institution of the Lord's Supper they mix with that Popish humane invention of kneeling in the Act of receiving which they constitute such a necessary part thereof that they will not admit any to receive in any other posture To the second viz. From how many have they gone a whoring He answers it concerns him that accuseth to shew Answ And that concern I dispatched chap. 4. of S. T. To the third viz. Is not a great part of their Worship drops of the Whores cup of Fornication Mr. T. though he multiply many words answers not at all not understanding or being willingly ignorant of my intendment in those expressions which was solely this that their Divine Service wherein a great part of their Worship doth consist is for the most part taken out of the Service-Book of Rome which Mr. T. may disprove if he can Sect. 2. A third Character of false Prophets mentioned Jer. 23. 13. A fourth Jer. 6. 14. c. A fifth Isa 56. 11. c. Which exactly agree to the present Ministers THE third Character of a false prophet mentioned in S. T. is this That they strengthen the hands of evil doers that none doth return from his wickedness Jer. 23. 13. This it 's said the present Ministers do whilst though in the general they denounce the Judgments of God against sinners they Saint them in the Chancel tell them that the body of Christ was broken for them To which our Animadverter â—ubjoyns Sect. 4. 1. Mr. Gatakers Paraphrase upon the Text is That they confirmed them in their wickedness by bearing them in hand that they should do well enough whatsoever Gods Messengers tell them though they continue in their sins Answ 1. The sin laid to their charge is strengthening the hands of evil doers whether they did this practically or doctrinally is not expressed 't is all one Probably they told them they were the holy People the true Church had his Temple and Ordinances with and amongst them and therefore God could not reject destroy them notwithstanding the Prophesie of Jeremiah to the contrary whom they reviled as a made seditious fellow thereby labouring to take off the people from an attendance on the Prophesie and threatnings given forth by him This we charge the present Ministers to be guilty of as the holy People and Church of God they admit the visibly prophane and wicked to the Lords Table and their Children to Baptism bury them as holy Brethren whom they call so not upon the accoâ—nt of Creation but Christianity which their conversations contradict and Church-membership with them though they die in the very act of drunkenness of whose joyful resurrection to eternal Life they profess they have a sure and certain hope which can be referred to no other but the person interred they asperse reproach those who would deal truly and roundly with them as seditious mad persons that are fit for the Stocks Prisons Dungeons whereby they evidently strengthen their hands in their wickedness 2. It is not true that the false Prophets told them expresly that they should do well enough though they continued in their siâ—s they flattered them with the mercy and patience of God the priviledges and immunities he had crowned them with by which they lead them into the belief of this that God would not reject them 3. The Assembly in their Annotations explain the Phrase of strengthening the hands of evil doers with this they confirm them in their wickedness and so keep them from Repentance Ezek. 13. 22. Which by the wayes and means instanced in 't is known the present Ministers do 4. 'T is not charity as he intimates to say to a known Drunkard Swearer that the body of Christ was broken the blood of Christ shed for him that he should take and eat and drink the Bread and Wine in â— membrance that Christ died for him but cruelty tending to the nourishment of false peace and confidence to the ruine of millions of Souls If Judas was at the Sacrament he was a visible Saint is no Warrant to administer it to persons of the complexion intimated The expressions above mentioned are not at all like those used by the Apostle 1 Cor. 8. 11. Heb. 10. 29. He speaks of visibly Saints these are spoken of and to the visible wicked and prophane 5. That these things do not confirm and strengthen the hands of evil doers was the alone thing to have been proved by our Animadverter but to that he speaks not at all What he further mentions is a pretended reply to what is remarked touching the Ministers of England that it is a rare thing to hear of one Soul that is brought over to God by all their Preaching so that visibly that Judgment of God seems to be upon them Jer. 23. 32. Therefore they shall not at all profit this people
which one of their Reverend Prelates hath been moâ—e than once heard to say That the presence of Christ in the Sacramenâ— is not Symbolical but Realiter and upon that account we give adoration 't is like more are of his mind as horrible Idolatry as bowing before a Crucifix or Image 2. That Christ is not alone the Head of the Church 3. They seem to attribute greater efficacy to the Blood than the Body of Christ whilst they pray That their bodies may be made clean by his Body and their souls by his most precious Blood as they do in the prayer before that which is used at the Consecration 4. That Christ descended into Hell as if he descended into the place of the Damned as â—he Papists hold To which Mr. T. 1. 'T is in the Creed call'd the Apostles Answ 1. This is no part of Scripture Nor 2. ever composed by them whose name it bears Nor 3. is it certain when or by whom it was so done 4. To this very day it was never in any full and general Council confirmed and established So that its being in the Creed proves it not so authentick as that we are bound to believe it 5. What is said by Bishop Usher touching this matter I have not leisure to enquire since it 's put after his burial it can signifie no other descent but into the place of the damned which is as rotten a figment as ever was invented 3. Touching Man 1. They generally own I speak especially of them who are called the Church free-will And 2. an implicite Faith not in words but really and indeed whilst they say We must practise in Worship the determinations of the Church though we our selves see no reason for them because she hath determined them and that this is reason sufficient for our so doing i. e. We must in these things believe â—or Faith must preceed practice in the Worship of God as the Church believes 4. Touching Worship They hold 1. That Worship devâ—sed by man though abused to Idolatry is the Worship of God with which he is well-pleased 2. That God is more particularly to be worship'd in one place than in another and that these places being Consecrated are the Houses and Churches of God and upon that account holy and to be reverenced 3. That reading an Homilie or a few Prayers out of the Liturgie is a more excellent worship of God though no where commanded in the Scriptures than Preaching which must therefore give way to it 4. That none must be suffered publickly to worship God or privately except in their own Families but according to Forms of mans devising Which 5. they say Is the Worship of God 5. Touching the Sacraments 1. They seem to intimate that there are more than two when they say there are two only generally necessary to salvation 2. That Women may Baptize in casu necessitatis as the Papists hold and that such Baptism is valid 3. That Baptism is to be administred with a Cross in the fore-head 4. That all Children when baptized are regenerate and received by the Lord for his own Children by adoption Common-Prayer-Book of Publick Baptism 5. That Children being baptized have all things necessary for their salvation and shall undoubtedly be saved 6. That all that are baptized have received remission of sins Confirmation before the imposition of hands 7. They seem to make the imposition of hands a Sacrament when they say 'T is a sign to certifie Children of Gods grace and favour towards them Ibid. in the Prayer after the imposition of hands Yea they really do so if the definition they themselves give of a Sacrament be right viz. That it is an outward and visible Sign of an inward and spiritual Grace 8. So they to make Matrimony by that expression used by them consecrated the state of Matrimony to such an excellent mystery in one of the Collects in the form of the solemnization of Matrimony 9. They adore before the Elements of Bread and Wine 10. That the wicked and ungodly may receive it 11. That though the most notorious offenders be partakers of it yet the People that joyn with them are not defiled thereby 12. That the Body of Christ was broken the blood of Christ was shed particularly for them 6. Touching the Church 1. That under the time of the Gospel there is a National Church 2. That the most wicked and their seed may be compelled and received to be members of the Church which is notoriously known nor have they the face to deny it though Mr. T. talkes as if they would to be consonant to their principles and practice 3. That 't is not lawful to separate from this Church whoever do so are Sectaries Schismaticks to be excommunicated imprisoned a bloody error 4. That the Clergie is the Church as is the Pope and his Conclave to the Romanists 5. That these is another Head of the Church besides Christ 6. That 't is not in the power of the Church to choose their own Officers 7. That 't is in the power of Kings to appoint the highest Church-Officers 8. That Lord-Bishops are Officers of the Church of Christ though no where of his appointment 9. That Lord-Bishops can give the Holy Ghost and power to forgive and retain sins 10. That 't is in the power of a Priest to absolve from sins In the Visitat of the Sick 11. That 't is not in the power of the Church to excommunicate but the Bishop 12. That Pastors and Teachers are to be ordained by Lord-Bishops 13. That dumb Ministers are lawful Ministers of Christ 14. That the Ministry Worship and Government which Christ hath appointed to his Church is not to be received or joyned unto unless the Magistrates where they are reputed Christians do allow it And this their practice preacheth forth 7. Touching things supposed indifferent 1. That 't is in the power of the Church i. e. the Bishops in their Convocation to make that which is in it self indifferent a necessary part of Worship 2. To devise what Rites it pleaseth and add to the Worship of Christ 3. That Marriage may be forbidden at certain Popish seasons as in Lent Advent Rogation week 4. That the Cope Surplice Tippet Rochet are meet and decent Ornaments for the Worship of God and ministry of the Gospel 5. That Altars Candles Organs are necessary and useful in the Church of God Mr. T. his thoughts are vain when he thinks that they will not assert this Certainly they will not be so imprudent as to aver that they lavish the Gold out of the Bag for the erection of that in the Service of God which is neither necessary nor useful 6. That there may be Holy Dayes appointed to the Virgin Mary John Baptist the Apostles all Saints and Angels together also with Fasts on their Eves on Ember dayes Fridayes Saturdayes so called heathenishly enough Mr. T. answers They will deny this to be their Tenent and câ—tes Whitgift c. telling
odious with Ministers and People whereby they were necessitated to joyn in Communion by themselves Praecurs Sect. 12. p. 48. Because it is manifest from Acts 2. 41. 46. 1 Cor. 10. 1 2 3. 12. 13. Persons were Baptized before they brake bread together therefore the taking any without Baptism to the Lords Supper will but strengthen men in their opinion that their Infant Sprinkling is sufficient Therefore he sees a nececessity of desisting from that enterprâ—se of admitting persons of different perswasions touching Baptism into their communion ibid. p. 49. The Christian-Church-constitution of Volunteers is better ibid. Sect. 11. pag. 431. In the Worship of God it was wont to be accounted a certain Rule that Gods Worship should be observed according to his appointment and no otherwise ib. Sect. 16. p. 66. My opposing the Bishops began with the soonest And for my non conformity Reasons were given with some of the first I justifie not the Ceremonies ibid. Sect. 21. p. 89. It is true our English Prelatical Divines do account Baptism sufficiently administred that is so done yea though it were by a Popish Priest or a Midwife ibid. p. 91. However for the Tenet of the Peoples governing by Vote I know no reason why they he speaks of those called Independants should be called a Sect rather than their opposites The Excommunication which â—he Scripture speaks of is no where made a part of Government or of the Elders Office any more than the Peoples In Antiquity its apparent out of Cyprian That the People had a great hand in Elections Excommunications Absolutions ibid. p. 93. No one Country City or Tribe together were gathered by the Apostles or other Preachers into the Christian visible Church but so many of all as the Lord vouchsafed to call by his Word and Spirit 1 Cor. 1. 26. Not many wise men Ergo Not the whole Nation And afterward to Mr. B. Question Hath he not commanded to disciple Nations He answers Yes to make Disciples of all Nations by preaching the Gospel to every creature but no where by Civil Authority to gather a whole City Country or Tribe and to draw them into a National and City-Covenant together â—bid Sect. 22. p. 97. Jeroboams Sacrificing and keeping a Feast at another time thâ—n God appointed Ahaz his forming an Altar after the pattern of that of Damascus Nadab and Abihu their offering strange fire keeping Holy Dayes to Saints he condemns as Will-worship Full Review of the Dispute conceâ— Infant-Baptism p. 3. 1 Pet. 2. 9. Which are meant only of the Elect and true Believers of every Nation are applied to a National Church consisting of a great part of either ignorant persons that know little or nothing of Christianity or persecutors of Godliness profanely despising the Word and hating the Godly ibid. pag. 27. God forbad Infants under eight dayes old to be circumcised in that he appointed the eighth day to be Circumcised Now if this be a forbidding to Circumcise before as I acknowledge it is and so do many Protestant Divines as Paraeus Com. in Gen. 17. 11. then that is forbidden which is otherwise than God appointed ibid. p. 81. And p. 180. He reckons the Cross in Baptism amongst Popish usuages such as Bell Baptism Baptizing of Dead persons I said it is a carnal imagination that the Church of God is like to civil Corporations if persons were admitted to it by birth nor is it to the purpose to prove the contrary that Mr. M. tells me the Jewish Church was in the like civil Corporations for I grant it was the whole Nation whereas the Christian Church hath another constitution ibid p. 265 266. If Christ did say to Judas that his Body was broken for him and his Blood shed it will be hard to avoid thence the proof of Universal Redemption I think it the safe stand most likely tenent that Judas went out afore the Lords Supper p. 291. ibid. Christ is the Head of the visible Church in giving them Officers outward order direction ibid. p. 294. But all these are alterd now the Church is not National no one High-Priest Temple Sanhedrim ibid p. 334. I know that our Army hath done so much for the setling the Church as that the Anti-Prelatists Congregations had been either none or much oppressed if they had not broken the force of the opposite party Nor dare I be so unthankful to God or them as not to acknowledge the great Mercy and benefit we at this day enjoy thereby however Mr. B. fret at our Liberty and jibe at the Instruments ibid. p. 383. A not commanding is a plain forbidding Mr. Collings provoc pro. ch 5. Nothing is lawful in the Worship of God but what we have precept or president for which whoso denies opens a door to all Idolatry and Superstition and Wil-worship in the world which Mr. T. approves of ibid p. 408. Of divine Institution there is no reason can be right but what is from Gods own appointment though it may seem right to us it should be so In things positive our reason is deceivable and Gods appointment is only to be attended ibid p. 461. And now Sir though I might to these Collections which are diametrically opposite to the main principles of your Theodulia the very basis upon which that Fabrick stands have added many more as you well know yet am I willing to spare you not knowing but the Lord may give you to see and bemoan your evill in gladding the hearts of the Wicked sadning the Righteous or confirming them in crooked paths who have turn'd aside thereunto which notwithstanding your natural temper and heâ—ght of spirit with which we are sufficiently acquainted that will pâ—oâ—pt you to say something in a way of self-justification is not impossible for God to do If you write in Answer to our Reply and to the purpose you shall receive a Return 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in a spirit of meekness and christianity If we meet therein wiâ—h meer dictates without tender of proof impertinent citations of Scriptures without the least attempt to minifest their congruity with the assertion they are introduced to prove and a parcel of passionate railing expressions in the stead of the words which the Wisdom that is from above and the Spirit of our dear Lord teacheth which we too often meet with in your Theodulia you have your Answer Farewell FINIS