with greater Reason be said of the true Faith and Religion which is the Foundation of Charity and all other Christian Vertues Thirdly It follows that it is a gross and stupid Errour of some of the Vulgar who esteem it sufficient to Salvation if you only believe in Christ and that he dyed for your Sins altho' as to many other Points of Faith pertaining to the Sacraments and Sacrifice of the Church c. you believe nothing For after this rate almost all sort of Hereticks should be saved For all of them believe in Christ otherwise they were not Hereticks but Apostates and believe some few excepted that he dyed for our Sins Then also the Montanists and Novatians Donatists Sabellians Arrians Macedonians Eutychians Monotholites and the like Pests of the Church shall be saved Why then hath the Church in all Ages so vehemently oppos'd her self against Heresies Why does St. Paul the Apostle command us to avoid the Man that is an Heretick after the 1st or 2d Admonition T it 2. Why does he bid us beware of their Speech which eateth as a Canker 2 Tim. 2. In vain all these things are said and done if Hereticks may be saved I am sure this Fancy is against the Consent of all Ages Let us suppose says St. Augustine a Man to be chast Lib. 4. contr Donat. c. 8. continent not covetous nor idolatrous but bountiful and compassionate to the Poor an Enemy to none not contentious patient quiet envying none sober frugal but yet a Heretick such a one without all doubt meerly because he is an Heretick shall never enjoy the Kingdom of God For as St. James witnesseth he that hath offended in one Commandment is made guilty of all James 2. and Ioseth all Justice though he keeps the rest because he contemns the Law-maker himself who made the whole Law So he that obstinately denies one Point of Faith although he believe the rest is guilty of dis-believing all and loses his whole Faith and Religion because he despiseth the Author of it For it is one and the same first and supreme Verity which hath revealed all Points of Faith and proposed them to our Belief by the Church his Spouse the Pillar and Ground of Truth 1 Tim. 3. He therefore that shall obstinately reject one Article of Faith and will not acquiesce in the Testimony of the Church is thereby judged to dis-esteem the Authority of God the supreme Verity of whom the Church is the Publisher Interpreter and Organ Neither matters it that there are some principal Points of Faith which he thinks he believes because he does not believe them with Divine Faith which relies only upon Divine Authority that is infallible otherwise he would believe the rest proposed to him in the same manner but he believes them with a kind of Humane Faith that is to say because by his private Judgment he is induced to believe them taking upon himself the Authority of judging and discerning what things are to be believed and what denied and rejected Therefore the chief reason or motive of his Belief is private Judgment and for that Cause all his Faith is humane and unprofitable It is therefore most certain that as true Justice extends it felf to the performance of all the Commandments so the true Faith which is requisite to Salvation extends it self to a belief of all those things which God hath revealed so that we must believe them all either expresly or be ready to believe them if they be propounded to us the right way Hereby is manifest what great Care is to be taken that we chuse and profess the true Faith and Religion since it is the Foundation of our Salvation and that without it we shall certainly be damn'd Whereupon I have undertaken to propound some Considerations obvious and manifest to all rational People whereby they may take a right course in their Choice of the true Religion The first Consideration drawn from the tending to Perfection which Christian Religion excites us to THat Religion is to be preferred which conduces most to Purity and Holiness of Life which draws our Minds from all affection to earthly Things and raises them to the love of heavenly For this is the chief end of Religion to alienate the Minds of Men from Things temporal here below and to elevate them towards the thinking loving and pursuing of such as are celestial and eternal Only the Catholick Religion teaches perfection of Life Now such is only the Catholick Religion For this persuades to abstain from the Pleasures of the Flesh and Snares of this Life This alone teaches to contemn Riches and Honours and to renounce them when possessed for Christ's sake This exhorts to Fastings Hair-cloth and other Afflictions of the Body whereby the Flesh is brought under Subjection and subdued to the Spirit Hence are there such great numbers of Men and Women in the Catholick Church who contemning Riches Honours and Pleasures which they either enjoyed or might have enjoyed have bid adieu to the World and mortifying their Flesh have wholly devoted themselves to the Service of God and Contemplation of Divine Things Amongst these are many Noble Men and their Sons and Daughters many of the rich Gentry and their Children many great Wits many famous for their Eloquence and knowledge in all kind of Literature which is an evident sign of the Divine Spirit and true Religion For that Religion cannot chuse but be Heavenly which withdraws Man's Nature fixed on Earthly Things and raises it up to Heavenly which expels the Love of that which is Temporal and instils an affection to that which is Everlasting and in a word which can work such wonderful Changes in Men. The Tree is known by its Fruits Other Religions especially the Lutheran Calvinist and Fanatick For of these only I intend to treat in this Discourse do no such thing For they are so far from teaching Mortification of the Flesh Other Religions take away the study of Perfection and of all good Works Contempt of Earthly Things and cutting off carnal Pleasures that they call Fasting the Tradition of Men whereby God is worshipped in vain abstinence from Flesh with them is Superstition Monastick Vows they say are impious vain and not at all to be observ'd that Chastity is impossible that all Men are bound to marry and lye with a Woman which Luther affirms to be as necessary as Meat Drink L. de Vit. conjug and Sleep By which Doctrine it is come to pass that none of those who are of these New Religions do either mortifie their Flesh by Fasting or abide continent or abstain from Conjugal and Carnal Pleasures or abandon their Riches and imbrace Poverty for the Love of Christ but all of them are for a sensual easie and Worldly Life agreeable to the Inclination of the Flesh and corrupt Nature None of them have so much as a Notion of what it is to lead an Angelical Life upon Earth as many of the
cleansed from our Sins and by whose Faith we are justified Apoc. 1.7 for there is no other Name under Heaven given among Men whereby we must be saved Act. 4.12 All these things were in vain and false if every one might be saved in his own Religion Object Perhaps some will say that Christ is indeed our Redeemer and all Good to us proceeds from him yet a belief in him is not abfolutely necessary to Salvation for it sufficeth to believe that all our Happiness springs from the Bounty of God and is needless to know the means of conferring it Answ But this is repuguant to the Holy Scripture and Reason because the Scripture plainly teaches that Christ's Redemption is not applied to us Why Faith in Christ is necessary to Salvation but by Faith in him and therefore all that bâ—lieve not in Christ are without Justification remain in Sin and are the Children of Wrath and Damnation 'T is likewise against Reason because to be made partakers of any great and singular benefit all reason requireth to know our Benefit and Benefactor that we may know him as 't is meet with all thanksgiving for the condition of the Benefit and Benefactor requires this gratitude therefore since the benefit of our Redemption is so strange and great and he that gave it so sublime and excellent and the manner of bestowing It so wonderful 't is requisite we should know all this least we should live and die altogether ungrateful to so great a Benefactor least like the Jews we should return Curses for a Blessing and Blasphemies for Thanksgiving 'T is therefore absurd that those who believe not in Christ should be partakers of the same Happiness with them that are to be saved by Faith in Christ the which also is confirmed by this that none can be saved who is ignorant of God and the benefit of his Creation else all Idolaters may be saved therefore neither he can be saved that is ignorant of the benefit of our Redemption because the benefit of our Redemption is far greater and more admirable and pertains more to the Glory of God and Christ and requires of us a more ample Honour Service and Thanksgiving Nor is it sufficient to know in general The benefit of our Redemption is to be known in particular that all this Happiness comes to us from God this is not enough to pay that gratitude and honour due to him but we ought to know what and how great this benefit is how and in what manner and way he conferred it namely that he delivered us from Sin and Eternal Death that he opened us the passage to Eternal Life and that also by a way most stupendious and strange to wit by uniting our Nature to his own and therein suffering death for us For this chiefly commends his Charity Mercy and Justice this requires of us all Obedience all Praise Benediction and Thanks-giving and these are principally to be known by us as necessary to Salvation Third Reason Again if every one may be saved in his own Faith then that Faith sufficeth to Salvation which is no infused gift of God but a Humane Perswasion conceived by a private judgment supported by Humane Authority and built on a fallible foundation For although the Turks believe one God Maker of Heaven and Earth and Rewarder of Good and Evil Works yet this Faith is not from the Holy Ghost but from a private Judgment or rather from the Devil for they do not so believe because God hath revealed it to Men by some true Prophet but because Mahomet whom they imagine to be God's Prophet and Instrument to instruct Mortals has so declared it in his Alcoran Therefore although that which they believe is true yet because the Foundation and all their reason of believing is false and pernicious to wit that Mahomet is a Prophet of God the Faith it self whereby they believe is deceitful and in regard of the foundation on which it depends is noxious and destructive to Salvation necessarily infecting the Mind with the contagious Errours of that Sect. How then can it be said that that Faith is sufficient to their Salvation or that they can be saved by this Faith How can that Faith which is uncertain fallible and pestilential be laid for a foundation of Justice and Salvation In like manner the Jews although they believe the same things and many more consonant to Truth yet that Faith whereby they believe these things is deceitful and far from the Spirit of God For the main reason of their belief is because their Rabbins and Doctors of their Synagogue so interpret the Scriptures for these are a Rule of Faith to them or which is the same thing the Holy Scripture as 't is subject to their Interpretation But all this reason of believing is false and deceitful and no less harmful than that of the Turks For now it is as bad to believe the Rabbins to be indued with the Spirit of God for the right interpretation of Scripture as Mahomet to be a Prophet of God nor are they driven to less absurdities by force of that Principle How then can such a Faith be the Basis or Ground-work of Salvation Fourth Reason Lastly This Opinion makes no difference between Turcism Judaism and Christianity but in some small matters nothing at all necessary to Salvation so that 't is all one what Religion you live in because you may be saved in any which is to open a way to the Alcoran and to equalize Mahomet with Christ or rather to introduce Atheism For to allow of every Religion is to take away all Religion and think none necessary since there can be but one only true Religion The Fundamental Reason on which this Opinion chiefly depends is of no moment For First if it be not incredible That God for many thousand years An Answer to the Foundation of the other Opinion left the whole World in Idolatry except the Jewish Nation a little part of it and suffered the same to run headlong into destruction although amongst them there were many famous Wits and serious Worshippers of their Gods and Lovers of Humane Justice and Honesty it ought not to seem incredible that the Turks and Jews at this time live in the state of damnation Secondly The Turks and Jews now who believe not in Christ are less excuseable then of old the Heathens were that did not acknowledge one God Maker of Heaven and Earth The reason is because when almost the whole World was overspread with Idolatry the violence of common custom swept away all nor did reason much sway with private Men to doubt of their Religion and if any doubt did arise there was no easie way of knowing the Truth But now since the Christian Faith hath compassed the World so that Christians are to be found every where both Jews and Turks have manifold occasions to doubt of their Religion and if they refuse or carelesly neglect to confer with
Great and St. Hilarion St. Martin St. Nicholas St. Benedict St. Malachy St. Bernard St. Dominick St. Francis of Paul St. Francis Xaverius to omit innumerable others Besides that their Miracles were not counterfeited Their Miracles were no Lies may easily be proved many ways 1st Because they were written by most grave and authentick Authors For the Miracles of St. Gregory who was therfore call'd Thaumaturgus that is the Worker of Miracles were written by St. Gregory Nyssen in the Life of him and by St. Basil in his Book of the Holy Ghost chap. 29. The Miracles of St. Anthony by St. Athanasius and St. Hierome of St. Martin by Severus Sulpitius of St. Nicholas by divers Greek Authors of St. Benedict by St. Gregory the Great and others of St. Malachy by St. Bernard of St. Bernard by several eminent Authors in his own time of St. Francis by St. Bonaventure of St. Dominick by those who being Eye-witnesses of them were reconcil'd to the Catholick Faith of St. Francis of Paul by the Bull of his Canonization and the Miracles of St. Francis Xaverius after a strict scrutiny and sworn Witnesses were approv'd of by publick Testimony of the Vice-Roy of India Who can believe that these Men famous for Sanctity Learning and Authority would to the damnation of their Souls and eternal infamy of their good Name forge these Miracles and impose them upon the World For a Lie in things pertaining to Religion is a most grievous mortal Sin Then again if they were false and feigned the vanity of them might easily have been discovered by the Men of that Age wherein they were written But no body ever rejected them except Heathens Jews or Hereticks Add hereunto that many of these Miracles were confirm'd by the publick Testimony of Bishops or Magistrates through a previous knowledge of them Lastly to say that they were false and counterfeited is to take away all belief of History and overthrow all knowledge of former times For all the Acts of Antiquity may be said to be false and feigned since they cannot be proved but by the Authority of the Writers In like manner that their Miracles were not wrought by help of the Devil nor by the Devil is manifest divers ways 1st Because they were done by most holy Men and such as were entirely devoted to God's Service Who can believe that St. Francis St. Dominick St. Bernard St Benedict St. Martin c. had any Commerce with the Devil Again because their Works were far above the Devils Power For the Devil cannot open the Eyes of the blind nor cure the lame nor raise the dead nor give immediate cure to Paralitticks or restore dead and withered Limbs c. All these things are above the power of Nature And hence never any Magicians could do such such things by the Devil's aid But our Saints have done many such Miracles and almost innumerable and that in a trice by the touch only or by the sign of the Cross by a short prayer and oftentimes only by a word of Command 3dly Because those which are done by the Art of the Devil either continue but a little while being delusions and deceptions of the Sight as appears by that which Conjurers do or if they last long they are done by natural Causes and exceed not the power of them Moreover they are for the most part unprofitable to Men vain and hurtful as to make Fire to descend from Heaven to make a Statue or Idol speak c. which shall be done by Anti-Christ and his false Prophets in the last days as 't is written in the Revelations Chap. 13. nor do they tend to amendment of Life But the Miracles of the Saints have a permanent and solid effect and are profitable to Mankind exciting us to the fear of God and amendment of our Lives 4thly New Miracles are never allowed of in the Church but by great Examination before-hand for Witnesses are examined and commonly under Oath the Fact it self is also looked into whether 't was not done by Virtue of Nature or Help of the Devil all Circumstances are likewise considered as by what means order and occasion in what place and time to what end and for whom and before whom the Miracle was wrought And oftentimes there are not wanting Persons that are emulous who are willing to undervalue and slight the matter overmuch or endeavour what they can to render it suspicious and therefore they let nothing escape untry'd or unexamin'd So that it is impossible the Fraud should lie hid long if there were any and it concerns the Divine Providence not to permit Men to be so miserably deluded especially after so great care and diligence used by them to find out the Truth 5thly If the Miracles of the Church were from the Devil to retain Men in a flase Religion Why does he not do the same in other false Religions namely amongst the Turks Arrians Anabaptists Libertines c. Why does he forbear to work Miracles amongst all these and do them only in the Catholick Church Is it because he loves it better than all the rest But he should not neglect them by whom he may enlarge his Dominions He is delighted with variety of false Worships and accommodates himself to the Genius Dispositions and Affections of all Therefore since only the Catholick Religion hath Miracles and no false Religion hath or can have them 't is a clear sign that the Miracles of the Catholick Church are not from the Devil Lastly What reason is there that they should be counted Fictions or performed by the Devil Is it because they cannot be done But God is Omnipotent and did many the like by his Apostles as appears in Scripture Or is it because they are repugnant to Scripture But our Lord hath plainly promised this Grace of Miracles saying Verily verily I say unto you he that believeth in me the Works that I do shall he do also and greater Works than these shall he do because I go to my Father and whatsoever you shall ask the Father in my Name that will I do that the Father may be glorified in the Son Joh. 14.12 c. By which Words he insinuates that the Gift of Miracles shall always remain in the Church not only amongst the Apostles but many Apostolical Men and People of eminent Sanctity in due time and place This Promise therefore of our Lord we see fulfilled when Holy Men do Miracles Or is it for lack of Witnesses Besides the Writers most worthy of belief we have the credit and consent of the People the Testimony of Bishops and Magistrates after a strict enquiry and examination of the matter by Sworn Witnesses There are not any ancient Matters of Fact except those recorded in the Holy Scriptures which have so many and so considerable Witnesses Add hereunto that in every Age yea almost every year there are many great Miracles done in several places by the Saints reigning with Christ in Heaven especially
de unitati Ecclesiae Ninthly They both deny Prayer for the Dead Fasts in Lent or at any other time c. This heretofore taught the Arrians Witness Epiphanius Heres 75. and St. Aul de Heres c. 33. Tenthly Both of them deny Veneration to Sacred Images of Christ and his Saints and to Holy Relicks and call it Idolatry The same of old did Vigilantius as St. Hierome witnesseth and so did the Iconomachists witness Zonoras Cedrinus Nicephorus Iconomachis Hereby is clearer than the Sun at Noon day that the Chief Tenets of Luther and Calvin's Religion are old Heresies long ago condemned by the Church and were always taken for Heresies in the Church The same might be easily proved of other Sects Hence it follows that these New Religions are nothing but the Filth and Scum of old Heresies formerly condemned Vid. Bel. de nov Eccl. c. 9. Coccium de sign Eccl. l. 8. c. 30. The Eleventh Reason from the want of a Rule of Faith THese New Religions have no certain Rule of Faith which you may follow Therefore they are not to be allowed For Points of Religion ought to be defined certain and immutable That they have no certain Rule of Faith whereby can be determined what is necessary to be believed and what not is manifest First Because they will not allow the Traditions of the Church nor the Authority of General Councils nor of the Ancient Fathers and Doctors of the Church who were before our Debates Luther rejects all Traditions in the First Chapter to the Galat. And Calvin l. 4. Instit And both of them teach That nothing is to be believed nor received which is not contained in Holy Seripture L. 4. c. 8. s 6 7 8. in Antidoto ad 4. Sess Coneil Triden General Councils which have had hitherto in the Church the highest Authority for they are as the Assemblies of Princes and Noblemen in Christ's Kingdom Luther so contemns that whatsoever they have defined he would have it all to be subject to the judgment of every private Person Nay he says 'T is a great madness that Councils should conclude what we are to believe In Art 115. c. Moreover what we ought to believe and what not is to be left to the judgment of every Spiritual Man The same Calvin insinuates saying ' The ' Church ought not to judge what Books are Canonical and what not but this belongs to the private Spirit L. 1. c. 7. s 1.24 Lastly as touching the Fathers Luther ' cares not for a thousand Augustines ' nor a thousand Cyprians Lâ— cont Reg. Augl Calvin also in many places contemns them and averrs that they erred Therefore none of these is a Rule of Faith to them Whether the Scripture is a sufficient Rule of Faith but they say The Scripture it self is their Rule of Faith for this cannot err But 't is easie to shew that this Rule is not sufficient First Because by this Rule we cannot judge of Scripture it self that it is Scripture So that this Rule is uncertain to us which ought to be the most certain of all things For it cannot appear out of Scripture that this or that Book is truly the Scripture that it is not supposititious or counterfeited by some Impostor that this or that Sentence is not perverted c. Lastly that there is nothing added or diminished pertaining to the substance of Doctrine All this cannot appear out of Scripture but is only proved by some humane and weak Conjectures if you exclude the Tradition of the Church and so the whole Foundation of our Faith will depend upon a few uncertain Conjectures Then again the force of Scripture consists not in the sound of Words but in the Sence which is the Life and Soul of Scripture But there may be a thousand Controversies of the Sence which cannot be decided out of Scripture if you exclude Tradition and Exposition of the Fathers as 't is manifest by experience For touching the sence of these Words This is my Body and of many others there is a great dispute between the Lutherans and Calvinists If you say with Calvin that the Judge of Scriptures Whether the judgment of Scripture belongs to the private Spirit and the Sence thereof belongs to the inward Spirit this is nothing else but to constitute the dictamen of the Interior Spirit that is the private judgment of every one to be the chief Rule of Faith For every one may say that he has the Spirit and by his inspiration judges this part to be Holy Scripture and not that this to be the right sence of Scripture and not that So a Lutheran according to his Spirit judges the Epistle of St. James to be straw and the Revelations of St. John to be of doubtful Authority But a Calvinist by his Spirit judges both to be the Word of God So Luther judges by his Spirit to abolish the false Opinion That there are Four Gospels In the Prologue of the New Testament for the Gospel of St. John is the only true beautiful and principal Gospel and to be preferred far before the other three Likewise the Epistles of Baul far excel Peter's The thee Gospels of St Matthew Mark and Luke he would willingly have renounced because they are clearly for Merits necessity of Good Works and Observation of the Commandments and commend Chastity and Poverty But since he durst not totally reject them he is willing to disparage their Authority and to insinuate that they were not written by the Spirit of God In like manner Calvin by his Spirit judges this to be right sence of these Words This is my Body That is This Bread is the Figure of my Body But Luther according to his Spirit judges otherwise and says these Words of Christ This is my Body are thus to be understood This Bread is truly my Body I omit many other sayings whereby it is manifest that according to them the private Spirit of every one makes a Rule of Faith or which is the same thing the Scripture is expounded according to every Ones private judgment Secondly That is not to be held a proper Rule of Faith which is equally accommodated or fitted to all contrary Opinions For all the Sects of this time although they are at Daggers-point about many principal Tenets adopt the Scriptures to be their Rule and fit it for their purpose For the Lutherans say they rely upon Scripture so do the Calvinists and likewise the Anabaptists nor is it any wonder because every one receives the Scripture not according to the common understanding of the Church or exposition of the Fathers as Catholicks do but according to the sentiment of every one's private Spirit So you may easily adapt the Scripture for all Heresies Whence it is plain that a Rule thus framed can be of no moment being referred to every one's private judgment Thirdly If there should be a Judge that should so give sentence in any
their Apostles such as Luther Calvin Melancton Zwinglius c. who they suppose were indued with the Spirit of God or because each one by his own judgment conceives them to be contained in the Scriptures or lastly because the private Spirit inwardly witnesseth them to be true or that such is the sence and meaning of the Holy Scripture For whatsoever the Sectaries of this time believe they believe for some of these three reasons and one of the three they make the foundation of their Faith and motive of belief But these three Foundations or Motives of belief are altogether deceitful as you shall see That the first Foundation namely the authority of Luther Calvin and others that devised these New Religions is deceitful is manifest because experience shews they could be deceived and did really err in many things For many things they revoked many things they corrected they contradicted themselyes in many things as is clearly demonstrated in the Ninth Consideration and Sixth Reason of my Consult about Religion Hence it is that now but few depend on their Authority saying they were Men subject to Errour and therefore their Followers desert them as they list where they think they can find some better Doctrine Their Authority therefore is deceitful even in the Opinion of their own Disciples and Followers Nor is the other ground less deceitful to wit their own private judgment whereby they expound the Scriptures For many things which are indeed false to a private Judgment seem to be true and those things which at first seemed to be true are afterwards found to be false Hence it is that there are such diversity of Opinions such chopping and changing of Religions because Humane Judgment is very weak especially in the Mysteries of Faith and Understanding of the Scripture which transcend Humane Capacity Many Answer that in believing Whether they rely on Scripture they do not rely on their own judment but the Holy Scriptures which cannot err How miserably they are deceived herein appears by this that almost all Sectaries say they rely upon Scripture when they disagree in many things amongst themselves and teach things contrary to one anothers Doctrine which could not rationally be done if they relyed upon the lawful understanding of Scripture and not on their own private judgment For the Scripture is no where contrary to it self it disagrees in no place with it self therefore the reason why they so much differ amongst themselves is because they interpret the sence of Scripture according to their own private Judgment which is divers according to the variety of Judgments and Understandings of Men. They rely therefore upon Scripture not as 't is interpreted by the Holy Fathers of the Catholick Church but according to their own private Judgment For the virtue and efficacy of the Scripture consists not in the naked Words but in the right meaning and interpretation Therefore their whole foundation is their own private judgment which how deceitful it is the dissentions of so many Sects clearly demonstrate Lastly The Third Foundation of their belief on which many The private Spirit at this time depend is the most deceitful of all because among the Fanaticks who pretend most of all to the instinct of the Spirit there are the greatest differences and divisions amongst themselves which could not be unless the Spirit which rules and governs them and on which they depend were deceitful and various The same is observable amongst the Lutherans and Presbyterians and the different Sects and Factions of them both for every one is certain of the truth of his Opinion by the private Spirit which instructs him whereby it is most manifest and clear that this Spirit is not the Holy Spirit the Spirit of God and Truth which cannot teach contradictions and be against it self but the Wicked Spirit the Spirit of Errour Who is a Lyar from the beginning and the Father of Lies who lives in the Children of unbelief Joh. 8.44 of whom the Apostle says Because they received not the love of the Truth that they might be saved therefore God shall send them strong delusions to believe a Lye c. 2 Thes 2.11 And in another place In the latter times some shall depart from the Faith attending to the Spirits of Errour and Doctrines of Devils 1 Tim. 4.1 for every Heresie is the Doctrine of Devils And S. John Believe not every Spirit but try the Spirits whether they are of God because many false Prophets are gone out into the World 1 Joh. 4.1 This is that Spirit which rules in the Hearts of Hereticks and whose Testimony brag of as thinking it to be the Holy Ghost This so blinds their Understandings and perverts their Fancies that they take Light to be Darkness and Darkness Light they esteem the most clear Truth of the Catholick Faith to be Errour and their own foul and dismal Errours to be the clear Truth and certainly were they not totally bewitched and blinded they might easily perceive that that Spirit which inwardly they feel is not the Spirit of God or at least they could not choose but doubt of it since every Sect amongst whom there is so great dissension touching their chiefest Principles lays equal claim to the Testimony of this Spirit boast of it and follow it and in maintaing their Tenets repugnant to each other chiefly depend on it But this happens by the just Judgment of God For as the Jews who would not receive Christ were permitted to be blinded by the Devil as 't is plainly gathered from the Apostle 2 Thess 2. So Hereticks who have deserted the Catholick Faith which is no less a Sin than that of the Jews are permitted to be blinded by Satan and led into all Ernour And if a Man but attentively consider A greater facination of the Devil in our Hereticks than in the Jews he shall perceive a more powerful operation of the Devil in our Hereticks and a greater facination of their Mind than there is in the Jews and Turks and this for two Reasons First Because the Jews agree in their Belief and have no different Sects amongst them Among the Turks or Mahometans there be only two and they not much different But amongst the Hereticks of our days there are numbers of Sects some propagated one out of another by the rise of New Opinions mutually condemning one another of Heresie and all these are sprung up within 100 years or thereabout which is a clear sign that the Devil has a great power in the Minds of these Man to disturb their Fancies pervert their Imaginations and Judgments that they can neither stand nor rest any where Secondly Because the vulgar People among the Jews and Turks rely not upon their own judgment nor the instinct and testimony of the private Spirit but upon the judgment of their Doctors or which is the same thing upon their Scripture as 't is expounded by the Doctors of their own Religion Therefore they
Church ought to Preach but those that are sent by Lawful Authority according to the Apostle How shall they Preach unless they be sent Otherwise a great confusion would spring in the Church For every one then would take upon him the Office of Preaching and governing the Church and sow what Errors he pleased For if in a Temporal Republick or Humane Government no Man can intrude himself and assume the Magistracy to govern the People in Earthly Affairs pertaining only to this Life but ought to have Commission from the Prince how much less in the Church in the Spiritual Kingdom of Christ can any one arrogate to himself the Office of a Pastor to govern the People in things belonging to their Eternal Salvation but ought to have Authority from the Supreme Head of the Church For a confusion of Government in the Church is much more to be avoided than in a Republick since this tends to a destruction of Souls whereas the other is but the loss of our Fortunes or Bodies Again He that entreth not by the door into the Sheepfold but climbeth up some other way the same is a Thief and a Robber saith our Lord Joh. 10. But he that without any Lawful Mission and Authority assumes the Office of a Pastor in the Church does not enter in at the door but climbeth up some other way as the Fathers every where expound it and as 't is plain enough of it self For what is it else to enter by the door than to enter by a Lawful way by legitimate Authority For a door is the ordinary way appointed whereby to enter into the Sheepfold and signifies this Lawful Authority whereby Ministers ought to be admitted into the Sheepfold of Christ to govern and feed Christ's Flock Moreover our Lord says by St. John He that speaketh of himself seeketh his own Glory but he that seeketh his Glory that sent him the same is true and no injustice is in him Joh. 7.18 By which Words he signifies we must not believe those who come of themselves and are not lawfully sent because they seek their own glory and profit to which end all their Doctrine is directed Lastly The Apostle in his Epistle to the Hebrews judges this Mission to be so necessary that he requires it in Christ our Lord No Man taketh this Honour to himself but he that is called of God as Aaron So Christ also did not glorifie himself that he might be made a High Priest but he that said to him Thou art my Son this day have I begotten thee Hence it is that our Lord so often inculcated to the Jews his Mission namely that he did not come of himself but was sent by his Father and confirms the same many ways Hereby it is clear that Luther Calvin and the like new Doctors are not to be heard nor their Doctrine believed but avoided and detested because 't is apparent they came of themselves without any Lawful Authority It is evident that they have usurped to themselves this Function and Duty of Pastors and a Right to Reform the Church It is manifest they entred not by the door and by a legal way but climb'd up another way into the Sheepfold and therefore according to the Sentence of our Lord they are to be taken for Thieves and Robbers Perhaps they will say they were sent immediately from Christ Christ sent them not as of old God sent the Prophets in an extraordinary manner to Reform the People and as Christ sent his Apostles to convert the World and as St. Paul after our Lord's Ascention was not sent by Men nor received the Gospel from Men but immediately from our Lord Jesus Christ But First 't is not enough to say this and boldly to affirm it but they must prove it and evince it to be true lest the People and other ordinary Pastors lawfully renounce them as Impostors As the Prophets of old and the Apostles did not only say that God sent them but abundantly prov'd and demonstrated the same by many Miracles Secondly All Arch Hereticks and false Prophet in all Ages have said the like namely that they were sent of God and received their Authority from him Therefore all are to be imbraced or none For why should I believe for example sake that God sent Calvin rather than Luther Munster Arrius or any other Arch Heretick since he cannot shew greater Proofs or Reasons of his Mission than the others Thirdly If God sent Calvin then he did not send Luther and so the contrary because if two Prophecy contradictions and condemn one another in their Doctrine of resie they destroy the Religion of each other Wherefore if God sent both of them he should be against himself deny and overthrow himself destroying by one what he built up by the other Amongst the Prophets which God sent there was always an exact agreement of Doctrine Fourthly If God sent Luther or Calvin to reform the Church I ask at what time and in what place did God confer on them this Ministry What Words did he say to them either outwardly or inwardly How did he declare to them the points of Reformation what order and method did he prescribe them How or in what Form did he appear to them Whither exteriourly in a visible manner as he did to St. Paul or interiourly by an imaginary Vision in some ecstasie as to the Prophets and to S. John the Evangelist in his Revelations For all these things God is wont to do when he sends any One extraordinarily and the Prophets themselves presently when they began to Preach declared all this that the People might understand by whom they were sent or what charge was given them as it appears by the Prophet Isai Chap. 1. c. Ezek. 1. c. Dan. 2. and 9. c. In fine all the Prophets were used to Evidence this in the first place as you may see in their Prophecies In like manner it is known at what time and by what Words our Lord sent his Apostles and what he enjoyn'd them c. But these new Prophets were so inconsiderate that they never thought of this to be reputed immediately sent from God for there is no mention hereof made by them which is a most certain sign that they are compelled of necessity to tell a most grievous untruth by saying God sent them For who can doubt if they had the least colour of Divine Mission they would not have inserted it in their Writings and presently manifested the same to the whole World expressing the time place manner and precept of our Lord together with other circumstances Fifthly If God sent them he did not only send them as Reformers of Manners as the Prophets were sent but as Reformers of all Doctrine and Religion and therefore an exact narration and description of their Mission was chiefly necessary and a nomination of the points which God would have reformed and in his Name and Words propounded to the Church as the Prophets
of old were used to do when they proposed to the People the Divine Commandments in the Name of God But these New Prophets have not proceeded in this manner but by chance and as their matter required they fell from one Opinion to another as it happens in Disputes and Contentions when their Minds were more and more exasperated and as by experience they could learn how to accommodate themselves in their Affairs and incommode or undermine the Pope's Authority which condemned them For what ever they perceived would be most prejudicial to the See of Rome or advantageous to it they decreed points of Faith accordingly and varnished them over with the Word of God as I shall shew hereafter Sixthly In Humane Policy if any should pretend Authority to govern it is not sufficient to say that he was sent by the Prince of the Country who was far of and could not conveniently come himself but he must shew his Patent or Commission signed with the King's Seal which then is diligently examined least there should be any fraud in the case and if there should be the least sign of a shamm or cheat it is not to be admitted till a full and certain proof thereof be made The same we see in the Apostolical Legates who all shew their Patents authentick wherein their Mission and Commission is contained otherwise they are not credited nor have Authority What madness is it then to admit into the Church and Kingdom of Christ not only New Pastors but likewise Reformers of the whole Religion of the Church only upon their saying that Christ sent them and that they have the Spirit of God without shewing any Patent or Miracle to prove it Seventhly The account of time also is strongly against them for if the Church fell away about 600 years after Christ and became the Synagogue of Antichrist as they teach Why was the Mission of these Reformers delay'd to these times Why did God forsake his Church 900 years together and suffer it to continue in its ruines in Superstition and Idolatry as nothing belonging to him and after the accomplishment of so many Ages should send first to her these New Reformers or Chief Masters Is this the Love of Christ towards his Church which he hath cleansed with his Blood which he hath quickened with his Spirit and which he hath adopted or chosen for his Spouse He shew'd himself much kinder to his Handmaid the Synagogue by sending them many Prophets to reclaim them still prone to Idolatry and grand Impieties Therefore if these Men would have been thought Reformers they should have feigned the Church to have faln but a little before them and not for so many Ages to have lain putrified in its ruines Otherwise this long distance of time confutes their Mission and shews it to be very imprudently forged Eightly Hereunto may be added other most certain signs that Christ did not send them as their vicious Life Pride contempt of the Holy Fathers the Errors and Lies wherein they were taken besides their inconstancy of Doctrine which I shall declare in the following Reasons Ninthly and Lastly They teach that nothing is to be believed but what is in Scripture Let them therefore shew out of the Scriptures that they were sent by God to reform the Church In what place and by what Words of Scripture did our Lord give this Authority to Luther or Calvin Otherwise we cannot believe them being themselves Judges nor receive them as Reformers of the Church And here I cannot forbear to insert a ridiculous fancy of the Lutherans which yet made a great noise among them They endeavoured to establish the Mission of their Prophet by a certain Prophecy of St. Ambrose and St. Augustine contained forsooth in this verse Tibi Cherubin et Seraphin incessabili voce proclamant that is To thee Cherubins and Seraphins continually do cry For some years ago they erected an Effigies of Luther cut in Brass with this Inscription A divine and wonderful Prophecy of St. Ambrose and St. Augustine shewing the time and coming of Luther wherein he began to write against the Roman-Antichrist as it is contained in the Letters of this Versicle representing the date of the year which is a thing worthy the note and admiration of all Faithful Christians TIbI CherVbIn et SeraphIn InCessabILI VoCe proCLaMant The Numeral Letters of this Versicle are 1517. in which year of our Lord Luther began first to Preach But this was certainly a very poor shift For First By such Numeral Hitts nothing certain can be concluded by any Wise Man as hath appeared by many Examples in former ages from the success of things But Secondly Grant it a prophetical speech concerning Luther the exultation and gratulation of the Celestial Spirits for the Preaching of Luther need not to be signified thereby as the Lutherans would have it but rather the blindness of Luther and all that are of his Sect as in the 6th of Isaiah where the Seraphins in like manner cry Holy holy holy is the Lord God of Hosts the whole Earth is full of his Glory from which place these Versicles are put in the Hymn is designed the excecation or blindness of the Jews as by the sequel it is gathered For God is provoked at the view of his Holiness which abominates all Sin to execute revenge and just Judgment upon so great Wickedness and Impiety In like manner they shall cry for Vengeance at the end of the World Apoc. 4.8 To conclude if we write these Names according to the Hebrew manner by m and not by n that is Cherubim and Seraphim as they ought to be written so the Number will rise to 3157. which being ended the Cherubims and Seraphims will still cry Holy holy holy but this Clamour will not be for joy of the success of Luther's Gospel but an approbation of his just punishment whereby he and all his Associates shall be tormented to all Eternity The Fourth Reason from a want of Miracles Miracles necessary THese new Religions with the Authors of them are very much to be suspected because they were introduc'd without Miracles or Signs from God For these were chiefly necessary First That so they might shew themselves to be no Impostors but true Pastors sent by Almighty God and to convince the World they ought to be received For since it is manifest in Scripture that in the later days many false Prophets shall arise bragging to be sent from God therefore our Lord gave us a special warning of them not to give ear to them without infallible proofs of their Mission which cannot be but by Signs and Tokens from God as are Miracles Prediction of things to come Revelation of things hid c. for since these things are above the power of Creatures 't is plain demonstration they are of God And therefore they are like Patents signed with God's Great Seal in proof of their Mission from him Hence it is that as many as were ever
sent immediately from God to teach the people were impowered to work Miracles or supernatural Signs to prove the verity of their Mission So Moses being about to conduct the Children of Israel out of Egypt and give them a Law came with authority to do prodigious Miracles and he himself did innumerable or God also about him who so often appeared to him in a visible shape So all their Prophets proved the truth of the Mission by Miracles or revealing of Secrets The same did Christ himself Lord of the Prophets who although 't was demonstrable in Scripture that he was the Messias and that it evidently appeared by the testimony of St. John the Baptist yet presently at the beginning of his Preaching he shewed that he was sent by his Father for the Salvation of Mankind by many Miracles and said to the Pharisees that out of hatred would not give credit to him if they would not believe him for his own sake at least they should believe him being convinced by the greatness of his Works In like manner all the Apostles proved the legality of their Mission amongst the Jews and Heathens by many Miracles To conclude so did the first Doctors of divers Nations which were converted from Paganism to our Faith Wherefore since their new Prophets say that they were immediately sent from God if they do not confirm it by Miracles or supernatural signs as all others have done whom God immediately sent they ought not to be credited or believed Nor does it avail any thing to say that St. John the Baptist did no Miracles because God work'd many Wonders and supernatural things about him whereby his Mission was sufficiently manifest Also his Austerity of Life and Sanctity of Manners was no small Miracle Therefore no body could doubt but that God sent him Moreover Miracles were absolutely necessary to prove them to be sent not only as Converters of Manners but also as Reformers and Correctors of all Religion to re-edifie the Church lapsed to raise again the Kingdom of Christ extinct and to make all things new How great Miracles had been necessary for them whereby to convince the World that they were bound to believe such Wonders and Paradoxes and to receive them for such Reformers If they had raised a thousand from the dead and cured a hundred thousand lame blind and sick of the Palsie it had been scarce enough to make one believe so great a matter First Because the Apostle saith Though we or an Angel from Heaven preach any other Gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you let him be Anathema that is accursed Gall. 1.8 And repeating the same again for greater confirmation of the matter he adds as I said before so say I now again If any one preach any other Gospel unto you than that you have received let him be Anathama Gal. 1.9 If we ought not to believe an Angel from Heaven preaching any thing contrary to the received Doctrine of Faith how many and great Miracles were requisite to be shewed by a mortal Man that preaches contrary to the approved Faith before he is to be certainly believed as that Christ's Church is utterly fallen that Idolatry hath got into it and extinguished the Faith that all are in the state of Damnation that the chiefest points of Religion are to be reformed and that God sent Luther or Calvin to make this Reformation Was it not fit that all the Miracles of Christ and his Apostles should have been revived by this Reformer Again because the Catholick Religion which now storishes has been above a thousand years in possession as our Adversaries confess and esteemed over all the World for the true Religion of Christ and they that fell from it were counted Hereticks Therefore without great and evident Miracles to make it appear a wicked and unjust possession it cannot lawfulâ—y be disturbed And the Signs from God ought to be so apparent and convincing that there 's no room left for any Tergiversation or denial otherwise we are not bound to believe them but rather obliged to favour so long a possession and not desert the Catholick Religion I add farther that the Catholick Religion in all those Ages was famous for the Glory of Miracles Wisdom and Sanctity of the Professors and even now is Therefore there is need of many greater and more renowned Miracles to be shewed before she can be lawfully dispossessed cast down and rejected also of greater Wisdom and Piety and that by publick Fame in the followers of these new Religions than were ever in the Professors of the Catholick Religion Lastly When the Religion of the Old Testament amongst the Jews was to be changed and to pass from the Shadow to the Truth from the Type to the Exemplar although our Lord could clearly out of the Scriptures convince that this change was to be made and that God sent him for this purpose yet he was pleased to confirm the same with many and great Miracles thereby to take away all occasion of cavilling and back-sliding How many Miracles therefore shall we think needful when a change is attemted to be made of the Religion of the New Testament which the Scriptures expresly declare shall never be changed but that God will be with it to the end of the World and the Gates of Hell shall never prevail against it Who can prudently believe without great Miracles a thing so strange and new such a Parodox as well against the Scriptures as the judgment of the Fathers Yea what Miracles can be sufficient to make one to believe it to be probable By this it is plain that we deservedly require Miracles of them and that they deal with us most injuriously and impiously when they command us to believe them in matters of so great weight without any Miracles and unless we do believe them to persecute us grievously But say they we prove our Tenets from the Scripture Whether they prove their Tenets from Scripture True but in your own sense not according to the consent of the Holy Fathers and received Doctors of the Church who lived before our Controversies and therefore could not be partial in their Opinions Again those proofs of yours drawn like a Spider's Web out of your selves are as easily dissolved by Catholick Doctors And there have sprung up so many new Reformers so many Repairers of the ruined Church so many Ralsers of Religion extinguished who though they are very contrary amongst themselves and contradict one another each Sect striving to destroy what the other builds yet all of them confirm their Principles by Scripture all of them relie solely upon this Testimony for their Foundation according to their own Construction Threfore this way of probation must be to all or none And to each of these Expositors it may be said if nothing is to be believed but what is in the Scripture where I pray does it tell you that God sent you to reform the fallen Church or Religion
In opere Inscripto Lutherus Septiceps Of the Communion of the Eucharist Gasper Querhamer a Lay Saxon observed in Luther's Works In Tabula contrad Luther Thirty six Contradictions and printed them when Luther was living to his great shame and confusion and the diminution of his Authority And of Communion under both kinds Cochlaeus has noted seven contradictory Articles In fine Cochlaeus's whole Book called Lutherus Septiceps contains nothing else but Luther's Contradictions and contrary Opinions in almost all his controverted Articles in the express Words of Luther Now in every contradiction of necessity one part must be false As to Calvin Coccius relates Twenty four Contradictions of his in his very own Words It is enough for me to set down two of them Touching God's Omnipotency in one place he says nothing is impossible to the Word of God Luk. 1. And in another place he says That Dream of an Absolute Power in God which the School Doctors have introduced is an execrable Blasphemy Psa 23. Again I abhor this Doctrine in which the Papist Divines please themselves feigning in God a certain Absolute Power Of Christ's Godhead in one place he writes That Christ is true God of the same Essence with his Father De Predestin 1 Joh. 5.1 In another place he says The Name of God by way of excellency Contr. Gentil refutat 10. belongs to the Father only that he only and properly is the Creator of Heaven and Earth ay and that Son according to his Godhead is subject to the Father Again That it is a hard and improper expression of the Nicene Creed God of God Light of Light In his Second Epistle to the Polanders he affirms That Christ according to his Divine Nature is less than the Father Lo whither he tumbles by being a Novelist These things being positive and clear in their own Writings what Wise Man can be induced to believe that God sent them to reform the Church For how shall they raise the fallen Church when they so vilely destroy their own Doctrine Who have so little Learning or Prudence and circumspection as not to avoid contradictions in matters of the greatest moment Certainly whosoever contradicts himself and presently pulls down what he hath newly erected 't is clearer than the Noon-day that he speaks not by the Spirit of God For if I build again the things which I destroyed says St. Paul I make my self a Prevaricator Gal. 2.18 The Spirit of God cannot be contrary to himself cannot deny himself Take notice likewise That although in many things they contradict themselves and overthrow their own Principles yet they have Face and Impudence to say that they are certain their Doctrine is true and the very Doctrine of Christ For thus Luther writes I am certain I received my Doctrine from Heaven Cont. Reg. Aug. Again I am certain that my Doctrine is not mine but Christ's And in another place he says that he is so absolutely sure Cont. Stat. Eccles that he will have no Body to be Judge of his Doctrine no not the Angels and that none can be saved who believes not his Doctrine In like manner Calvin oftentimes says That he is a Prophet that he can deceive none unless God deceive him as I have shewed in the Fifth Reason Hereby 't is a clear demonstration that not only they speak not by the Spirit of God having such open and manifest Errours and Contradictions but also are to be look'd upon as Impostors who deceive the People For he that says he is certain that his Doctrine in which are many Errours and Contradictions is of God may well be supposed not to deal fairly and sincerely but to speak against his own Conscience and so to impose upon the People 'T is manifest that such a one hath no Internal Illumination from God to make him certain of the Truth of his Doctrine by the Testimony of God For God cannot testifie or reveal Contradictions With what Face therefore can they so impudently affirm that they are sure their Doctrine is of God or Christ's Doctrine Therefore they deal not honestly and sincerely but endeavour to blind the World But some will confess that they erred now and then at the beginning when they had not yet fully received the Spirit of God but afterwards they did not err nor change their Opinions But this has no colour of Truth at all For all those who ever have been immediately sent by God to teach the People have presently at the beginning of their Mission had the infallible assistance and direction of God so that they could never in the least err in their Doctrine As 't is manifest by the Prophets and Apostles Nay there was greatest need of this direction in the begiuning because then chiefly all things were to be discussed the Teachers and their Doctrine to be examin'd that so they might gain Authority and be believed For if they had been catch'd in any Errour or Contradiction at first all their Authority would have fallen to the ground and perished In the like case if Calvin and Luther were sent by God to reform the Church there was great need that presently at the beginning their Doctrine should be solid and sound free from all Contradiction and Errour least they might justly be rejected as Impostors Then again I ask when at length did they obtain this plenitude or fulness of the Spirit so as never to err any more How could that appear to the World that Men may know they are to be credited at last though they were not at first For unless this can be shew'd we may rightly presume that they may erre in their future who manifestly have erred in their former Writings To conclude that they were various in their Life that they changed and mended their Principles and in divers little Books which they published and sometimes in one and the same Book they writ several contradictions it is apparent by those few things afore-mentioned and by many more which Cochlaeus Coccius and others have recorded in their own words For the longer they stood out in opposition to the Catholick Church more invective and bitter they became against it and what more mildly they alledged at first afterward they made worse or changed to the contrary The Seventh Reason from tht malicious Deceits and Frauds they make use of THat Religion is to be suspected whose Authors and Defenders use malicious Deceits Frauds and Lies to propagate it For the true Religion wants no such helps but only the false which being destitute of true and solid Reasons must necessarily place its hope and confidence in a Lye But the Authors and Propagators of the Lutheran and Calvinistical Religion used many Frauds and Lies to encrease their Sect therefore it is worthily to be suspected That they used most malicious Frauds and Deceits False Tenets imposed upon Catholicks is manifest because they imposed upon Catholicks many things falsely that so they
ean a false Faith avail to Salvation Then 't is all one Whether you believe the Creed in such a manner or in no manner Then every one may be saved though he does not believe many Articles of Faith The same I may say of the Scriptures for if it be sufficient to believe the Scriptures according to every one's interpretation since his sence may be oftentimes erroneous 't will be also enough though you do not believe them at all For a false Faith can be no more necessary to Salvation than no Faith whereby a Man believes nothing absolutely But if you say that we must believe the Symbol or Creed in its true sence then you condemn the Sectaries of these times none of which believe all the Articles of the Creed in the same sence with Catholicks and all of them differ in the explication of the Creed amongst themselves Therefore since there is but only One Truth all the Religions of these Times must necessarily swerve from the Truth except One only and therefore are insufficient to Salvation That they differ much in the sence or meaning The differences of Sectaries in understanding the Creed of the Creed is manifest For that Article And in Jesus Christ his only Son is explicated one way by the Arrians and many Calvinists namely that the Son is less than the Father and by the Catholicks and Lutherans another way for they hold him equal and of the same Substance with the Father The Article concerning Christ's descent into Hell the Calvinists interpret one way saying Christ sustained the Torments of the Damned doubted of his Salvation and was afraid he should have been utterly swallowed up by Eternal Death The Catholicks and Lutherans interpret it another way and will admit of no such exposition saying it is Calvin's Blasphemy The Article of Christ's Ascension into Heaven c. the Lutherans and Vbiquitarians expound one way holding Christ's Body to be every where as his Divinity is otherwise the Calvinists and Catholicks who doubt not but that such Expositions do overthrow in a manner all the Creed as Christ's Incarnation Nativity Passion Death Assension into Heaven and his Coming to Judgment The Article of Judging the Quick and Dead Catholicks expound one way saying that Christ shall so Judge as to reward our Good Works in Heaven and punish our Bad Works in Hell otherwise the Calvinists and Lutherans who deny all reward to Good Works and averr that an account will be only had of our special Faith at the Day of Judgment The Article concerning the Holy Ghost Catholicks and Lutherans understand one way the Arrians and many Calvinists another way The Article of the Church Lutherans and Calvinists understand of the invisible Congregation of the Predestinate Catholicks of the visible Congregation of Catholicks in which many are Predestinated and many Reprobate The Article of the Communion of Saints the Luthcrans and Calvinists so extenuate that they take away almost all Communion which is taught by Catholicks The Article of Remission of Sins they explicate of no imputation not acknowledging any Internal Renovation by inherent Justice and Grace infused as Catholicks judge Sins to be remitted Hereby is manifest how great a difference there is in the understanding of the Creed Therefore since there is but one Truth this we have shewed in our Consultation to be amongst Catholicks all Sects must of necessity hold a false Faith and false exposition of the Creed If therefore a true belief of the Creed is requisite it cannot be that every one may be saved in his own Faith If a false Faith sufficeth how can a false Faith be profitable to Salvation Sixth Reason The Holy Scripture is of no less Authority than the Apostles Creed nor is it a less injury to God to deny any thing expresly declared in the Scriptures than to reject any Article of the Apostles Creed therefore there is no reason why our Faith should be tyed to the Creed and in other things we should be left to our Liberty seeing we are as much obliged to believe all things in Scripture as in the Apostles Creed For although we are not bound to know all things distinctly contained in the Scriptures yet we ought to believe in general insomuch that we cannot without the sin of Heresie reject any part thereof as false and doubtful With what colour therefore or what probable shew of reason can it be said it matters not how you believe in other things so be it you believe in Christ and the Apostles Creed Why are we bound to believe the Creed rather than the whole Scripture since it is not of greater Authority than the Scriptures This is a fancy certainly too vain and rude void of any foundation Seventh Reason In all our Faith we must not only regard what we believe Our whole Faith depends on the foundation or motive of our belief but likewise and that chiefest of all upon what foundation we believe or what is the sole motive of our belief For upon this the whole Nature and Property of our Faith depends For as the motive of our belief is which we call the Foundation of our Faith such is the Faith it self If that be certain and cannot be deceitful our Faith also is certain and infallible If it be deceitful our Faith also will be uncertain and liable to Errour For Example The Turk believes that there is one God Creator of all things Why Because the Alcoran so teaches which he believes to be written by the Spirit of God His Faith although this which he believes be true depends on a false and fallacious foundation by force of which he is bound to believe many false and blasphemous things as that there are not Three Persons in the Godhead Father Son and Holy Ghost that Christ is not God and that he is less than Mahomet that Circumcision is to be observed and the like Therefore this Faith by virtue of this foundation is fallible and erroneous 'T is the same case with all Hereticks The Faith of all Sects depends on a false foundation This being laid down I thus argue That Faith which depends on a fallacious foundation although it believes some things which are true yet cannot be said to be sufficient to Salvation but the Faith of all Sectaries of this time depends on a fallacious or wrong foundation therefore it cannot be sufficient to Salvation The Proposition is manifest of it self For how can that which is false and lying be the Basis or Foundation of Eternal Salvation how can the true Religion whereby we please God be founded on a false belief Certainly this is as far from all reason as if you should say that Truth depends on a Lye Wisdom upon Errour and Vertue upon Vice It remains then to prove the Assumption or other proposition viz. That all Sectaries rely on a fallacious foundation A threefold foundation I shew thus They believe their Opinions either for the authority of