conveened together and sent for the Advocat who assured them that there was not nor should not bee any such thing but that the act should be conceived in so clear terms that it should not be possible to draw in under any part thereof a power to the Lords of Exchecquer to dispute let be to decyde in heretable rights And as the Subjects heretable rights and infeftments are by this act saved from being decyded or annulled by incompetent judges so your Majestie is no wayes prejudged thereby seeing the Lords of Session who by the laws of that Kingdome are proper and competent judges of heretable rights and infeftments may and will decyde any questions which may concerne your Majestie the nature tenor and validitie of any heretable right After reading and debateing of the former answers and agitation anent the Earle of Traquaires carriage in Parliament in refusing these things therein till whereunto he had consented in the Generall Assembly Especially that act of Assembly of the date the 17. of August whereby Episcopacie and the civill power and places of Kirkmen was condemned as contrary to the Confession of faith and constitutions of that Church And declared to be unlawfull and removed out of that Church and Kingdome and all the subjects by act of the Assembly with the Commissioners consent ordained to subscryve the Confession of faith with the Assemblies explanation Our Commissioners as they at the closure of all their hearings did humbly crave That his Majestie would be graciously pleased to command the Parliament to proceed and ratifie the conclusions of the Assembly and passe such other acts as were necessar for establishing Religion and the peace of that Kingdome And did require that his Majestie would signifie his pleasure concerning the desires of the Parliament and did urge their dispatch showing his Majestie the danger and prejudices which might result from delay But his Majestie commanded them to attend his time and leasure and appointed the 23. of March for the next hearing And that all farther propositions and demands which were to be made to them would be given in to them in writ that they might answere the same against that time Vpon the 20. day of the foresaid moneth of March about six a clock at night The Earle of Traquair sent to our Commissioners these propositions following PRotestation against the Thesaurer and privie seales precedencie That their giving way to the Thesaurer and privie seal should not prejudge them of their right The act anent the constitution of the Parliament in time coming being by the articles remitted to his Majestie to be considered till the next Parliament was thereafter questioned by some of the Nobilitie and Barons who orged the same to be brought in in open Parliament without any such reference Article craving every Commissioner of the Shyres to have a severall voice Article craving the Parliament to choose their owne Clerke or to have two of every Estate joyned with the Register and that all acts voiced in Parliament be immediatly subscryved by two of every Estate Article for every Estates choosing of their owne Lords of articles Act discharging proxies Article against the book intituled a large Declaration Commissioners of Shyres to give a roll of freeholders out of which the Justices of peace are to bee chosen Act anent the disorders of the North. Articles craving the Councell to be subalterne and censurable by the Parliament No patent of Nobilitie to be granted to any but such as have Ten thousand markes of yearely Land rent No taxation to be granted but in plain Parliament Act of pacification Article craving particular Commissions of Justiciarie and leiveteinandrie to be discharged Article in favours of Sheriffes and Stewards onely to be obliged to produce horning for the taxation Patent of making powder to be discharged Act discharging remissions for slaughter and theft but upon satisfaction to the partie Act discharging protections Act of common relief Article craving the act 1633. ordaining that confirmations and infeftments of Ward-lands shall not prejudge the Kings Waird to be repealed Act discharging the duetie payed to the Conservatour upon the coale Article craving the ammunition and armes brought in since the beginning of these troubles to be free of custome Article anent the election of the president of the Session and admission of the Judges presented by his Majestie Act craving Statesmen being Noblemen to have but one voyce His Majesties warrant for Master William Hay his deputation in his fathers place opposed by the rest of the Clerkes Vpon the 23. day of March the subsequent answers were presented to his Majestie by our Commissioners to these former propositions viz THe protestation made by some Noblemen that their giving way to the present Thesaurer and privie Seales precedencie should not prejudge them of their right Carries the reason of the protestation in it self Because in Law and practise it is usuall to any who conceive themselves prejudged even in these things where acts of Parliament passes against them To protest multo magis in such a case as this is it lawfull for them to protest That their giving way to that which they conceive hath no Law for it should not prejudge their right which is onely craved prout de Jure The act anent the constitution of the Parliament remitted by the articles to be considered by your Majestie till the next Parliament was questioned and urged that the same might bee brought in open Parliament without any such reference for diverse reasons First because in that act there was a clause craving it might be enacted that there should bee stataria parliamenta once in two or three yeares at least at which clause of the act so soon as it was understood by the proponers and ingivers thereof that your Majestie might conceive the same to derogat from the freedome of your royall power of indicting Parliaments when your Majestie pleased They did passe from that part and clause of the act And albeit it may easily bee demonstrat from the prejudice which your Majesties ancient and native Kingdome susteines through want of your royall and personall presence and their living at so farre a distance from the place of your Majesties residence how requisite it is that there bee frequent Parliaments holden in that Kingdome yet lest the desires of your Majesties subjects might seeme in any wayes to trench upon your authoritie they did passe from that part of their desire and did onely insist that there might bee a right constitution of the Parliament and that an act might be past for rescinding and repealing of such former acts of Parliaments as repugne the acts and conclusions of the Assembly which is conceived to be so absolutelie necessar as there neither can be a valide Parliament without the same nor can the acts and conclusions of the generall Assembly be ratified which to refuse were both contrar to the principall end for which the Parliament was indicted and against your Majesties royall
of that article or act craving the Councell to be subalterne and censurable by the Parliament Is from the warrant of former Lawes cited in the act it self wherein there is no more craved but that the former acts of Parliament against leasing makers and makers of division betwixt the King and his Subjects may bee revived And that the Councell and Session may bee comptable to your Majestie and the Parliament for any injustice shall happen to bee committed by them Where it is alledged there was one article That no taxation should bee granted but in plaine Parliament we remember of no such article or motion proponed As concerning the act of pacification The warrant and ground thereof flowes from the humble petitions and remonstrances of your Majesties Subjects wherein they did cleare their loyaltie and made offer of their civill and duetifull obedience to your Majestie And which by their humble supplication to your Majesties Commissioner and Lords of Councell and to the Estates of Parliament insert and registrat in the records thereof They have againe solemnely renewed And from your Majesties favour in condescending to the articles of pacification wherein your Majesty was graciously pleased That an act of pacification or oblivion should be past And in the narrative of the Act it selfe there is one humble and thankfull acknowledgement of your Majesties goodnes and Justice and is drawne up in such termes as was conceived might best expresse your Majesties fatherly care and goodnesse toward your ancient and native Kingdome without wronging the true and loyall meaning and intention of your Majesties Subjects And as for the body and legall part of the act the same was after much debating framed with advyce of Lawyers and consented unto by the parties chiefly interessed As to that article anent particular commissions of Justiciarie and Lievtennandrie all which was intended or desired thereby was That the abuses of these commissions might be in all humilitie represented to your Majestie by your Commissioner And that your Majestie might be graciously pleased to grant the like commissions onely upon weightie and necessar causes and to endure onely during the time of necessitie and the ingivers of the act was content to have it reformed that way As concerning that act given in for sheriffes and stewards craving that they might only be oblidged to produce hornings for the taxation It is not a new desire but that which hath been craved by them in diverse former Parliaments And they think that production of horning against the persons lyable in payment should bee an exoneration to them because they alledge they want many of the casualities and benefices which Sheriffes had of old by vertue of their office As concerning the proposition which was made anent the patent for making of powder All that wee remember was craved by the in-givers of that article was that in respect the Earle of Linlithgowes patent was voyde by a clause irritant in his patent whereby he was oblidged to keep the Works going and which are now decayed and the Countrey frustrate of the benefit and profit which might have accressed to them through that commoditie That therefore it might be allowed to any who were most fit and able to undergo the worke to make powder As concerning the act given in for discharge of remissions for murther slaughter theft but upon satisfaction to the partie All that was intended or craved thereby was onely That the heavie prejudices redounding to the Countrey by remissions purchased upon misinformation might be by supplication presented to your Majesties consideration That by your Majesties goodnesse and justice the like inconveniences in time coming may be prevented As for that act craving discharge of protections there was nothing craved thereby but the reviving of two former acts of Parliament viz the 47. act Parl. 11. and 13. act of the 23. Parl. K. Ja. 6. without any derogation to your Majesties power or authoritie which was done with the Commissioners consent Likeas it was recommended to him to represent the same to your Majestie with the reasons thereof The reason of the act of common reliefe is Because as the blessings of Religion and peace which from your Majesties happy governement and fatherly affection to your Majesties ancient and native Kingdome especially at this troublesome time are common benefites whereof every good subject ought to be sensible So is it agreeable with reason and justice that according to their interest every one may contribute a proportionall part of the charges which hath been spent for so good ends and the ordinar cause for which taxations are granted are ad relevationem imperii ob conservationem libertatis ac dignitatis ac religionis vel ob utilitatem communem subditorum wherefrom albeit some be averse yet the consent and voices of the most part should oblige for these ends whereunto your Majesties consent and royall authoritie is humbly craved to be added that the same may flow from your Majesties goodnesse and Justice and have execution to inferre payment thereof seeing the whole Commissioners of Shyres and Burrowes and the whole Nobilitie very few excepted are content freely and willingly to make offer of their proportionall part thereof As for that article craving the act 1633. ordaining that confirmations and infeftments of Waird lands shall not prejudge the Kings Waird to bee repealed There was no dispute nor conclusion made there-anent in articles neither as we remember was it craved by that article that the act 1633. bee repealed simply but that the meaning of that act may be explained and interpreted As for the article or act anent the duetic payed to the conservatour upon coale The same is craved to bee discharged by the coal-masters because it was an unlawfull exaction which he had no warrant to exact by his gift which was instructed in articles by production of his gift whereupon the act was past in articles The desire craving ammunition and armes brought in to be custome-free is warranted in Law in so farre as the commodities either expected or imported for the particular use of Noblemen Barons and Free-holders which are for their owne use and not to be sold againe are by act of Parliament declared to be custome-free As concerning the article anent the election of the President of the Session and admission of the Judges presented by his Majesty There was no new thing craved thereby but the ratifying and approving of the 39. act Par. 6. K. Ja. 6. 1579. And that allanerly in so farre as concernes the freedome of election to be made by the Senatours of the Colledge of Justice of the president thereof without any other clause of the said act Neither doth the act given in beare any thing concerning the admission of any other Judges presented by your Majestie As for that article anent Statesmen being Noblemen to have but one voice we remember nothing of any such question As to the last proposition Concerning the opposition made by the rest of
Religion our recourse must be onely to the GOD of Jacob for our refuge who is Lord of Lords and King of Kings and by whom Kings doe reigne and Princes decree Justice And if in speaking thus out of zeale to Religion and the dutie we owe to our Countrey and that charge which is laid upon us any thing hath escaped us sith it is spoken from the sinceritie of our hearts wee fall down at your Majesties feet humbly craving pardon for our freedome Having thus with your Majesties permission cleared the loyaltie of your Subjects That wee may next shew the reason of their demands and equitie of their proceedings in Parliament We doe first crave that if our answers cannot give plenarie satisfaction to the objections and exceptions that shall bee made against their proceedings That our not knowing of these objections albeit wee did often require your Majesties Commissioner to shew the same that we might be the more able to give your Majestie content yet being still concealed from us and the Records and Registers of Parliament being kept up from us may serve much for our excuse and if any of the propositions or articles sought or craved in Parliament shall seem harsh at the first view to these who know not our laws That we do expect from them the judgment of charitie who ought rather nor passe rash censure on us to professe ignorantiam juris facti alieni and that they would distinguish betwixt the desires and actions of a Parliament who being conveened by royal authority and honoured with your Majesty or your Commissioners presence are makers of Laws and against whom there is no law and the actions of privat persons against whom laws are made And as the desires of the Subjects are no other in the matter but what they did humbly crave in their former petitions and are necessar for establishing of Religion and the good and peace of the Kingdome which can never repugne to the Kings honour and are agreeable to the articles of pacification so in manner they are agreeable to the Lawes and practises of that Kingdome And to condiscend more specially all the articles given in are either such as concern privat subjects such as are for manufactories trade of Merchants others of that kind which doe not so much concern your Majestie or the publick as the interest of privat men which are but minima de minimis non curat lex Or they are publick acts which do concerne Religion and liberties of the Kirk and Kingdome as the ratifying the conclusions of the Assembly the act of constitution of Parliament the act of rescission the act against poperie and others of that kinde wherein because the Parliament knew that the eyes of the world were upon them that hard constructions have beene made of their proceedings and that malice is prompted for her obloquies and waiteth on with open mouth to snatch at the smallest shadow of disrespect to your Majestie That our proceedings may bee made odious to such as know them not wee have endeavoured to walk with that tendernesse which becometh duetifull Subjects who are desirous to limite themselves according to reason and the rule of Law For better understanding whereof we must distinguish betwixt regnum constituendum and regnum constitutum a Kingdome before it be settled and a Kingdome which is established by Laws wherein as good subjects esteeme it their greatest glorie to maintaine the honour and lawfull authoritie of their King so good Kings as your Majesties father of ever blessed memorie affirmes holding that maxime That salus populi est supremalex will be content to governe their Subjects according to the Law of God and fundamentall laws of their Kingdome Next we must distinguish betwixt the Kirk and State betwixt the Ecclesiastick and civil power both which are materially one yet formallie they are contradistinct in power in jurisdiction in laws in bodies in ends in offices and officers and albeit the Kirk and Ecclesiastick Assemblies thereof bee formally different and contradistinct from the Parliament and civill Judicatories yet there is so strict and necessary a conjunction betwixt the Ecclesiastick and civill jurisdiction betwixt Religion and Justice as the one cannot firmely subsist and bee preserved without the other And therefore like Hypocrites twinnes they must stand and fall live and die together which made us in all our petitions to your Majestie who is custos utriusque tabulae to crave that as matters Ecclesiastick may be determined by the generall and other Assemblies of the Kirk and matters civill by Parliament So specially to crave that the sanction of civill law should be added to the Ecclesiastick conclusions and constitutions of the Kirk and her Assemblies lest there should be any repugnance betwixt the Ecclesiastick and Civill laws which your Majestie did graciously condescend unto And your Majesties Commissioner representing your Majesties royall person and power in the generall Assembly wherein all the Congregations and Parishes of Scotland are represented after particular inquirie anent the true and reall causes of the evils which do so much trouble the peace of that Kirk and Kingdome Having found that the government of the Kirk by Bishops and Civil places and power of Kirk-men amongst other novations brought in that Kirk were two main causes of these evils And having consented that Episcopacie bee removed out of the Kirk of Scotland and that the Kirk be removed off the state And declared all civill places and power of Kirk-men to be unlawfull in that Kingdome And having ratified the Covenant ordaining all the Subjects to subscribe the same with the generall Assemblies explanation in that sense and being oblidged to ratifie the conclusions of the Assembly in Parliament It doth necessarly follow that Bishops who usurped to be the Kirk and did in name of the Kirk represent the third estate and Abbots Priors and all others who did represent the Kirk to bee taken away which also by necessar consequence doth infer that there bee an act of constitution of the Parliament without them and an act for repealing the former laws whereby the Kirk was declared the third estate and Bishops did represent the Kirk both which the Kirk hath now renounced and condemned So that unlesse the act of constitution of the Parliament and act rescissorie passe it is impossible either to have a valide Parliament or to ratifie the conclusions of the Assemblie which your Majestie hath graciously condiscended to performe and which your Subjects are oblidged to maintain neither doth the passing of these acts wrong the Kirk nor State nor diminish your Majesties princely power and royall authoritie not the Kirk because she hath renunced and condemned that civill power and worldly pompe conferred upon her in time of Poperie esteeming the same not to bee a priviledge but a detriment incompatible with her spirituall nature and as being repugnant to the doctrine and discipline of that Kirk volenti non fit injuria nor is the
of the Estates No change of the value of money or coynage thereof but by advice of Parliament Book of rates to be revised by Parliament The Castles of Edinburgh Dumbarian and Stirling to be intrusted onely to Natives and these to be chosen from time to time of honest men by advice of the Estates Act anent the Judicatorie of Exchecquer Because these propositions were delivered to our Commissioners without any objection against the same or querees concerning these demands They did require that if there were any querees to be demanded of them or any objections to be made against these or any other acts and propositions given in to the articles That the same might be set down in writ Wherunto it was answered That his Majesty was to make no propositions to them but that his Majestie being informed that such motions and propositions have been made either in face of the articles or to his Commissioner hath taken notice thereof as prejudiciall to his Majesties authority And therefore required them to show the reasons why they did demand the same Vpon the 16. of March when our Commissioners did appeare before his Majesty They did present their answers in writ to the former queree and propositions in manner following viz AS our power and instructions from the Parliament doe warrant us to show that their proceedings and desires are agreeable to the Lawes and practise of the Kingdome and to the articles of pacification So we are enjoyned particularly to answer all objections which either were proponed or which they conceived could be proponed against the acts and proceedings of the Parliament And as concerning any other question which was not moved in Parliament nor is against the articles and propositions given in to them As the same did not fall within the consideration of the Parliament So neither can it come within the compasse of our instructions as that whereunto wee have warrant to answer It is also to bee understood that the propositions and acts given in to the articles are not statutes but are onely proponed and given in to them to be prepared for the Parliament That the Parliament may enact or refuse the same as they shall find them expedient or inexpedient for the good of the Church and State And as concerning the queree anent the prorogation of the Parliament we are warranted by our instructions and informations to show that the prorogation of Parliaments of that Kingdome once being conveened in plaine Parliament and having chosen articles or entred on actions hath ever been done with consent of the three Estates as may be seene in the reigne of King James 6. Queen Mary K. Ja. 5. K. Ja. 4. K. Ja. 3. K. Ja. 2. K. Ja. 1. And so forth in all the printed and written Records of Parliament And they are confident that your Majestie will be graciously pleased to keep that order and forme of prorogation of Parliaments which all your most worthie and Royall Antecessours did Neither did the Parliament expect that your Majestie who did graciously grant this Parliament for establishing of Religion ratifying the conclusions of the Assemblie and settling the peace of the Kingdome and hath accordingly given an ample power under your Majesties broad Seale pro tentione observatione Parliamenti without any power or clause of prorogation or delay would require this Parliament to be prorogued without consent of the Estates of Parliament Till these things be performed which your Majestie was graciously pleased to condescend unto Where it may be objected That a Parliament was prorogued or continued De mandato Regis It is answered That proves the denomination of the act to be taken from the King But doth nowayes prove that the act was made without consent of the Estates more then that act of Parliament of K. Ja. 2. holden at Edinburgh the 28. of June 1450. fol. 33. Bearing that the three Estates did continue the Parliament without naming the King will inferre that the Estates wanted the Kings consent For it is usuall that the denomination of acts of Parliament is taken sometimes from the King onely sometimes from the Estates and sometimes from both And that the prorogation was done by act of Parliament is enough to prove it to be done with consent of the Estates And the Letter written by K. Ja. 6. in the Parliament May 1604. To the Lord Balmerinoch his Majesties Secretary That seeing the Parliament of England was continued therefore the Estates should continue the Parliament of Scotland which they did doth evince that the Parliaments were continued with consent of the Estates And having thus according to the instructions given to us showne the Judgement of the Parliament whose Language and mind wee ought now to speak and not our own privat opinions anent the forme and order of prorogation which hath been constantly observed in all preceeding Parliaments we doe so much tender your Majesties royall power and lawfull authoritie which we have solemnely sworne never to diminish as wee neither dare nor will presume to exceed our instructions to define what your Majestie may doe in the hight of your power For to dispute à posse ad esse is both against Law and Divinity And what ever your Majestie may doe in the hight of your power we hope your Majestie will ever bee graciously pleased to rule your Subjects according to Law the continuall practice whereof we have showne in this point neither know we any former Law or practice to the contrair And if any man hath informed your Majesty or affirmed that it is otherwayes affirmanti incumbit probatio As concerning that act whereby it is craved that the power of the articles may bee defined wee have direction and information from the Parliament to show the equity lawfulnesse and expediencie of that act which may easily bee perceived from the reasons contained in the narrative of the act it selfe which brevitatis causâ is referred thereto as also from the written records and printed acts of Parliament from the nature of all Committees and from the present estate and condition of the Parliament of that Kingdome For as it is cleare by the historie of that Kingdome and the records of Parliament that there was never such a thing heard of as Lords of articles untill the time of King David Bruce So it is manifest in all the printed and written records of Parliament since that time that many Parliaments had no Lords delegat for articles at all and when there was any chosen the nomination and election of them was ever with the common consent and advice of the whole Parliament till the Parliament in anno 1617. That the Bishops took upon them to remove out of plaine Parliament to the Inner-house and choysed some out of the Noblemen the Noblemen them and they two choysed the Commissioners to be on articles of Shires and Burroughs which as it was against the first institution form of election of al preceeding articles introduced by
with the prelats So do it fall ought to be removed with them ut effectus removetur cum fua causa for they being removed cannot choise the noblemen to be on articles as the Noblemen cannot chose them nor can they both together choyse the Barons Burgesses So that it doth of necessity follow that there bee no articles but that all bee done in face of plaine Parliament as it was of old or else if articles be that the ordour of election be from the whole Parliament or that every Estate of Parliament make choise of such of their owne number as are to bee on articles For according to the common received maxime Quod omnes tangit ab omnibus approbari debet status ac ordines regni who are chosen to represent the whole Kingdom and are appointed to conveen in their name for establishing such Lawes as are necessare for the good of the Common-wealth ought to discharge that trust themselves and not to intrust potestatem vniversis commissam to some few delegat persons exceptonely in cases of necessitie and utilitie which either may be done or omitted according to conveniencie and occasion of affaires For as this freedome of chosing or not chosing of articles in practise and de facto was arbitrarie and changeable pro occasione distinctione temporum So there is never any statutorie law enjoyning the necessitie of articles or determining the power and manner of their proceeding in actibus liberis of the Law non currit prescriptio And it is very agreeable with reason that the power of articles which is but a committee delegate from the Parliament to prepare matters for their consideration have not a boundlesse and illimited power but bee comptable to them and the power of articles is onely preparative and no wayes determinative and is but curatio by vertue of a delegation which ends at the redemand of the granter and ought no wayes to be privative of the Parliaments power but only cumulative and they ought before closing or ryding of the Parliament to render an accompt to them of all that hath been proponed or past in articles That the whole Parliament may have a competent time for consideration agitation mutuall communication discussion and deliberation of the reasons and conclusions of these articles which are to be voiced and not to vote blindly and without foreknowledge to agree or disagree to such things as by their suffrages are enacted to bee laws which requires not onely voycing but also hearing free reasoning and ripe advisement as is clear by the commissions granted by the Shyres and Burroughs to their Commissioners and from the acts of Parliament K. Ja. 1. Par. 7. act 101. And acts of Parliament 1584. and 1587. K. Ja. 6. As for answer to the new augmentation of customes and book of rates It is humbly acknowledged that the customes belongeth to your Majestie as a part of the patrimonie due to your Crowne likeas by diverse acts of Parliament especially by the 179. act Par. 13. 206. act Par. 14. and act 251 254. Par. 15. K. Ja. 6. It is evident that the customes of native and forraigne commodities hath beene imposed with consent of the Estates and this new augmentation was onely imposed by the Excheckquer and condiscended unto by some of the Burrows upon promise as is affirmed by them made by the Earle of Traquair your Majesties Thesaurer That the present book of rates without alteration should be ratified in the next Parliament the performance whereof was onely craved by that article given in And that no new augmentation should be imposed upon custome but that which is agreeable to justice and the Laws of the Kingdome Which the burrows conceived they might verie lawfully represent to your Majestie and the Parliaments consideration The reason and occasion of that article given in to your Majestie and the Parliament anent the value of money and concerning copper-money doth flow from the sensible losse and great prejudice which your Majesties Subjects of that Kingdome doth sustain by the huge quantity of copper money which hath been coyned there and allowed with advice of your Majesties Councel to passe currant at a rate so far above the intrinsique value thereof as beside what is coyned within the Kingdome there are likewise a great quantitie coyned abroad in other Countreys and brought in to Scotland and a great quantity of false ones forged by Tinkers and through occasion thereof all other money is exported and taken away and no other money almost left and the crying of them up and down in so short space of late hath brought the esteeme and value of them to such an uncertainty and confusion as no man knows now at what rate they should passe or whether they should passe or not which to your Majesties Subjects is a very great prejudice especially to Tradesmen and other poore people in whose hands most part of that base money is whose distrest condition cryes to your Majestie for remeid Likeas the importing of Dollars from forraigne kingdomes and tollerating of them to passe for a long time at a higher rate and price nor is answerable to the true value and above that price gave occasion to export and take away your Majesties own coyne and the crying down of the Dollars thereafter by your Majesties Councell at such a time when as there was little or no other money in Scotland occasioned great scarcitie of money in that Kingdome From the by-past experience of which losse and for remeid thereof that article craving that the value of money should not bee altered without advice of the Estates of Parliament was given in without thought or intention to trinch in any sort upon your Majesties royal authority but that your Majestie for the good of your Subjects may bee graciously pleased That the standart of the money consisting in the fynnes the weight price of money which from time to time hath been ruled and set down in Parliament be not altered but by advice of the Parliament And that the fynnes price and weight of money hath been ruled and determined by Parliament may bee seen by that act of Parliament holden by King David the second in anno 1366 in these words Statutum quod fabricetur moneta de materia jam all at a in regnum quod in pondere metallo aequipolleat monetae currenti in Anglia fiat in ipsa signum notable per quod possit ab omni aliaprius fabricata evidenter cognosci quousque in proximo Parliamento super hoc maturius avisari possit The same is also manifest from a great many other acts in the reignes of K. Ja. 1. K. Ja. 2. K. Ja. 3. K. Ja. 4. K. Ja. 5. K. Ja. 6. Especially K. Ja. 1. Par. 1. cap. 23. anno 1424. Item K. Ja. 2. Par. 6. cap. 29. and Par. 8. cap. 33. Par. 13. cap. 59. Par. 14. cap. 72. Item K. Ja. 3. Par. 1. cap. 9. Par. 3. cap. 18.
Par. 4. cap. 21. Par. 6. cap. 46. Par. 7. cap. 50. Par. 8. cap. 64. Par. 13. cap. 93. Item K. Ja. 4. Par. 1. cap. 2. Par. 2. cap. 17. Par. 5. cap. 55. Item K Ja. 5. Par. 7. cap. 99. Item K. Ja. 6. Par. 1. cap. 17. Item in the unprinted acts of K. Ja. 6. Par. 5. anno 1578. Par. 7. cap. 106. Par. 8. amongst unprinted acts an 1584. Item in his 13. Par. an 1593. amongst the unprinted acts And such like in printed acts of his Par. 15. cap. 249. Par. 16. c. 9. And in the Parliament an 1633 holden by your Majesties self There is commission given in Parliament to the secret Councel and other Commissioners anent the frequent course of Dollars and base copper money by reading of which acts It is most manifest That the fynnesse weight and price of money hath been ruled and determined by your Majesties predecessours and your Majesties self with advice of Parliament neither is it meaned nor intended that your Majesties royall priviledge which hath beene and is due to your Majestie and your royall antecessours shall thereby in any fort be trinched upon nor impared The reason of that article whereby it is humbly craved that the castles of Edinburgh Dumbartan and Striviling may be intrusted onely to Natives and these to be chosen by advice of Parliament of such faithfull and honest men as do tender your Majesties honour and the safetie of the Kingdome may be seene not onely from the nature and importance of the charge but likewise from the former practise of your Majesties royall predecessours who did dispose of these castles with the speciall advice and counsell of their Parliament as is recorded in the old Registers of the Parliament 1368. Likeas fol. 83. of the old acts K. Ja. 4. It is concluded by advice and deliverance of the three Estates That Patrick Lord Haills be keeper of the castle of Edinburgh and artilerie of the same c. Item fol. 21. cap. 35. K. Ja. 6. in the old acts The three Estates ordaines the castle of Dumbar and fort of Inchkeith to be demolished and destroyed that no foundation remain thereof Likeas by diverse unprinted acts as in anno 1578. and 1585. and 1606. Your Majesties houses hath beene disposed of with advice of Parliament And not onely nationall statutes but the common law of nature and Nations do forbid the receiving of strangers to bee keepers of the strengths of a free Kingdome And when the Parliament of Scotland 1604. gave commission anent the Union with England with exception of reserving of free Monarchie and the fundamentall laws liberties and priviledges of that Kingdome Your Majesties father in his printed speech to the Parliament of England 1607 when he interprets that clause of fundamental laws declares that hee could not make Scotland a naked Province without libertie and set Garisons over it as the Spaniards do over Cicilie and Naples or govern them by Commissioners So that his Majestie in his owne interpretation doth acknowledge that the putting in of Garisons especially of strangers as of English men in the Forts and Castles of Scotland as the King of Spain puts in Cicilie and Naples or as the King of England puts English in the Forts of Ireland is a breaking of the fundamentall laws and liberties of Scotland and the using of it like a naked conquest Province like unto Cicilie Naples or Ireland And as your Majesties Subjects gave an undoubted proofe how tender their mindes are in the point of obedience to your Majesties commandements not onely in delivering of the Castles to be disposed of at your Majesties pleasure without any assurance other then their confidence in your Majesties goodnesse and justice so have they of late given a verie submisse and rare testimonie of their obedience in the humble reception of these strangers and ammunition which your Majestie was pleased to send to the Castle of Edinburgh where the honours of the Crown and Kingdome and registers are keept preferring their obedience to your Majesties cōmandment to their own safety even at this time when their ears are filled with rumors of hostill preparation against them All which makes them and us in their names humbly to supplicat and expect that your Majestie will bee graciously pleased by recalling of that Garison to free your loyall subjects of these feares and dangers who will ever be ready to hazard their lives and fortunes to do your Majestie service Neither doe they in the act which is given in to the articles arrogat or assume power by themselves to appoint keepers for your Majesties Castles but do humbly crave that your Majestie may out of your goodnesse be graciously pleased to declare for further satisfaction of your Subjects that the Captains and Commanders of your Majesties Castles may bee chosen by advice of the Estates of Parliament And that such as shall happen to be placed betwixt Parliaments may beetryed and found by your Majesties Councell to be men of such qualitie as are fit and able to undergo that charge which in the judgement of the Parliament derogats nothing from your Majesties royall power As for reasons of the act anent the judicatorie of the Exchequer we have set down some few of the many reasōs which do sufficiētly prove the equity justnes therof 1 The Session and Exchecquer are distinct judicatories and not subordinat one to another and cannot be coincident in the same object And therefore seeing the question of right and nullitie of rights is competent to be decyded by the Lords of Session by way of action or exception it is altogether incompetent to be discussed by the Lords of Exchecquer 2 The Lords of Exchecquer are incompetent judges in a declaratour of nullitie by way of action and consequently cannot annull any right by way of exception which is a more summar way And it were absurd in law seeing the subject and question is one whether proponed by way of exception or action that incompetent judges of the action they should have a more absolute and summar jurisdiction by way of exception 3 It appears by an act of Parliament not printed 1593 intituled Commission to the Exchecquer anent decyding suspensions in the Kings cause that before the said act the Exchecquer had not power to decyde in suspensions while it was given them by the Parliament farre lesse then can it be thought that they ever had or can have power to decyde in the point of heretable rights Neither doth the late act 1633 authorize the Exchecquer to decyde therein expresly And if it bee truely considered some generall words contained therein intermixt with the particular cases therein exprest should not nor cannot be extended to so high a point as the disputing and decyding of the Subjects their heretable rights Likeas at the making of the said late act the Lords of Session having heard some surmize that your Majesties Advocat was giving in such an act seven or eight of them
and gracious Declarations And that it is impossible without passing the rescissorie act and act of constitution to have a valide Parliament to ratifie the conclusions of the Assembly is manifest Seeing by the former constitution of the Parliament no act of Parliament can passe without the consent of the three Estates of which the Kirk was the third As is to bee seen by the act of Parliament 1609. And any act for ratifying the conclusions of the assembly or for any other cause whatsoever which can be past in this Parliament till the Parliament be lawfully constitute without prelates or any other representing the Kirk cannot be valid but may be quarrelled and annulled upon that formall and fundamentall ground of the former constitution of Parliament which stands established by the acts of Parliament 1584.1587.1597 and 1606. By all which it is clear that the Parliament was constitute of the three Estates whereof the Kirk is one that no act of Parliament could be made but by the special advice consent of the three estates that the Prelats voting in parliament and representing of the third Estate was a priviledge granted to the Kirk and that they as her office-bearers had onely vote in name of the Kirk may be clearly seen by the 231. act Par. 15.1597 K. Ja. 6. Where the Kings Majestie and his Highnesse Estates restores Ministers provyded to Prelacies to have vote in Parliament and that upon this reason as having speciall consideration of the great priviledges and immunities granted by his predecessours to the holy Kirk within this Realme and to the speciall persons exercing the office dignitie and title of prelats within the same which have represented one of the Estates And that the saids prelats have been from time to time conserved in the same integritie wherein they were at any time before So that his Majestie out of his singular affection to the advancement of Religion declares this Kirk to be a true and holy Kirk and that the Ministers and pastors within the said Kirk provided to the office place title and dignitie of a Bishop or prelat shall at all time hereafter have vote in parliament suchlike and as freely as any other Ecclesiastick prelat had at any time bygone And that all Bishopricks shall be disponed to actuall preachers which proves that in time of poperie and ever untill that time 1597. this priviledge of vote in Parliament was granted to the Kirk and only to the speciall persons who by vertue of their office did represent the Kirk which is also clear from the act of annexation 1587. whereby all the Temporalities of benefices were annexed to the Crowne notwithstanding whereof they did vote still in Parliament in name of the Kirk having no Temporalities at all till the Parliament in the yeare 1606 Wherein it is clear in the act of restitution of the estate of Bishops And also in the 6. act of the Parliament 1609 That vote in Parliament is given to prelats as one of the priviledges and liberties granted to the Kirk whom they did represent and did ever sit pro Clero upon his Majesties right hand and voyce in name of the Kirk But seeing in the late Generall Assembly holden at Edinburgh after particular inquyrie anent the true and reall causes of the evils which did so much trouble the peace of that Kirk and Kingdome It is found that the government of the Kirk by Bishops and civill places and power of Kirk-men especially their voting in Parliament amongst other novations brought in that Kirk were two mayne causes of these evills And that the Generall Assembly with consent of your Majesties Commissioner representing your royall power and person hath removed Episcopacie our of the Kirk of Scotland and declared all civill places and power of Kirk-men to be unlawfull in that Kingdome as contrary to the Confession of faith and constitutions of that Kirk and hath ratified the Covenant ordaining all the subjects to subscryve the same with the generall assemblies explanation in that sense And your Majestie being obliged to ratifie the conclusions of the assemblie in Parliament It doth necessarily follow that Bishops who usurped to bee the Kirk and did in name of the Kirk represent the third Estate be taken away which also by necessar consequence doth inferre that there be an act of constitution of the Parliament without them and an act for repealing the former Laws wherby the Kirk was declared the third Estate and Bishops did represent the Kirk Both which the Kirk hath now renounced and condemned as a detriment and prejudice incompatible with her spirituall nature Neither doth the passing of these acts wrong the Kirk nor State nor diminish your Majesties Princely power as was demonstrat by that which was spoken to your Majestie the 3. of March and which we did thereafter present to your Majestie in writ which for brevitie wee absteine to repeat And if your Majesties Commissioner deny that he did consent to the act of assembly August 17 whereby Episcopacie and the civill places and power of Kirk-men and in speciall their voting in Parliament was declared to be unlawfull as being contrare to the Confession of faith and constitutions of that Kirk and that he did approve that all the subjects should subscryve the Confession of faith with the generall assemblies explanation we offer to prove the same by the very acts of the assembly and records thereof bearing his assent first verbally and there after given in by writ The trueth whereof wee are able also to verifie and make good by witnesses of all ranks of persons who were present at the assembly And so soone as these Declarations which the Commissioner caused registrate in the bookes of Councell as being emitted by him in the generall assembly were required to be insert in the records of assembly which was eight dayes at least after the rising of the assembly The Commissioners of the Kirk discharged the Clerk to insert the same as not being emitted in the assembly and as contrarie to the acts thereof and true declarations made by the Commissioner in the generall assembly which are registrate in the bookes thereof and doeth beare his consent for which he got publick thanks The reason of that article craving every Commissioner of the Shyres to have a sever all voyce appeares in the very proposition it self For that any who by the lawes of the Kingdome and by their commissions comes authorized as Commissioners to heare treat and determine in Parliament and yet not to have a decisive voice in Parliament seemes to be repugnans in adjecto and that by the ancient practise the whole Barons and Free-holders within that Kingdome had vote in Parliament may be seen in the old records of Parliament as in the reigne of K. Ja. 1. in his 6. and 7. Parl. K. Ja. 2. in the old acts fol. 26.33 36. K. Ja. 3. in the 112. act Parl. 14. Item Parl. 1487. 15. October The Parliament being continued
all freeholders are enjoyned to come to Parliament to treat and conclude notwithstanding whereof no such priviledge was claimed in this Parliament but onelie craved the declaration and determination of the Parliament whether each Commissioner of the two sent from a Shyre have right in law of a severall decisive voice which if at any time it hath been marked otherwayes they alledge the same hath proceeded from the ignorance errour or corruption of the Clerk And as the Barons and Free-holders are the far greatest part of the body of that Kingdome and that all of them of old had voice in Parliament till their absence by some late acts especially the 101 act Par. 7. K. Ja. 1. and Par. in anno 1587. K. Ja. 6. is dispensed with and they exeimed from necessitie of coming and of the unlaws which they were lyable to pay for none compeirance providing they send Commissioners in their names to vote in Parliament They think it agreeable both with law and reason that every one of these few Commissioners who do represent so many should have a severall decisive voice And the act of Parl. holden by K. J. 6. an 1587. bears that the Commissioners of Shyres shall be equall upon articles with the Burrowes and shall have votes in Parliament The meaning whereof doth import that every one of the saids Commissioners shall have a decisive voice because quod de omnibus dicitur de singulis dicitur and if both the Commissioners of one Shyre should have but one decisive voyce then it would follow that every one of them hath but half a voice and consequently when the one is absent the other being present should have no voice and one could not bee chosen upon the articles without the other both which are contrare to reason and custome And it is undenyablie true and constant by continuall custome that when there is onely one of the two Commissioners of a Shyre chosen upon the articles that one by himself without concurse of his collegue hath a plenarie voice in articles Therefore it follows necessarly that as every one of two Commissioners have a full voyce in articles so each one of the two should have a full voice perse and severally in Parliament otherwise every one of them would have but half a voice in Parliament and a full voice in articles And the act given in anent the Barons voices is not to demand or crave any new thing or novation or new priviledge to bee granted to them but onely craves the declaration and determination of Parliament which in justice may bee craved by any who desire their right to be cleared Neither is there any such thing craved in Parliament as the chosing of any other Clerk but it was onely humbly craved that some should bee allowed from the Parliament to sit by the Clerks to mark that the voices were rightly enumerat That article whereby it is craved That every Estate may chose their own Lords of articles or else That the Lords of articles be chosen from the whole Parliament is agreeable to the libertie of all free judicatories who have power to chose their own preparative Committees who except they be chosen by the judicatorie it selfe or by these whom they do represent cannot be justly reput to have any power from them for their power is onely from them from whom they are delegat and they can onely propone or voice in articles in name of these who did chose them and gave them power and what they do in name of these who did not give them power is a non habente potestatem But because the reason of this article is more fully cleared in one of our former answers anent the power of articles which is coincident with this article wee remit to the former answer The reasons of that act desiring that proxies may bee discharged and that no patent of Nobilitie be granted to any but such as have 10000 marks of yearly land rent are contained in the act it self it seems not to be agreeable to reason and equitie That the honour and power of voting in Parliament which is conferred on Noblemen and their successours personally and whereby they have power to reason voice and judge according to law and conscience can be intrusted to another with an implicit faith to determine and give the judgement of the granter of the proxie in matters of highest moment concerning Religion your Majesties service and the good of the Countrey before the granter thereof know so much as what is to bee proponed in Parliament And as concerning the second part of the act craving that no patent of Nobilitie may bee granted to any who are not Natives but such as have 10000 marks of Land rent The same was remitted and recommended to the Commissioner to bee represented and remonstrat to your Majestie whose gracious answer they do expect As concerning the book intituled A large declaration The generall Assembly taking notice thereof and conceiving that thereby your Majestie that Kirk and whole Kingdome is wronged did give in a supplication to the Commissioner and Lords of your Majesties privie Councel humbly craving to represent the same to your Majesties gracious consideration Like-as in the articles of Parliament the Estates did humbly recommend the Assemblies supplication to the Commissioner for obtaining graciously the desire of the said supplication Neither did they know a more humble and respective way for redresse and removing these imputations which lyes upon them by occasion of that book concerning which amongst the other particulars recommended to the Commissioner to be represented to your Majestie They do confidently expect the return of your gracious answer As concerning that proposition whereby it is desired That the Commissioners of Shyres may be allowed to give in a roll of free holders out of the which the Justices of peace are to bee chosen The reason of that desire is Because the Commissioner of each severall Shyre knows best who are the fitteft and ablest men within their own severall Shyres for your Majesties service and the good of the Countrey which is no wayes craved to derogat from your Majesties power of chosing but onely as an expedient to be past or refused as your Majestie and the Parliament shall think convenient As concerning that act anent the disorders in the North The reason why the same was craved did result from the complaints and grievances against the thift oppression slaughter and great insolencies committed these diverse years bygone and of late in those parts the redresse and remedie whereof and for keeping peace in that part of the Countrey deserves your Majesties consideration and justice And all that we remember was required of the Parliament was That the former acts of Parliament made for punishment of thift rapine and oppression might be revived with such farther addition as your Majestie should finde expedient and conduceable for the peace of the countrey which wee hope your Majestie will ever tender The reason
the Clerks against Master William Hayes deputation in his fathers place The Commissioner to whom they did produce their reasons in writ can best give an accompt thereof And albeit wee have in obedience to your Majesties commandement according to our bound duetie shown the reasons why these propositions whereof your Majestie hath taken notice as prejudiciall to your authoritie were demanded yet many of these propositions are of so small moment being onely and me erely about the interest of privat persons as they are of no publick concernement de minimis non curat lex Nor doth the Parliament stick upon these or any other articles of that kind any farder nor as they have cleare warrant of Law and as your Majestie and Estates shall find them convenient for the good of your Subjects But the humble and earnest desire of your Majesties Parliament is That seeing wee have showne your Majestie their humble desires and reasons of their demands your Majestie may bee graciously pleased to command the Parliament to proceede and ratifie the conclusions of the Assemblie and passe such acts as are necessar for establishing of Religion and for the good and peace of the Kingdome according to the articles of pacification That by the mutuall embracement of Religion and Justice under your Majesties happie government Trueth and peace may kisse one another and the joy and chearefull obedience of your Majesties Subjects may bee encreased After the deliverie and reading of which answers and answering all objections which were proponed by his Majestie or those of the Committee thereupon which our Commissioners immediatly after their parting with his Majestie did put in writ They declared that they had according to their Instructions with honest and willing hearts performed that charge which was laid upon them and did show his Majestie how much Religion and that whole Kingdome did suffer by delayes And that it would please his Majestie to give them their dispatch that they might returne to those that sent them who are longing much for the returne of his Majesties gracious answer Being thereafter removed and within the space of halfe an houre called in The Kings Majestie said That hee could not now appoint them any time for dispatch But that his Majestie would take his owne time to consider of their answers and would then make his farther pleasure knowne to them AFter that our Commissioners had thus acted their part faithfully in what was committed to them by us demanded of them by the King and could be expected from them by others This Declaration cometh forth under his Majesties name which may make his Majesties pleasure knowne to them and no more but known they being shut up and one of the Noblemen put in prison upon some pretensions of our powerfull enemies which what they are shall appear afterward so that they are deprived not onely of the benefit of further hearing but of all libertie to just fie themselves and their proceedings A necessitie therefore is laid upon us to compare the Proceedings with the Declaration that if there be any demands accusations or objections as we beleeve there bee few or none which have not been proponed to them they may now be examined by us and satisfied First concerning the forme of electing the articles nothing can be said by us which can so satisfie the minds of such as are not acquainted with this difficulty as the article it self as it was conceived which yet with other particulars of this kinde we are constrained to spare lest these papers grow to a greater bignesse then wee intended for the article is disjunctive that either the whole Parliament or each estate by themselves severally shall choose the articles And therefore although it were proven by some practicks that every Estate did not choose their ovn articles but that they were chosen by the whole Parliament this doth not militat against us but falleth into the other part of the disjunction contained in the article We holding this constantly that neither by the records of Parliament which are keeped up from us and unto which we appeal nor so farre as we can learne of old Noblemen who have assisted in Parliament for many years by the testimonies of Parliamentarie men in the yeare 1609. and 1612. specified in the Declaration pag. 21. or any other year before 1617 can it be showne that the forme used since the year 1617. had place in the election of the articles it was introduced with the Prelats and must go forth with them again it being impossible that Bishops having no place in Parliament by vertue of the act of Assembly and of his Majesties Declaration promising to confirme the acts of the Assembly can have any place in the articles And therefore that it was necessarie that the election of the articles should be altered unto the forme used before 1617. even when Prelats had voice in Parliament which can neither reflex upon his Majesties royall authoritie nor upon the internall life or externall lustre and glorie of the high court of Parliament What is objected for the power of the articles Declaration pag. 21. is so clearly and fully answered by our Commissioners pag. 19 20 21. that nothing more Nothing can belong to them by vertue of any preceeding act of Parliament or by the nature of the thing it self which is to be a preparatory committee for the Parliament that shall by us be denyed although it must be confessed that it belongeth properly to the Parliament to determine their power as in their wisedome they shall finde convenient Concerning the constitution of the Parliament it was necessar that it should suffer also some alteration but that was accidentall and by inevitable consequence following upon the act of the Assembly and subscription of the Covenant by his Majesties Commissioner and upon his Majesties irrevocable Declaration which can never bee interpreted to have any affinitie with Treason spoken of in the Declaration except we will say that the Kings Majestie and the whole Estates of Parliament who have full and uncontrolable power to make and abolish laws can runne themselves in the guiltinesse of that crime upon changing of their own laws and customes the fear is greater that acts of Parliament made for the advantage and advancement of Prelats against the Confession of Faith and Covenant of God and against many protestations of the Kirkbe Laes-Majestie divine to be repented of lest it pull down upon us the wrath threatned this day Acts of rescission or repealing are so necessar that it were not onely an incongruitie but a repugnance to make a new act and withall to suffer former acts ordaining the contrarie to stand in vigour and not to abolish them but the cause of quarrelling is in the matter of this act of rescission which cannot be remeeded except by rescinding of the act of Assembly of the Confession of faith and Covenant and of his Majesties Declaration which wee trust shall never be repented of since it
first and afterward a matter of demurre and astonishment Although our Commissioners formerly sent were repulsed yet we did not desist but remembring that we were dealing with our own native King who might be moved to know and compassionat us his own people at last we sent this humble supplication for a new hearing To the Kings most excellent Majestie the Remonstrance and Supplication of the Noblemen and Commissioners of Shyres and Burrows his Majesties good Subjects of the Kingdome of SCOTLAND Humbly shewing THat where the great want of your Majesties royal presence in person at thâ—â—â—igh Court of Parliament as we have also at other times experienced hath been apprehended by our adversaries for a fit opportunitie to their mis-informations and hard impressions against our proceedings in Parliament as trenching upon your Majesties sacred and inviolable authoritie as not warranted by the fundamentall laws and laudable practices of this your Majesties ancient and native Kingdome or as contrary to the promises and remonstrances which were made to your Majestie by your humble subjects in the truth of their hearts and were in the same sense graciously accepted by your Majestie And although to our common regrate and the suspending of our hopes and humble desires your Majestie hath thought meet to give order to Your high Commissioner to prorogat the Parliament yet such hath been your Majesties wisedome justice and goodnesse which in all humble thankfulnesse shall ever bee remembred by us that your Majestie hath kept one ear for us and would not harken and give place in your Royall heart to suggestions and obloquies of our enemies till the reasons of our proceedings were made known from our selves and we should have the favour of a full hearing And for this end it was your Majesties royall pleasure to permit and allow the Estates of Parliament to send some of their number to give your Majestie true information which being conceived by them for a sufficient warrant made them direct two Noblemen the Earle of Dumfermling and the Lord of Lowdoun to your Majesties Court instructed with full commission to that effect But since your Majestie judged it not convenient to grant unto them accesse and audience at that time We now from the sense of the distressed condition of this your Majesties Kingdome which we nothing doubt but your Majestie will in your tender and fatherly car compassionar do in all earnestnesse desire and in all humility supplicat that your Majestie may be pleased upon this our declaration that we intend nothing but what shall merit approbation at the throne of your Majesties justice to give commandment for the proceeding of the Parliament that thereby our evils may bee cured before they be past remedie many dangerous consequents may be prevented and the troubled estate of this Kirk and Kingdome speedily settled which is the longing desire and universall expectation of all your Majesties peaceable Subjects Or if your Majestie shall finde it necessary for their further satisfaction against all exceptions to make particular inquirie and to take notice of the reasons of our proceedings and demands from our own mouthes which we shall be most willing to render in that case we are confident that your Majesties royall ears will be in the meane while shut against the sinister informations of such men as are fallen out with the times and think our common calamities a mitigation of their just sufferings And doe humbly entreat that your Majestie may be pleased to give signification of your Royall will hereanent and to grant warrant for sending some from us to your Majesties presence that so soone as may be the Parliament long since begun by your Majesties indiction may by your Majesties wisedome and goodnesse have the wished conclusion to your Majesties honour and the joyfull acclamation of the whole Kingdome To which this answer was given At his Majesties Court at Whitehall the 11 day of December 1639. HIs Majestie having read and considered this supplication is gracioufly pleased to permit such number of them to repair thither as they shall please to shew the reasons of their demands Sic subscribitur Sterline VPon this answer foure Commissioners were sent who did acquite themselves in their charge as is expressed before in their Supplications speeches answers and whole proceedings Concerning which there be three things mentioned in the Declaration to make them all null and themselves odious First that they were not instructed with sufficient Commission which is abundantly answered by themselves pag. 14. For their commission behoved to be deficient either in the forme and authoritie or in the subject and matters to be treated The authoritie was as great as first the Parliament then sitting and thereafter the Commissioners of the Parliament could grant And where it is said pag. 44. that they were persons of no great eminencie who did subscribe Their Commission we desire to be considered 1. That the first commission was subscribed by the Subjects of every qualitie sitting in Parliament 2. That the second commission could not be subscribed in that manner the Parliament being no more sitting but prorogated but behooved to be subscribed by the Commissioners of the Parliament authorized to sit at Edinburgh for making remonstrances and receiving answers from his Majestie The meanest of these Commissioners whosoever he was in person was in this act of greater authoritie and eminencie then the most eminent in the Kingdome who was not clothed with the same commission And therefore although there were many Noblemen in Edinburgh for the time yet they did not signe the commission because they had no warrant from the Parliament and that for me of doing hath been reprehended in former times as displeasant to his Majestie and so was the authority sufficient As for their limitation in the matters to be treated before his Majesty it may appear by his Majesties allowing them to come up under the Secretaries hand that they went to give the reasons of the demands made in Parliament and withall did declare as is contained in their proceedings pag. 45. that the Parliament doth not stick upon these or any other articles of that kinde any further nor as they have clear warrant of law and as his Majestie and the Estates shall find them convenient for the good of the Subjects And did supplicat that his Majestie would be pleased to command the Parliament to proceed and ratifie the conclusions of the Assembly and passe such acts as are necessarie for establishing Religion and for the good and peace of the Kingdome according to the articles of pacification But that we may remove all suspition of latent or underhand dealing wee have here set down the just copie of the instructions given to our Commissioners first and last Instructions from the Noblemen and Commissioners of Shyres and Burrows conveened to attend this present Parliament To the Earle of Dumfermling and Lord Lowdoun concerning such businesse as they have desired to be imparted to the Kings Majestie
Subscribed with their hands At Edinburgh the first day of November 1639. By some of each Estate for themselves and as representing the rest of their number at their command and desires 1. FIrst to shew and declare that our desire anent Religion is That wee may enjoy the same according to Gods word the Confession of Faith and constitutions of the Kirk of Scotland and that all matters Ecclesiasticall shall be determined by the assemblies of the Kirk without incroatching upon the libertie priviledge and government of any other reformed Kirk 2. To shew and declare That wee never had nor have any intention to diminish his Majesties greatnes and authoritie which by the law of God and of this Kingdome and by the descent of 108 Kings wee acknowledge to be due to his Majestie neither did we ever intend to impair or withdraw our selves from civil and temporal obedience to his Majestie but in every thing to carrie our selves as becometh faithfull humble and loyall Subjects whereof we shall be ready to give reall demonstrance and proof when his Majesties service shall require the same 3. To shew how grievous it is to his Subjects That wee heare his Majestie is mis-informed and displeased with any of our proceedings The lawfulnesse and loyaltie whereof we desire ye may clear to his Majestie 4. Ye would give to his Majestie a true information of all our proceedings in the Assembly and Parliament whereof ye have the special acts and reasons for the same and justifie them against al aspersions and objections especially ye would clear they do no wayes trinch upon the Kings authoritie whereof his Majestie seems to be mis-informed 5. Ye would shew the great prejudices of this Kirk and Kingdome by continuall by-gone letts and delayes of the progresse of the Parliament and how much it may contribute to his Majesties honour the Subjects content and for procuring of heartie and chearfull obedience That the affairs of this Kirk and Kingdome may without longer delay be settled especially seeing all the Subjects desires are given in to the Parliament and articles and are such as agree with the articles of pacification without the least wronging of his Majesties authoritie or impairing of the Subjects civill and duetifull obedience 6. Ye would therefore urge after your clearing of all objections made against any of our acts and proceedings That his Majestie may bee graciously pleased to direct his Commissioner to go on in Parliament without further delay to determine all the articles by the advice of the Estates and to the ratifying of the conclusions of the late Assembly and settling all such other things as may conduce to the publick peace and good of this Kingdome according to the articles of pacification and his Majesties Commission under the great Seal 7. For the clearer determining of all questions ye would earnestly desire the production of the laws and records of Parliament the up-keeping whereof is contrarie to all law practique and reason 8. If the King will not condescend to give order to his Commissioner to goe on presently in Parliament for ratifying the acts of the Assembly and for determining and deciding such acts as are given in to the articles then at the least his Majesty may be graciously pleased to enjoyne the Commissioner to prorogate the Parliament in the tearmes contained in the offer made to him which ye have with you 9. And if his Majestie send for the Commissioner ye would try and advertise whom yee think fittest to bee sent from the Estates with the Commissioner to informe the Kings Majestie more fully and to procure his Majesties warrant for their up-coming for better clearing of matters and for his Majesties further satisfaction 10. Ye would be frequent and sure in your advertisements to us how our businesse goeth and what yee conceive will be fittest to be done by us here 11. Ye would remember the many grievous complaints given in to my Lord Commissioner and Lords of articles by these of this Nation who are In-dwellers in Ireland of whom oathes are exacted unwarrantable by the Lawes of the Church of Ireland as also some of this Nation have been pressed in England with the like oathes At Edinburgh 20. Jan. 1640. Instructions from the Commissioners appointed by the Estates of Parliament to make remonstrances to his Majesty of the reasons of the prepositions and proceedings in Parliament and for receiving his Majesties answers and upon the return thereof to remonstrat their humble desires to his Majesty upon all occasions given to the Earle of Dumfermeling Lord Lowdoun Sir William Douglas of Cavers and Master Robert Barclay Provest of Irwing Commissioners direct to his Majesty with the advice of the Noblemen and Commissioners of Shires and Burrows conveined for the time which are added to the former instructions granted to the said Earle of Dumfermeling and Lord Lowdoun by the Estates of Parliament Novemb. 1. 1639. SEeing the Earle of Dumfermling and Lord Lowdoun were den yed accesse to impart to his Majestie the former Instructions given to them by the Estates of Parliament and seeing upon their returne his Mejestie was petitioned to give order for proceeding of the Parliament or if his Majestie should finde it necessary for his further satisfaction to take notice of the reasons of our proceedings from some of our selves that his Majestie would give signification of his Royall pleasure here-anent and grant warrant for such as should be sent And that now his Majesty by his answer to our supplication hath allowed and given warrant that such as we think fit to send may repair to his Majesty to shew the grounds and reasons of our demands Wee have for discharging of our humble duetie according to his Majesties commandement sent you up to impart to his Majesty the former Instructions given to the Earle of Dumfermling and Lord Lowdoun To shew that our proceedings and desires are agreable to the Lawes and practises of the Kingdome and articles of pacification as you were also directed to doe by the former Instructions which when you have cleared lest verball expressions be controverted you shall give in the summe of our demands and crave the answers thereof in writ and what else shall be objected against us or replyed for our justification and that for avoyding contestation about words in time hereafter If you bee called to give answer and account to the English Committee or Councell or any other Judicatorie you would show that you are sent onely to his Majesty and discharged likeas wee doe heereby discharge you to answere to any Committe or Judicatorie who cannot meddle in matters of the Parliament of this Kingdome being independent of any but of God and the King Because wee heare that sinistrous informations and the late relation made by his Majesties Commissioner before the whole Councell of England hath given hard impressions against our proceedings whereof as we cannot but be sensible so you shall crave that his Majesty out of his tender care and
in them c. If their answers did give the reasons of the demands in Parliament as it may appear by their proceedings they did in so many of them as were controverted for other demands there was no just exception against them as is acknowledged Declaration Pag. 45. 47. they were not impertinent but satisfactorie although they did not satisfie our adversaries who were determined to receive no satisfaction but in the overthrow either of our Religion and Liberties or of our selves It could not in reason be expected that three or foure Commissioners should hold a Parliament there with a Committee and leave nothing to a Parliament here but an approbation of their doing This hath more in it then can be told in few words It had been good before the Councel of England had given their opinion which we beleeve was not their sentence that they had called to their remembrance that our Commissioners were sent not to give judgement but to give the reasons of our demands and that they behoved to keep themselves within the compasse of their instructions that in the time of the peace making his Majestie thought it not meet to insist in the three Querees of calling and dissolving Assemblies and of a negative voice as may be seene before in the first part of this answer pag. 13. And that his Majestie did graciously acknowledge that all matters Ecclesiasticall whereof this being understood of the Assemblies of the Kirk is one ought to be determined in the Assemblies of the Kirk according as it is determined in the late generall Assembly act August 17. of prorogating or dissolving of Parliaments and other assemblies our declaration speaketh pag. 55. What other supreame powers in the Christian world may do by their different laws constitutions and customes were long and laborous to enquire but wee shall strive to keep our own without wronging any other Kingdome either by our sentence or opinion especially in times of danger Before we come to the third part of the Declaration we meet with the answer of three objections which are supposed to be made upon our part The first is pag. 47. that his Majestie promised unto us a free Parliament and we adde that a speciall promise was made of the ratification of the acts of the Assembly in Parliament and of settling other such things as may conduce to the good and peace of the Kingdome Like as we were oblidged both by the nature of the thing it self and our promise To seek nothing but to enjoy our Religion and liberties according to the Ecclesiasticall and civil laws of the Kirk and Kingdome and not to diminish his Majesties greatnesse and authority But when the Parliament is conveened the acts of the Assembly are refused to be ratified in so far that his Majesties Commissioner refuseth to repeall and rescind such acts of Parliament as are inconsistent with the ratification of the acts of the Kirk although it cannot upon any shadow of reason be denyed that the Parliaments power and freedome consisteth in this to make and unmake laws as in their prudence shall seem convenient Other articles which were proponed as they were conceived to be for the peace and good of the Kingdome so neither in the intention of the proponers nor in their own nature and condition did they touch or trench upon his Majesties Glorie Crowne Sceptre or Power as is before made manifest they all tending either to the sensible good of the Subject or to the reforming of such abuses as do obscure his Majesties justice and goodnesse and being granted would conciliat love reverence and cheerfull obedience to his Majesties government The second objection supposed to be made by us Declaration pag. 48. is from his Majesties allowing of the Covenant and commanding of the Lord Marquesse of Hammiltoun the former high Commissioner and other his Majesties Subjects to subscribe it and from the Earle of Traquair his Majesties high Commissioner his subscription or allowance of the subscribing of the Covenant It was never in our mindes to make use of the first our reasons are extant in print against it as subtilie disappointing and destructive of our intended reformation against the late novations and against Episcopacie it self the waggoner which had brought them in and when it was subscribed by some few it was done with this expresse Declaration That they subscribe it in no other sense but that which it had in the yeare 1580 when it was at first subscribed which is found by the Assemblies of the Kirk contrarie to the Lord Marquesse his meaning quite repugnant to Episcopacie and all the attendants thereof in Kirk and State wee indeed acknowledged it to be the same in substance with that which we have subscribed of late but that by our adversaries who ever set themselves against our explanation and application thereof to the late corruptions and innovations was not acknowledged till the Assembly at Edinburgh and by some of them is still denyed what is pertinent for the clearing this question was so fully written at that time that nothing needeth now to be added Concerning the Earle of Traquair it is alleadged Declaration pag. 50. that we have no warrant for our actions for rebellious courses and treacherous combinations no man can have warrant and we detest and disclaime them from his subscription of the Covenant First because it is evinced by the petition of the Generall Assembly for subscribing of the Covenant that our subscription before this time was neither laudable nor warrantable where wee intreat the reader whosoever to make some pause and compare the words of the Supplication of the Assembly with the words of the Declaration The words of the supplication as it was presented before the Councel table standeth registrat in the books of Assembly and Councell is prefixed to many subscribed copies of the Covenant even that which was subscribed by the Commissioner and Councel and is printed supra pag. 40. ANd following the laudable example of our predecessours 1589 do most humbly supplicat your Grace his Majesties Commissioner and the Lords of his Majesties most honourable Privy Councell to injoyne by act of Councell that the Confession and Covenant which as a restimony of our fidelitie to God and loyaltie to our King wee have subscribed may be subscribed by all his Majesties Subjects The words of the Supplication as they are cited in this Declaration pag. 50. NOw following the laudable example of their predecessours they doe humbly supplicate for the same and that they may be allowed and warranted to subscribe it The cogging and cosenage is so grosse that we are forced to turn our answers in this point obvious to every ey into a complaint that any of whatsoever quality shall be suffered after this foul and falsifying way to wrong the Kings honour and the Kingdomes peace in so high a matter as is a Covenant Next our actions are said to be unwarranted because this Covenant by that which is prefixed to the
Commissioners subscription is declared to be one and the same with that of 1580. which giveth no warrant to such actions as ours are Where fiâ—st we desire it to be known universally that the Earle of Traquair his Majesties Commissioner did subscribe the Confession of Faith and Covenant with the explanation of the Assembly First in the house of Parliament in presence of the Lords of articles Septemb 6. both as Commissioner with the declaration made in the Assembly to be prefixed to his subscription and as Traquair simplie as other subjects have done Next that he subscribed the Covenant in the new house of Exchecquer as a Counsellour with other prime Lords of Counsell Roxburgh Lawderdaile Southesk and many others and that without any Declaration at all even the Marques of Huntlie shew his desire to subscribe with others but that he would have done it with protestation of his liberty outwith the Kingdome which the Ministers who were present to take the oath and subscription of the Lords could not admit But neither his Lordship nor any other pretended any scruple either in Religion or civill obedience to the King against their subscription so that neither in the Assembly nor in the Parliament-meeting of the articles nor at the Councell Table was there any suspition of treasonable combination against the King from this subscription Secondly if both that of the 1580. and this of 1638. be one then certainly this hath no more then that and that hath no lesse then this Neither is there any other difference of the one from the other but as was expressed in our Protestation Septemb. 22. 1638. such as is of a march stone hid in the ground and uncovered c. for this end and for giving full satisfaction to authority these words Wee have sworne and doe sweare not onely our mutuall concurrence and assistance for the cause of Religion c. but also that wee shall concurre with our friends and familiars in quiet manner or in armes as wee shall be required of his Majesty his Councell or any having his authority in every cause that may concerne his Majesties honour according to the Lawes of this Kingdome and the duetie of good Subjects c. are insert in the Supplication of the Generall Assembly first part of this representation pag. 48. Our third objection is That the demands proponed by us in Parliament are but matters in fieri which is so praegnant that it cannot be answered if it be considered as it was modestly proponed and very truly exponed by our Commissioners in their proceedings pag. 45 46. for many demands may be made to the articles which may be rejected by them and many things may be concluded in articles to be proponed to the Parliament which in face of Parliament being disputed may be judged inconvenient Demands are not definitions nor propositions to be accompted conclusions Things done by men must be in fieri before they be in facto esse every conception cometh not to the rypenesse to be a birth BY that which we have said we believe we are free before and in the Assembly and Parliament of insolencies and the heavy censures of Rebellion and Treason which are so ordinarily and at every other word thundered out that they are become the lesse formidable unto us who desire that all our actions and proceedings in this cause may be seen in their own colours and who are supported with this inward testimony that we fear God and still honour the King although nothing can proceed from us which will please our adversaries except we will follow their rules which are not unlike those of the Jesuits found at Padua when they were expelled the territory of Venice One of them was that men should take heed that they presse or inculcat not too much the Grace of God Another was that men must beleeve the Hierarchicall Church although it tell us that that is black which our ey judgeth to be white Vnto which we may adde the third invented by Ignatius Loyola of blinde obedience which we have no mind to practise because it is repugnant to the essence of the vertue of obedience which proceedeth from knowledge and election We intreat our adversaries to shew us in good earnest and not by way of railing In what sense have we incurred the censure of Rebellion and Treason in the Assembly as is alledged pag. 52. The Assembly was conveened by his Majesties authority countenanced from the beginning to the end by his Majesties high Commissioner all things were done with high respect to the Kings Majestie and with frequent prayers for his happines Nothing was put in deliberation till it was first proponed to his Majesties Commissioner nor any thing determined without his advice consent and approbation all was done in that order and decencie which this Nation out of use of Assemblies through the tiranny of Prelats usurping the jurisdiction of the Kirk could attain unto at the first or second time and all was closed with rejoycing in God and with many praises and prayers for the King under whose Majestie the Commissioner also had his own part And yet in the Assembly we must be guilty of Rebellion and Treason We cannot be mooved to think but the mitre of an usurping Prelat by the authority of a Nationall Councell may be thrown to the ground without the violation or smallest touch of the Crown or Scepter of Imperiall Majesty because we deny both the Tenets of the Romanists One that the temporall power of Princes is directly subordinat and subject unto persons Ecclesiasticall as having all power given them of God Another of such of them as are touched with a little shame that the temporall authority doeth not reside in persons Ecclesiasticall but is given unto them indirectly as necessar for the Spirituall which is but a shift and a difference of words what then should our judgment be of unlawfull and usurping prelats and popâ—lâ—ngs may be easily known by others or if need were made known by our selves if this were not a digression onely this much we intended that to dethrone a prelat and to over-turn prelacie we judge it no Treason against the King And so we come to the answer of the third part of the Declaration touching our faults since the Parliament Not three or foure but Ten transgressions and exorbitancies are here libelled against us The first three are the provyding of men munition and moneyes for our own defence which in us who are the Estates of a free Kingdome is held lawfull by the Law of God and Nature by our acts of Parliament by the practise of other reformed Kirks by the testimony of famous Divines by the assistance contributed by our own Princes to other Kirks and States invaded and distressed and we adde by the judgment of many amongst our selves who in the beginning of our troubles and before the late pacification had about this their own scruples wherein since considering what is done in England for
his Majesties happy government And did hold in the other hand the sword of just and innocent defence against the oppression and violence of the Enemies of the Kings honour and of our peace Which we are confident by no Law of God or Nations can be judged to be rebellion or laes-Majesty Our petition at that time when we are said to have been in the hight of rebellion we have here set down whole the Declaration containing but a part thereof We did then write our mind whereof we never did repent and which we desire may be known to all men To the Kings most excellent Majesty The supplication of his Majesties Subjects of SCOTLAND humbly shewing THat where the former meanes used by us have not been effectuall for recovering your Majesties favour and the peace of this your Majesties native Kingdome wee fall down again at your Majesties feet most humbly supplicating that your Majestie would be graciously pleased to appoint some few of the many worthy men of your Majesties Kingdome of England who are well-affected to the true Religon and to our common peace To heare by some of us of the same disposition our humble desires and to make knowne to us your Majesties gracious pleasure That as by the providence of God we are joyned in one Iland under one King so by your Majesties great wisedome and tender care all mistakings may be speedily removed and the two Kingdomes may be kept in peace and happinesse under your Majesties long and prosperous reigne For which we shall never cease to pray as it be commeth your Majesties most humble Subjects With the Supplication sent to his Majesty by the hand of the Earle of Dumfermling a Letter was sent to the Earle of Holland and others of the Councell of England about his Majesty In these words MOST NOBLE LORDS ALthough wee have been labouring this long time past by our Supplications Informations and Missives to some of your Lordships to make knowne to his Majesty and the whole Kingdome of England the loyaltie and peaceablenesse of our intentions and desires and that we never meaned to deny to his Majestie our dread Soveraigne and native King any point of temporall and civill obedience yet contrary to our expectation and hopes matters to this day growing worse and worse both Kingdomes are brought to the dangerous and deplorable condition wherein they now stand in the sight of the world In this extreamitie we have sent to his Majestie our humble supplication beside which we know no other meane of pacification and doe most earnestly intreat that it may bee assisted by your Lordships that if it bee possible by a meeting in some convenient place of some prime and well-affected men to the reformed Religion and our common peace matters may bee accommodate in a faire and peaceable way and that so speedily and with such expedition as that through farther delayes which wee see not how they can be longer endured our evills become not incurable wee take God and the world to witnesse that we have left no meanes unassayed to give his Majestie and the whole Kingdome of England all just satisfaction And that wee desire nothing but the preservation of our Religion and Lawes If the fearefull consequents shall ensue which must be very neare except they be wisely and speedily prevented we trust they shall not bee imputed unto us who till this time have been following after peace and who doe in every duetie most ardently desire to shew our selves his Majesties faithfull Subjects and Your Lordships humble servants His Majestie being pleased to admit some of us to repair to the Camp neare Barwick and granting unto them a safe conduct under his Majesties hand our Commissioners presented our humble desires the last words whereof are expressed in the Declaration but we have set them down intire that both the reasonablenesse of our petitions and the loyaltie of our hearts may be knowne to all men First it is our humble desire that his Majesty would be graciously pleased to assure us that the acts of the late Assembly at Glasgow shall be ratified by his Majesty in the ensuing Parliament to be holden at Edinburgh July 23. since the peace of the Kirk and Kingdome cannot endure further prorogation Secondly that his Majesty from his tender care of the preservation of our Religion and Lawes will be graciously pleased to declare and assure that it is his Royall will that all matters Ecclesiasticall bee determined by the Assemblies of the Kirk and matters civill by Parliament which will be for his Majesties honour and keeping peace and order amongst the subjects in the time of his Majesties personall absence Thirdly that a blessed pacification may bee speedily brought about and his Majesties Subjects may be secured our humble desire is that his Majesties ships and forces by land be recalled that all persons ships and goods arrested may be restored the losses which we have sustained by the stopping of our trade and negotiating be repaired and we made safe from violence and invasion And that all excommunicat persons all Incendiaries and Informers against the Kingdome who have out of malice caused these commotions for their own private ends may be returned to suffer their deserved punishment And the Proclamations and Manifestoes sent abroad by them under his Majesties name to the dishonouring of the King and defaming of the Kingdome may be suppressed As these are our humble desires so is it our griefe that his Majestie should have been provoked to wrath against us his most humble loving subjects shal be our delight upon his Majesties assurance of the preservation of our Religion and Lawes to give example to others of all civill and temporall obedience which can be required or expected of loyall subjects Of those our desires the grounds and reasons following were given in writ at his Majesties command REASONS AND GROUNDS of our humble desires WEE doe first humbly desire a ratification of the acts of the late Assembly in the ensuing Parliament 1. Because the civill power is the keeper of both Tables and whereas the Kirk and Kingdome are one body consisting of the same members there can be no firme peace nor stabilitie of order unlesse the Ministers of the Kirk in their way presse the obedience of the civill Lawes and Magistrat and the civill power adde their sanction and authoritie to the constitutions of the Kirk 2. Because the late Generall Assembly indicted by his Majestie was lawfully constitute in all the members thereof according to the constitutions and order prescribed by acts of former Assemblies Thirdly because no particular is enacted in the late Assemblie which is not grounded upon the act of preceeding Assemblies And is either expressely contained in them or by necessary consequence may be deduced from them That the Parliament be keeped without prorogation his Majestie knowes how necessary it is since the peace of the Kirk and Kingdome call for it without longer delay Wee did
of questions were withholden The Lord Commissioner his usurpation in the chosing of the articles above any thing that ever was done by any Commissioner or any of our Kings themselves before The act of oblivion refused except it had been turned in an act of pardon which his Majestie did not presse but passed by and caused delet in the time of the treatie The act of relief so necessary for the Subjects refused and the matter of Coyne altogether disordered The Parliament prorogat against the laws and continuall custome of this Kingdome and against the articles of the treatie The labouring of division by all means in the time of the sitting of the Parliament whereof some were shameful and unnaturall as is confessed since under the hand of some of the conspiratours upon theremorse of their conscience The Lords of Dumfermling and Lowdoun sent from the Parliament and that upon a warrant shewed by the Lord Commissioner were not honoured with his Majesties presence but commanded to return Scandalous relations of the proceedings of our Parliament made at the Councel table of England and judged there but the benefit of hearing before the Councel denyed to our Commissioners The Committee appointed by our Parliament for necessarie and pertinent ends is quarrelled and an English Committee of some few allowed to sit and judge of our Parliament The answers of our Commissioners taxed as impertinent but no particular reason given to shew that they are such The Covenant allowed by the Assembly and subscribed by the Lord Commissioner disallowed and that which was rejected before esteemed Our Commissioners pressed to give their judgement concerning calling and dissolving Assemblies and the negative voice in Assemblies contrary to the laws of this Kirk and Kingdome otherwise not to be heard Counsellours and officers of Estate discharged their places summarlie and never heard Commandment given to the town of Edinburgh to publish a Proclamation for discharging the Earle of Argyle from executing the office of justiciarie belonging heretablie to him by act of Parliament and to disclaime and disallow a Committee appointed by Parliament Commandment given to the towne of Edinburgh to receive to the Castle Garrisons of strangers over their own heads and to furnish all materials for their own ruine Great violence and outrage done by the Castle of Edinburgh not onely against men and buildings but women and children for many dayes past without any provocation from the towne A terrible commission granted to Northumberland for subduing and destroying us before our Commissioners who were waiting and ready to clear our intentions and actions had a hearing Great preparations by sea and land at home and from abroad against us before it was told us for what fault Our Ships and goods taken and the owners stripped naked and more barbarously used then by Turks and Infidels and we referred by the Governour of Barwick to the Councel of England for satisfaction Letters sent for eight Noblemen to repair to Court to be put it seemeth in the same condition with the Lord of Lowdoun The restraint of our Commissioners and the imprisonment of the Lord Lowdoun against all equitie law and conscience All things devised and done that may make a rupture and irreconcilable warre between the two Kingdomes All means used to disgrace this Kirk and Kingdome Books Pasquils Maskes honouring of our cursed Prelats advancing of our deposed Ministers denying presentation to Kirks c. No other answer given to our Commissioners there or to us here concerning the reasons of our demands whether they satisfie or not but a declaration given out denouncing a warre and armies coming upon us The Parliament of England which was called upon the sentence of the Councel animated by the relation made by the Commissioner that it was fit to use force against us hath not seen just cause of warre or of giving moneyes for war and so to enter in a nationall quarrell and therefore is broken up and yet the expedition ceaseth not By this time it may bee evident how matters stand all being brought to a worse condition then at the beginning nothing done nor granted for the enjoying of our Religion and liberties but all the means which have been used by us not onely before the Assembly and Parliament but even in the Assembly so peaceably ended with the consent of the Commissioner are censured for Rebellion Treason and contempt of authoritie Large profession is made before God and the world of a constant intention that wee shall enjoy our Religon and liberties and more then this we nor do nor did ever desire how then cometh it that wee rest not satisfied since his Majestie is disposed to grant all our desire The fallacie may bee soone seen The Declaration professeth that his Majestie never did hinder us from the enjoying of our Religion c. because his Majestie is still in the opinion at least our enemies would have it to appear that the Service Book the Canons Episcopacie are nothing against our Religion And therefore would grant us a Religion that may consist with them and take them all within the compasse of it In this sense the Lutherans Arminians Papists were they our Superiours would grant us the enjoying of our Religion because they conceive it not to be Religion wherein we differ from them and Politicks please themselves with a few principles of religion what is over those to be but superfluous or indifferent And where it may be opposed that his Majestie grants the enjoying of our Religion and liberties according to our Ecclesiastical and civil laws the same deception doth recurre and can never be removed till determination passe in Assembly and Parliament what are Religion and liberties by our laws This was therefore the summe of our desires from the beginning which his Majestie was also graciously pleased to grant but when the Assembly hath conveened and determined And when it beginneth to appear what the determination of the Parliament is like to be then all is called and counted rebellion Treason and contempt of authoritie in the Assembly and Parliament although proceeding soberly posedly and upon such grounds as were furnished by the lawes of the Kirk and Kingdome This is the round that wee have runne and wee are led back to the point at which we had our beginning A circular course which forteth well with the advise professed in a divisive meeting in the time of the Parliament and since discovered I will never bee an adviser of his Majestie to invade this Kingdome by hostility but to make shows upon our borders that we may be ever in armes our means may be consumed and we inpoverished that so the King at last may obtain his ends which is to turne this work into Penelopes â—ebbe to doe and undoe and thus to labour in vaine But the adviser might have been better acquainted with the Scottish temper of his own countreymen Seeing then that our humble desires of enjoying our Religion and Liberties are