one to forbear for a season from the use of their Privilege in the participation of the Supper of the Lord in case of scandal and offence which would be taken at it and ensue thereon And if any Person shall refuse a Submission unto them in this Act of Rule the Church hath no way for its Relief but to proceed unto the total Removal of such a Person from their whole Communion For the Edification of the whole Church must not be obstructed by the Refractoriness of any one among them THIS Excommunication as we have proved before is an act of Church-Authority exerted in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ. And if so then it is an act of the Officers of the Church namely so far as it is Authoritative for there is no Authority in the Church properly so called but what resides in the Officers of it There is an Office in the Church which is meerly Ministerial without any formal Authority that is of the Deacons But there is no Authority in exercise but what is in the Elders and Rulers of the Church And there are two Reasons which prove that the power of Excommunication as to the Authoritative Exercise of it is in the Elders of the Church 1. Because the Apostles by virtue of their Office-Power in every Church did join in the Authoritative Excommunication as is plain in the case insisted on 1 Cor. 5. And there is no Office-Power now remaining but what is in the Elders of the Church 2. It is an Act of Rule But all Rule properly so called is in the hands of Rulers only We may add hereunto that the care of the preservation of the Edification of all its Members of the Correction and Salvation of Offenders is principally incumbent on them or committed unto them as we have declared as also that they are best able to judge when and for what this Sentence ought to be denounced against any which requires their best skill in the Wisdom of Spiritual Rule And therefore the omission of the exercise of it when it was necessary is charged as a neglect on the Angels or Rulers of the Churches as the due execution of it is commended in them And therefore unto them it doth belong with respect unto their Office and is thereon an Office-Act or an Act of Authority HOWBEIT it cannot be denied but that the Interest yea the power of the whole Church in the Fraternity of it is greatly to be considered herein For indeed where-ever the Apostle Treats of it he doth not any where recommend it unto the Officers of the Church in a peculiar manner but unto the whole Church and the Brethren therein This is evident in the places before quoted Wherefore the whole Church is concerned herein both in point of Duty Interest and Power 1. In point of Duty for by virtue of the mutual watch of all the Members of the Church over each other and of the care incumbent on every one of them for the Good the Honour the Reputation and Edification of the whole it is their Duty jointly and severally to endeavour the purging out from among them of every thing that is contrary unto those ends And they who are not concerned in these things are dead and useless Members of the Church 2. In Interest they have also a concernment therein They are to look that no root of bitterness spring up amongst them lest themselves are at length defiled thereby It is usually said that the good are not defiled by holding Communion with them that are wicked in a participation of holy Ordinances And there is some Truth in what is said with reference unto wicked undiscovered Hypocrites or such as are not scandalously flagitious But to promote this Perswasion so as to beget an opinion in Church-Members that they are no way concerned in the scandalous Sins and Lives of those with whom they walk in all Duties of Spiritual Communion openly avowing themselves Members of the same Body with them is a Diabolical Engine invented to countenance Churches in horrible security unto their ruine But yet besides that defilement which may be contracted in a joint participation of the same Ordinances with such Persons there are other ways almost innumerable whereby their Example if passed by without Animadversion may be pernicious unto their Faith Love and Obedience Wherefore they are obliged in point of Spiritual Interest as they take care of their own Souls to concurr in the ejection out of the Church of obstinate Offenders 3. In point of Power For the Execution of this Sentence is committed unto and rests in the Body of the Church According as they concurr and practise so it is put in Execution or Suspended for it is they who must withdraw Communion from them or the Sentence is of no use or validity this punishment must be inflicted by the many who also are to restore him who is so rebuked Wherefore Excommunication without the consent of the Church is a meer nullity BUT if any one shall say that Excommunication is not an Act of Authority nor of Office but of Power residing in the community resulting from their common suffrage guided and directed by the Officers or Elders of the Church I shall again take up this Enquiry immediately and speak unto it more distinctly lest what is here spoken should not be sufficient unto the satisfaction of any OUR next Enquiry is concerning the object of this Church Censure or who they are that ought to be Excommunicated And 1. THEY must be Members of that Church by which the Sentence is to be denounced against them And this as we have proved before they cannot be without their own consent One Church cannot Excommunicate the Members of another They are unto them as unto this matter without and they have no power to judge them The foundation of the Right to proceed against any herein is in their own voluntary engagement to observe and keep the Rules and Laws of the Society whereunto they are admitted The offence is given unto that Church in the first place if not only And it is an Act of the Church for its own Edification And there is a nullity in the Sentence which is ordained decreed or denounced by any who are not Officers of that Church in particular wherein the Sin is committed 2. THESE Church-Members that may be justly Excommunicated are of Two sorts 1. SUCH as continue obstinate in the practice of any scandalous Sin after private and publick admonition The process from the first Offence in Admonition is so stated in ordinary cases Matth. 18. that there is no need farther to declare it The Time that is to be allotted unto the several Degrees of it shall be spoken unto afterwards And unto a right judgment of obstinacy in any scandalous Sin it is required 1. That the Sin considered in it self be such as is owned to be such by all without doubting dispute or haesitation It must be some Sin that is
arrived unto those which they called general under the conduct of the Pope whose Senate they were BUT these things have no countenance given them by any Divine Institution Apostolical Example or practice of the First Churches but are a meer product of Secular Interest working it self in a Mystery of Iniquity SINCE the Dissolution of the Roman Empire Nations have been cast into distinct Civil Governments of their own whose Sovereignty is in themselves by the event of War and Counsels thereon emergent Unto each of these it is supposed there is a Church-State accommodated as the Church of England the Church of Scotland the Church of France and the like whose Original and Being depends on the First event of War in that Dissolution Unto these new Church-States whose Being Bounds and Limits are given unto them absolutely by those of the Civil Government which they belong unto it is thought meet that Ecclesiastical Synods should be accommodated But in what way this is to be done there is not yet an agreement but it is not my present business to consider the differences that are about it which are known unto this Nation on a dear account Yet this I shall say that whereas it is eminently useful unto the Edification of the Church Catholick that all the Churches professing the same Doctrine of Faith within the Limits of the same Supream Civil Government should hold constant actual Communion among themselves unto the ends of it before mentioned I see not how it can be any abridgment of the Liberty of particular Churches or interfere with any of their Rights which they hold by Divine Institution if through more constant lesser Synods for Advice there be a communication of their mutual concerns unto those that are greater until if occasion require and it be expedient there be a general Assembly of them all to advise about any thing wherein they are all concerned But this is granted only with these Limitations 1. That the Rights of particular Churches be preserved in the free Election of such as are to be Members of all these Synods 2. That they assume no Authority or Jurisdiction over Churches or Persons in things Civil or Ecclesiastical 3. That none are immediately concerned in this proper Synodal Power or Authority which what it is we shall enquire who are not present in them by their own Delegates FOR that kind of Synods which some call a Classis which is a convention of the Elders or Officers of sundry Parochial Churches distinguished for Presential Communion ordinarily in some acts of it by virtue of their Office and for the exercise of Office-Power it is the constitution of a new kind of particular Churches by a combination of them into one whose Original distinction is only in the Civil Limits of their Cohabitation which probably may be done sometimes and in some places unto Edification 4. THE Persons of whom all sorts of Ecclesiastical Synods are to consist must be enquired into And there is nothing of meer humane prudential constitution that hath longer obtained in the Church than that those should be Officers of the Churches only And whereas after the days of the Apostles we have no Record of any Synods of more Churches than one until after the distinction was made between Bishops and Presbyters they were made up of both sorts of them But afterwards those who were peculiarly called Bishops enclosed this Right unto themselves on what grounds God knows there being no one Tittle in the Scripture or the Light of Reason to give them countenance therein IT must therefore be affirmed that no Persons by virtue of any Office meerly have Right to be Members of Ecclesiastical Synods as such Neither is there either Example or Reason to give colour unto any such pretence Farther is no Office-Power to be exerted in such Synods as such neither conjunctly by all the Members of them nor singly by any of them Officers of the Church Bishops Pastors Elders may be present in them ought to be present in them are meetest for the most part so to be but meerly as such it belongs not unto them The Care Oversight and Rule of the Churches whereunto they do belong the Flock among them distinctly is committed unto them and for that they are instructed with Power and Authority by virtue of their Office. But as unto their conjunction in Synods which is a meer act and effect of the Communion of Churches among themselves it is not committed unto them in a way of peculiar Right by virtue of their Office. If it be so without respect unto the power of the Magistrate in calling them or of the Churches in choosing them then it belongs unto them all for that which belongs unto any of them as such by virtue of Office belongs equally unto all and if it belongs unto all then it belongs unto all of one sort only as for instance Bishops or unto all of all sorts as for instance Presbyters also If it be stated in the latter way then every Presbyter as such by virtue of his Office hath Right and Power to be present in all Ecclesiastical Synods equal with that of the Bishops For although it be supposed that his Office is not equal unto theirs yet it is so also that this Right doth equally belong unto his Office. If the former be avowed namely that this Right belongs unto Bishops only such as are pleaded for by virtue of their Office as such then 1. I desire that any tolerable proof of the confinement of this Right unto such an Office be produced either from the Scripture or Reason or the Example of the First Churches which as yet I have never seen 2. I fear not to say that a false presumption hereof was one principal cause and means of introducing Tyranny into the Churches and the utter ruine of their Liberty CONCERNING the composition that is made herein that some should convene in Ecclesiastical Synods by their own personal Right and in virtue of their Office and others by a kind of Delegation from some of their own Order it being a meer political constitution which I shall immediately speak unto it is not here to be taken notice of THERE is nothing therefore in Scripture Example or the Light of Natural Reason with the principles of all Societies in Union or Communion that will lead us any farther than this that such Synods are to be composed and consist of such Persons as are chosen and delegated by those Churches respectively who do act and exert their Communion in such Assemblies So was it in the First Example of them Act. 15. The Church of Antioch chose and sent Messengers of their own number to advise with the Apostles and Elders of the Church at Jerusalem at which Consultation the Members of that Church also were present And this is the whole of the nature and use of Ecclesiastical Synods It is on other accounts that they make up so great a part of the History
FOR whereas there are three things required unto a Covenant between God and Man. 1. That it be of Gods appointment and institution 2. That upon a prescription of Duties there be a solemn engagement unto their performance on the part of Men. 3. That there be especial promises of God annexed thereunto in which consists the matter of Confederation whereof mutual express Restipulation is the form they all concurr herein 9. THIS Covenant which we intend is not the Covenant of Grace absolutely considered nor are all the Duties belonging unto that Covenant prescribed in it but the principal of them as Faith Repentance and the like are presupposed unto it nor hath annexed unto it all the promises and privileges of the New Covenant absolutely considered but it is that which is prescribed as a Gospel Duty in the Covenant of Grace whereunto do belong all the Duties of Evangelical Worship all the powers and privileges of the Church by virtue of the especial promise of the peculiar presence of Christ in such a Church 10. WHEREAS therefore in the constitution of a Church Believers do give up themselves unto the Lord and are bound solemnly to engage themselves to do and observe all the things which Christ hath commanded to be done and observed in that state whereon he hath promised to be present with them and among them in an especial manner which presence of his doth interest them in all the Rights Powers and Privileges of the Church their so doing hath the nature of a Divine Covenant included in it which is the Formal Cause of their Church Sate and Being 11. BESIDES as we have proved before there are many mutual Duties required of all which join in Church Societies and Powers to be exercised and submitted unto whereunto none can be obliged without their own consent They must give up themselves unto one another by the will of God. That is they must agree consent and engage among themselves to observe all those mutual Duties to use all those Privileges and to exercise all those Powers which the Lord Christ hath prescribed and granted unto his Church See Jerem. 50.4 5. 12. THIS compleats the confederation intended which is the Formal Cause of the Church and without which either expresly or virtually performed there can be no Church State. 13. INDEED herein most Men deceive themselves and think they do not that nor that it ought to be done and dispute against it as unlawful or unnecessary which for the substance of it they do themselves and would condemn themselves in their own Consciences if they did it not For unto what end do they join themselves unto Parochial Churches and Assemblies To what end do they require all Professors of the Protestant Religion so to do declaring it to be their Duty by penalties annexed unto its neglect Is it not that they might yield obedience unto Christ in their so doing Is it not to profess that they will do and observe all whatsoever he commands them Is it not to do it in that Society in those Assemblies whereunto they do belong Is there not therein virtually a mutual Agreement and Engagement among them unto all those ends It must be so with them who do not in all things in Religion fight uncertainly as Men beating the Air. 14. NOW whereas these things are in themselves and for the substance of them known Gospel Duties which all Believers are indispensably obliged unto the more express our engagement is concerning them the more do we glorify Christ in our Profession and the greater sense of our Duty will abide on our Consciences and greater encouragement be given unto the performance of mutual Duties as also the more evident will the warranty be for the exercise of Church Power Yet do I not deny the Being of Churches unto those Societies wherein these things are virtually only observed especially in Churches of some continuance wherein there is at least an implicit consent unto the first Covenant-Constitution 15. THE Lord Christ having instituted and appointed Officers Rulers or Leaders in his Church as we shall see in the next place to look unto the discharge of all Church Duties among the Members of it to administer and dispense all its Privileges and to exercise all its Authority the consent and engagement insisted on is expresly required unto the constitution of this Order and the preservation of it For without this no Believer can be brought into that Relation unto another as his Pastor Guide Over-seer Ruler unto the ends mentioned wherein he must be subject unto him partake of all Ordinances of Divine Worship administred by him with Authority in obedience unto the will of Christ They gave their own selves to us saith the Apostle by the will of God. 16. WHEREFORE the Formal Cause of a Church consisteth in an Obediential Act of Believers in such numbers as may be useful unto the ends of Church Edification jointly giving up themselves unto the Lord Jesus Christ to do and observe all his Commands resting on the promise of his especial presence thereon giving and communicating by his Law all the Rights Powers and Privileges of his Church unto them and in a mutual Agreement among themselves jointly to perform all the Duties required of them in that State with an especial subjection unto the Spiritual Authority of Rules and Rulers appointed by Christ in that State. 17. THERE is nothing herein which any Man who hath a conscientious sense of his Duty in a professed subjection unto the Gospel can question for the substance of it whether it be according to the mind of Christ or no. And whereas the nature and essential properties of a Divine Covenant are contained in them as such it is a Foundation of any Church State. 18. THUS under the Old Testament when God would take the postâ—rity of Abraham into a new peculiar Church State he did it by a Solemn Covenant Herein as he prescribed all the Duties of his Worship to them and made them many blessed promises of his presence with powers and privileges innumerable so the people solemnly Covenanted and engaged with him that they would do and observe all that he had Commanded them whereby they coalesced into that Church State which abode unto the time of Reformation This Covenant is at large declared Exod. 24. For the Covenant which God made there with the people and they with him was not the Covénant of Grace under a legal dispensation for that was established unto the Seed of Abraham Four Hundred years before in the Promise with the Seal of Circumcision nor was it the Covenant of Works under a Gospel dispensation for God never renewed that Covenant under any consideration whatever But it was a peculiar Covenant which God then made with them and had not made it with their Fathers Deut. 5.2 3. whereby they were raised and erected into a Church State wherein they were intrusted with all the Privileges and enjoined all the Duties which God had
Churches being called and gathered by their Ministry they were given unto the Church and placed in the Church for the exercise of all Office with Power unto their Edification according to the Rules and Laws of their constitution Act. 1.14 15. Chap. 6.1 2 3 4. 1 Cor. 3.22 Chap. 12.28 Ephes. 4.11 12 13 14. 2. THIS Power is ceased in the Church It is so not by virtue of any Law or constitution of Christ but by a cessation of those actings whence it did flow and whereon it did depend For unto this Apostolical Office and Power there was required 1. An immediate personal call from Christ himself 2. A Commission equally extensive unto all Nations for their Conversion and unto all Churches equally for their Edification 3. An Authority in all Churches comprehensive of all that power which is in the ordinary constitution of them distributed among many 4. A Collation of extraordinary Gifts as of infallibility in Teaching of working Miracles speaking with Tongues and the like Whereas therefore all these things do cease and the Lord Christ doth not act in the same manner towards any this Office and Power doth absolutely cease For any to pretend themselves to be Successors unto these Apostles as some with a strange confidence and impertinency have done is to plead that they are personally and immediately called by Christ unto their Office that they have Authority with respect unto all Nations and all Churches and are indued with a spirit of Infallibility and a power of working Miracles whereof outward pomp and ostentation are no sufficient evidences And certainly when some of them consider one another and talk of being the Apostles Successors it is but Aruspex Aruspicens 3. LEAST of all in the ordinary state of the Church and the continuation thereof hath the Lord Christ appointed a Vicar or rather as is pretended a Successor with a plenitude of all Church Power to be by him parcelled out unto others This is that which hath overthrown all Church Rule and Order introducing Luciferian Pride and Antichristian Tyranny in their room And whereas the only way of Christs acting his Authority over the Churches and of communicating Authority unto them to be acted by them in his Name is by his Word and Spirit which he hath given to continue in his Church unto that end unto the consummation of all things the Pope of Rome placing himself in his stead for these ends doth thereby sit in the Temple of God and shew himself to be God. But this is sufficiently confuted among all sober Christians and those who embrace it may be left to contend with the Mahometans who affirm that Jesus left John the Baptist to be his Successor as Haly succeeded unto Mahomet 5. ALL these by whom the ordinary Rule of the Church is to be exercised unto its Edification are as unto their Office and Power given unto the Church set or placed in it not as Lords of their Faith but as helpers of their joy 1 Cor. 2.2 Chap. 3.21 22 23. 2 Cor. 1.24 Ephes. 4.11 12 13 14. 1 Pet. 5.1 2. For the Church is the Spouse of Christ the Lambs Wife and by virtue of that Relation the enfeoffment into this power is her Due and Dowry all particular Persons are but her Servants for Christs sake For though some of them be Stewards and set over all their fellow Servants yet he hath not given them the trust of power to rule his Spouse at their own will and to grant what they please unto her 6. BUT as this whole Church Power is committed unto the whole Church by Christ so all that are called unto the peculiar exercise of any part of it by virtue of Office-Authority do receive that Authority from him by the only way of the communication of it namely by his Word and Spirit through the Ministry of the Church whereof we shall treat afterwards V. THESE things being thus premised in general concerning Church Power we must treat yet particularly of the communication of it from Christ and of its distribution as unto its Residence in the Church 1. EVERY Individual Believer hath Power or Right given unto him upon his believing to become the Son of God Joh. 1.12 Hereby as such he hath a Right and Title radically and originally unto with an interest in all Church Privileges to be actually possessed and used according to the Rules by him prescribed For he that is a Son of God hath a right unto all the privileges and advantages of the Family of God as well as he is obliged unto all the Duties of it Herein lies the foundation of all right unto Church Power for both it and all that belongs unto it is a part of the purchased Inheritance whereunto right is granted by Adoption wherefore the first original grant of all Church Power and Privileges is made unto Believers as such Theirs it is with these Two Limitations 1. That as such only they cannot exercise any Church Power but upon their due observation of all Rules and Duties given unto this end such are Joint Confession and Confederation 2. That each individual do actually participate therein according to the especial Rules of the Church which peculiarly respects Women that do believe 2. WHERE-ever there are two or three of these Believers the smallest number Right and Power is granted unto them actually to meet together in the name of Christ for their mutual Edification whereunto he hath promised his presence among them Matth. 18.19 20. To meet and to do any thing in the name of Christ as to exhort instruct and admonish one another or to pray together as v. 19. there is an especial Right or Power required thereunto This is granted by Jesus Christ unto the least number of consenting Believers And this is a second preparation unto the communication of Church Power Unto the former Faith only is required unto this Profession with mutual consent unto and agreement in the Evangelical Duties mentioned are to be added 3. WHERE the number of Believers is encreased so as that they are sufficient as unto their number to observe and perform all Church Duties in the way and manner prescribed for their performance they have Right and Power granted unto them to make a joint solemn Confession of their Faith especially as unto the Person of Christ and his Mediation Matth. 16.16 18. as also to give up themselves unto him and to one another in an holy Agreement or Confederation to do and observe all things whatever that he hath Commanded Hereon by virtue of his Laws in his Institutions and Commands he gives them power to do all things in their Order which he grants unto his Church and enstates them in all the Rights and Privileges thereof These Believers I say thus congregated into a Church State have immediately by virtue thereof power to take care that all things be done among them as by the Lord Christ they are Commanded to be done in and by his
Spiritual Gifts in Preaching with a refusal of undertaking a Ministerial Office or without design so to do upon a lawful Call cannot be approved 3. The Rules proposed concern only ordinary cases and the ordinary state of the Church extraordinary cases are accompanied with a warranty in themselves for extraordinary Actings and Duties 12. THE Call of Persons unto the Pastoral Office is an Act and Duty of the Church It is not an Act of the political Magistrate not of the Pope not of any single Prelate but of the whole Church unto whom the Lord Christ hath committed the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven And indeed although there be great differences about the nature and manner of the Call of Men unto this Office yet none who understand ought of these things can deny but that it is an Act and Duty of the Church which the Church alone is impowered by Christ to put forth and exert But this will more fully appear in the consideration of the nature and manner of this Call of Men unto the Pastoral Office and the actings of the Church therein THE Call of persons unto the Pastoral Office in the Church consists of Two Parts 1. Election 2. Ordination as it is commonly called or sacred Separation by Fasting and Prayer As unto the former Four things must be enquired into 1. What is previous unto it or preparatory for it 2. Wherein it doth consist 3. It s necessity or the demonstration of its Truth and Institution 4. What influence it hath into the communication of Pastoral-Office-Power unto a Pastor so chosen 1. THAT which is previous unto it is the Meetness of the Person for his Office and Work that is to be chosen It can never be the Duty of the Church to call or choose an unmeet an unqualified an unprepared Person unto this Office. No pretended necessity no outward motives can enable or warrant it so to do nor can it by any outward act whatever the Rule or Solemnity of it be communicate Ministerial Authority unto Persons utterly unqualified for and uncapable of the discharge of the Pastoral Office according unto the Rule of the Scripture And this hath been one great means of debasing the Ministery and almost ruining the Church it self either by the neglect of those who suppose themselves entrusted with the whole power of Ordination or by Impositions on them by Secular Power and Patrons of Livings as they are called with the stated Regulation of their Proceedings herein by a defective Law whence there hath not been a due regard unto the antecedent preparatory Qualifications of those who are called unto the Ministry TWO ways is the Meetness of any one made known and to be judged of 1. By an evidence given of the Qualifications in him before-mentioned The Church is not to call or choose any one to Office who is not known unto them of whose frame of spirit and walking they have not had some experience not a Novice or one lately come unto them He must be one who by his ways and walking hath obtained a good Report even among them that are without so far as he is known unless they be enemies or scoffers and one that hath in some good measure evidenced his Faith Love and Obedience unto Jesus Christ in the Church This is the chief Trust that the Lord Christ hath committed unto his Churches and if they are negligent herein or if at all-adventures they will impose an Officer in his House upon him without satisfaction of his Meetness upon due enquiry it is a great dishonour unto him and provocation of him Herein principally are Churches made the Overseers of their own Purity and Edification To deny them an Ability of a right judgment herein or a liberty for the use and exercise of it is Error and Tyranny But that Flock which Christ purchased and purified with his own blood is thought by some to be little better than an Herd of brute Beasts Where there is a defect of this personal knowledge for want of opportunity it may be supplied by Testimonies of unquestionable Authority 2. By a trial of his Gifts for Edification These are those Spiritual Endowments which the Lord Christ grants and the Holy Spirit Works in the Minds of Men for this very end that the Church may be profited by them 1 Cor. 12.7 And we must at present take it for granted that every true Church of Christ that is so in the matter and form of it is able to judge in some competent measure what Gifts of Men are suited unto their own Edification But yet in making a judgment hereof one Directive means is the Advice of other Elders and Churches which they are obliged to make use off by virtue of the Communion of Churches and the avoidance of offence in their walk in that Communion 2. AS to the nature of this Election Call or Choice of a Person known tried and judged meetly qualified for the Pastoral Office it is an Act of the whole Church that is of the Fraternity with their Elders if they have any For a Pastor may be chosen unto a Church which hath other Teachers Elders or Officers already instated in it In this case their concurrence in the choice intended is necessary by way of common suffrage not of Authority or Office-Power For Election is not an Act of Authority but of Liberty and Power wherein the whole Church in the Fraternity is equal If there be no Officers stated in the Church before as it was with the Churches in the Primitive Times on the first Ordination of Elders among them this Election belongs unto the Fraternity 3. THAT therefore which we have now to prove is this That it is the Mind and Will of Jesus Christ that meet Persons should be called unto the Pastoral Office or any other Office in the Church by the Election and Choice of the Church it self whereunto they are called antecedently unto a sacred solemn separation unto their respective Offices For 1. UNDER the Old Testament there were three ways whereby Men were called unto Office in the Church 1. They were so extraordinarily and immediately by the nomination and designation of God himself So Aaron was called unto the Priesthood and others afterwards as Samuel to be Prophets 2. By a law of Carnal Generation so all the Priests of the Posterity of Aaron succeeded into the Office of the Priesthood without any other call 3. By the choice of the people which was the call of all the ordinary Elders and Rulers of the Church Deut. 1.13 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Give to your selves It was required of the people that they should in the first place make a judgment on their Qualifications for the Office whereunto they were called Men known unto them for Wise Understanding Righteous walking in the Fear of God they were to look out and then to present them unto Moses for their separation unto Office which is Election It is true that Exod. 13.15 It is
said that Moses chose the Elders But it is frequent in the Scripture that where any thing is done by many where one is chief that is ascribed indifferently either to the many or to the chief Director So is it said Israel sent Messengers Numbers 21.21 Moses speaking of the same things says I sent Messengers Deut. 2.26 So 1 Chron. 19.19 They made peace with David and served him which is 2 Sam. 10.19 They made peace with Israel and served them See also 2 King. 11.12 with 2 Chron. 23.11 as also 1 Chron. 16.1 with 2 Sam. 6.17 and the same may be observed in other places Wherefore the people chose these Elders under the conduct and guidance of Moses which directs us unto the right interpretation of Act 14.23 whereof we shall speak immediately THE First of these ways was repeated in the foundation of the Evangelical Church Christ himself was called unto his Office by the Father through the unction of the spirit Isa. 60. Heb. 5. And he himself called the Apostles and Evangelists in whom that call ceased The second ordinary way by the privilege of natural Generation of the stock of the Priests was utterly abolished The third way only remained for the ordinary continuation of the Church namely by the Choice and Election of the Church it self with solemn Separation and Dedication by Officers extraordinary or ordinary THE first instance of the Choice of a Church-Officer had a mixture in it of the first and later way in the case of Matthias As he was able to be a Church-Officer he had the choice and consent of the Church as he was to be an Apostle or an extraordinary Officer there was an immediate divine disposition of him into his Office the latter to give him Apostolical Authority the former to make him a president of the future actings of the Church in the call of their Officers I say this being the first example and pattern of the calling of any Person unto Office in the Christian Church-State wherein there was an interposition of the ordinary actings of Men is established as a Rule and President not to be changed altered or departed from in any Age of the Church whatever It is so as unto what was of common Right and Equity which belonged unto the whole Church And I cannot but wonder how Men durst ever reject and disanul this divine Example and Rule It will not avail them to say that it is only a matter of Fact and not a precept or institution that is recorded For 1. It is a Fact left on record in the holy Scripture for our Instruction and Direction 2. It is an example of the Apostles and the whole Church proposed unto us which in all things not otherwise determined hath the force of an institution 3. If there was no more in it but this that we have a matter of common Right determined and applied by the Wisdom of the Apostles and the entire Church of Believers at that time in the World it were an impiety to depart from it unless in case of the utmost necessity WHEREAS what is here recorded was in the call of an Apostle it strengthens the Argument which hence we plead For if in the extraordinary call of an Apostle it was the mind of Christ that the Fraternity or Multitude should have the liberty of their suffrage how much more is it certainly his mind that in the ordinary call of their own peculiar Officers in whom under him the concernment is their own only that this Right should be continued unto them THE order of the proceeding of the Church herein is distinctly declared For 1. The number of the Church at that time that is of the Men was about an Hundred and Twenty v. 15. 2. They were assembled all together in one place so as that Peter stood up in the midst of them v. 15. 3. Peter in the name of the rest of the Apostles declares unto them the necessity of choosing one to be substituted in the room of Judas v. 16 17 18 19 20. 4. He limits the choice of him unto the especial Qualification of being a meet witness of the Resurrection of Christ unto those who constantly accompanied him with themselves from the Baptism of John that is his being Baptized by him whereon he began his publick Ministry 5. Among these they were left at their liberty to nominate any two who were to be left unto the lot for a determination whether of them God designed unto the Office. 6. Hereon the whole multitude 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 appointed Two that is the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Men and Brethren unto whom Peter spake v. 16. did so 7. The same Persons to promote the work prayed and gave forth their Lots v. 24.26 8 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Matthias was by the common suffrage of the whole Church reckoned unto the number of the Apostles I say not that these things were done by the Disciples in distinction from Peter and the rest of the Apostles but in conjunction with them Peter did nothing without them nor did they any thing without him THE exception of Bellarmine and others against this Testimony is that it was a grant and a condescention in Peter and not a declaration of the Right of the Church that it was an extraordinary case that the determination of the whole was by Lot are of no validity The pretended concession of Peter is a figment the case was so extraordinary as to include in it all ordinary cases for the substance of them And although the ultimate determination of the Individual Person which was necessary unto his Apostleship was immediately Divine by Lot yet here is all granted unto the people in their choosing and appointing Two in their Praying in their casting Lots in their voluntary opprobatory Suffrage that is desired THIS blessed Example given us by the Wisdom of the Apostles yea of the spirit of God in them being eminently suited unto the nature of the thing it self as we shall see immediately compliant with all other directions and Apostolical examples in the like case is rather to be followed than the practice of some degenerate Churches who to cover the turpitude of acting in deserting this Example and Rule do make use of a mock-shew and pretence of that which really they deny reject and oppose THE Second Example we have of the practice of the Apostles in this case whereby the preceding Rule is confirmed is given us Act. 6. in the Election of the Deacons Had there ensued after the choice of Matthias an instance of a diverse practice by an exclusion of the consent of the people the former might have been evaded as that which was absolutely extraordinary and not obliging unto the Church But this was the very next instance of the call of any Church-Officer and it was the first appointment of any ordinary Officers in the Christian Church For it falling out in the very year of Christs Ascension there is no
Suffrage of the people 2. I have shewed instances before out of the Scripture that when a thing is done by the whole people it is usual to ascribe it unto him or them who were chief therein as elsewhere the same thing is ascribed unto the whole people THE same Authors contend that the liberty of choosing their own Officers or Elders such as it was was granted unto them or permitted by way of condescention for a Season and not made use of by virtue of any right in them thereunto But this permission is a meer imagination It was according to the mind of Christ that the Churches should choose their own Elders or it was not If it were not the Apostles would not have permitted it and if it were they ought to ordain it and practise according to it as they did Nor is such a constant Apostolical Practice proposed for the direction of the Church in all Ages to be ascribed unto such an Original as Condescension and Permission Yea it is evident that it arose from the most fundamental principles of the constitution and nature of the Gospel Churches and was only a regular pursuit and practice of them For 1. THE Calling of Bishops Pastors Elders is an Act of the power of the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven But these Keys are originally and properly given unto the whole Church unto the Elders of it only Ministerially and as unto exercise Pastors are eyes to the Church But God and Nature design in the first place sight to the whole Body to the whole Person thereunto it is granted both subjectively and finally but actually it is peculiarly seated in the eye So is it in the grant of Church-Power it is given to the whole Church though to be exercised only by its Elders THAT the grant of the Keys unto Peter was in the Person and as the representative of the whole confessing Church is the known judgment of Austin and a multitude of Divines that follow him So he fully expresseth himself Tractat. 124. in Johan Peter the Apostle bare in a general figure the person of the Church For as unto what belonged unto himself he was by Nature one Man by Grace one Christian and of special more abounding Grace one and the chief Apostle But when it was said unto him I will give unto thee the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven c. he signified the whole Church c. Again the Church which is founded in Christ received from him in the person of Peter the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven which is the power of binding and loosing UNTO whom these Keys are granted they according to their distinct interests in that grant have the Right and Power of Calling their Bishops Pastors or Elders for in the exercise of that Trust and Power it doth consist But this is made unto the whole Church And as there are in a Church already constituted several sorts of persons as some are Elders others are of the people only this Right resideth in them and is acted by them according to their respective capacities as limited by the light of nature and divine institution which is that the Election of them should belong unto the body of the people and their Authoritative Designation or Ordination unto the Elders And when in any place the supream Magistrate is a Member or Part of the Church he hath also his peculiar Right herein THAT the power of the Keys is thus granted originally and fundamentally unto the whole Church is undeniably confirmed by Two Arguments 1. THE Church it self is the Wife the Spouse the Bride the Queen of the Husband and King of the Church Christ Jesus Psal. 45.10 John 3.29 Revel 21.9 Chap. 22.17 Matth. 25.1 5 6. Other Wife Christ hath none nor hath the Church any other Husband Now to whom should the Keys of the House be committed but unto the Bride There is I confess another who claims the Keys to be his own but withal he makes himself the Head and Husband of the Church proclaiming himself not only to be an Adulterer with that Harlot which he calleth the Church but a Tyrant also in that pretending to be her Husband he will not trust her with the Keys of his House which Christ hath done with his Spouse And whereas by the Canon Law every Bishop is the Husband or Spouse of his Diocesan Church for the most part they commit an open Rape upon the people taking them without their consent at least are not chosen by them which yet is essential unto a lawful Marriage And the Bride of Christ comes no otherwise so to be but by the voluntary choice of him to be her Husband FOR the Officers or Rulers of the Church they do belong unto it as hers 1 Cor. 3.21.22 And Stewards in the House 1 Cor. 4.1 the Servants of the Church for Jesus sake 2 Cor. 4.5 IF the Lord Christ have the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven that is of his own House Heb. 3. If the Church it self be the Spouse of Christ the Mother of the Family Psal. 68.13 the Bride the Lambs Wife and if all the Officers of the Church be but Stewards and Servants in the House and unto the Family if the Lord Christ do make a grant of these Keys unto any whereon the disposal of all things in this House and Family doth depend the Question is Whether he hath originally granted them unto his holy Spouse to dispose off according unto her judgment and duty or unto any Servants in the House to dispose of her and all her concernments at their pleasure 2. THE power of the Keys as unto binding and loosing and consequently as unto all other acts thence proceeding is expresly granted unto the whole Church Matth. 18.17 18. If he shall neglect to hear them tell the Church but if he neglect to hear the Church let him be unto thee as an Heathen Man and a Publican verily I say unto you whatsoever ye shall bind on Earth shall be bound in Heaven and whatsoever ye shall loose on Earth shall be loosed in Heaven What Church it is that is here intended we have proved before and that the Church is intrusted with the power of binding and loosing And what is the part of the Body of the people herein the Apostle declares 1 Cor. 5.4 2 Cor. 2.6 SECONDLY This Right exemplified in Apostolical Practice is comprehended in the Commands given unto the Church or Body of the People with respect unto Teachers and Rulers of all sorts for unto them it is in a multitude of places given in charge that they should discern and try false Prophets fly from them try Spirits or such as pretend Spiritual Gifts or Offices reject them who Preach false Doctrine to give testimony unto them that are to be in Office with sundry other things of the like nature which all of them do suppose or cannot be discharged without a Right in them to choose the worthy and reject the unworthy as
are These Gifts Offices and Officers being granted by Christ unto the Churches Ephes. 4.12 where-ever there is a Church called according to his Mind they do in and by their Choice of them submit themselves unto them in the Lord according unto all the Powers and Duties wherewith they are by him intrusted and whereunto they are called 3. IT is required that Persons so chosen so submitted unto be so solemnly separated dedicated unto and confirmed in their Office by Fasting and Prayer As this is consonant unto the Light of Nature which directs unto a solemnity in the susception of publick Officers whence proceeds the Coronation of Kings which gives them not their Title but solemnly proclaims it which on many accounts is unto the advantage of Government so it is prescribed unto the Church in this case by especial Institution But hereof I shall speak farther immediately THIS Order of calling Men unto the Pastoral Office namely by their previous Qualifications for the Ministry whereby a general designation of the Persons to be called is made by Christ himself the orderly Choice or Election of him in a voluntary subjection unto him in the Lord according to the Mind of Christ by the Church it self followed with solemn Ordination or setting apart unto the Office and discharge of it by Prayer with Fasting all in obedience unto the Commands and Institution of Christ whereunto the communication of Office-Power and Privilege is by Law-constitution annexed is suited unto the light of Reason in all such cases the nature of Gospel Societies in Order or Churches the ends of the Ministry the Power committed by Christ unto the Church and confirmed by Apostolical Practice and Example HEREIN we rest without any further dispute or limiting the Formal Cause of the Communication of Office-Power unto any one Act or Duty of the Church or of the Bishops or Elders of it All the three things mentioned are essential thereunto and when any of them are utterly neglected where they are neither formally nor virtually there is no lawful regular Call unto the Ministry according to the Mind of Christ. THIS Order was a long time observed in the Ancient Church inviolate and the foot-steps of it may be traced through all Ages of the Church although it first gradually decayed then was perverted and corrupted until it issued as in the Roman Church in a Pageant and Shew instead of the Reality of the things themselves For the Trial and Approbation of spiritual Endowments previously necessary unto the Call of any was left unto the Pedantick Examination of the Bishops Domesticks who knew nothing of them in themselves the Election and Approbation of the people was turned into a mock-shew in the sight of God and Men a Deacon calling out That if any had Objections against him who was to be Ordained they should come forth and speak Whereunto another cries out of a corner by compact He is learned and worthy and Ordination was esteemed to consist only in the outward sign of Imposition of Hands with some other Ceremonies annexed thereunto whereby without any other consideration there ensued a flux of Power from the Ordainers unto the ordained BUT from the beginning it was not so And some few Instances of the Right of the people and the exercise of it in the Choice of their own Pastors may be touched on in our Passage Clem. Epist. ad Corinth affirms That the Apostles themselves appointed approved Persons unto the Office of the Ministry 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 by or with the consent or choice of the whole Church 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is to enact by common consent which makes it somewhat strange that a learned Man should think that the Right of the People in Elections is excluded in this very place by Clemens from what is assigned unto the Apostles in Ordination IGNAT Epist ad Philadelph 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 writing to the Fraternity of the Church It becomes you as a Church of God to Choose or Ordain a Bishop TERTVLL APOL Praesident probati quique Seniores honorem istum non pretio sed Testimonio adepti The Elders came unto their Honour or Office by the Testimony of the people that is by their suffrage in their Election ORIGEN in the close of his last Book against Celsus discoursing expresly of the Calling and Constitution of Churches or Cities of God speaking of the Elders and Rulers of them affirms That they are 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Chosen to their Office by the Churches which they do Rule THE Testimony given by Cyprian in sundry places unto this Right of the People especially in Epist. 68. unto the Elders and People of some Churches in Spain is so known so frequently urged and excepted against to so little purpose as that it is no way needful to insist again upon it Some few things I shall only observe concerning and out of that Epistle As 1. IT was not a single Epistle of his own more ordinary occasions but a determination upon a weighty Question made by a Synod of Bishops or Elders in whose Name as well as that of Cyprian it was written and sent unto the Churches who had craved their advice 2. HE doth not only assert the Right of the people to choose worthy persons to be their Bishops and reject those that are unworthy but also industriously proves it so to be their Right by Divine Institution and Appointment 3. HE declares it to be the Sin of the People if they neglect the use and exercise of their Right and Power in rejecting and withdrawing themselves from the Communion of Vnworthy Pastors and choosing others in their room 4. HE affirms that this was the Practice not only of the Churches of Africk but of those in most of the other Provinces of the Empire Some passages in his Discourse wherein all these things are asserted I shall transcribe in the Order wherein they lie in the Epistle NEC sibi plebs blandiatur quasi immunis esse a contagio delicti possit cum sacerdote peccatore communicans ad injustum illicitum Praepositi sui Episcopatum consensum suum commodans Propter quod plebs obsequens praeceptis Dominicis Deum metuens a peccatore praeposito separare se debet nec se ad Sacrilegi Sacerdotis Sacrificia miscere quando ipsa maxime habeat potestatem vel eligendi dignos sacerdotes vel indignos recusandi quod ipsum videmus de Divina Authoritate descendere FOR this cause the people obedient to the Commands of our Lord and fearing God ought to separate themselves from a wicked Bishop nor mix themselves with the Worship of a Sacrilegious Priest. For they principally have the power of choosing the worthy Priests and rejecting the unworthy which comes from Divine Authority or Appointment as he proves from the Old and New Testament Nothing can be spoken more fully representing the Truth which we plead for He assigns unto the people a Right and Power of separating
unto the Ministry of the Word as Pastors and Teachers who are Elders also are devested of the Right of Rule in the Church or discharged from the exercise of it because others not called unto their Office are appointed to be assistant unto them that is Helps in the Government For the Right and Duty of Rule is inseparable from the Office of Elders which all Bishops or Pastors are The Right is still in them and the exercise of it consistent with their more excellent Work is required of them So was it in the First Institution of the Sanhedrim in the Church of Israel Exod. 18.17 18 19 20 21 22 23. Moses had before the sole Rule and Government of the People In the addition that was made of an Eldership for his assistance there was no diminution of his Right or the exercise of it according to his precedent power And the Apostles in the constitution of Elders in every Church derogated nothing from their own Authority nor discharged themselves of their care So when they appointed Deacons to take care of Supplies for the Poor they did not forgo their own Right nor the exercise of their Duty as their other Work would permit them Gal. 2.9 10. And in particular the Apostle Paul manifested his concernment herein in the care he took about Collection for the Poor in all Churches 8. AS we observed at the entrance of this Chapter the whole Work of the Church as unto Authoritative Teaching and Rule is committed unto the Elders For Authoritative Teaching and Ruling is Teaching and Ruling by virtue of Office And this Office whereunto they do belong is that of Elders as it is undeniably attested Act. 20.17 c. All that belongs unto the Care Inspection Oversight Rule and Instruction of the Church is committed unto the Elders of it expresly For Elders is a Name derived from the Jews denoting them that have Authority in the Church The First signification of the Word in all Languages respects Age. Elders are Old Men well stricken in years unto whom respect and reverence is due by the Law of Nature and Scripture Command unless they forfeit their Privilege by levity or wickedness which they often do Now Ancient Men were originally judged if not only yet the most meet for Rule and were before others constantly called thereunto Hence the Name of Elders was appropriated unto them who did Preside and Rule over others in any kind ONLY it may be observed that there is in the Scripture no mention of Rulers that are called Elders but such as are in a subordinate Power and Authority only Those who were in supream absolute power as Kings and Princes are never called Elders But Elders by Office were such only as had a Ministerial Power under others Wherefore the highest Officers in the Christian Church being called Elders even the Apostles themselves and Peter in particular 1 Epist. Chap. 5. v. 1.2 it is evident that they have only a Ministerial Power and so it is declared ver 4. The Pope would now scarce take it well to be esteemed only an Elder of the Church of Rome unless it be in the same sence wherein the Turkish Monarch is called the Grand Signior But those who would be in the Church above Elders have no Office in it whatever usurpation they may make over it 9. TO the compleat constitution of any particular Church or the perfection of its Organical State it is required that there be many Elders in it at least more than one In this proposition lies the next foundation of the Truth which we plead for and therefore it must be distinctly considered I do not determine what their number ought to be nor is it determinable as unto all Churches For the Light of Nature sufficiently directs that it is to be proportioned unto the Work and End designed Where a Church is numerous there is a necessity of encreasing their number proportionable unto their Work. In the days of Cyprian there was in the Church of Carthage Ten or Twelve of them that are mentioned by Name And at the same time there were a great many in the Church of Rome under Cornelius Where the Churches are small the number of Elders may be so also For no Office is appointed in the Church for pomp or show but for labour only And so many are necessary in each Office as are able to discharge the Work which is allotted unto them But that Church be it small or great is not compleat in its state is defective which hath not more Elders than one who have not so many as are sufficient for their Work. 10. THE Government of the Church in the judgment and practice of some is absolutely Democratical or Popular They judge that all Church-Power or Authority is seated and setled in the Community of the Brethren or Body of the People And they look on Elders or Ministers only as Servants of the Church not only materially in the Duties they perform and finally for their Edification serving for the good of the Church in the things of the Church but formally also as acting the Authority of the Church by a meer delegation and not any of their own received directly from Christ by virtue of his Law and Institution Hence they do occasionally appoint Persons among themselves not called unto not vested with any Office to Administer the Supper of the Lord or any other solemn Offices of Worship On this principle and supposition I see no necessity of any Elders at all though usually they do conferr this Office on some with solemnity But as among them there is no direct necessity of any Elders for Rule so we treat not at present concerning them 11. SOME place the Government of many particular Churches in a Diocesan Bishop with those that act under him and by his Authority according unto the Rule of the Canon Law and the civil constitution of the Land. These are so far from judging it necessary that there should be many Elders for Rule in every particular Church as that they allow no Rule in them at all but only assert a Rule over them But a Church where there is no Rule in it self to be exercised in the Name of Christ by its own Rulers Officers Guides immediatly presiding in it is unknown to Scripture and Antiquity Wherefore with these we deal not in this Discourse nor have any apprehension that the power of presenting Men for any pretended Disorder unto the Bishops or Chancellors Court is any part of Church-Power or Rule 12. OTHERS place the Rule of particular Churches especially in cases of greatest moment in an Association Conjunction or Combination of all the Elders of them in one Society which is commonly called a Classis So in all Acts of Rule there will be a conjunct acting of many Elders And no doubt it is the best provision that can be made on a supposition of the continuance of the present Parochial Distribution But those also of this
judgment who have most weighed and considered the nature of these things do assert the necessity of many Elders in every particular Church which is the common judgment and practice of the Reformed Churches in all places 13. AND some there are who begin to maintain That there is no need of any more but One Pastor Bishop or Elder in a particular Church which hath its Rule in its self other Elders for Rule being unnecessary This is a Novel Opinion contradictory to the sence and practice of the Church in all Ages And I shall prove the contrary 1. THE pattern of the First Churches constituted by the Apostles which it is our Duty to imitate and follow as our Rule constantly expresseth and declares That many Elders were appointed by them in every Church Act. 11.30 Chap. 14.23 Chap. 15.2 4 6 22. Chap. 16.4 Chap. 20.17 c. 1 Tim. 5.17 Phil. 1.1 Tit. 1.5 1 Pet. 5.1 There is no mention in the Scripture no mention in Antiquity of any Church wherein there was not more Elders than One nor doth that Church answer the Original Pattern where it is otherwise 2. WHERE there is but one Elder in a Church there cannot be an Eldership or Presbytery as there cannot be a Senate where there is but one Senator which is contrary unto 1 Tim. 4.14 3. THE continuation of every Church in its original State and Constitution is since the ceasing of extraordinary Offices and Powers committed to the Care and Power of the Church it self Hereunto the Calling and Ordaining of ordinary Officers Pastors Rulers Elders Teachers do belong And therein as we have proved both the Election of the People submitting themselves unto them in the Lord and the solemn setting of them apart by Imposition of Hands do concurr But if there be but One Elder only in a Church upon his Death or Removal this Imposition of Hands must either be left unto the People or be supplied by Elders of other Churches or be wholly omitted all which are irregular And that Church-Order is defective which wants the Symbol of Authoritative Ordination 4. IT is difficult if not impossible on a supposition of One Elder only in a Church to preserve the Rule of the Church from being Prelatical or Popular There is nothing more frequently objected unto those who dissent from Diocesan Bishops than that they would every one be Bishops in their own Parishes and unto their own People All such pretences are excluded on our principles of the Liberty of the People of the necessity of many Elders in the same Church in an equality of Power and the Communion of other Churches in Association But practically where there is but One Elder one of the extreams can be hardly avoided If he Rule by himself without the previous Advice in some cases as well as the subsequent consent of the Church it hath an eye of unwarrantable Prelacy in it If every thing be to be Originally Transacted Disposed Ordered by the whole Society the Authority of the Elder will quickly be insignificant and he will be little more in point of Rule than any other Brother of the Society But all these Inconveniencies are prevented by the fixing of many Elders in each Church which may maintain the Authority of the Presbytery and free the Church from the Despotical Rule of any Diotrâ—phes But in case there be but one in any Church unless he have Wisdom to maintain the Authority of the Eldership in his own Person and Actings there is no Rule but Confusion 5. THE nature of the Work whereunto they are called requires that in every Church consisting in any considerable number of Members there should be more Elders than One. When God first appointed Rule in the Church under the Old Testament he assigned unto every Ten Persons or Families a distinct Ruler Deut. 1.15 For the Elders are to take care of the Walk or Conversation of all the Members of the Church that it be according unto the Rule of the Gospel This Rule is eminent as unto the holiness that it requires above all other Rules of moral Conversation whatever And there is in all the Members of the Church great Accuracy and Circumspection required in their walking after it and according unto it The Order also and Decency which is required in all Church-Assemblies stands in need of exact care and inspection That all these things can be attended unto and discharged in a due manner in any Church by One Elder is for them only to suppose who know nothing of them And although there may be an appearance for a season of all these things in such Churches yet there being not therein a due compliance with the Wisdom and Institution of Christ they have no present Beauty nor will be of any long continuance THESE considerations as also those that follow may seem jejune and contemptible unto such as have another frame of Church-Rule and Order drawn in their Minds and Interests A Government vested in some few Persons with Titles of Preheminence and Legal Power exercised in Courts with Coercive Jurisdiction by the Methods and Processes of Canons of their own framing is that which they suppose doth better become the Grandeur of Church-Rulers and the State of the Church than these Creeping Elders with their Congregations But whereas our present enquiry after these things is only in and out of the Scripture wherein there is neither shadow nor appearance of any of these practices I beg their pardon if at present I consider them not 10. WE shall now make Application of these things unto our present purpose I say then 1. Whereas there is a Work of Rule in the Church distinct from that of Pastoral Feeding 2. Whereas this Work is to be attended unto with diligence which includes the whole Duty of him that attends unto it And 3. That the Ministry of the Word and Prayer with all those Duties that accompany it is a full Employment for any Man and so consequently his principal and proper Work which it is unlawful for him to be remiss in by attending on another with Diligence And 4. Whereas there ought to be many Elders in every Church that both the Works of Teaching and Ruling may be constantly attended unto 5. That in the Wisdom of the Holy Ghost distinct Works did require distinct Offices for their discharge all which we have proved already our enquiry hereon is Whether the same Holy Spirit hath not distinguished this Office of Elders into those two sorts namely those who are called unto Teaching and Rule also and those who are called unto Rule only which we Affirm THE Testimonies whereby the Truth of this Assertion is confirmed are generally known and pleaded I shall insist on some of them only beginning with that which is of uncontroulable evidence if it had any thing to conflict withal but prejudices and interest and this is 1 Tim. 5.17 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is Praesum Praesidio to Preside to Rule Praesident
have to do and the manner how they are to do it is altogether unreasonable and senceless unto them who have another Idea of Church-Affairs and Rule conceived in their Minds or received by Tradition and riveted by Interest And on the other hand those who know little or nothing of what belongs unto the due Edification of the Church beyond Preaching the Word and reaping the Advantage that is obtained thereby cannot see any necessity of the distribution of these several Works and Duties unto several Officers but suppose all may be done well enough by One or Two in the same Office. Wherefore it will be necessary that we treat briefly of the Nature of the Rule of the Church in particular and what is required thereunto which shall be done in the close of this Discourse 9. THE Exceptions which are usually put in unto this Testimony have not the least countenance from the Text or Context nor the matter treated of nor Confirmation 〈◊〉 any other Divine Testimony It is therefore in vain to contend about them being such as any Man may multiply at his pleasure on the like occasion and used by those who on other considerations are not willing that things should be as they are here declared to be by the Apostle Yet we may take a brief Specimen of them Some say it is Gifts absolutely without respect unto distinct Offices that the Apostle Treats of which hath been disproved from the Text and Context before Some say that Rule is included in the Pastoral Office so as that the Pastor only is here intended But 1. Rule is not his principal Work which he is to attend unto in a peculiar manner with diligence above other parts of his Duty 2. The care of the Poor of the Flock belongs also to the Pastoral Office yet is there another Office appointed to attend unto it in a peculiar manner Act. 6. 3. He that Ruleth is in this place expresly distinguished from him that Exhorteth and him that Teacheth Some say that he that Ruleth is he that Ruleth his Family But this is disproved by the Analysis of the Chapter before declared And this Duty which is common unto all that have Families and confined unto their Families is ill placed among those publick Duties which are designed unto the Edification of the whole Church It is objected that he that Ruleth is here placed after him that giveth that is the Deacon I say then it cannot be the Pastor that is intended if we may prescribe Methods of expressing himself unto the Apostle But he useth his Liberty and doth not oblige himself unto any Order in the annumeration of the Offices of the Church see 1 Cor. 12.8 9 10 28. And some other Exceptions are insisted on of the same nature and importance which indeed deserve not our consideration 10. THERE is the same Evidence given unto the Truth argued for in another Testimony of the same Apostle 1 Cor. 12.28 God hath set some in the Church First Apostles Secondarily Prophets Thirdly Teachers after that Miracles then Gifts of Healings Helps Governments Diversities of Tongues I shall not insist on this Testimony and its Vindication in particular seeing many things would be required thereunto which have been Treated of already Some things may be briefly observed concerning it That there is here an Annumeration of Officers and Offices in the Church both extraordinary for that season and ordinary for continuance is beyond exception Unto them is added the present exercise of some extraordinary Gifts as Miracles Healing Tongues That by Helps the Deacons of the Church are intended most do agree because their Original Institution was as helpers in the Affairs of the Church Governments are Governours or Rulers the Abstract for the Concrete that is such as are distinct from Teachers such hath God placed in the Church and such there ought to be But it is said that Gifts not Offices are intended the Gift of Goverment or Gift for Government If so then these Gifts are either ordinary or extraordinary if ordinary how come they to be reckoned among Miracles Healing and Tongues if extraordinary what extraordinary Gifts for Government were then given distinct from those of the Apostles and what instance is any where given of them in the Scripture Again If God hath given Gifts for Government to abide in the Church distinct from those given unto Teachers and unto other Persons than the Teachers then is there a distinct Office of Rule or Government in the Church which is all we plead for 11. THE Original Order in these things is plain in the Scripture The Apostles had all Church-Power and Church-Office in themselves with Authority to exercise all Acts of them everywhere on all occasions But considering the nature of the Church with that of the Rule appointed by the Lord Christ in it or over it they did not they would not ordinarily exercise their power by themselves or in their own persons alone And therefore when the First Church consisted of a small number the Apostles acted all things in it by the consent of the whole Multitude or the Fraternity as we have proved from Acts the First And when the number of Believers encreased so as that the Apostles themselves could not in their own Persons attend unto all the Duties that were to be performed towards the Church by virtue of Office they added by the direction of the Holy Ghost the Office of the Deacons for the especial discharge of the Duty which the Church oweth unto its poor Members Whereas therefore it is evident that the Apostles could no more personally attend unto the Rule of the Church with all that belongs thereunto without an entrenchment on that labour in the Word and Prayer which was incumbent on them than they could attend unto the Relief of the Poor they appointed Elders to help and assist in that part of Office-Work as the Deacons did in the other THESE Elders are first mentioned Act. 11.30 where they are spoken of as those which were well known and had now been of some time in the Church Afterwards they are still mentioned in conjunction with the Apostles and distinction from the Church it self Acts 15.2 4 6 22. Chap. 16.4 Chap. 21.18 Now the Apostles themselves were Teaching Elders that is such as had the Work of Teaching and Rule committed to them 1 Pet. 5.1 2 Joh. 1. And these Elders are constantly distinguished from them which makes it evident that they were not Teaching Elders And therefore in all the mention that is made of them the Work of Teaching or Preaching is no where ascribed unto them which at Jerusalem the Apostles reserved to themselves Act. 6.2 3. but they are every where introduced as joining with the Apostles in the Rule of the Church and that in distinction from the Church it self or the Brethren of it Yea it is altogether improbable that whilst the Apostles were at Jerusalem giving themselves wholly unto the Word and Prayer that they
should appoint in the same Church many more Teaching Elders though it is plain that the Elders intended were many I SHALL add for a close of all that there is no sort of Churches in being but are of this perswasion that there ought to be Rulers in the Church that are not in Sacred Orders as some call them or have no interest in the Pastoral or Ministerial Office as unto the dispensation of the Word and Administration of the Sacraments For as the Government of the Roman Church is in the hands of such Persons in a great measure so in the Church of England much of the Rule of it is managed by Chancellors Officials Commissaries and the like Officers who are absolutely Lay-Men and not at all in their holy Orders Some would place the Rule of the Church in the Civil Magistrate who is the only Ruling Elder as they suppose But the generality of all Protestant Churches throughout the World both Lutherans and Reformed do both in their judgment and practice assert the necessity of the Ruling Elders which we plead for and their Office lies at the foundation of all their Order and Discipline which they cannot forgo without extream confusion yea without the ruine of their Churches And although some among us considering particular Churches only as small Societies may think there is no need of any such Office or Officers for Rule in them yet when such Churches consist of some Thousands without any opportunity of distributing themselves into several Congregations as at Charenton in France it is a weak imagination that the Rule of Christ can be observed in them by Two or Three Ministers alone Hence in the Primitive Times we have instances of Ten Twenty yea Forty Elders in a particular Church wherein they had respect unto the Institution under the Old Testament whereby each Ten Families were to have a peculiar Ruler However it is certain that there is such a Reformation in all sorts of Churches that there ought to be some attending unto Rule that are not called to labour in the Word and Doctrine CHAP. VIII The Nature of Church-Polity or Rule with the Duty of Elders HAVING declared who are the Rulers of the Church something must be added concerning the Rule it self which is to be exercised therein Hereof I have Treated before in general That which I now design is what in particular respects them who are called unto Rule only whereunto some Considerations must be premised 1. THERE is Power Authority and Rule granted unto and residing in some Persons of the Church and not in the Body of the Fraternity or Community of the People How far the Government of the Church may be denominated Democratical from the necessary consent of the people unto the principal Acts of it in its exercise I shall not determine But whereas this consent and the liberty of it is absolutely necessary according to the Law of Obedience unto Christ which is prescribed unto the Church requiring that all they do in compliance therewith be voluntary as unto the manner of its exercise being in dutiful compliance with the guidance of the Rule it changeth not the State of the Government And therefore where any thing is Acted and Disposed in the Church by Suffrage or the plurality of Voices the Vote of the Fraternity is not Determining and Authoritative but only declarative of consent and obedience It is so in all Acts of Rule where the Church is Organical or in compleat Order 2. THAT there is such an Authority and Rule instituted by Christ in his Church is not liable unto dispute Where there are Bishops Pastors Elders Guides Rulers Stewards instituted given granted called ordained and some to be Ruled Sheep Lambs Brethren obliged by command to obey them follow them submit unto them in the Lord regard them as over them There is Rule and Authority in some persons and that committed unto them by Jesus Christ. But all these things are frequently repeated in the Scripture And when in the practical Part or Exercise of Rule due respect is not had unto their Authority there is nothing but Confusion and Disorder When the People judge that the Power of the Keys is committed unto them as such only and in them doth the Right of their Use and Exercise reside that their Elders have no interest in the disposing of Church Affairs or in Acts of Church Power but only their own suffrages or what they can obtain by reasoning and think there is no Duty incumbent on them to acquiesce in their Authority in any thing an Evil apt to grow in Churches it overthrows all that beautiful Order which Jesus Christ hath ordained And if any shall make Advantage of this Complaint That where the People have their due Liberty granted unto them they are apt to assume that Power unto themselves which belongs not unto them an evil attended with troublesome Impertinencies and Disorder tending unto Anarchy let them remember on the other hand how upon the confinement of Power and Authority unto the Guides Bishops or Rulers of the Church they have changed the nature of Church-Power and enlarged their Usurpation until the whole Rule of the Church issued in absolute Tyranny Wherefore no fear of consequents that may ensue and arise from the darkness ignorance weakness lusts corruptions or secular interests of Men ought to entice us unto the least Alteration of the Rule by any prudential Provisions of our own 3. THIS Authority in the Rulers of the Church is neither Autocratical or Sovereign nor Nomothetical or Legislative nor Despotical or Absolute but Organical and Ministerial only The endless Controversies which have sprung out of the mystery of iniquity about an Autocratical and Monarchical Government in the Church about power to make Laws to bind the Consciences of Men yea to kill and destroy them with the whole manner of the execution of this Power we are not concerned in A pretence of any such Power in the Church is destructive of the Kingly Office of Christ contrary to express Commands of Scripture and condemned by the Apostles Isa. 33.22 Jam. 4.12 Mat. 17.5 Chap. 23.8 9 10 11. Luke 22.25 26. 2 Cor. 1.24 1 Cor. 3.21 22 23. 2 Cor. 4.5 1 Pet. 5.1 25. 4. AS the Rule of the Church in those by whom it is exercised is meerly Ministerial with respect unto the Authority of Christ his Law and the Liberty of the Church wherewith he hath made it free so in its nature it is spiritual purely and only So the Apostle Affirms expresly 2 Cor. 10.4 5 6. For its object is spiritual namely the Souls and Consciences of Men whereunto it extends which no other Humane Power doth nor doth it reach those other concerns of Men that are subject unto any political Power Its end is Spiritual namely the Glory of God in the guidance and direction of the Minds and Souls of Men to live unto him and come to the enjoyment of him the Law of it is spiritual
helpful to each other in the common Work which they are called unto But such as are utterly destitute of these Gifts are not called unto this Work nor any part of it 3. THE Power that is exercised herein is the Power and Authority of Christ committed unto the Elders Our Authority which the Lord Christ hath given us for Edification and not for Destruction 2 Cor. 10.8 It is granted unto the Rulers of the Church not formally to reside in them as the Power of a King is in his own person but ministerially and instrumentally only For it must be the Authority of Christ himself whereby the Consciences of Men are spiritually affected with reference unto spiritual Ends whereby they are bound or losed in Heaven and Earth have their Sins remitted or retained And the consideration hereof is that alone which gives a due regard unto the Ministry of the Church in the discharge of their Office among them that desire to commend their Consciences unto the Lord Christ in what they do 4. THE especial Design of the Rule of the Church in its Government is to represent the Holiness Love Compassion Care and Authority of Christ towards his Church This is the great end of Rule in the Church and of all the Discipline which is to be exercised by virtue thereof Whilst this is not attended unto when the Officers and Rulers of the Church do not endeavour in all the actings of their Power and Office to set forth these Vertues of Christ to exemplifie that impression of them which he hath left in his Laws and Rule with the Divine Testimonies which he gives of them in his own person they utterly deviate from the principal end of all Rule in the Church For Men to act herein in a way of Domination with a visible Elation of Mind and Spirit above their Brethren with Anger Wrath and Passion by Rules Order and Laws of their own devising without the least consideration of what the Lord Christ requires and what is the frame of his Heart towards all his Disciples is to reflect the highest Dishonour imaginable upon Christ himself He who comes into the Courts of the King in Westminster Hall when filled with Judges Grave Learned and Righteous most ordinarily be allowed to judge of the King himself his Wisdom Justice Moderation and Clemency by the Law which they proceed upon and their manner of the Administration of it But God forbid that Christians should make a Judgment concerning the Holiness Wisdom Love and Compassion of Christ by the Representation which as is pretended is made of him and them in some Courts wherein Church-Rule and Discipline is Admistred When any had offended of old their Censure by the Church was called the Bewailing of them 2 Cor. 12.24 and that because of the Sorrow Pity and Compassion whereby in that Censure they evidenced the compassion of the Lord Christ towards the Souls of Sinners This is scarce answered by those pecuniary mulcts and other penalties which with indignation and contempt are inflicted on such as are made Offenders whether they will or no. Certainly those who love the Lord Jesus Christ in sincerity and have a due honour for the Gospel will at one time or another begin to think meet that this stain of our Religion should be washed away 2 dly THE Rule and Law of the exercise of Power in the Elders of the Church is the Holy Scripture only The Lord Christ is the only Law-giver of the Church all his Laws unto this end are recorded in the Scripture no other Law is effectual can oblige or operate upon the object or unto the ends of Church-Rule If the Church make a Thousand Rules or Canons or Laws for Government neither any of them nor all of them in general have any the least power to oblige Men unto obedience or compliance with them but only so far as virtually and materially they contain what is of the Law of Christ and derives force from thence As the Judges in our Courts of Justice are bound to judge and determine in all cases out of and according to the Law of the Land and when they do not their Sentence is of no validity but may and ought to be reversed But if wilfully or of choice they should introduce Laws or Rules not legally established in this Nation judging according unto them it would render them highly criminal and punishable It is no otherwise in the Kingdom of Christ and the Rule thereof It is by his Law alone that Rule is to be exercised in it There is nothing left unto the Elders of the Church but the Application of his Laws and the General Rules of them unto particular cases and occasions To make to bring to execute any other Rules Laws or Canons in the Government of his Church is to usurp on his Kingly Dominion whereunto all Legislative Power in the Church is appropriate Nor is it possible that any thing can fall out in the Church that any thing can be required in the Rule of it nor can any instance be given of any such thing wherein for the ends of Church-Rule there is or can be any more left unto the Rulers of it but only the Application and Execution of the Laws of Christ. Unto this Application to be made in a due manner the Wisdom and Skill before described is requisite and that alone Where there are other Laws Rules or Canons of the Government of the Church and where the Administration of them is directed by Laws Civil or Political there is a skill in them required unto that Administration as all will confess So is the Wisdom we before described and that alone necessary unto that Rule of the Church which the Lord Christ hath ordained the Instrument and means whereof is his Word and Law alone 3 dly THE matter of this Rule about which it is conversant and so the Acts and Duties of it may be reduced unto Three Heads 1. THE Admission and Exclusion of Members Both these are Acts of Church-Power and Authority which are to be exercised by the Elders only in a Church that is Organical and compleat in its Officers There is that in them both which is founded in and warranted from the Light and Law of Nature and Rules of Equity Every Righteous voluntary Society coalescing therein rightfully upon known Laws and Rules for the Regulation of it unto certain ends hath naturally a power inherent in it and inseparable from it to receive into its incorporation such as being meet for it do voluntarily offer themselves thereunto as also to reject or withhold the Privileges of the Society from such as refuse to be Regulated by the Laws of the Society This power is inherent in the Church essentially considered antecedently unto the enstating of Officers in it By virtue of their mutual confederation they may receive into the privileges of the Society those that are meet and withdraw the same privileges from those that are unworthy But in
these actings of the Church essentially considered there is no exercise of the Power of the Keys as unto Authoritative Rule but what is meerly Doctrinal There is in what it doth a declaration of the Mind of Christ as unto the State of the Persons whom they do receive or reject But unto the Church as Organical as there are Elders or Rulers instated in it according unto the Mind of Christ there is a peculiar Authority committed for those Acts of the Admission and Exclusion of Members Unto this end is the Key of Rule committed unto the Elders of the Church to be applied with the consent of the whole Society as we shall see afterwards 2 dly THE Direction of the Church in all the Members of it unto the observance of the Rule and Law of Christ in all things unto his Glory and their own Edification And all these things may be reduced unto these Four Heads 1. Mutual Intense peculiar Love among themselves to be exercised continually in all the Duties of it 2. Personal Holiness in Gracious Moral Obedience 3. Vsefulness towards the Members of the same Church towards other Churches and all Men absolutely as occasion and opportunity do require 4. The due performance of all those Duties which all the Members of the Church owe mutually unto each other by virtue of that Place and Order which they hold and possess in the Body About these things is Church-Rule to be exercised for they all belong unto the preservation of its Being and the attainment of its Ends. 3 dly HEREUNTO also belongs the disposal of the outward concernments of the Church in its Assemblies and in the management of all that is performed in them that all things may be done Decently and in Order The disposal of Times Seasons Places the way and manner of managing all things in Church-Assemblies the Regulation of Speeches and Actions the appointment of Seasons for extraordinary Duties according unto the General Rules of the Word and the Reason of things from present Circumstances are Acts of Rule whose Right resides in the Elders of the Church THESE things being premised we may consider what is the Work and Duty of that sort of Elders which we have proved to be placed by Christ for Rule in the Church For considering that which hath been spoken before concerning the Pastoral Office or the Duty of Teaching-Elders of the Church and what hath now been added concerning its Rule in general I cannot but admire that any one Man should have such a confidence in his own Abilities as to suppose himself meet and able for the Discharge of the Duties of both sorts in the least Church of Christ that can well be supposed Yea supposing more Teaching-Elders in every Church than one yet if they are all and every one of them equally bound to give themselves unto the Word and Prayer so as not to be diverted from that Work by any inferior Duties if they are obliged to labour in the Word and Doctrine to the utmost of their strength continually it will appear at length to be necessary that there should be some whose peculiar Office and Duty is to attend unto Rule with Diligence And the Work of these Elders consists in the things ensuing 1. THEY are joined unto the Teaching Elders in all Acts and Duties of Church-Power for the Rule and Government of the Church Such are those before declared This is plain in the Text 1 Tim. 5.17 Both sorts of Elders are joined and do concurr in the same Rule and all the Acts of it one sort of them labouring also in the Word and Doctrine Of both sorts is the Presbytery or Eldership composed wherein resides all Church-Authority And in this conjunction those of both sorts are every way equal determining all Acts of Rule by their common suffrage This gives Order with a necessary representation of Authority unto the Church in its Government 2. THEY are in particular to attend unto all things wherein the Rule or Discipline of the Church is concerned with a due care that the Commands of Christ be duly observed by and among all the Members of the Church This is the substance of the Rule which Christ hath appointed whatever be pretended unto the contrary Whatever is set up in the World in opposition unto it or inconsistent with it under the Name of the Government of the Church is foreign unto the Gospel Church-Rule is a due care and provision that the Institutions Laws Commands and Appointments of Jesus Christ be duly observed and nothing else And hereof as unto the Duty of the Elders we may give some instances As 1. TO watch diligently over the ways walking and conversation of all the Members of the Church to see that it be blameless without offence useful exemplary and in all things answering the holiness of the Commands of Christ the honour of the Gospel and profession which in the World they make thereof And upon the observation which they so make in the watch wherein they are placed to instruct admonish charge exhort encourage comfort as they see cause And this are they to attend unto with Courage and Diligence 2. TO watch against all risings or appearances of such differences and divisions on the account of things Ecclesiastical or Civil as unto their Names Rights and Proprieties in the World that are contrary unto that Love which the Lord Christ requireth in a peculiar and eminent manner to be found amongst his Disciples This he calls his own new Command with respect unto his Authority requiring it his Example first illustrating it in the World and the peculiar fruits and effects of it which he revealed and taught Wherefore the due observance of this Law of Love in it self and all its fruits with the Prevention Removal or Condemnation of all that is contrary unto it is that in which the Rule of the Church doth principally consist And considering the Weakness the Passions the Temptations of Men the mutual Provocations and Exasperations that are apt to fall out even among the best the influence that Earthly occasions are apt to have upon their Minds the frowardness sometimes of Mens natural Tempers the attendance unto this one Duty or part of Rule requires the utmost diligence of them that are called unto it And it is meerly either the want of Acquaintance with the nature of that Law and its Fruits which the Lord Christ requires among his Disciples or an undervaluation of the Worth and Glory of it in the Church or inadvertency unto the causes of its decays and of breeches made in it or ignorance of the Care and Duties that are necessary unto its preservation that induce Men to judge that the Work of an especial Office is not required hereunto 3. THEIR Duty is to warn all the Members of the Church of their especial Church-Duties that they be not found negligent or wanting in them There are especial Duties required respectively of all Church-Members according unto the distinct
shall wilfully and obstinately transgress in any of these things it is the Right and Duty and in the Power of the Church to remove him from its Society BUT this is not the entire nor the next immediate Ground Reason or Warranty of Ecclesiastical Excommunication For this natural Equity will not extend it self unto cases that are in things Spiritual and Supernatural nor will the actings of the Church thereon reach unto the Consciences of Men for the proper ends of Excommunication Wherefore it was necessary that it should have a peculiar Institution in the Church by the Authority of Jesus Christ. For 1. THE Church is such a Society as no Men have Right or Power either to enter into themselves or to exclude others from but by virtue of the Authority of Christ. No warranty from the Light of nature or from the Laws of Men or their own voluntary confederation can enable any to constitute a Church-Society unless they do all things expresly in obedience unto the Authority of Christ. For his Church is his Kingdom his House which none can constitute or build but himself Wherefore it is necessary that the power of Admission into and Exclusion from the Church do arise from his Grant and Institution Nor is it in the power of any Men in the World to admit into or exclude from this Society but by virtue thereof 2. EXCOMMVNICATION is an act of Authority as we shall see afterwards But no Authority can be exercised in the Church towards any person whatever but by virtue of the Institution of Christ. For the Authority it self however ministerially exercised by others is his alone and he exerts it not but in the ways of his own appointment So in particular the Apostle directs that Excommunication be exerted in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ that is in and by his Authority 1 Cor. 5.4 3. THE Privileges from which Men are excluded by Excommunication are not such as they have any Natural or Civil Right unto as hath been proved but meerly such as are granted unto the Church by Jesus Christ and Men cannot by virtue of any Agreement among themselves without a Warranty from him by his Institution Expel others from the Privileges which are meerly of his Grant and Donation He alone therefore hath given and granted this Power unto the Church namely of Excluding any by the Rules and Ways of his Appointment from the Privileges of his Grant which is the peculiar Power of Excommunication inquired after 4. THERE is such an Efficacy assigned unto Excommunication in binding the Consciences of Men in retaining their Sins in the Destruction or Mortification of the Flesh in the Healing and Recovery of Sinners as nothing but the Authority of a Divine Institution can give unto it By virtue of natural Light and mutual Consent Men may free themselves from the Company and Society of those who will not walk with them according to Rules of Communion agreed upon among them but they cannot reach the Minds and Consciences of others with any of these Effects 5. THAT Excommunication is an express Ordinance of our Lord Jesus Christ in his Churches is fully declared in the Scripture For 1. The power of it is contained in the Authority given by Christ unto the Church under the Name of the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven For the Power expressed therein is not meerly Doctrinal and Declarative as is the preaching of the Gospel the consequent whereof upon the Faith or Unbelief of them that hear it is the Remitting or Retaining of their Sin in Heaven and Earth but it is Disciplinary also as it is appropriated unto the House whose Keys are committed unto the Stewards of it And seeing the design of Christ was to have his Church Holy Vnblamable and without offence in the World that therein he might make a Representation of his own Holiness and the Holiness of his Rule and whereas those of whom it is constituted are liable and subject unto Sins scandalous and offensive reflecting dishonour on himself and the Church in being the occasion of sinning unto others that design would not have been accomplished had he not given this Authority unto his Church to cast out and separate from it self all that do by their Sins so give offence And the neglect of the exercise of this Authority in a due manner was the principal means whereby the Glory Honour and usefulness of the Churches in the World were at length utterly lost 2. It hath a direct Institution Matth. 18.15 16 17 18 19 20. If thy Brother shall Trespass c. tell it unto the Church but if he neglect to hear the Church let him be unto thee as an Heathen Man and a Publican Verily I say unto you whatsoever ye shall bind on Earth shall be bound in Heaven and whatsoever ye shall loose on Earth shall be loosed in Heaven c. After all the Learned and Unlearned Contests that have been about this place the sence of it is plain and obvious unto such as whose Minds are not clouded with prejudices about such Churches and such Excommunications as are utterly foreign unto the Scripture But that by Trespasses in this place Sins against God giving scandal or offence are intended hath been proved before as also that by a Church a particular Christian Congregation is intended This Church hath the cognizance of the scandalous offences of its Members committed unto it when brought before it in the due Order described Hereon it makes a Determination designing in the first place the Recovery of the Person offending from his Sin by his hearing of its Counsel and Advice But in case of Obstinacy it is to remove him from its Communion leaving him in the outward condition of an Heathen and a Publican So is he to be esteemed by them that were offended with his Sin and that because of the Authority of the Church binding him in Heaven and Earth unto the punishment due unto his Sin unless he doth Repent The Rejection of an offending Brother out of the Society of the Church leaving him as unto all the Privileges of the Church in the State of an Heathen declaring him liable unto the Displeasure of Christ and Everlasting Punishment without Repentance is the Excommunication we plead for and the Power of it with its Exercise is plainly here granted by Christ and Ordained in the Church 3. According unto this Institution was the practice of the Apostles whereof we have several Instances I might insist upon the Excommunication of Simon the Magician a baptized professor by Peter who declared him to have neither part or lot in the Church upon the discovery of his wickedness Act. 8.13 20 21 22 23. Yet because it was the single Act of one Apostle and so may be esteemed extraordinary I shall omit it However that fact of the Apostle is sufficiently declarative of what is to be done in the Church in like cases and which if it be not done it cannot be
Man hath by Faith and his conjunction unto a visible Church been translated into the Kingdom of Christ his just rejection out of it is the Redelivery of him into the visible Kingdom of Satan which is all that is here intended And this is an act suited unto the end whereunto it is designed For a Man hereby is not taken out of his own Power and the conduct of his own Mind not acted or agitated by the Devil but is left unto the sedate consideration of his present state and condition And this if there be any spark of ingenuous Grace left in him will be effectually operative by shame grief and fear unto his Humiliation especially understanding that the design of Christ and his Church herein is only his Repentance and Restauration HERE is therefore in his instance an Everlasting Rule given unto the Church in all Ages the ordinary Occurrences of the like cases requiring an ordinary Power for Relief in them without which the Church cannot be preserved That it is the Duty of the Church enjoined unto it by the Lord Jesus Christ and that necessary unto its Glory it s own Honour and Edification to reject scandalous Offenders out of its Communion is evidently declared in this place And to suppose that to be the Duty of the Church which it hath no Power or Authority to discharge seeing without them it cannot be discharged is a wild imagination 4. THE Duty of the Church herein with such other particular Duties as suppose the Institution hereof are in many places directed and enjoined It is so in that insisted on 1 Cor. 5. The foundation of the whole Discourse and practice of the Apostle there Recorded lies in this That Churches ought to cut off from among them scandalous Offenders and that to the End they may preserve themselves pure and that this they ought to do in the Name of Christ and by virtue of his Authority Vers. 2 4 7. And this is the whole of that Excommunication which we plead for The manner of its Administration we shall consider afterwards 2 Cor. Chap. 2.6 7 8. The Apostle commends the Church for what they had done in the Excommunication of the Incestuous person calling it a Punishment inflicted on him by them Vers. 6. He gives also an account of the Effect of this Sentence against him which was his Humiliation and Repentance Vers. 7. And hereon gives direction for his Restauration by an Act of the Church forgiving him and confirming their Love unto him Men may fansie to themselves strange Notions of Excommunication with reference unto its Power the Residence of that Power its Effects Extent and Ends and so either on the one hand erect it into an Engine of Arbitrary Domination over the Church and all the Members of it or deny on the other that there is any such Institution of Christ in force in his Churches But we can be taught nothing more plainly of the Mind of Christ than that he hath given Power unto his Church to cast out of their Communion obstinate scandalous Offenders and to restore them again upon their Repentance enjoining it unto them as their Duty And it is an Evidence of a woful degeneracy in Churches from their Primitive Institution when this sentence is so administred as that it hath an effect by virtue of Humane Laws or the outward concerns of Men but no influence on their Consciences unto Humiliation and Repentance which is the principal End of its appointment The Apostle treats of the same matter Gal. 5.7 8 9 10 11 12. He speaks of those false Teachers who opposed and overthrew what lay in them the Fundamental Doctrine of the Gospel These at that time were in great Power and Reputation in the Churches of the Galatians whom they had corrupted with their false Opinions so as that the Apostle doth not directly enjoin their immediate Excision yet he declares what they did deserve and what was the Duty of the Church towards them when freed from their Delusions Vers. 12. I would they were even cut off that trouble you Men have exercised their Minds in curious conjectures about the sence of these Words altogether in vain and needlesly The curiosity of some of the best of the Ancients applying it unto a forcible Eunuchism is extreamly fond No other Excision is intended but that which was from the Church and to be done by the Church in obedience unto the Truth Neither the Subject Matter treated of the nature of the Crime condemned nor the state of the Church or design of the Apostle will admit of any other Exposition 2 Thessal 3.7 The Apostle gives command unto the Brethren of the Church and that in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ to withdraw from every Brother that walketh disorderly What it is to walk disorderly he declares immediately namely to live in an open disobedience unto any of the commands of Christ not after the Tradition which he received of us that is the Doctrine of the Gospel which he had delivered unto them This withdrawing is as unto Church-Communion which cannot be done but upon some act of the Church depriving them of the Rights of it For if every Member of the Church should be left unto his own judgment and practice herein it would bring all things into confusion And therefore Vers. 14. he requires that a note be set on such a Person by the Church that is a Sentence be denounced against him before the Duty of withdrawing from him by the Brethren be incumbent on them See to the same purpose Tit. 3.10 11. 1 Tim. 5.20 Revel 2.2 14 15 20 21. IT is therefore evident that this Censure Judgment Spiritual punishment is an Institution of Christ for whose Administration he hath given Authority unto his Church as that which is necessary unto its Edification with its preservation in Honour Purity and Order THERE have been many Disputes about it as unto its Order and Kinds Some suppose that there are two sorts of Excommunication the one they call the lesser and the other the greater Some three sorts as it is supposed there were among the Jews There is no mention in the Scripture of any more sorts but one or of any Degrees therein A segregation from all participation in Church-Order Worship and Privileges is the only Excommunication spoken of in the Scripture But whereas an offending Person may cause great disorder in a Church and give great scandal unto the Members of it before he can be regularly cut off or expelled the Society some do judge that there should a Suspension of him from the Lords Table at least precede total or compleat Excommunication in case of Impenitency And it ought in some cases so to be But this Suspension is not properly an especial Institution but only an act of prudence in Church-Rule to avoid offence and scandal And no Men question but that this is lawful unto yea the Duty of the Rulers of the Church to require any
are come unto it is best for Edification that all Persons peaceably dispose themselves into those Societies with whom they most agree in Principles and Opinions especially such as relate or lead unto practice in any Duties of Worship But 4. WITH respect unto such Opinions if Men will as is usual wrangle and contend to the disturbance of the peace of the Church or hinder it in any Duty with respect unto its own Edification and will neither peaceably abide in the Church nor peaceably depart from it they may and ought to be proceeded against with Censures of the Church VIII WHETHER persons Excommunicated out of any Church may be admitted unto the hearing of the Word in the Assemblies of that Church Answ. 1. THEY may be so as also to be present at all Duties of Moral Worship for so many Heathens and Vnbelievers 1 Cor. 14.23 24. 2. WHEN persons are under this Sentence the Church is in a state of expecting of their Recovery and Return and therefore are not to prohibit them any Means thereof such as is preaching of the Word IX HOW far extends the Rule of the Apostle towards persons rejected of the Church 1 Cor. 5.11 With such an one no not to Eat as that also Note that Man and have no company with him that he may be ashamed 2 Thess. 3.14 1. TO Eat comprizeth all ordinary Converse in things of this Life Give us our daily Bread. 2. To Note is either the act of the Church setting the Mark of its Censure and Disapprobation on him or the Duty of the Members of the Church to take notice of him as unto the End of not keeping company with him Wherefore 2. HEREIN all ordinary Converse of Choice not made necessary by previous occasions is forbidden The Rule I say forbids 1. All ordinary Converse of Choice not that which is occasional 2. Converse about Earthly secular Things not that which is Spiritual for such an one may and ought still to be admonished whilst he will hear the word of Admonition 3. It is such Converse as is not made previously necessary by Mens mutual Engagement in Trade and the like For that is founded on such Rules of Right and Equity with such Obligations in point of Truth as Excommunication cannot Dissolve 3. NO suspension of Duties antecedently necessary by virtue of natural or moral Relation is allowed or countenanced by this Rule Such are those of Husband and Wife Parents and Children Magistrates and Subjects Masters and Servants Neighbours Relations in propinquity of Blood. No Duties arising from or belonging unto any of these Relations are released or the Obligation unto them weakned by Excommunication Husbands may not hereon forsake their Wives if they are Excommunicated nor Wives their Husbands Magistrates may not withdraw their Protection from any of their Subjects because they are Excommunicate much less may Subjects withhold their Obedience on any pretence of the Excommunication of their Magistrates as such And the same is true as unto all other natural or moral Relations 4. THE Ends of this prohibition are 1. To testifie our Condemnation of the Sin and disapprobation of the person guilty of it who is Excommunicated 2. The Preservation of our selves from all kinds of participation in his Sin. 3. To make him ashamed of himself that if he be not utterly profligate and given up unto total Apostasie it may occasion in him thoughts of returning X. HOW ought persons Excommunicated to be received into the Church upon their Repentance Answ. 1. AS unto the internal manner with all readiness and chearfulness with 1. Meekness to take from them all Discouragement and disconsolation Gal. 6.1 2. With Compassion and all means of Relief and Consolation 2 Cor. 2.7 3. With Love in all the demonstrations of it Vers. 8. 4. With Joy to represent the Heart of Christ towards Repenting Sinners 2. THE outward manner of the Restauration of such a person consists in 1. His Testification of his Repentance unto the satisfaction of the Church 2. The express Consent of the Church unto his Reception 3. His renewed Ingagement in the Covenant of the Church whereby he is re-instated or jointed again in the Body in his own proper place In all which the Elders by their Authority are to go before the Church ALL sorts of persons do now condemn the Opinions of the Novatians in refusing the Re-admission of lapsed Sinners into the Church upon Repentance But there may be an Evil observed amongst some leading that way or unto what is worse And this is that they seek not after the Recovery of those that are Excommunicated by Prayer Admonition Exhortation in a spirit of Meekness and Tenderness but are well satisfied that they have quitted themselves of their Society It is better never to Excommunicate any than so to carry it towards them when they are Excommunicated But there is a sort of Men unto whom if a Man be once an Offender he shall be so for ever XI OUR last Enquiry shall be Whether Excommunication may be regular and valid where the matter of Right is dubious and disputable As many such cases may fall out especially with respect unto the occasions of Life and mutual Converse or when the matter of Fact is not duly proved by positive Witnesses on the one hand and is denied on the other Answ. 1. THE foundation of the Efficacy of Excommunication next and under its Divine Institution lies in the Light and Conviction of the Consciences of them that are to be Excommunicated If these are not affected with a sense of Guilt as in dubious cases they may not be the sentence will be of no Force nor Efficacy 2. A CASE wherein there is a difference in the judgment of good and wise Men about it is to be esteemed such a dubious Case as is exempted from this Censure Nothing is to be admitted here to take place but what is reprovable by natural Light and the concurrent Judgment of them that fear God. 3. IF the case be about such a Right or Wrong in pretended Fraud Over-reaching or the like as is determinable by Civil-Laws the Church is no judge in such Cases unless it be by way of Arbitration 1 Cor. 6. 4. IF the Question be about Doctrines that are not in Points fundamental so as those who dissent from the Church do carry it peaceably and orderly there can be no proceedure unto Ecclesiastical Censures But if Men will do at on their own Opinions wrangling contending and breaking the Peace of the Church about them there are other Rules given in that case 5. IF the matter of Fact be to be determined and stated by Witness it is absolutely necessary by virtue of Divine Institution that there be Two or Three concurrent Testimonies one Witness is not to be regarded See Deut. 19.15 Numb 35.30 Matth. 18.16 c. Wherefore the ensuing Rules or Directions are to be observed in the matter of Excommunication 1. NO Excommunication is to be allowed in
Order of the sacred separation of Persons qualified unto the Office of the Ministry that is to be Bishops Elders or Pastors is here clearly represented For 1. They were chosen by the people the Apostles who were present namely Paul and Barnabas presiding in the Action directing of it and confirming that by their consent with them 2. A time of Prayer and Fasting was appointed for the Action or discharge of the Duty of the Church herein 3. When they were so chosen the Apostles present solemnly prayed whereby their Ordination was compleat And those who would have the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 here mentioned to be 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or an Authoritative imposition of hands wherein this Ordination did consist do say there is an 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in the words that is they feign a disorder in them to serve their own Hypothesis For they suppose that their compleat Ordination was effected before there was any Prayer with Fasting for by imposition of Hands in their judgment Ordination is compleated so Bellarmine A Lapide on the place with those that follow them But first to pervert the true signification of the Word and then to give countenance unto that wresting of it by assigning a disorder unto the Words of the whole Sentence and that such a disorder as makes in their judgment a false Representation of the matter of Fact related is a way of the Interpretation of Scripture which will serve any turn 4. This was done in every Church or in every Congregation as Tindal renders the Word namely in all the particular Congregations that were gathered in those parts for that Collection and Constitution did always precede the Election and Ordination of their Officers as is plain in this place as also Tit. 1.5 So far is it from Truth that the Being of Churches dependeth on the Successive Ordination of their Officers that the Church essentially considered is always antecedent unto their Being and Call. BUT because it is some Mens interest to entangle things plain and clear enough in themselves I shall consider the Objections unto this rendition of the Words The whole of it lies against the signification use and application of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Now although we do not here argue meerly from the signification of the Word but from the representation of the matter of Fact made in the context yet I shall observe some things sufficient for the removal of that Objection As 1. THE native signification of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 by virtue of its Composition is to lift up or stretch forth the hands or an hand And hereunto the LXX have respect Isa. 58.9 where they render 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the putting forth of the finger which is used in an ill sence by 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is the same with 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 nor is it ever used in any other signification 2. THE first constant use of it in things Political or Civil and so consequently Ecclesiastical is to Choose Elect Design or Create any Person an Officer Magistrate or Ruler by Suffrage or common consent of those concerned And this was usually done with making bare the hand and arm with lifting up as Aristophanes witnesseth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 He is a great stranger unto these things who knoweth not that among the Greeks especially the Athenians from whom the use of this Word is borrowed or taken 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 was an act 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of the whole Assembly of the people in the choice of their Officers and Magistrates 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is by common Suffrage to decree and determine of any Thing Law or Order and when applied unto Persons it signifies their Choice and Designation to Office. So is it used in the first sence by Demosthenes Orat. in Timoch 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The people confirmed my sayings by their Suffrage And in the other Philip. 1. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Neither the Senate nor the People choosing him to his Office. So is the Passive Verb used to be created by Suffrages 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 was the act of choosing whose effect was 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the determining Vote or Suffrage Porrexerunt manus Psephisma notum est saith Cicero speaking of the manner of the Greeks And when there was a division in choice it was determined by the greater Suffrage Thucid. Lib. 3. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 As many instances of this nature may be produced as there are reports of calling Men unto Magistracy by Election in the Greek Historians And all the farther compositions of the Word do signifie to choose confirm or to abrogate by common Suffrages 3. THE Word is but once more used in the New Testament 2 Cor. 8.19 where it plainly signifies Election and Choice of a Person to an Employment 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 He was chosen of the Churches to travel with us 4. IT is acknowledged that after this was the common use of the Word it was applied to signifie the thing it self and not the manner of doing it Hence it is used sometimes for the obtaining or collation of Authority or Dignity or Magistracy any manner of way though not by Election To appoint to create But this was by an abusive application of the Word to express the thing it self intended without regard unto its signification and proper use Why such a use of it should be here admitted no Reason can be given For in all other places on such occasions the Apostles did admit and direct the Churches to use their liberty in their choice So the Apostles and Elders with the whole Church sent chosen Men of their own Company to Antioch such as they chose by common Suffrage for that end so again ver 25. I will send whom you shall approve 1 Cor. 16.3 The Church chose them the Apostle sent him who was chosen by the Church to be our Companion 2 Cor. 8.19 Look out from among your selves Act. 6. If on all these and the like occasions the Apostles did guide and direct the people in their right and use of their Liberty as unto the Election of Persons unto Offices and Employments when the Churches themselves are concerned what reason is there to depart from the proper and usual signification of the Word in this place denoting nothing but what was the common practice of the Apostles on the like occasions 5. THAT which alone is objected hereunto by Bellarmine and others who follow him and borrow their whole in this case from him namely that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Grammatically agreeing with and regulated by Paul and Barnabas denotes their act and not any act of the people is of no force For 1. Paul and Barnabas did preside in the whole action helping ordering and disposing of the people in the discharge of their Duty as is meet to be done by some on all the like occasions And therefore it is truly said of them that they appointed Elders by the
even the Word Command and Direction of Christ himself alone the Acts and Exercise of it in binding and loosing in remitting and retaining Sin in opening and shutting the Kingdom of Heaven are all Spiritual meerly and only Neither can there be an Instance given of any thing belonging unto the Rule of the Church that is of another nature Yea it is sufficient eternally to exclude any Power or Exercise of it any Act of Rule or Government from any Interest in Church-Affairs that it can be proved to be Carnal Political Despotical of external Operaration or not entirely Spiritual 5. THE Change of this Government of the Church fell out and was introduced gradually upon an advantage taken from the unmeetness of the People to be lead under this Spiritual Rule For the greatest part of them that made up Christian Churches being become ignorant and carnal that Rule which consists in a spiritual influence on the Consciences of Men was no way able to retain them within the bounds of outward obedience which was at last only aimed at There was therefore another kind of Rule and Government judged necessary to retain them in any Order or Decorum And it must be acknowledged that where the Members of the Church are not in some degree Spiritual a Rule that is meerly Spiritual will be of no great use unto them But principally this change was introduced by those that were in possession of the Rule it self and that on two grounds 1. Their unskilfulness in the management of this Spiritual Rule or weariness of the Duties which are required thereunto This made them willing to desert it with that perpetual labour and exercise of all sorts of Graces which are required in it and to embrace another more easie and more suited unto their Inclinations 2. A desire of the Secular advantages of Profit Honour and Veneration which tendered themselves unto them in another kind of Rule By these means was the Original Government of the Church which was of Divine Institution utterly lost and a Worldly Domination introduced in the room thereof But the brief delineation given of it before with what shall now be added will demonstrate sufficiently that all these Disputes and Contests which are in the World between the Church of Rome and others about Church-Power and Rule are utterly foreign unto Christian Religion 6. I SHALL therefore briefly enquire into these three things 1. What is the Skill and Polity that is required unto the Exercise or Administration of the Government of the Church 2. What is the sole Law and Rule of it 3. What are the Acts and Duties of it What it is conversant about especially those wherein the Office of Ruling Elders doth take place 1. THE Polity of Church-Government subjectively considered is generally supported to consist 1. In a skill learning or understanding in the Civil and especially the Canon Law with the additional Canons accomodating that Law unto the present state of things of the Nation to be interpreted according unto the general Rules of it 2. Knowledge of and Acquaintance with the Constitution Power Jurisdiction and Practice of some Law Courts which being in their original grant of Power manner of Proceeding Pleas and Censures meerly Secular are yet called Ecclesiastical or Spiritual 3. A good Discretion to understand a-right the extent of their Power with the bounds and limits of it that on the one hand they let none escape whom they can reach by the discipline of their Courts and on the other not entrench so far on the Civil-Power and the Jurisdiction of other Courts according to the Law of the Land as to bring themselves into charge or trouble 4. An acquaintance with the Table of Fees that they may neither lose their own profit nor give advantage unto others to question them for taking more than their due But in these things we are not at present concerned 8. THE skill then of the Officers of the Church for the Government of it is a spiritual Wisdom and Vnderstanding in the Law of Christ for that end with an Ability to make application of it in all requisite Instances unto the Edification of the whole Church and all its Members through a ministerial Exercise of the Authority of Christ himself and a due Representation of his Holiness Love Care Compassion and Tenderness toward his Church 1. THE sole Rule and Measure of the Government of the Church being the Law of Christ that is the Intimation and Declaration of his Mind and Will in his Institutions Commands Prohibitions and Promises an Vnderstanding herein with Wisdom from that Understanding is and must be the whole of the Skill enquired after How this Wisdom is bestowed as a spiritual Gift how it is to be acquired in a way of Duty by Prayer Meditation and study of the Word hath been intimated before and shall fully be declared in our Discourse of spiritual Gifts All Decrees and Decretals Canons and Glosses come properly in this matter under one Title of them namely Extravagant The utmost Knowledge of them and Skill in them will contribute nothing unto this Wisdom Neither are any sort of Men more strangers unto it or unacquainted with it than they are for the most part who are eminently cunning in such Laws and the Jurisdiction of Ecclesiastical Courts But Wisdom in the knowledge of the Will of Christ as revealed in the Scripture is that alone which is of use in the Government of the Church 2. A PART of this Wisdom consisteth in an Ability of Mind to make Application of the Law of Christ in all requisite Instances unto the Edification of the Church in general and all the Members of it respectively This Wisdom is not notional only but practical It consists not in a speculative comprehension of the sence of the Rule or of the Mind of Christ therein only though that be required in the first place but in an Ability of Mind to make Application of it whereunto Diligence Care Watchfulness and spiritual Courage are required Some are to be Admonished some to be Rebuked sharply some to be cut off in which and the like cases a spirit of Government acting it self in Diligence Boldness and Courage is necessary And this is one reason why the Lord Christ hath appointed many Elders in each Church and those of several sorts For it is seldom that any one Man is qualified for the whole work of Rule Some may have a good understanding in the Law of the Churches Government yet through a natural Tenderness and an insuperable kind of Modesty not be so ready and prompt for that part of this Discipline which consists in Reproofs and Severity of Censures Some may not have so great an Ability for the Indagation of the sence of the Law as others have who yet upon the knowledge of it being discovered unto them have readiness and boldness in Christ to apply it as occasion doth require All Elders therefore in their variety of Gifts are to be
ascribed unto them Ver. 5. All these things do suppose a Right and Duty thereon to Act according to their Interest in Excommunication to reside in the whole Church Wherefore 5. THERE are some Acts belonging hereunto that the Church it self in the Body of the Fraternity cannot be excluded from without destroying the nature of the Sentence it self and rendring it ineffectual Such are the previous cognizance of the Cause without which they cannot be blamed for any neglect about it preparatory Duties unto its Execution in Prayer Mourning and Admonition which are expresly prescribed unto them and a Testification of their consent unto it by their common Suffrage Without these things Excommunication is but a Name with a noise it belongs not unto the Order appointed by Christ in his Church 6. HENCE arise the Duties of the Church towards an Excommunicated Person that are consequential unto his exclusion from among them Such are Praying for him as one noted by the Church and under the Discipline of Christ avoiding Communion with him in publick and private that he may be ashamed and the like all which arise from their own voluntary actings in his exclusion and such as without a judgment of the cause they cannot be obliged unto 7. YET on the other side unto the formal compleatness of this Sentence an Authoritative Act of Office-Power is required For 1. There is in it such an Act of Rule as is in the hands of the Elders only 2. The Executive Power of the Keys in binding and loosing so far as it comprizeth Authority to be acted in the Name of Christ is entrusted with them only 8. WHEREFORE I shall say no more in answer unto this Enquiry but that Excommunication is an act of Church-Power in its Officers and Brethren acting according unto their respective Rights Interests and Duties particularly prescribed unto them The Officers of the Church act in it as Officers with Authority the Brethren or the Body of the Church with Power yet so as that the Officers are no way excluded from their Power Consent and Suffrage in the acting of the Church but have the same Interest therein with all other Members of the Church but the Community of the Church have no Interest in those Authoritative actings of the Officers which are peculiar unto them Where either of these is wanting the whole Duty is vitiated and the sence of the Sentence rendred ineffectual I. IT is Enquired Whether Excommunication justly deserved may and ought to be omitted in case of trouble or danger that may ensue unto the Church therein IT is usually granted that so it may and ought to be which seems in general to have been the judgment of Austin THE Troubles and Dangers intended are three-fold 1. From the Thing it self 2. From the Persons to be Excommunicated 3. From the Church 1. TROUBLE may arise from the Thing it self For there being an exercise of Authority or Jurisdiction in it over the Persons of Men not granted from the Civil Magistrate by the Law of the Land those that execute it may be liable unto Penalties ordained in such cases 2. THE Persons to be Excommunicated may be Great and of great Interest in the World so as that if they receive a provocation hereby they may occasion or stir up Persecution against the Church as it hath often fallen out 3. THE Church it self may be divided on these considerations so as that lasting differences may be occasioned among them which the omission of the Sentence might prevent FOR Answer hereunto some things must be premised As 1. HERE is no supposition of any thing sinful or morally evil in the Church its Officers or any of its Members by refusing to omit the pronouncing of this Sentence Whether there be any Sin in giving occasion unto the troubles mentioned to be avoided by an omission of Duty is now to be enquired into 2. WE must suppose 1. That the cause of Excommunication be clear and evident both as unto the merit of the Fact and the due Application of it unto the Person concerned so as that no Rational indifferent Man shall be able to say that it is meet that such an one should be continued a Member of such a Society as it ought to be where-ever Excommunication is administred 2. That sufficient Time and space of Repentance and for giving satisfaction unto the Church whereof afterwards hath been allowed unto the Person after Admonition 3. That the Church doth really suffer in Honour and Reputation by tolerating such a scandalous Offender among them I ANSWER On these suppositions I see no just Reason to countenance the omission of the Execution of this Sentence or to acquit the Church from the guilt of Sin in so doing For 1. THE first presence of Danger is vain There is not the least shadow of Jurisdiction in this Act of the Church There is nothing in it that toucheth any thing which is under the Protection and Conservation of Humane Laws It reacheth not the Persons of Men in their Lives or Liberties nor their Estates or the least Secular Privileges that they do enjoy it doth not expose them to the Power or Censures of others nor prejudge them as unto Office or Advantage of Life There is therefore no concernment of the Law of the Land herein no more than in a Parents disenheriting a Rebellious Child 2. AS unto danger of Persecution by the means of the Person provoked I say 1. The same may be pleaded as unto all other Duties of obedience unto Jesus Christ wherewith the World is provoked and so the whole profession of the Church should give place to the fear of Persecution To testify against Sin in the way of Christs appointment is a case of Confession 2. The Apostles were not deterred by this consideration from the Excommunication of Simon Magus the seducing Jews Hymeneus and Alexander with others 3. The Lord Christ commandeth and reproveth his Churches according as they were strict in the observation of this Duty or neglective of it notwithstanding the fear of Persecution thereon Revel 2.3 And 4. He will take that care of his Church in all their obedience unto him as shall turn all the consequents thereof unto their advantage 3. AS unto danger of Differences in the Church there is nothing to be said but that if Rule Order Love and Duty will not prevent such Differences there is no way appointed of Christ for that end And if they are sufficient for it as they are abundantly they must bear their own blame who occasion such Differences II. BUT it may be said What if such an Offender as justly deserves to be Excommunicated and is under admonition in order thereunto in case of Impenitency should voluntarily withdraw himself from and leave the Communion of the Church is there any necessity to proceed against him by Excommunication Answ. 1. SOME say it is enough if it be declared in the Church that such an one hath cut off himself from the